October 4th, 2017- IT (2017), Andy Muschietti
So first of all I’m a liar. We did not watch this last night we actually watched it the day after it came out and then we went home and watched IT (1990) and then we woke up the next day and talked about the two IT’s all day and then we went to go see IT (2017) again. I’m reviewing it now because we got distracted watching The Great British Bake Off last night and forgot to watch a horror movie.
“I really liked IT” would be the understatement of the year. I thought it was smart, brutal, joyful, all while being reverent of the original. It was a little heavy handed with the themes at times, and they took the floating concept to a weirdly literal conclusion, but overall I thought it was a more than worthy update.
Bill Skarsgard’s Pennywise has a heightened supernatural quality. It’s easy to see him as a malevolent creature; some old bit of evil arcana embodied. He’s a monster for sure, not a guy in a clown suit. This concept is brought home by clever attention to detail. His eye color changes when he goes in for the kill, his face opens into a toothy mess along the lines of his clown makeup, his general size seems to change from scene to scene. His presence is bigger than a creepy clown, which is great because I’m not a coulrophobe. Which is not to say Tim Curry’s Pennywise falls flat. That is a classic, incredibly creepy performance, but watching them back to back I do get more of a “ew it’s a creepy hobo in a clown costume” vibe from Curry compared to “oh hey it’s fear incarnate” from the update. Also one is a TV movie from the 90’s and one is an R-Rated movie from right now so that probably has something to do with it.
The cast is awesome. Definitely got the same nostalgic rush as I did from Stranger Things. Both are such great tributes to kid gang movies of the 80’s and 90’s. It’s the kind of material that makes you really excited about the way people are treating horror recently and the time and intention that is going into these movies/shows. It’s not a throwaway genre!
I also thought the fears were done really well. Each individual kid’s greatest fear says a lot about their character, upbringing and maturity level. Some of them are dealing with grief, some of them are being abused on a day to day basis and some of them are scared of a painting in their dad’s office (albeit a really creepy painting). There is a wide range of experiences and levels of fear, but all of their fear is real and dangerous. It feels high stakes, even though the solution is ultimately as simple as just stick together.
Another thing I really liked about the update was that they included the house on Neibolt Street, a great haunted house scene from the book. It was pretty much everything I want out of an iconic haunted house sandwiched into a coming of age monster movie.
I feel like IT gave me a horror movie sampler with some real scares and great acting and writing. I will most likely go see IT another time in theaters because giving my money to Stephen King and everyone else involved feels good.
9 out of 10. This was really close to a perfect horror movie to me. LOVED IT.