For the first time in quite a while my brain is trying to feed me fanfic lines and so I jotted a bit down but I'm not sure I want to pursue the threads. Gonna let it marinate and see if something emerges. Maybe the S2 finale will spark or stifle the urge.
After some time, when years of iterations had tweaked and altered the scenarios, Cate could no longer say whose thoughts had originated the daydreams, hers or her parents'. During those years there was a lot of time to think, and everyone around her did a lot of thinking, and so Cate did a lot of thinking, too, about what they thought like they were her own thoughts.
They started in different ways, maybe the doorbell rang or there was a phone call or a police cruiser rolled up the driveway, but they all ended in the same way: Caleb, smiling, returned. In the early versions Caleb, alive and whole and well, maybe hungrier for wear, had had to wait for the compulsion to wear off and he'd come running back the moment he could. Maybe some nice folk found him and tried to get him home right away but he refused their help, at first, because he had to, because of Cate's orders, but the spell wore off and they got him home. In subsequent retellings, Caleb aged, he'd come back with different stories and explanations about he survived, but always he was just waiting to return, eager to be reunited with them.
Cate's parents never stopped hoping.
Or maybe Cate never stopped hoping.
If Caleb came back maybe her parents would see that everything was ok, that Cate hadn't meant to cause Caleb any harm, that they could let Cate out of her room, that there didn't need to be a door that locked her in because Cate understood now what her powers were, what might happen, and she wouldn't do that again, and maybe her parents could stop looking at her like she was the vilest, most grotesque creature on the planet, and maybe even stop thinking it. Maybe all of them--her parents, Caleb, and Cate--could sit down together at the dinner table and have a meal. Maybe they'd all laugh. Maybe they'd all be happy. Maybe her mother and father would hug her.
A lifetime of isolated homeschooling did nothing to prepare Cate for the number of people who thought about wanting to fuck her. Even with the medication, the thoughts leaked in. The first instances were shocking--and confusing. The sources were mostly men, the older the more egregious, in the most mundane settings, after the barest of introductions or across-the-room sightings.
Cate had an idea of what friends were supposed to be, what they were supposed to do, formed from the media that had kept her company in her room and, later, the thoughts warm and dark, supportive and jealous, loyal and resentful of a student body surrounding her.
That is to say, Cate was never sure she was doing friendship correctly but she wasn't sure anyone else knew how to do it either.
Sometimes Cate looked at Jordan, bitter at their parents for being unable to accept them in their entirety, and wondered if her parents maybe could have loved her if the Compound V had made her a bigender child and not a telepath they were scared to touch. By comparison, maybe, like if her parents had been exposed to the telepathy first and then were offered the option of switching their child's powers, like software that could be deleted and installed.
Cate liked Luke and Andre, a lot, how they rolled through life with the confidence conferred by the envy of others, but Jordan could understand on some level the denial that haunted Cate: that for her parents it surely wasn't about who Cate was, but what, that if the powers that had manifested had been different, the story could have been different, too. That, beyond all the confusing frills on the surface, there was someone loveable beneath.
They had to believe that.
There were days, late nights, that Cate wished she could tell Jordan that she understood, but no one really likes knowing someone can read your mind.
But she couldn't help it.
Her inability to prevent hearing, though, never changed any judgment on the fact that she did, so maybe there really wasn't someone loveable underneath if this was who Cate was.
What people didn't know she knew couldn't hurt them.