Research Studies for the Biological Level of Analysis
GENERAL LEARNING OUTCOMES
Outline principles that define the biological level of analysis (8 marks)
Explain how principles that define the biological level of analysis may be demonstrated in research (8 marks)
Money - sex change case study
Longitudinal study on David Reimer, a boy who lost his penis in a circumsicion accident
Advised his parents to give him a sex change; real aim was to prove that nurture determines gender identity, not nature
Proves that psychosexual development is determined by chromosomes and hormones
Rosenzweig, Bennet and Diamond (1972) - role of environmental stimulation on brain plasticity
To investigate whether environmental factors affected development of neurons in cerebral cortex
Brains of enriched environment rats were denser
Kasamatsu and Hirai - Japanese Monks serotonin study
Investigation into how sensory deprivation affects the brain
Found that sensory deprivation triggered release of higher levels of serotonin
Discuss how and why particular research methods are used at the biological level of analysis (22 marks)
Rosenzweig, Bennet and Diamond (1972) - role of environmental stimulation on brain plasticity
To investigate whether environmental factors affected development of neurons in cerebral cortex
Brains of enriched environment rats were denser
Suffered damage to hippocampus due to encephalitis, suffers retrograde and anterograde amnesia
Cannot form new memories, but remembers emotional and procedural memories
Discuss ethical considerations related to research studies at the biological level of analysis. (22 marks)
Money - sex change case study
Longitudinal study on David Reimer, a boy who lost his penis in a circumcision accident
Advised his parents to give him a sex change; real aim was to prove that nurture determines gender identity, not nature
Proves that psychosexual development is determined by chromosomes and hormones
Lindstroem et al. Schizophrenia and dopamine
Aim was to determine whether or not schizophrenic patients had differences in dopamine levels compared to non-schizophrenics
Schizophrenics had higher levels of dopamine production in their brains
Explain one study related to localization of function in the brain (8 marks)
Sperry (1968) - hemisphere disconnection
A natural experiment with the aim of investigating behavioural, psychological and neurological effects of disconnecting brain hemispheres
After a brain disconnection surgery, patients were shown visual information for 1/10th of a second on each eye (so eye has no time to focus / adjust) - information seen by left eye goes to right hemisphere etc.
Tactile stimulus only to left or right side, screen covered to remove vis. ID, information about object felt by left hand goes to right hemisphere etc.
Brain is localised - speech and writing in left, processing of visuals in right
Using one or more examples, explain the effects of neurotransmission on human behaviour (8 marks)
Kasamatsu and Hirai - Japanese monks serotonin study
Investigation into how sensory deprivation affects the brain
Found that sensory deprivation triggered release of higher levels of serotonin, triggering hallucinations
Using one or more examples, explain the functions of two hormones on behaviour (8 marks)
Marucha (1997) the effects of stress on time taken to recover
To investigate the link between stress levels and the body's ability to recover
11 dental students had their soft palates punctured during a) summer holidays and b) before exams began
Took longer to heal under stress
Rosenthal - melatonin study
In countries where low-light periods in winter are very long, people produce higher levels of melatonin for prolonged periods of time
Causes Seasonal Affective Disorder
Discuss two effects of the environment on physiological processes (22 marks)
Locked up for 13 years with little to no stimulation, cannot speak or walk properly
Psychologists have been trying to restore her ability to speak and think like a normal child but the "window" of learning has passed
Rosenzweig, Bennet, Diamond (1972) - the role of environmental stimulation on brain plasticity
To investigate whether environmental factors affected development of neurons in cerebral cortex
Brains of enriched-environment rats were denser
Bremner et al. (2003) - Stress, PTSD and memory problems related to reduction of hippocampal volume
Aim was to measure the volume of hippocampus based on theory that prolonged stress (raised cortisol levels) may reduce its volume
Found that hippocampus was smaller in PTSD patients than control
Examine one interaction between cognition and physiology in terms of behaviour. Evaluate two relevant studies. (22 marks)
Suffered damage to hippocampus due to encephalitis, suffers from retrograde and anterograde amnesia
Cannot form new memories, but remembers emotional and procedural memories
Milner and Scoville - case study of HM
HM suffered from severe epilepsy, had a surgery to remove parts of his temporal lobe but surgery also accidentally removed parts of hippocampus, suffers from retro- / anterograde amnesia
Discuss the use of brain imaging technologies in investigating the relationship between biological factors and behaviour. (22 marks)
Lindstroem et al. - schizophrenia and dopamine
Aim was to determine whether or not schizophrenic patients had differences in dopamine levels compared to non-schizophrenics
Schizophrenics had higher levels of dopamine production in their brains
Raine et al. (1997) - brains of murderers
To discover if murderers who plead not guilty for reasons of insanity (NGRI) showed evidence of brain abnormalities
NGRIs had less activity in the pre-frontal cortex (self-control / emotion) and amygdala / medial temporal hippocampus (inhibition of violence, fearlessness, unable to perceive consequences)
Milner and Scoville - case study of HM
HM suffered from severe epilepsy, had a surgery to remove parts of his temporal lobe but surgery also accidentally removed parts of hippocampus, suffers from retro- / anterograde amnesia
With reference to relevant research studies, to what extent does genetic inheritance influence behaviour? (22 marks)
Caspi et al. (2003) - gene mapping study
Analyse possible role of (mutated) 5-HTT gene (responsible for serotonin production) in depression, longitudinal study using self-report of feelings after stressful event
Those with mutations were more likely to experience depression than those with normal gene
However, 43% of the world population has this mutation
Could be triggered by event - Nurnberg - 80% of women who have traumatic life events experience depression
Price - bipolar disorder in twins
Investigate relationship of BP in 216 pairs of DZ and MZ twins raised apart
MZ twins raised together - 68% concordance rate, MZ twins raised apart - 67% c.r., DZ twins 23%
Scarr and Weinberg - is intelligence genetic?
Trans-racial adoption participants, Afro-American children adopted by white families with existing biological children
Adopted children showed no significant IQ difference to biological children
Class may influence intelligence (due to quality of education)
Discuss ethical considerations in research into genetic influences on behaviour (22 marks)
Lindstroem et al. - Schizophrenia and dopamine
Aim was to determine whether or not schizophrenic patients had differences in dopamine levels compared to non-schizophrenics
Schizophrenics had higher levels of dopamine production in brains
Raine et al. (1997) - brains of murderers
To discover if murderers who plead not guilty for reasons of insanity (NGRI) showed evidence of brain abnormalities
NGRIs had less activity in pre-frontal cortex (self-control / emotion) and amygdala / medial temporal hippocampus (inhibition of violence, fearlessness, unable to perceive consequences)
Rosenzweig, Bennet and Diamond (1972) - role of environmental stimulation on brain plasticity
To investigate whether environmental factors affected development of neurons in cerebral cortex
Brains of enriched environment rats were denser
Examine one evolutionary explanation of behaviour (22 marks)
Fessler et al (2006) - disgust sensitivity in pregnant women
To investigate disgust sensitivity in first trimester of pregnancy, conducted a web survey where women had to indicate disgust levels in different scenarios
The weakened immune systems of pregnant women in first trimester made them more sensitive to dangerous foods
Curtis et al (2004) - similar to Fessler et al.
But used male and female participants of various ages from 165 different countries
Females had higher disgust ratings than men, disgust levels increased with age
Disgust helps protect those in situation where immune system was being hindered (pregnancy, age)