obsessed with stories where the message is that you can't bring someone back from the dead even if you can bring someone back from the dead

seen from Malaysia
seen from Türkiye
seen from China

seen from Malaysia
seen from United States

seen from United Kingdom

seen from United Kingdom

seen from Malaysia
seen from China
seen from United States
seen from China
seen from United States

seen from United Kingdom

seen from United States

seen from Netherlands

seen from United States

seen from India
seen from United States
seen from South Africa

seen from United States
obsessed with stories where the message is that you can't bring someone back from the dead even if you can bring someone back from the dead
How do you feel about the story of Alcestis and Admetus?
I actually recently read Euripides' Alcestis in Greek and I have to say: it's funny. I get how it was slotted as a satyr play. Admetus is a buffoon. He's constantly lamenting about how he can't live without his wife, begging her not to leave him, saying he'll die along with her, talking about how the grief is worse than death, like dude. We all know she's dying on your behalf. You could just agree to die like you were supposed to and she'd live. And then it feels so comic with tons of stuff happening in the house and the slaves stepping out into the street to describe it to the chorus. Even before Heracles shows up with his genre-bending powers, the only way I can take this play is as a parody of tragedy.
underappreciated weird part of alcestis (aside from. you know. all the other weird parts) is that when admetus is yelling at his dad for refusing to die for him he says that since his wife died in his place, like a father should have, he now considers himself his wife's child instead of his father's child.
admetus is a strong contender for stupidest man in greek tragedy+. and the competition is fierce.
Can you yap to me about your take on Alcestis and Admetus? They make me unwell :3
I've mostly postponed thinking about Alcestis until later this year when I will eventually have to tackle the issue of Alcestis' three-day silence, but I did just read a really cool chapter about it (Chiara Blanco, “Touching Death in Euripides’ Alcestis” in Sensing Greek Drama) that suggests that the final scene would have been understood as Heracles tricking Admetus into dying with Alcestis and joining her in death/the underworld... the chapter rests on the idea that the stage image of the 'recognition,' with Heracles forcing Admetus to take the hand of the silent and immobile veiled woman, possibly represented on stage by a statue rather than an actual actor, recreates the motif of hand-clasping commonly found in funerary art and joins him to her statue-like and corpse-like state. so the tableau on the stage is that of a reunion between the spouses in the afterlife, with the hand-clasping echoing the marriage ritual of taking the bride by the hand as well as funerary art. and Admetus' avoidance of death (spelled out in the prologue) is revealed as just a temporary postponement. idk how I feel about the argument as a whole but it's a fascinating take that does make Admetus' characterization throughout make a lot of sense, not to mention the genre categorization of Alcestis as satyr drama.
very weird reverse-beruriah situation going on in alcestis. inversion of the olive tree bed in the odyssey. admetus has to be willing to betray his wife in order to get her back.
the house in alcestis is the definition of party in the front, business in the back. spatial division of the domestic interior into feasting and mourning and all.
i just think it’s neat that in greek tragedy a character is played by different bodies when living and when dead. when teucer and agamemnon and odysseus are in front of ajax’s corpse arguing about whether to bury it, it’s not the same body as the one we saw delivering his suicide speech. cassandra goes into the house of atreus in one body and is carried out as another. when orestes shows aegisthus clytemnestra’s body it’s not the same body as when she was alive. the dead body is a different body than the living body.