It's always interesting to me when I see people make Alice and Henry out to be really close friends or sibling like. Because, before the curse they didn't interact much and didn't really have positive interactions at all. They literally meet because Alice was asked by Rumplestiltskin— a man she met a few hours earlier— for help with his grandson. That help being drugging him then kidnapping or making him see that room/cave thing with the vines while drugged. And yk obviously in a show like OUAT first impressions aren't typically the best to go off of, but Alice had knowledge she shouldn't have had and told Henry about it in a warning.
Then months go by and the next time they see each other it's on the edge of the resistance camp because Alice was looking for her dad. In this scene its obvious that Henry doesn't really like her but Ella's the one to hear her out first because she's introduced to her as being "from wonderland."
After that I'm not sure we get another scene of them set before the curse. Which leads me to their first curse meeting, a less hostile meeting but still strange. Tilly sees Henry go to Roni's bar from the roof of a short building, stares him down while getting down from there, continues to just stare this random guy down then walks off.
Now, if my memory serves correctly, they see each other again when Rogers needs her help getting information on Eloise Gardener. And what exactly is Tilly doing when he sees her again? Selling stolen watches. In this episode they also briefly are in the same scene when she tells Rogers what she found out.
Again, if my memory is accurate to this shows timeline, they meet again when Rogers needs a place to hide Tilly. And yk he agreed and stuff and doesn't think Tillys capable of murder. But him and Tilly don't really talk directly to each other.
Its interesting to me that theyre often characterized as closer than they are because yeah Henry cares about her and Alice is grateful for Henry by the end of season 7. They're also barely in each other's lives for most of the time they know each other. Hell if anything Alice is closer to Ella just from their scene together in episode 8 😭😭 (which I will make a separate post about)
Anyway, if you hc them as being friends that's great, have whatever characterization you want!! I can't stop you lol


















