blind-crow95 said: I think stargirl is in a different earth
Yeah, it probably is. That was certainly the original intent, but I wasn't sure once Crisis happened. But that certainly makes sense, as they'd have to explain the duplicate Icicles, Shades, Fiddlers, etc who are nothing like their Arrowverse counterparts. Jay being similar between Earths is just one of those instances in which the counterparts are very alike.
drjohnjacobjinglefaustus said: God I hope so, when I read that they change his power set amongst other things I went 🤢
The Flash's Shade was such a forgettable failure that I genuinely had forgotten about him until that post....that’s pretty darned sad, to be honest. Fingers crossed for good stuff in Stargirl! If nothing else, that show does love its JSA mythos.