"I wish I could hate you"
What if Timmy wasn't the only one affected by the erasure of all magic traces from his life?
[Part 2/2]
Not the continuation most would've expected, I know.
Basically, if everything magical would be removed once Timmy loses his godparents, that would also affect Nimmy. No matter his origin (through a wish that gets undone, as his magical twin etc.) he would ultimately suffer the same fate. So now, no one except Timmy knows he exists. Technically, he shouldn't even exist anymore at all.
This, excluding my redemption brainrots, is basically the only plot where the twins would team up. As polar opposites, they would make a good duo actually. And who knows, maybe they can beat Da Rules together.
I also made a story collection to this TwistedTwins AU: https://archiveofourown.org/works/49864654/chapters/125879563