sings the teenage mutant ninja turtles theme song until it gets stuck in the other’s head: Probably Cas, and then he’d laugh when Reid starts humming it under his breath.
rides the biggest, scariest roller coaster at the amusement park – twice: Reid. He’d probably drag Cas to do it with him tbh
stays up until 3am hunting for shiny pokemon: ???Cas probably. Reid will drag him back to bed whenever he finds him awake though
gives really nice massages: Reid
draws all over napkins: Cas will doodle all over anything tbh
buys +$90 worth of lush products: Cas does. He uses them, too(must be why he’s so pretty)
has a mug reserved for alcohol: I don’t think either of them would.
cooks enough pasta to feed the whole neighbourhood: Cas. Reid is the one who feeds it to the stray animals though
falls asleep immediately after sex: Cas would. Reid would probably lay there quietly until he falls asleep
only drinks soda: Neither tbh.
makes terrible puns at every given opportunity: cas
will try any food once: I think Cas and Reid would both like trying new food.