Summary: Based off of the song All In My Head by Tori Kelly, lots of flashbacks, Reader looks back on her time with Michael while he was graceless
Pairing: Michael x Reader, Michael x Sadie (it’s confusing)
Characters: Human!Michael, Reader, Sadie (OC angel)
A/N: Italics are flashbacks. I meant to make this happy but it just took a turn for the worse, very very worse.
When Michael showed up at your door a month ago, you were shocked to say the least. Apparently he had lost his grace and the first person he thought to go to was you. The first couple days had been a little rough, having to constantly remind the former angel to eat and sleep, but eventually he got the hang of it. It made you beyond happy when he chose to stay and help you hunt. You may or may not be harbouring a slight crush on Michael. Okay so you were in love with him. Originally you had thought that there was no way he could love you back, but now you weren’t so sure......
“I’m coming.” You walked to the door, expecting anyone but who was there. “Michael?”
“What are you doing here? And why didn’t you just poof in?”
“Well, I kinda lost my grace.” Lost his grace? Did that mean...
“Are you human?” He nodded and you waved him in, shutting the door behind him. “What happened?”
“I don’t really want to talk about it. Can I stay here for a little while? At least until I get the hang of the whole human thing? You’re the only one I trust right now.”
“Yeah, Michael, stay as long as you want.”
“It’s not your fault Michael.”
“Yes it is. If I had just been a little faster, the werewolf wouldn’t have gotten close enough to hurt you.”
“Michael, people get hurt. It is not your fault. You did your best.”
“I know, I just hate seeing you in pain.”
“Michael? Earth to Michael?” He jumped, as if he forgot that you were sitting there.
“What?” You laughed at his look of innocence.
“You were staring again.”
“Sorry.” He looked down, and you smiled at the blush that crept across his face.
“Yeah, Michael?” You looked up from the lore book you were reading.
“Do you want to go to the movies? Take a break from the case? There’s that new Marvel movie you were talking about seeing?”
“Sure.” He hadn’t looked up the whole conversation, but she could see a smile light up his face.
“That was awesome!” Michael chuckled and you looked over at him. “What?” You asked laughing.
“You’ve already said that. Like 7 times.”
“Cause it was! And that ending scene with Thor was hilarious!” He smiled looking down at the ground.
“Morning, sleepy head.” You opened your eyes to find Michael sitting at the table, research books opened.
“What time is it?” You groaned.
“What?! Why didn’t you wake me up?” You jumped out of bed.
“You needed the rest. Plus you’re cute when you sleep.” You blushed, running into the bathroom to get ready for the day.
Which all led up to where you were now, about to go into the warehouse you had tracked the demon to. You walked in, only to find someone had beat you there. The demon was tied to a chair, while a woman stood there questioning it. You turned to say something, only to find his jaw hanging open.
“Sadie?” She turned when Michael spoke, her face lighting up.
“Mikey!” She ran and jumped into his arms, capturing his lips in a kiss, while you stood there dumbfounded. “Guess what ?”
“What babe?” You watched the whole exchange, apparently forgotten about.
“I’ve been chasing down demons and look what I found.” She held out a vial that was glowing.
“My grace?” She nodded and he spun her around, both of them laughing. He drunk the vial and then they both disappeared, without so much as a goodbye. Leaving you alone in the warehouse with the demon.
