On Loving My Best Friend at 16
It’s quiet, this loving. It sneaks up on you. One day you’re sitting beside each other and she’s playing with your hair absentmindedly and the next your heart is swelling and you can’t describe the warmth that spreads through you when she takes your hand and squeezes, but you know you’re not supposed to scoot closer to her when you’re already inches apart. And it burns to see her with that other girl but you can’t tell if you miss her and all the minutes you used to spend together or if you’re wishing you were the other girl. And does your stomach hurt when she comes out to you because you’re afraid of the implications or because you know that it means the way you heart races around her could become more real?
It’s quick, this loving. It sneaks up on you. One moment you’re laughing at one of her jokes and the next you’re wishing to kiss the smile off her face. You’ve never felt this way about a girl before and you know you shouldn’t, so you bury it but it keeps resurfacing and swallowing you whole. You’re holding hands on the way to class and she’s kissing your forehead when you’re upset and her sweater is just warm enough for those mornings when you forget yours. And you’re six feet under when you realize you’re in love with her. And she’s moving on and on and maybe when she gave you that jar of things she loved about you she meant it that way too. But it’s too far away now to touch. You’re still holding her hand but it’s distant now and you’re fighting every week and she’s pretending everything’s fine but when you call her out for lying, she says lying isn’t the worst a person can do and you stay because she loves you and you promised never to leave. And you’re still in love—how could you ever stop?—but you’re forgetting all the good for the bad. You’re in love with a statue who you can barely call best friend.
It’s long, this loving. She doesn’t deserve it and neither do you. You’re no longer 16 swinging your hands on the walk to class and she’s not kissing your forehead and reading your poems each night. You had an always like Hazel and Gus and now she flinches from your hugs. You had an always like Hazel and Gus but not like that, because just friends spend all day sending just hearts back and forth and vowing to live together above a bookstore you own together, because just friends hold hands in a dimly lit movie theatre and just friends kiss each other’s cheeks and just friends have the kind of passion people write poems about. And you haven’t talked in over a year now and it’s both of your faults and you know now that you confused manipulation for love but you still wonder if she felt that way too.
It still burns, this loving, in a forest somewhere you cannot visit. You’re lying each time you say you do not miss it.
Maybe loving your best friend was a mistake but now you know why all the poets weep. You were never meant for her. This loving was a futile thing, but it was strong and real and hopeful.
Like a bird, you set it free.











