for an eternity
🌷 v-day prompt: fake date, real feelings
anna (eternity) x reader
pairing: anna (eternity) x female reader warnings: eternity au, angst, hidden feelings, fake date, jealousy, arguing, making up, confessions, fluff, valentine’s day fic, 18+ word count: 1.3k
"almost there," anna smiled gently, adjusting the tripod to make sure the entire picnic layout was in frame. "put your hand here." your breath hitched in your throat when she grabbed your hand and placed it high up on her thick exposed thighs, her white satin dress doing the camera plenty of favors. you nearly evaporated into thin air when she gripped your jaw firmly and tilted your head, "now look at me just like that." she rasped, rubbing her index finger across your bottom lip while staring deeply into your chocolate brown eyes, "perfect."
you were easy like sunday morning, melting into her as your deepest desires lingered in a single innocent touch. as hard as you tried not to, you completely softened looking at the woman in front of you. her big brown eyes and cherub cheeks mirrored your own, but she was incredibly different from you. anna was effortlessly tantalizing and clever enough to pull you by an invisible leash you'd made snug all on your own.
but god she was so beautiful, you could never deny her. and so you tried to drill into your head that this was just a scheme, some ridiculous ploy to enact revenge on an ex of hers. you had no business even saying yes to this outrageous plan, especially when you had unrequited feelings for anna, and on valentine's day of all days... it was pathetic. but anna went all out with the fake picnic date and with the way she was casually touching you like you've been hers for an eternity— you just couldn't pretend anymore.
"anna, is this just- what are we doing here?"
"what do you mean? we're obviously making content for my instagram and tiktok silly! you know that crash out checks my socials daily and when these pics drop-."
"is that all this is? this is just content for you? like you're only doing this to make some irrelevant ex jealous in hopes that he... i don't know reaches out to you or something? and what are you going to do if he does reach out, get back with him?" you rambled, averting your eyes anywhere else but her face as your heartbeat thumped furiously in your chest.
"do you seriously think i'd get back with that jackass?" anna rasped.
"i don't know, would you?"
"of course not!"
"then what's the point in all of this!? i mean granted we’re in your backyard, but you put together a really cute picnic, you told me to wear all white and for what!? just for shits and giggles!?"
"umm okay... you sound so mad right now."
"you know what anna i am so mad right know," you swiftly rose to your feet smoothing out your clothes, "and so freaking stupid." you turned on your heels and stormed through the backyard and into her house.
without stopping you grabbed your purse off of the couch and headed to her front door, your eyes blurring a bit. just before you could reach the handle anna was grabbing you, turning you around to her. "what's going on with you? you're acting like a totally different person, is it because it's valentine's day?" anna asked sincerely, her face full of concern, "don't tell me you got a thing about valentine's day..."
"yes it's valentine's day and you're making me spend it with you to get revenge on an ex who you secretly want back! i think you have the thing about valentine's day!"
anna tilted her head and scrunched up her face, clearly aggravated at this point. "let's back track for a minute, i'm making you spend valentine's day with me? how!? you could have said no, you could be anywhere but here with me right now but you aren't!"
you sniffled as a stray tear ran down your cheek, you shook your head cursing yourself for not catching it in time, "you're right, i don't know what i was thinking believing you felt the same way i do."
anna gripped your chin sharply making you gasp and your eyes widen in shock, "who fucking said i don't feel the same? did you ever ask me?" she asked firmly, swiping her knuckle across your damp cheeks.
"n-no but- anna i know you know how i feel about you and this is just torture at this point." you sighed in defeat, looking utterly confused and a bit suspicious when anna started to laugh.
"ha i know, that was kind of the point." anna looped her hand in yours and gently led you over to the couch, she gestured for you to sit and you did. "i know i told you i wanted to do this to make that jackass ryan jealous, but i sort of kind of lied."
"why would you lie to me though?"
"i don't know, maybe i thought it would be easier to get you to spend valentine's day with me if you thought you were helping me?"
"you didn't have to bring up ryan though, i still would have been right here with you. so why didn't you just ask me?"
"the same reason you never told me you had feelings for me, it's hard to be vulnerable you know? you put yourself out there and expose your heart all to get rejected, it just doesn't feel good."
"well," you took a deep breathe and rested your manicured fingers on her knee. you slowly trailed your eyes back up to her face, you had her full attention. "i like you… and i've been hoping you felt the same way about me for quite some time now. do you?"
the silence between you two was deafening, all you could hear was birds chirping outside and sounds of cars passing by. you started to feel uncomfortable in your own skin and decided to take the hint. just when you were about to stand up again you felt anna gracefully cupping your cheek and turning your face towards her. you melted into her warm touch sinking deeper into her palm as your eyes fluttered closed, instantly subdued.
you felt her soft plump lips on yours, gentle at first and then coaxing your mouth open with her tongue. your body instantly heated up and you couldn’t stop the filthy moan from leaving your parted lips. anna’s tongue grazed your bottom lip before slipping inside of you, exploring and tasting you.
you gently pulled back from her, just enough to see her alluring eyes trained on you and her swollen lips trapped between her teeth. “anna, u-um.”
“i like you too, a whole lot actually and i want to officially make this a real valentine’s day date.” anna took one last glance at you before getting up and disappearing into the kitchen. shyly, you ran your fingers over your swollen lips, still dazed from the kiss. meanwhile, the other woman beamed back into the room carrying a bouquet of white roses and a card.
you stood from the couch, butterflies instantly filling your belly as your nerves took over. “what’s this?”
“happy valentine’s day,” anna cooed, holding the gifts out to you. you smiled shyly and took them, instantly smelling the flowers. “read the card.”
i thought if i could make you jealous you’d finally say something, that was stupid. the truth is, i don’t want anyone else. i want you. so instead of pretending to be something i’m not, i’m asking properly. will you go on a date with me?
xoxo, anna
you smiled looping your arms around anna’s shoulders and pressed your lips to hers, she rubbed her hands down your waist and pulled you closer to her. you moaned at her touch and slipped your tongue between her lips groaning at the taste of her.
anna released your mouth with a pop, “so is that a yes?”
you nodded your head and pecked her lips again, “so where are you taking me for our first real date?”
“my backyard, come on girl it’s already set up.”
“anna!”