(it started when we were younger)
Her phone buzzes from where it’s laying near her face. Riley blinks at it, watching the play of light across the screen as it wakes up briefly and then goes back to sleep. She draws her fingertips in nonsense patterns along the fitted sheet underneath her and wonders when it’ll be the last text.
Her excuse is that she’s not feeling well. It keeps her from the relentless pressure of school for a precious twenty-four hours. It keeps the hallway outside of her room deserted. It doesn’t stop the texts, though. It’s self-torture to keep her phone on. Each chirp shreds through her brain.
It’s -- David, right. He’s all sunlight and the freedom-infused smell of the lake in summer and calm page-turning after school. He’s impish pranks and a laugh that’s never cruel. And Matt, too. Matt is comfort, and he’s safe. He is all brilliance under a bad boy attitude. He’s not the kind of boy her mother wants her hanging out with but he’s perfect. Other people just don’t see that. They both are.
She thinks of the texts clogging her inbox and struggles to contain the terror that threatens to make good on her excuses of being ill.
She does not deserve them. Not as friends. Much less as -- whatever. She doesn’t know why they don’t understand that but she can’t bear to see it when they do. So, this. Hurting before they can hurt. It’s a lot of things, but it’s not kind, and it’s not mature. She knows that.
The thought occurs that she should wash their sweatshirts and give them back. They don’t belong to her. It’s true enough that it slices her deep, and all of a sudden, against her will, she’s crying, pressing her mouth into her pillow so she won’t make a sound.
Riley has been selfish. She recognizes that. All of this messiness is her fault. She let herself return the kisses. She reached out for Matt’s hand, David’s elbow, when she should have ducked away. She’s got no business with two good guys like them. None at all.
(Amanda Calloway knows that, somehow, and treats her accordingly.)
She makes some awful little snivelling noises as she gathers the last threads of her courage and picks up her phone. She cringes as she checks her texts, curling up into a tighter ball under a small mountain of blankets.
[text: David] Riley, I have lost control of this situation
[text: David] Matt is thinking about
[text: David] this is matt and david is a nasty liar who lies
She thinks she distantly hears the sound of her heart collapsing. She scrolls down to the newest messages.
[text: Matty] hey sweetheart
[text: Matty] thinking about you. you let me know if you want me to come pick you up, alright?
[text: David] sunshine girl <3 you okay?
She wants to say, no, I’m not. She wants to ensconce herself in their warmth and safety. She wants to pretend, just for one more night, that they love her and they want her and it’s something she could, in some permutation of existence, deserve.
But she knows the truth. So she doesn’t. She pulls her covers up further. She lets her traitor of a mind twirl back to the last night she’d spent curled up with them. Matt had been in the middle, and his shoulder had been so solid under her cheek. David’s thumb had brushed endlessly up and down the inside of her wrist in a way she couldn’t forget.
[text: David, Matt] I’m good <3 thanks
They never needed her in the first place. They’ll be happy together. She thinks about that, how they look together, holding hands or laughing at some shared joke. Matt was her first kiss, David the second, clean, untouched kisses. It’s just that maybe they’ll get bored of her trembling knees.
And maybe they won’t want her to complicate stuff between them. She’s not their excuse for being together, a convenient intermediary to feign bisexuality or whatever people think of boys who like girls at the same time as liking boys. She’s not their phase. People will think that. It’s easier than the reality: that she is bad for them, that she will infect them, that she has no business being with good guys.
Riley chances a last look at these tiny kilobytes of evidence of love and deletes them and turns her phone off.
It’s a good thing, she tells herself. It’ll be fine. It’s better like this.