So as we go into the 6th season I wanted to share my ezra theory with u because after this I'm just gonna watch and enjoy. Ezra and ali have a son named charles. Ezra is adopted and he hates his adopted family. He desperately wants a real blood family of his own. He almost had it with maggie, but his mom took care of that. So when Ali gets preggo he is determined to keep the baby but Ali isn't on board. She wants to put him up for adoption.
Part 2: "that night" Ali is pregnant. She is planning to leave and go have the baby. I think ian also may think it's his and byron does too. They all don't want her to go thru with the pregnancy. I think Ezra is so obsessed with Ali and is protective of their baby. Fueled by jealousy and anger he hurts anyone else who keeps him from finding her and their son. Mona helped her get away so I think he threatened her into helping him get her back (by being A).
Part 3: Mrs D knows about ezras obsession and the baby and is helping ali escape with Peters help/money. She plants the decoys: cece, bethany, and sarah to fool ezra from finding her. If ali is in her room, Mrs D can keep her safe but obviously ali goes out that night. Resort for Ezra to steal the game and torture the girls: spencer= threatened his pregnant girlfriend with a shovel while she was carrying their baby, hannah= took her place/looks like her so it's painful for him to look at her,
Part 4) emily= he's jealous of the romantic relationship they had, aria= he isn't mad at her, he's mad at her dad who had a romantic relationship with her so he uses aria to get back at byron. Cece and Ezra are bro/sis and she helped him as much as she could with ali. When he went cray tho she turned on him and asked 4 mrs ds help. Their real dad is ted. Who is also cray. And he's also bethany dad Ezra built the dollhouse to capture ali and make her live their with the baby hense the game room.
Part 5) super complicated but if u have questions I've answered them all in my notebook that I can think of. :) even if I'm super wrong it was fun to think of and now I can sit back and watch it unravel without so many ??????? In my head.
-------------------------------
I really like this theory and I love that it is original (which is hard now with everyone throwing out a million wild possibilities)
I even think I could add to your theory....
What if Ali was so sorry to Aria because she should have warned her that she was getting involved with a psycho stalker!
I actually think there are lots of connections to this theory.
Meanwhile I am going to watch season 6 and keep noting clues but If I don’t see some decent connections to the earlier season’s and feel like everything ties together then I won’t be writting any new theories either.....