Videogames on the "Border"
Wired has a review of the new Borderlands 2 hybrid shooter that dropped this week, and the reviewer asks: "Does Borderlands exist in a little niche all its own, alienating both shooter and RPG fans alike with foreign gameplay concepts? Or is it a gateway drug, allowing nerds of both stripes to experience the joys of the other side, and ultimately leading to experimentation with harder stuff?"
The conceit of both Borderlands games is that you run around shooting things as in your standard FPS, but in an open-ended world where you take quests from NPCs, collect tons of loot which you equip for the boost in stats, and gain experience -- all to level your character up, to make him more powerful, so he can shoot bigger and badder badasses. The author in the article wonders if the FPS and RPG worlds would have a tough time blending, or whether devotees of one gameworld could coexist in another.
I would suggest what Borderlands accomplishes isn't so much the bridging of disparate genres, but the expansion of both (or to be honest, the evolution of the FPS). The hidden-in-plain-sight secret of RPGs is that people play them because: yes, they like to explore, role-play, aquire shinies, level up, etc ... but they also like to kill things. It's just in an RPG, when you kill things, you're rewarded for it. Not just the accomplishment of the kill but with the dice-roll chances of finding nice treasure or with gold, and usually a smidge of experience. This isn't to suggest that FPS players are satisfied with more witless entertainment; just that the reward options are a lot more diverse in the RPG world.
So will a hybrid be a gateway game, bringing the two, seldom mixed classes together -- sort of like the end of a 90s high school movie where the jocks and the goths got together in the parking lot for a musical number? Maybe, but as an RPG fan who used to play of lot FPS and grew tired of them, it's more of just the feeling of eating your cake and having it too. Maybe that's the future of these games ... a mashup of the elements from all that work the best.