Staggering Drunk All The Time
27 JULY 1883. Austin Daily Statesman.
THE SHOOTING AFFRAY -- At the Avenue Hotel -- Capt. Winn and His Wife Both Shot, One Through the Arm and the Other in the Hand -- Full Particulars -- Statement of Both Sides
On the heels of the excitement, so to speak, of the raid of the highwayman, came another quite as startling, in the shooting of Capt. Winn and his wife, yesterday, at the Avenue Hotel. It occurred about half past 10 o'clock in the morning, and no sooner were the shots heard than a large crowd thronged to the hotel office and on the stairs leading thereto, to learn the particulars of the tragic affair. A reporter for the Statesman happened to be near the spot at the time of the shooting and at once pushed his way through the mass of people and was admitted to the rooms where the wounded man and woman lay.
In an interview with Capt. Winn, he said that J. C. Terrell came to his hotel several days ago in a very deplorable condition, having been on a drunken spree for several weeks (to all appearance), and asked to be admitted as a guest, saying he would like to remain a few weeks, until he could sober up and entirely recover from the debauch he had been on. The captain says he told him that he was a stranger and he could not take him unless he paid in advance. He referred the captain to Col. Murphy whom, he said, well knew him and who would vouch for his responsibility. The captain refused to permit him to become a guest of the hotel unless he paid in advance, stating that he had not to look up Col. Murphy. The man then told him he would pay $20 on his bill and when he had boarded that out he would get more money to pay him further. The captain says he told him this would be all right and gave him a room; the man giving him $20. The captain says he asked him how long he would want the room and he replied about twenty days. "Very well, then," said the captain, "I will take this money and use it," to which the man replied, "All right, do with it as you like, for I shall stay with you more than long enough to use it up." Upon this statement Capt. Winn says he took the money and used it as his own. The man was shown to his room and every attention paid him.
Thus matters went on until day before yesterday, when Mr. Terrell concluded to leave Austin and told Capt. Winn that he would like to settle with him. The captain said all right, but I have used the money and I have not enough today to pay the balance coming to you, but will collect it in a short time. They settled, and there was a balance due Terrell of $14.50. A Mr. Cune was owing about that amount, and he gave the man an order on that gentleman for the amount due Terrell. The latter took the order to Cune, but Cune did not pay it and he brought it back. Captain Winn then gave him a note for the amount, and the man went out to negotiate the due bill. The captain says he tried to sell the due bill and collect the money on the order too, and so when he came in demanded the papers from him. He did not stay that night at the hotel, but went away with the understanding that he would come in yesterday morning and get his money.
Yesterday morning he came back, but Captain Will says Cune had not paid him yet and he did not have the money for him. He asked to go to his room and the clerk gave him the key, and when he came back he claimed to have lost it. Then he demanded of Capt. Winn shirts and a coat which he claimed he had left with the hotel proprietor. Capt. Winn says he told him he did not leave any coat and shirts with him. Terrell claimed that he did, and some hot words followed. After the man had said considerable the captain made the remark, so he says, that the man was so drunk he did not know what he had been doing, judging from the fact he had lost the key to his room and accused him (Capt. Winn) of having his coat and shirt when he did not have them at all.
This made Terrell very angry, and he replied: "You think I am so drunk I don't know what I did with the coat and shirts?" "Yes, that is my opinion," replied the captain. "Well," said the man, "I will do this, then," and as he said it he took out his revolver and pointed it at the captain. Then he walked back without shooting, and Capt. Winn stepped into the hall. Terrell followed him and said, "That is your opinion is it?" to which the captain again replied: "It is."
"I will do this -- there," responded Terrell, and fired: the ball entering Capt. Winn's arm just about midway between the elbow and wrist, lodging against the bone. Mrs. Winn and her nephew then seized Terrell and tripping him threw him to the floor. When he fell Mrs. Winn went down with him, falling on top. As he lay there he deliberately, she says, put the pistol to her breast to shoot, and as he did that she seized it with her left hand, the palm of the hand closing over the muzzle. While she held the pistol in that position Terrell fired it, and the charge went through the center of her hand. Such is the statement of Capt. Winn and his wife.
A reporter for the Statesman interviewed J. C. Terrell, the man who did the shooting, at the city jail, and his story is, in some respects, widely different from Capt. Winn's.
He says his home is in Rocky Springs, Miss., and he came to Austin for his health. That he is a wealthy farmer and merchant at that place, but has been drinking very hard of late and since the 16 inst. has been "staggering drunk all the time," to use his own words. He went to the Avenue Hotel, but he says he did not tell the landlord how long he would stay or make any contract with him whatever. That he gave him $20, simply as a deposit for safe-keeping, and Captain Winn took it and used it without any permission at all. When he came to pay his bill the captain did not have the money to pay him the balance and gave him the order, which the man on whom it was drawn refused to honor, when he took the captain's note and started for the train but was left. He did not go back to the hotel that night but stayed with Mrs. Moore.
Yesterday morning he went to the hotel to get his coat and shirt, which he is very positive he left with Capt. Winn, and when he asked for them the captain told him he did not have them. He says he asked the captain if that was the way he treated his guests, at which Capt. Winn became very angry and used abusive language. He says he was angered at this language and took out his pistol and tried to kill the captain. He stated he meant to kill him, and it was because he did not aim as he intended that he did not.
He agreed with Mrs. Winn about that lady and her nephew throwing him to the floor, but positively denied that he shot Mrs. Winn and declared with as much positiveness that only one shot was fired and that only one empty shell was found in his revolver.
He was asked by the Statesman reporter if Mrs. Winn was in the room when he shot Capt. Winn, and he said she was not; that only himself and the captain were present. He was then asked if Mrs Winn could possibly have been hit by the shot fired at Capt. Winn, and he replied he was sure such a thing could not have occurred. After so stating he was asked how he could account for the wound in Mrs. Winn's hand? This he could not account for, and only reiterated he did not shoot her. Such is his statement.