Saddest fic of all, go! I've been trolling the superlative tag, and some were great. I'm looking for the saddest thing you guys got! <3 Love you all, thank you SO much for this blog.
Lol, we get this question so often that it is actually on our FAQ and the link goes directly to our tragedy tag (fics with Major Character Death). But that is kind of a technical approach and not everybody wants to read an MCD fic, right? And there’s a difference between a sad fic with happy/open ending and angsty fic with a tragic ending. Some time ago, mods here had a discussion about the saddest fic and we couldn’t all agree on the same fic! This time we decided to give you saddest fics by the mod and our guest reviewer, scaramouche.
Saddest fics from flyingcatstiel - As a rule, I don’t read MCD fics, which means that I’ve not read the most famous destiel tearjerkers. Except for that one time when my very first canon fic was Reflection of You (MCD and endverse!). Needless to say, I didn’t read any SU fics for a long time. So, I really can’t tell you how much my saddest fic compares to yours. These are fics that sneaked upon me, put me through an emotional wringer and lingered with me:
Chances by thecouchcarrot
cut it out, and then restart by cheesewithmy
It’s getting dark, too dark to see (submitted rec)
Muscle Memory by komodobits
Oh What A Beautiful City by moosefeels
The Sawdust Men by linoresearch
Smells Like Roses by bomarlowe
Someone I Forgot to Be by mathildadavis
the taste of gravel in the mouth by beenghosting
Things that Leave Marks by thestoryinsideme
Saddest fics from Kyrie - I read MCD and then drown in a pool of tears while saying, “that was so beautiful…sniff, sniff.” Most of these fics are MCD.
The Five People You Meet in Heaven by amarillogrande
How A Righteous Man Raises A Rose by swordofmymouth
In The Silence Afterward by ibroketuesday
In the Spine (submitted rec) by castiel_makes_his_mark_on_me
The Inexhaustible Silence of Houses
The Last Moonlight Serenade (not MCD!) by gankyourdarlings
Ninety One Whiskey (update: not MCD, but so many tears) by komodobits
Not All The Way Through by tracy_loo_who
Remnants (not MCD, tiny ficlet that moved me) by mclachlan
Terms Of Service by misachan
This Thing Called Free Will by tracy_loo_who
Saddest fics from scaramouche - I’m all about the pain that comes from the characters falling very, very low, and then slowly clawing their way back up. Hurt and healing, that’s my jam.
Doghouse Roses (unofficially recced here and here) by janie_tangerine
Down Like Water by museaway
Kingdom Come by cheesewithmy
The Last Moonlight Serenade by gankyourdarlings
My Eyes Are An Ocean by entangled_now
White Albatross by spnergiout
Your Heart Makes by schmerzerling
Note: we are going to link the saddest fic question from our FAQ to this post. You may also like our unrequited tag (fics where one is certain that their love is not returned) and unhappyish tag (fics where they separate at the end).
And here’s our feelings recovery tag, created specifically to help you to deal with all sad feelings, ;)