Heroes - Master Fic Rec List
Petlar
Wall Fics
Walled In - Sylar's been flirting with Peter for some time. Peter's resistance finally crumbles, but he's never been one for half-measures. (Her masterlist of Petar werks)
Together - They were together in the nightmare for five years.
Up Against The Wall - It seems to you that you’ve been here forever, as you lie on your cold, lumpy bed and stare up at the ceiling. Days, weeks, months, even years... what does it matter when every passing second only serves as a reminder that this life sentence is eternal and you’re never, ever getting out of it?
A Monster and A Man - So many emotions swirling about so fast that Peter only catches one, the one that repeats over and over. Fear.
Post Wall (Season 5) Fics
Hurt and Comfort - Peter's paramedic unit got a call for an apparent assault victim in a bad district of town: male, Caucasian, possibly broken arm, blood on his face, uncooperative.
Phone Sex - Peter and Gabriel call Noah to inform him that Gabriel is no longer a threat and get a little sidetracked.
Past Mistakes - No one expected what Claire Bennett's actions would have caused when she jumped off of the ferris wheel at the carnival. Three years later, Gabriel Gray finds himself alone. A chance meeting with an old enemy starts to change that.
Future Fics (5 years later)
Not So Simple Understanding - Different take on future events when Peter finds Sylar living happily with a child.
My Hero Is You - Peter goes to the future, learns something very interesting and returns to the past to make sure at least some of the future comes true.
First Season Fics
New Obsession - Peter can paint the future. So can Sylar. So neither was surprised when they suddenly slipped into an 'episode' and started to paint. If they had been next to each other, they might have thought it was odd that they had begun at the exact same time.
Games - Sylar and Peter have an...understanding.
Mirror Mirror, followed by We, The Fallen - Walking is hard, especially days, weeks, months on end. And he’s been walking, hasn’t he? For so long.
I Remember You - An expanded version of the confrontation from “Parasite”/".07%" How things ought to have gone down, at least in my head.
Obsession - “So you can find anyone - no matter where they are?”
Thick As Thieves - Part 1, Part 2, Part 3 - Peter lived through the nuclear discharge and after much deliberation decided to come back to New York conveniently without telling anyone he was still alive. But he soon finds out he isn’t the only one to have survived that night.
Let's Dance - a smutty AU take on Peter and Sylar's first meeting
Possibilities - Sylar can’t stop painting Peter.
Looking At the World From the Bottom of a Well - Somewhere, in between days, Sylar stopped hating them, and he started wishing that maybe they didn’t hate him so very much.
Painted - They all come back to the studio eventually.
Collision - What if Sylar had gone another way dealing with Peter?
Other World Outcome Fics
What Once Was - Sylar finds the piece of glass which killed Peter the first time. Of course Peter is there to comfort and help him with his guilt.
Fetishes - Part 1: A character with shape shifting discusses the impact the ability has on his sex life. Not graphic, just funny. Part 2: Gabriel's desire for rough sex pushes Peter to his limits.
As You Were - Peter sometimes wishes he could go back to that far simpler time when they were just enemies. Even that strange period when they thought they were brothers was better than this weird, twisted relationship. Wasn't it?
Shattered Salvation - This is the chronological compilation of the stories set in the Shattered Salvation AU, including Shattered Identity, Salvation of Acceptance, Bonus and Mature editions. It's a love story between Peter and Gabriel, set after The Fifth Stage.
Mask
Complete AU
A Little Thing - In which Peter's usual Saturday night activities are interrupted by Gabriel and his damned baseball cap, and his plots for its demise go slightly awry. (Kinda ooc, but cute)
Kindred Spirits - Part 1, Part 2 - Peter Petrelli befriends a lonely and depressed Gabriel Gray during their senior year in high school. (Best Petlar ever)
A Walk Down the Dark Path - Peter was in the last year of college when he met Gabriel, the soft spoken watch maker. Things were going well, but eventually Gabriel's jealousy and the need to prove himself led him going down the path of becoming Sylar…
Deception - Part 1, Part 2, Part 3, Part 4, Part 5, Part 6 - Sylar can't help but take advantage of Peter's new condition.
Some Parties Are More Fun Away From The Party - A Petrelli Family Reunion with a Peter/Sylar twist.
Homophobia - Peter and Gabriel walk down the street holding hands one night, when they get a rude reminder of the brutality of the world.
Of Bookstores and Past Encounters - Sylar corners Peter in the middle of a bookstore.
Fear Not For the Future - Part 1, Part 2, Part 3, Part 4, Part 5 - His destiny begins with one phrase, "Stop Sylar, save the world," uttered by a man from the future, a man with Peter's face. Set in an alternate time-line, the story is about Peter's struggle to keep Gabriel from turning into Sylar, while also dealing with threats from 'the company', a disapproving brother, and certain geneticists.
Slave Verse - In an Alternate Future, people with abilities have their memories wiped, their abiltiies neutralized and are enslaved. Sylar has escaped this. Peter did not. When Sylar hears Peter is up for sale, he gets to him before Nathan does.
Taking Risks - Gabriel Gray hated taking risks.
Fics with Violence
To Punish The Monster - Sylar was no longer human, he was a monster. He deserved to be punished. Didn't he?
Power Play - Peter and Sylar have a fight on the roof.
By These Labors Do We Keep The Wolves At Bay - Peter already knows what Sylar's mouth tastes like.
Shorts
A Life Worth Living - A night of love turns to something a bit more serious.
All Around Me - You're the sappiest man I've ever met. It's a miracle you weren't born a woman.
One Night Stand - It was only supposed to be an one night stand. So why did they continue this sick perversion?
Waiting - Sylar and Peter met each other within a gray middle, but each one had intentions that were both black and white.
Bonding Time - Peter and Sylar try a little bonding time.
Crossroads - Sylar’s ready to begin his quest to find his biological father, but first, he has to pay Peter Petrelli a little visit...
Brave the Elements - PWP, in a park, in the rain...
Four Months Gone - Peter and Sylar were stuck together for the four month time skip - this is what happened.
Sex on The Phone - While Peter's at work at the hospital, he gets a surprise phone call from none other than Sylar... Their conversation starts out as a heated argument, but eventually transpires into... something else...
These fics are so wrong, I might be going to hell or something
Black - Sylar accepts the spoils of war, and learns new flavors of wrong.
Survival - I ate your heart, and I own you, forever.
No Questions
Gabriel/Peter/Sylar Verse
Capn_mactastic's Masterlist
Bet - Sylar loses a bet, and Peter collects.
Why Do I Let You Do This To Me? - Peter torments Sylar into a game of kiss-catch.
Should We Wake Him? - After the incidents of Accommodating and Not So Accommodating, Gabriel and Sylar wonder if Peter's trying to tell them something.
Part 1 - I Can Do It, Part 2 - It's Not About You - Are you sure about this?
Sylar x Gabriel
(You Are) The Sickness In Between - He could have been looking into a mirror, if it hadn't been for the eyes. The eyes that guarded the truth of the other man, and told of the difference between them - the only difference. They were one, but yet not the same.
Sylaire
Post-Season 4
The Sweet Sound of Redemption - Although Sylar has found redemption, he finds he can no longer control the Hunger, especially around Claire. Claire finds it’s time to heal a lost soul…
Save The World, Save Yourself - Peter starts to worry that Sylar may slip back into his old ways so he takes Sylar to the future to show him what his life could be like if he stays on the right path.
Brave - Living, changing, trusting. It takes courage, even in a brave new world - Sylar/Claire - Post season 4 - Short story vignettes on how Gabriel learns to live and gain trust and eventually love.
Patterns of Force - In a world where the beast has been tamed a new evil rises. Secrets are revealed and time sometimes reopens old wounds. Remember: fate has a way of realizing itself.
I'm In Ruins - Sylar wants to prove to Claire he really has changed. Working in close proximity to her is only supposed to make things easier. But who is Claire without her stubbornness?
To Trust a Devil - In order to make Claire realize he's a changed man, Sylar will do anything she asks of him.
Braving the New World - Claire faces the immediate consequences of her jump while Sylar looks to continue the road of redemption.
When Lovers Sleep - Claire Bennet has finally put Sylar out of her mind, but one shared dream will pull him right back into her life, whether she likes it or not.
Tables Turned, Roles Reversed - Claire begins to turn dark with power and corruption, and Sylar has to save her from herself. Will she let him?
Brave New Fight - Sylar and Claire find common ground, and a common enemy, after sharing a traumatic experience. Incomplete and prolly discontinued.
The Evidence Never Lies - What if Sylar assumed Claire would fall into his arms once she knew he was "reformed?" What happens when she doesn't and he relapses into his old ways? Maybe Claire secretly wants the old Sylar back...
Early spring's dream
Picking Up Pieces - Claire has no job, and no future. She's done nothing but wonder what should have happened after she jumped, and desperately needs to find the one person that may be able to help her figure out who she is.
Something I Can Never Have - They both needed each other, her to be able to feel again if just for a brief moment, and him to escape his nightmare and to not be alone anymore.
A Poetic Retelling of an Unfortunate Seduction - She's in his blood now and he can't get her out.
Hidden Telekinesis Fics
What Pleasures These Phantom Hands Bring - Sylar uses his powers to stimulate Claire's body without really touching her, showing her that his powers aren't only used to cause pain.
Hands on Me - Sylar doesn't have to touch Claire to touch her. Tonight, that's what he's counting on. Pleasure can be its own form of torture. But which one of them is truly being tortured?
AUish
Death Becomes Her - Takes place after the Costa Verde explosion. Spoilers for S3 episode "I Am Become Death". Sylar confronts Claire one final time. He still has questions. And God help her, she better have the answers.
In Another Life - Sylar needs help from an unlikely hero, but gets much more than he bargained for.
Pretending - Part 1, Reality - Part 2 - She can't stay for long, so she might as well enjoy it while she can. He, on the other hand, doesn't like to wait.
Reformatory - Most evolved humans have been round up and kept prisoner by the company. Claire gets special, mild treatment in there given her origins, but can not stand the injustice done to the others anyhow.
Ready or Not - They've almost got a routine, and that's maybe the most disturbing thought that's ever crossed her mind.
Forget Me Not - Set around Shadowboxing; Claire discovers an amnesiac Sylar wandering around and takes it upon herself to help him.
Into the Quiet Night - AU to Fugitives Season; Claire involuntarily joins Sylar and Luke's roadtrip set before Shades of Gray, written based on the promo pics.
Future FUTURE Fic
Role Reversal - Only the regenerators survive in the distant future, but neither of them are what they used to be. They may or may not be enemies, but they're definitely not friends.
Throw Logic Out the Door - Logically, she knew that it was better for the world for him to be Gabriel Gray. But late at night, when she was clawing at the sheets while he made her scream ... she only wanted Sylar.
Keeping in Touch - Claire and Sylar are both moving on with their lives, but find it's easier to stay connected with each other.
Other
Untouched - He was soaking wet and unbearably sexy, smelling like rain and spice... I practically purred when he touched me with those calculating fingers of his, and then we both knew I was a goner.
Maybe you'll even love me - even though neither of them know it yet.
Lie to Me - Post 3x13 "Dual", following through canon. "Say it again," he mumbled. "Lie to me." And Claire stuttered out in a broken voice, "I want you to stop." A catalyst to a complex series of disasters and miracles that changes everything.
Detention - "What's wrong, Miss Bennett?" demanded Gray. "Haven't you given a blow job before?"
Selfish Generosity - Not all of Sylar's victims are weak.
Be My Escape - Claire meets Gabriel Gray before he becomes Sylar, some things change, some things are impossible to change. Is it possible for a cheerleader to save a desperate man from becoming the fate of becoming a monster?
The Chronicle of Perdition - Epic Sylaire fic.
Feeling Different - They say that a moment can change everything. Suddenly, that's becoming all too true for Claire. Always so sure, knowing exactly how she felt. Until now...
Calming Storm Waters - Who would've thought that a little swim in a pool would calm their stormy waters?
Bonnie and Clyde - Claire, imprisoned.
One Woman Show - In the mid 22nd century, humankind is in the grip of a global crisis that threatens extinction. The key to saving the world is locked inside the troubled mind of the the immortal Claire Bennett.
Pheromones - Claire's in college with the threat of Sylar looming over her. But what does he want?
Initiation - Even a serial killer can't resist a girl in uniform.
Halfway Around the World Before The Truth - When Sylar catches Claire working at a kissing booth, he decides to take advantage in the way only he can.
The Turn - Nothing is unfixable.
Lylar
Disturbances - This time it isn't Luke.