Can Cyberbullying Really Be Stopped Though?
Reading about trolling and social media this week got me thinking about the hopeless nature of preventing cyberbullying. It seems that as time goes on and technology progresses, society is trying to adapt to the ethic and regulations of online communities. “New crimes develop as new technologies provide new capabilities and new means of exploitation,” (Applin, S & Fischer, M 2015) such as Youtube expanding on it’s means as “a high-volume website, a broadcast platform, a media archive and a social network.” (Burgess & Green 2009, p.5) Though the site is an awesome, easy-to-use platform for sharing video content with the world, it also means the world can respond…and yeah, the world isn’t always super nice.
I suppose the problem with such a dynamic, critical site such as Youtube is what is considered as cyberbullying? Can a person be judgemental without being a bully? A comment like the one below for instance is one I got off a Youtube video for a camera review. (Rossi, E 2017) Would you consider that as cyberbullying? And if so, what can authorities actually do about it?
The fact of the matter here is that “laws [are] struggling to keep up with technology.” (Gallagher-Watson, A 2014) It’s so difficult to determine the severity of a comment when “both bullying and drama have imprecise definitions.” (Boyd, D 2014, p. 130) For instance, I remember a number of years ago, a girl I knew unfortunately happened to be part of the “40% of…internet users [who] report[ed] experiencing at least one form of online harassment.” (Pew Research Centre 2014, p. 3) She uploaded a photo to Facebook, which prompted some boys in her year level to make comments relating her weight; comparing her to Jabba the Hutt. Yeah, nasty, A+ definition of cyberbullying. They removed the comments quickly when they realised the severity of their ‘joke’ but she still felt action needed to be implemented. Though the school could take action against the boys, the police said there wasn’t much they could do about the situation. Their comments had been removed, the school suspended the boys and were told to write an apology letter to the girl, but with the vague nature of cyberbullying laws at the time, the police told the girl that there was limited evidence against the boys, and even if there was more, there was no definitive law to prosecute them.
Though “in recent years, cyberbullying, online abuse and harassment and related aberrant uses of social media have brought into being new laws along with platform controls and a wide array of cyber safety educational programs,” (McCosker, A 2016, p. 1) is there really going to be a point in which cyberbullying can be completely preventable and very much illegal? Or will the vague, circumstantial nature of interpretation be a dominant means of determining the severity of a troll comment?
Applin, S & Fischer, M 2015, ‘New technologies and mixed-use convergence: How humans and algorithms are adapting to each other’, Technology and Society (ISTAS), 2014 IEEE International Symposium, IEEE, Dublin, pp. 1-6.
Boyd, D 2018, ‘Bullying: Is the Media Amplifying Meanness and Cruelty?’, It’s Complicated: The Social Lives of Networked Teens, pp. 128-152.
Gallagher-Watson, A 2014, Cyberbullying – Laws Struggling To Keep Up With Technology, Colin Biggers & Paisley Lawyers, viewed 17 April 2018, <https://www.cbp.com.au/insights/insights/2014/june/cyberbullying-laws-struggling-to-keep-up-with-te>.
McCosker, A 2016, ‘Managing Digital Citizenship: Cyber Safety as Three Layers of Control’, Chapter 1, Negotiating Digital Citizenship: Control, Content and Culture, Rowman & Littlefield, London.
Rossi, E 2017, Sony RX100 V Hands-On Review: Why I Returned It After 2 Months, 4 April, viewed 17 April 2018, <https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=my7zAOLUDTo>.