I think I had someone tell me in an argument that fanfiction is about shipping and if I'm not comfortable with that then find something else. And like, as ironic as that was to say to me, a slash writer, I do vividly recall a time when most fics I read just weren't shipping. They weren't even character studies. The most popular fanfic genres known to me were parodies and crossovers, like putting the characters in another series for humorous effect. Making Prince of Tennis guys use their crazy tennis powers to fight crime. Putting Goku in Hogwarts with his exact power just to completely wreck the setting. Fics where this super smart character goes into another setting and totally pwns everyone. Whatever. There were also just a lot of "what if this other character was the chosen one?" type canon-divergencs. A lot of projected endings to shonens that never seem to end. Whack stuff like Harry Potter Becomes a Communist (honestly I never read that one just know it is (in)famous).
I feel like the shift of fanfiction is for shipping has actually stifled creativity and diversity of work in the fandom a lot. And it might be true that it's always been shipping, but non-shipping works weren't even at the periphery, esp for works with younger audience. And like, at least for me, who do enjoy gen work a lot, I always found the idea of "transformative fandom is for women and queers and women like shipping and men are interested in curative fandom" to be really stifling.
But with the move to ao3, which did start with slash focused audience from LJ, the segregation between the shipping part of the fandom and the non-shipping part kinda happened naturally. And I don't begrudge that at all. But really quickly the non-shipping transformative work kinda faded from our view and our community. And if you're women or queer and belongs in one half of the community you kinda just accept that fanfiction is about shipping, always have been.
A lot of times when I say gen fics people think fics focused on platonic relationships when fanfiction doesn't have to be character focused at all. There are fics that are just there to push the limit of the setting in ways canon never did. Fics can also be power fantasies. They can be thought experiments. They can be ways to air out certain philosophies/world views.
anyway. Idk. Sometimes I have more in common with straight guys when it comes to taste in fiction and wanna see that in fandom again but without having to hang out in straight guy dominant space, ya know?









