Lobster's Fandomless Advent Challenge Masterlist - 2025
All of my works in one place for my own Christmas themed challenge @fandomless-advent-challenge
I will (hopefully) post something every other day and run the prompt list through January as well to extend the holiday spirit!
I will be writing for Supernatural, Criminal Minds, Buffy the Vampire Slayer & Angel, Marvel Cinematic Universe, X-Men and Doctor Who.
Please send in as many requests as you'd like! Here are the guidelines for requesting, thank you!
How to request:
Pick any prompt from the list below
Pick any character/s from Supernatural, Criminal Minds, Doctor Who, Buffy the Vampire Slayer/Angel, X-Men movies or the MCU
All fics will be x reader so if it matters to you, pick a gender (female or neutral)
I'm happy to write romantic or platonic relationships so specify if it matters to you
Send in an ask with the prompt and character + any specifics if they matter to you
I will get to your request as soon as possible and post it according to the schedule below!
Posting Schedule
December 1st - Hot Chocolate - Version 1 - Any Male Character x GN!Reader + Version 2 - Any Female Character x GN!Reader ⤷ You wake up early to make hot chocolate and he/she loves it.
December 3rd - Surprise Decorating - Donna Noble, 10th Doctor x Fem!Reader ⤷ Donna Noble, friend, confidant and Christmas fiend. The Doctor, strangely dressed. You, stuck in the middle.
December 5th - The Perfect Gift - Spencer Reid x GN!Reader ⤷ People always shut down Spencer when he tried the tell them facts, all except you.
December 7th - Snowflake - Sam Winchester x GN!Reader ⤷ Laying in Sam's arms solidifies your love. For someone else.
December 9th - An Unexpected Guest - Arthur Ketch x Fem!Reader ⤷ Sure you invited him, but you're surprised when Ketch actually takes you up on your offer. Not that you're complaining, at all.
December 11th - Frostbite - Sam Winchester x GN!Reader ⤷ As the cold seeps in, everything feels heavier. Sam noticed, and tries to lift the weight, just a little.
December 13th - An Unexpected Gift - Dean Winchester x Fem!Reader ⤷ You get Dean the one thing in life he wants, making him realises he just might want one more.
December 15th - Cozy Couch Cuddles - Sam Winchester x GN!Reader ⤷ You're sick, Sam's lovesick, how painfully sweet can the two of you be?
December 17th - Your Favourite Grinch - Bucky Barnes x Fem!Reader ⤷ Somehow, Bucky Barnes has never seen How The Grinch Stole Christmas, something you plan to remedy.
December 19th - Snowed In - Steve Rogers x Fem!Reader ⤷ One little mission results in multiple injuries, but ends up being one of the best missions of your life.
December 21st - Home for the Holidays - Spencer Reid x Fem!Reader
December 23rd - "Be my Valentine?" - "It's Christmas" - Castiel x GN!Reader
December 25th - Looking at Lights Together - Penelope Garcia, Emily Prentiss & Jennifer Jareau x Fem!Reader
December 27th - Christmas Party - Klaus Mikaelson x Fem!Reader
December 29th -
December 31st -
January 2nd -
January 4th -
January 6th -
January 8th -
January 10th -
January 12th -
January 14th -
January 16th -
January 18th -
Available Prompts
Gingerbread Construction Zone
Ice Skating
Baking Cookies
Mistletoe
Too Much Eggnog
"I didn't get you a gift" - "You are my gift"
Ugly Sweaters
Last Minute Shopping
Secret Santa
"I'm cold" - "Here, have my jacket"
Christmas Movie Night
Thank you and have a happy holiday season!