She was ready to talk to him at last - Eli saw it as an encouraging sign. He’d had enough time to think and had come to the conclusion that he didn’t want to lose Abby - the passion may have gone from their marriage, but the life they’d built together was the most precious thing left to him. He’d already lost his purpose in life, he couldn’t lose his family as well!
Eli: “Abby, I’m so sorry! Please believe me! I know it sounds like a copout, but I never meant for it to go so far, it just...happened! Hurting you was never my intention though, I love you...”
Eli swept towards his wife, making like he was about to put his arms around her. Abby stiffened and pushed him away.
Abby: “Save your breath, Eli; I’m not here to listen to your excuses. And please don’t touch me.”
Eli shrank back as if she had slapped him, and gave her a pleading look: was she about to - no! She couldn’t!
Abby: “Here is how it’s going to be: you are going to do the right thing for once in your life. You are going to stand by your family and do your best to fix the mess you’ve made, but make no mistake, Eli: our relationship is over. We will remain married and co-parent Louis, but that is all.”
Eli: “I don’t understand...”
Abby: “Then let me make it perfectly clear: you betrayed me. Twice. Once I chose to forgive you, thinking you were a victim, but this time it’s different. You did what you did willingly and kept it hidden for months. You are a coward and a liar but I won’t let you just walk away from the consequences of your actions.”
Eli’s anger flared, drowning his guilt: how dare she! After all he’d lost! A coward?! A coward would have ended it then and there, but he had done his best to get on with life, be there for his family - and yes, the affair had been a mistake, but how dare she get all high and mighty when she was only doing this for appearances’ sake! Oh yes, Eli knew what this was about: politics!
Abby genuinely looked ready to slap him this time, but he turned his back on her before she could.
Abby: “You are a selfish man, Eli!"
Eli: “And you think everything is up to you, don’t you? That you always know best and damn the rest! Just like you did when you let Larkin lobotomize me - who gave you the right?!”
Abby was shocked; she couldn’t believe what she was hearing.
Abby: “Would you rather I had let you die?!”
Eli: “It wasn’t your decision to make!”
Abby: “But it was! It was, Eli! You were in no position to make it, so it fell to me! I chose to save you, yes, because you were my husband and I needed you, your children needed you! Are you saying they’re not worth living for?!”
They were...and yet, sometimes, they weren’t. It was not something Eli could ever explain to Abby though, she'd not had her soul ripped out of her, she couldn’t comprehend his loss. A chasm had opened up between them, never to be bridged.
Eli: “I’ll do what you ask - for them, not you. Only for them!”
Ellie, please get here soon, please oh please, Ellie!