Red, Pink, Yellow, and Purple!
Red ==> What my muse likes or find's attractive about your muse.
She is attractive, he won't lie and say that she isn't. He likes her personality, it's abit like his own, snarky and what not. And she's a fan, that's always a plus - she boasts his ego.
Pink ==> Would my muse date your muse (assuming my muse isn't in a relationship already.)
Probably yes. However he would take her on a date or two before formally asking her to be in a relationship with him. Mainly because he would want to get to know more about her. Also, people don't believe him but when it comes to dating he can be a gentleman.
Yellow ==> My muse's greatest fear relating to your muse.
That he won't live up to her expectations. He doesn't know what sort of stories she's heard or if they were even the true versions. He doesn't like to disappoint people so he's trying his best to impress her and live up to the stories.
Purple ==> A secret my muse would not want yours to learn.
Probably about how in some of those stories she has heard, he was actually a coward. People make stories about dragons very over-dramatic they don't realize that even dragons can be scared.