I have a theory and I’m starting with evidence before I tell you what it actually is. Here’s what we’ve got;
Mugglenet’s set visit of CoG reported them painting quite severe lashes on Ezra’s back
Ezra on the dvd extras of CoG said that credence had gone from one ‘intensely abusive’ situation to another by joining the circus
It’s also been reported by Yates and Rowling that the original script of CoG was ‘darker’ and had credence being mistreated much more ‘explicitly’
Credence’s shirt changed but I’m fairly sure he’s wearing the same trousers and waistcoat
Now’s the theoretical part;
Credence was with the circus for like 9 months, there’s NO WAY Skender did not know what and who he was... And surely he’d want to exploit that.
CONCLUSION: Skender beat Credence bc he refused to perform in the circus













