LOVE AT FIRST PROJECT
SUMMARY: Jenna Ortega has had a crush on you ever since you worked together on her series Stuck in the Middle. But you never realized she had feelings for youâuntil years later, when you reunited on Wednesday Season 2. The truth comes to light while the two of you appear alongside the cast on a game show to promote the series.
WARNING: nothing, fluffâwith a lil bit of angsty
---
Jenna Ortega has known you for almost a decade now. She first met you on the set of Stuck in the Middle Season 2, when she was just fourteen years old.
You, at sixteen, were already making a name for yourselfâa rising singer and actress in Hollywood. Even then, people on the internet recognized you as a trendsetter, admired for your bold style and the way you dressed better than anyone else in the room.
The very first time Jenna laid eyes on you, her world seemed to slow to a haltâas clichĂ© as it may sound. Her breath caught in her throat, her dark eyes widened in wonder, and her heart began to race uncontrollably in her chest.
You seemed to glow under the studio lights, and though you were surrounded by people, Jennaâs gaze remained locked on youâlike you were the moon among billions of scattered stars.
To her, you were simply the most beautiful person in the room. When the director formally introduced you to her, she felt a strange fluttering in her stomachâa ticklish, electric feeling that made her realize she had developed a crush on you.
But reality wasnât kind to her. During the short time you were on set together, Jenna could never quite work up the courage to be close with you. Whenever she tried to speak, her words tangled clumsily on her tongue, and she found herself stuttering in your presence.
Her cheeks would flush crimson, forcing you to ask if she was alright each time. You had her completely wrapped around your finger without even knowing itâshe was a flustered mess, a shy girl struggling to build even the simplest connection.
And as fate would have it, her time with you was cut short. Your role only lasted a few episodesâfour, to be exact. No one even told Jenna when you were leaving; she only realized it when she filmed a scene where your character was mentioned as having left for Europe.
After that shoot, she quietly asked the director about you. The answer shattered her: your work on the show was already done. The thought that you hadnât even said goodbye stung her deeply, though a part of her knew it wasnât surprising. After all, the two of you had barely exchanged ten words off-cameraâblame her flustered mess for that.
And to make matters worse, Jenna had never been the type to approach the people she likedâthen, or now. So instead of reaching out to you directly, she kept her distance. Instead of calling you, she found herself mentioning youâover and over again, on camera.
In every interview where she was asked who her celebrity crush was, your name always slipped from her lips. If the question was about someone she wanted to work with, or someone she fancied, people could already guess her answerâit was always you.
At first, she was shy about admitting her feelings publicly. Back then, most people either admired you because you were trending or because they wanted to be like you. And since the world wasnât so open about LGBTQ+ identities yet, they assumed Jenna only looked up to you, saw you as a role model.
But as she grew older, her answers only grew bolder. In every press junket, every movie promotion, every fan Q&Aâyour name lingered like a constant shadow. It didnât take long before fans started shipping the two of you, even though you hadnât spoken to herâhadnât even interacted with herâsince those early days.
People loved to believe there was something secret going on between you. They pointed out âcluesâ: you both wearing what looked like the same jacket, or being spotted in the same places. But those were just silly coincidences, baseless rumors. The truth was simplerâyou and Jenna had never spoken, not once since she was fourteen.
You had no idea you were being shipped with Jenna Ortega. In fact, you barely even knew who she wasâuntil you watched Wednesday Season 1. And that only happened because your friend, Olivia Rodrigo, forced you to sit through it.
You had no clue that Jenna harbored something deeper than admiration for you. No idea that while promoting Wednesday, she didnât just casually mention you as someone she wanted to work with, or someone she likedâshe went further. She said it boldly, confidently, fearlessly: you were her woman.
Yes. Without your knowledge or permission, Jenna Ortega claimed you as hers. But you were blissfully unaware. You werenât active on social media, and for good reason. It had ruined you once before, and you swore never to let it ruin you again.
But fate works in curious ways. When Wednesday Season 2 was confirmedâwith Jenna not just as its star but also as one of the producersâshe finally had the power to pull some strings. And she did. She begged the team to offer you a role, insisted that they bring you on board.
But you werenât just an actressâyou were also a singer, a global one at that. Your career was stretched between film and music, and at first, you declined the offer. You were in the middle of a world tour; your priorities lay elsewhere.
The producers called again, this time with more desperation in their voices, but still, you refused. Touring was your world, your commitment. And when Jenna heard of your rejection, it crushed her. Hopelessness wrapped around her like chains, and in a moment of weakness, she even wondered if she should learn how to manipulate you into saying yes. She nearly convinced herself to do it.
Lucky for youâand maybe lucky for her tooâher sanity, and her heart, stopped her just in time. The third time they called you came two months after filming had already begun. By then, the role originally meant for you had been given to someone elseâbut fate, in its strange way, intervened. The actress who took the part had fallen seriously ill and was barred from working for several months.
This time, it wasnât a producer or some studio executive on the line. It was Tim Burton himself. His voice, dark and deliberate, carried a kind of conviction that only he could muster. He told you he believed in youâthat you were the one who could breathe life into this character. That you werenât just a fit for the roleâyou were the role.
And oh, Jenna Ortega nearly kissed the ground he walked on when she heard you had finally agreed. She thought Tim had performed some kind of miracle. She didnât know the truth: that your âyesâ had less to do with him, or even with her, and everything to do with timing. You had just wrapped up your world tour, exhausted and raw, and the network had been pushing to send you onto a show you despised. To you, Tim Burtonâs offer wasnât just a roleâit was a lifeline, an open window in a house where every door had been locked.
No auditions. No grueling callbacks. Just your name, written on the contract, the role already secured for you. When the paperwork was settled and you finally stepped onto set, it was as if the universe itself had rewound time.
And Jennaâoh, dear Jenna. The moment her eyes landed on you again, the same rush she had felt years ago came crashing back. Her chest tightened, her breath faltered, her heart pounded like a drum of war. Time slowed, just like it had when she was fourteen, and youâstill glowing, still magneticâstood there as though you had stepped straight out of her memory and into her present.
When you approached her, Tim Burton himself made the introduction. And Jennaâoh, Jennaânearly collapsed on the spot. She swore her soul tried to escape her body the instant you stood in front of her.
âHi, my name isâwait, are you okay? Your nose is bleeding.â
Yes. As humiliating as it sounds, Jenna Ortega got a nosebleed the very first time she saw you again after all those years. Of course, she had seen you countless times beforeâyou just never knew it. She was always there in the crowd at your tours, whether you were performing in the West or halfway across Asia. Always present. Never absent. Her dedication hadnât gone unnoticed by the media, either; fans quickly pieced together what her constant presence meant. Jenna Ortega was, without a doubt, enamored with you.
And in that moment on set, as she stood mortified with blood dripping down her nose, Jenna wished she could evaporate into thin air. It was clichĂ©, cartoonish even, to have a nosebleed in front of her crushâbut fate had a cruel sense of humor. From then on, her co-stars never let her live it down. They teased her mercilessly, and the whole world seemed to know about her crush⊠except for you.
When Jenna finally mustered the courageâironic, considering she was a woman with the heart of a lionessâto talk to you properly, she decided to settle for friendship. That became her safe ground, her refuge. And to her surprise, it worked. You were oblivious, completely unaware of her little public display of affection, and Jenna secretly reveled in that. It gave her space to breathe, to pretend she was cool around you, even though on the inside she was dying. Half her mind begged her to steal a kiss; the other half forced her to play it safe.
But her patience was tested when youâher own crushâstarted shipping her with Emma Myers. Can you imagine it? Jenna Ortega, being âWenclairâdâ by the one person she wished would ship her with you.
It wasnât shocking, of course. Jenna herself was partly to blame for the Wenclair craze, but now that you were part of the seriesânow that your character was essential to the storyâshe thought, at the very least, youâd create a new ship with her.
Youâd done it before. Your âY/Viaâ ship with Olivia Rodrigo still had loyal fans, even though Olivia had a boyfriend now. Your playful ship with Dakota Johnson had been so strong it landed on billboards. You were the captain of these ships, the architect of fandom pairings, the one who breathed life into them.
So why not her? Why not you and Jenna? Why not your character with Wednesday Addams, when the chemistry was undeniable? Why couldnât you see how perfect the pairing was? Was it because you were too invested in Wenclair?
That question lingered in Jennaâs mind, unanswered, each day you worked together. Even as your friendship grew closer, stronger, untouchable, she never dared to ask.
But the irony was cruel: you werenât refusing to ship yourself with her because you didnât see it. You werenât ignoring the possibility because you didnât care. Noâquite the opposite.
You didnât ship it because somewhere along the way⊠you had fallen in love with her.
You couldnât help it. The time you spent together, the countless scenes you shared, the easy banter that sparked on and off setâit all chipped away at your defenses. And soon enough, the entire cast had caught on. They teased you both relentlessly, whispering how Wednesday Addams belonged not with Enid, but with your character.
The chemistry was laid bare for all to see. All but you and Jenna, who stood in the middle of it, pretending it wasnât thereâwhile your hearts told a very different story.
And so the little game of hiding feelings dragged on, even after the cameras stopped rolling. Months slipped past, your life swallowed by writing and recording songs for your new albumâand through it all, Jenna Ortega was there.
She had been with you from the very beginning, when the âsong ideaâ was nothing more than a scribble in your notebook: a track about a woman yearning for another woman⊠one who was in love with a man. You wrote it because of her. Because every thought, every lyric, circled back to Jenna. And you assumed, with painful certainty, that she was straight.
But you were wrong. She was hella gayâfor you.
You didnât know that, of course. All you knew was she said yes when you asked her to appear in your music video, brushing off her packed schedule as if your request mattered more than another film set, more than her reputation. She didnât even ask for pay. She just⊠showed up.
And god, you admired her. Her relentless work ethic, the way she balanced chaos and precision, her fire. Sometimes, in the quiet spaces of your mind, you let yourself imagine being her girlfriend instead of just her friend. Waking up early to make her breakfast before a shoot. Standing offstage while she worked, ready to catch her exhaustion in your arms. Pressing kisses to her temple when she collapsed into bed at night.
You did some of those things alreadyâjust not with the title you wanted. Not as her partner. Just as a friend. And that word burned you from the inside out.
Because you wanted to be more. Wife material. Future material. But instead, you were her sweet, reliable friend.
Which is why it hurt so badly, sitting there during promotions for Wednesday Season 2, watching her laugh with Percyâyour co-star who played Xavier.
The cast had been invited to film an episode of Hot Ones, the YouTube gauntlet of scorching wings and burning secrets. Everyone was crammed around tables, cameras and lights crowding the air, but your eyes refused to leave the pair across the room. Percy leaning closer, Jenna smiling at something he said. Too close. Too easy.
You couldnât stop staring. That was your flaw. When jealousy wrapped its claws around you, you always looked directly at the wound, pressing down on the bruise until it hurt worse.
And the internet hadnât helped. Weeks earlier, a TikTok rumor had exploded: Percy and Jenna spotted having dinner together. Whispers of dating, speculation climbing. She never told you about it, despite how religiously you shared timetables, daily updates, the tiniest details of life. The silence around it was deafening.
So now, watching them together, your mind spun. Was it true?
You sat stiff at your table beside Joy and Emma, their chatter washing over you like static, while across the room Jenna and Percyâs laughter carved fresh bruises in your chest.
âThey look so cute together. Theyâd make a good couple, right?â A staffer dropped a plate of wings onto your table, oblivious to the knife they had just twisted.
âYeah. Yeah, I guess,â you answered, forcing a polite smile. Bitterness hid behind your teeth, and only god knew how badly it hurt to say it.
Because what could you do? Nothing. Nothing at all. You were the one who blurred lines between performance and reality, who let fiction bleed into truth until you couldnât tell the difference. On screen, your character and hers had chemistry scripted into existence, feelings hidden beneath playful banter. On screen, love was inevitable.
But off screen? You convinced yourself it could never happen.
What you didnât know was Jenna felt the same. For over a year, friendship had been her shield, but every time your hand brushed hers, every time your smile lingered, she wanted more. She wanted you. She was terrified of losing you if she confessed, convinced you werenât interestedâno matter how many signs she missed.
Emma Myers, however, missed nothing. She had been watching you both with the patience of a cat stalking prey, sick of the constant sidelong glances, the loaded silences, the yearning etched into every stolen second.
âUrgh, could these two just confess and kiss already,â Emma muttered under her breath, eyes flicking between you and Jenna.
âWho?â Joy asked, innocence written across her face.
âNo one,â Emma deflected, though the wheels in her head had already started turning. She couldnât sit by and watch this misery unfold any longer.
By the time the cameras started rolling, Emma Myers had a plan.
And the gameâthe dangerous, ridiculous, inevitable gameâhad begun.
At first, Emma went for you.
When she drew the card, she knew the professional move would be to stick to the script. But Emma Myers wasnât in the mood for âprofessional.â Not when sheâd spent months watching you and Jenna dance around your feelings like star-crossed idiots.
So she went off-script.
âThis oneâs for you,â she said, her eyes locking on you with theatrical adoration. The crowd leaned forward, sensing her tone shift. Jennaâs gaze, though, never waveredâshe had been staring at you whenever she thought no one was watching, and Emma knew it.
âIf you could play a lesbian role, and you got to choose your co-star from people you already knowâwho would it be, and why? Answer the question⊠or eat a death wing.â
The room gasped and cackled, voices overlapping in a chorus of âooohs.â The staff exchanged confused looks, clearly wondering if that question had been on the card. It hadnât. But the cameras were rolling, and improv made for good television.
You blinked, heat rising to your cheeks. Your eyes flicked instinctively toward Jenna. It wasnât loud, it wasnât obviousâjust the kind of fleeting glance that spoke volumes to the one person who was desperate to catch it. Jennaâs chest tightened, her heart stumbling in its rhythm.
For Emma, that was confirmation enough. She expected you to say Jennaâs name, to rip the mask off then and there. But when you opened your mouth, you saidâ
âDakota Johnson, as always.â
Emmaâs smile faltered. âWhy?â she pressed, disappointment edging her voice.
You shrugged, tone light, professional. âItâs Dakota Johnson, love. Who wouldnât want to kiss Dakota Johnson?â
The table erupted in laughter and nods. A safe, clever answer. You handled it well. Too well. Emma narrowed her eyes. Professional or not, she wasnât letting you wriggle out of this game.
She waited for her next round, studying you and Jenna as you exchanged subtle glances, smiles that lingered too long, silences filled with unspoken tension. She was tired of it.
When her turn came again, Emma struckânot at you this time, but at Jenna.
âJenna,â Emma said sweetly, setting her card down. âEat a death wing⊠or tell the truth.â
Jenna smirked, ready. âGo on.â
Emma leaned in, her eyes gleaming with mischief. âOn The Tonight Show with Jimmy Fallon back in 2022, you claimed Y/N was your woman. And even before that, you used to say she was your crush. Soâwas that true? And if it was⊠do you still have a crush on her?â
The room froze.
Jennaâs eyes went wide, her expression instantly betraying her. Color flooded her cheeks, spreading fast until her face burned redder than the hot sauces lined on the table. She hadnât even touched a death wing yet, but the way she fumbled, the way she stared down at her plateâit looked like sheâd just swallowed fire.
The cameras caught everything.
And you⊠you sat there stunned, your chest tightening as if someone had just ripped the air from the room.
âItâs true.â
Jennaâs voice was steady, but her chest felt like it was splitting open. Finally, sheâd cleared the crystal buried beneath mud. But the air hung heavy, unsatisfied, as if more needed to be said.
And before she could add another wordâ
âWhat? You used to have a crush on me?â you blurted out, eyes locked onto hers, searching for something. Expectancy, disbelief, maybe even disappointment.
The possibility of your disappointment was enough to make Jenna fold.
âNot used to. I still do.â Her throat tightened, but she forced the words out. âJust⊠deeper than a crush now. âCrushâ feels childish when youâre twenty-three.â
Emma nearly shouted finally! but clamped her mouth shut, pressing her lips together so hard they hurt.
âSeriously?â you asked, stunnedâyour voice laced with a strange cocktail of relief and disbelief.
âYeah.â
âSince when?â
âSince forever.â Jenna muttered it like a confession to the floor, her shoulders tense as if bracing for rejection. But rejection didnât come. You werenât like thatâyou never had been. You were an actress, a singer, someone who could mask anything when the cameras were rolling.
So you masked it. For the rest of the show, you smiled, joked, and went along as if nothing had cracked open. The game carried on. Emma let it drop. And yet, under your skin, something buzzedâan ache, a thrill, a dizzy disbelief.
The love of your life had just confessed. And you? You were over the moon⊠and furious at yourself for not realizing sooner.
When filming wrapped, you rose first. Your manager fell into step beside you, rattling off tomorrowâs schedule, but her words blurred into static. Your focus was tethered to Jenna, who lingered across the room with Emma.
She caught your gaze. She smiled. You smiled back.
Your manager sighed, gentle but firm. âGo talk to her. Iâll save the schedule lecture for later.â
And you went.
Jenna excused herself from Emma, closing the distance until the two of you stood almost too closeâcloser than co-stars, closer than friends, closer than youâd ever dared to be before. She bit her lower lip, trembling under the weight of your eyes.
Her heart was a drumline, each beat faster, louder, harder. You just wanted to kiss her.
âWas it true?â you asked, voice low enough to curl down her spine like smoke.
âY-yes. And Iâm sorry⊠but you donât have to say anything about rejection, I knowââ
âWould you like to have a dinner date with me later? On me.â
Her brain short-circuited. âD-dinner date?â
You chuckled, leaning in until your words brushed her ear. âYes. Dinner date.â
Jenna could hardly contain herself. Her longtime crush, the girl she thought would politelyâor harshlyâbrush her off, maybe laugh it away, had just asked her out. On a dinner date. A dinner date.
Her head spun with the words. It sounded like a positive outcome. It was a positive outcome. Right?
Her heart thumped like a jackhammer as she replayed it in her mind. Dinner date. Those two syllables shouldâve been enough to soothe her panic, but noâher overthinking was louder than her pulse.
Dinner date⊠but was it romantic, or just a glorified friend hangout? A soft âthanks for liking me but we're better off friendsâ kind of dinner? Or the candlelit, butterflies-in-your-stomach kind sheâd been secretly scripting in her head since she was fourteen?
She tried to breathe, but it came out shaky Her nerves cracked. âFriendly⊠or romantic?â
âThe latter,â you whispered. âHopefully we kill those rumors too.â
Jenna Ortega nearly squealed. She wanted to jump, hug you, kiss youâeverything at once. Instead, she managed a breathless nod.
âSo thatâs your way of telling me Iâm not rejected?â You nodded, lips curling into the faintest smirk.
âAnd maybe my way of trying to steal your heart from your rumored boyfriend.â
The joke slipped out smooth, half-teasing, half-claiming. And when Jenna chuckledâsoft, nervous, but genuineâyou felt something in your chest unclench. She hated that rumor as much as you did. If she was going to be linked to someone, why couldnât it be you? Why couldnât the headlines, the whispers, the TikToks, all point toward the thing both of you secretly wanted?
In that moment, Jenna thought she could die happy.
So she did something recklessâsomething bold in its own quiet way. She canceled her evening shoot, claiming she felt unwell. Which wasnât entirely a lie. Her chest felt tight, her pulse refused to calm, her mind spinning like a carousel with only your face painted on every horse.
Backstage, she all but floated toward Emma, who greeted her with a smug grin that said mission accomplished.
âI went off-script,â Emma confessed with zero shame, like a kid caught with frosting on her fingers. âFigured somebody had to do it.â
Jenna, cheeks still warm, just laughedâsoft and grateful. She didnât even bother scolding her. Instead, she hugged her co-star, whispering a thank-you against her shoulder.
Because at lastâwhether it was scripted fate or messy, unscripted realityâEnid and Wednesday still had each otherâs backs. Even beyond the cameras. Even in real life.











