@fluff-pink-fox : has Catherine ever tried interacting woth her brother?
Oo, this is a good one
So, during the Heartslabyul chapter she catches a glance of Che'nya. And they have the typical "Alchemi?" "Alice?" But once Catherine realizes that Che'nya can identify her she runs away even though he tried to go after her. There's a part of Catherine that knows she shouldn't hold a grudge against Che'nya but she's also stubborn. Whenever he's in Heartslabyul she hides.
During winter break (in the story line) is when they actually get to talk. Well, cue Catherine breaking down in front of Che'nya. "Why did you chose them over me?!? I needed you!!! You abandoned me, Alchemi!! When I needed you... I was all alone.. I just wanted my brother..." It's the first time Che'nya heard anything like that from Catherine. Especially when the only time Catherine was able to sneak out and play, she got caught. Che'nya, scared for Riddle getting in trouble, ran away with him leaving Catherine.
They definitely are trying to be better, Catherine thought Che'nya's life was all fun and games but didn't know he had his own struggles. When she ran away he looked for her, but he could never find her. When he heard that she went into the forest he expected her to be dead from all the "monsters". So to see his sister alive was a shock, and to see her so different.
It's more Che'nya trying to repair their relationship, Catherine tries but also if she has her bad ending she doesn't want to be to close to him. So Che'nya doesn't have to lose his sister for the second time. They do have that sort of teasing/bickering sibling dynamic during her 3rd year tho








