Rating The twst boy's from each dorm starting highest to lowest in each dorm category!
Disclaimer this may also include how I believe the dynamic between a character and Yume might be but the ending results could change.
Heartslabyul !♡
Riddle Rosehearts: I believe that Riddle is my most favorite from Heartslabyul, which is quite surprising because the people who know like my posts from the past know that Ace was the topic in majority of my twst content. Onto Yume she most definitely shares the same sentiment of Riddle being her favorite person, from heartslabyul but until like Riddle's overblot she is a terrible influence on Riddle. Riddle though is a great influence on her its a difficult scenario I believe. But the moment Riddle overblots, I can't quite say how their dynamic will turn out because I've wrote nothing for it.
Ace Trappola: To be completely honest I believe that Ace is my second most favorite character from Heartslabyul, I would say the same is for Yume except at the moment he's a bit suffocating for her but in the future I believe that he will be the actual growth she needs to be better. Although; I am having some thoughts on how after Riddles overblot someone kinda.. asks a certain someone to teach them what it means to be their friend and if they could be friends.
Deuce Spade: Honestly I can't say I truly have an opinion on Deuce, I don't hate him but hes not a favorite. For me personally I feel like while Deuce is our friend he doesn't get the same sort of impact that Ace leaves. I mean it feels different in the manga and anime because in both those cases, you meet Deuce with Ace but in the game you meet Ace first and then you both drag Deuce into the whole thing and get him in trouble. Then its the same for the actual book one we drag Deuce into getting in trouble as well. Deuce and Ace both get similar amounts of screentime and yet; it feels as if we're closer to Ace example being book seven not gonna go deep into depth but Ace dreams of what we desire to go home and still be able to stay in twst Deuce forgets quite often that we wish to return home I feel and then his own dream hadn't even included like an ounce of us you know..? The four of us are friends yes but for me personally I feel like while we are clearly close to Deuce its quite obvious that the bond with Ace is you know.? Onto Yume. Because of the fact I decided to go with the anime and Manga interaction she met Deuce when she met Ace but she paid zero to no attention to that interaction because of that fact alongside the fact Ace will as everyone should know will be sharing a dorm with Yume she'll grow closer probably to Ace I mean yeah the next day as everyone knows Deuce will start that as well but in that short time period growth between Ace and Yume will be shown while growth between Yume and Deuce won't. I mean as everyone knows Deuce will tell Yume his backstory but.. its Yume. Not to mention while Ace will be able to see the bad qualities Yume has I don't believe Deuce will. So just as my opinion of Deuce Yume shall have the same no thoughts. Maybe it shall change but that change will be long after Ace and Yume.
Trey Clover: Hm.. How do I think of Trey.. We don't quite interact with him hes helpful in book one sure but then hes practically sidelined in book two where he should be helping but since hes injured he can't. I don't mind him I mean I personally don't believe his appearance suits my taste but I don't hate him. Yume? She's uncomfortable around him. They don't grow close they both simply will care for Riddle. Trey probably will like Yume like he undoubtedly believes that Yume is a good person for Riddle because Riddle needs friends just before Riddle's overblot he probably wished that instead of being a bad influence she would be a good one. Trey doesn't grow close to Yume and neither does she grow close to him although I will say this is book two she might like him a bit more then Deuce simply because what he does for Riddle.
Cater Diamond: Thoughts on Cater.. I don't like him? He's a bit to much for me. His lore is left unexplained like, I know he has depth but it will never be explained upon and the lore that is there because I don't have that much of an opinion on him I'm not willing to go and explore on that depth. I also don't have the favorable opinion on his design.. Yume's thoughts though. To her hes far too chatty for her liking not to mention all the words he uses are things she utterly can't comprehend none of them being in the books she used to have, not to mention how close he gets to her. Riddle and Cater are two different people she felt comfortable around Riddle so from the start any touch was welcomed but she while she doesn't quite understand it feels discomforting.
Savanaclaw !𖤓
Ruggie Bucchi: OH my goodness we have officially moved onto the hardest dorm to rank all the other dorms? Atleast I know where they stand this dorm sucks a- ahem.. I believe that Ruggie is cute. Lore? I know no one's lore in this dorm. To be completely honest they had so many directions to go for book two and they trashed it. I can't remember anything memorable about the book or the characters which is sad because I like the lion king and I love Scar. Anyways onto Yume's opinion. She.. hm.. I haven't thought about it simply because of the fact she hasn't met him, I believe that her thoughts will most likely include confusion? He confuses her but he reminds her of those squirrels she always saw climbing on the roses outside her window and then laying on the outside of her window. She'll probably have the opinion that he looks cute but they won't grow close not to mention Ruggie will run the moment shes around considering how scary women are.
Jack Howl: This.. is an interesting case. He's how do I put this? He's a freshmen, so it feels like we should be friends with him correct.? And we are. But hes simply not that important. He likes cactuses hes childhood friends with Vil he tries to help us during book three. But throughout all of that hes unimportant. Hes upset about everything that is going on in book two but.. he only helps after fighting Ace and deuce.? Then hes like he wants to do it alone. But before the duo fought him he wasn't doing anything. I'll be honest I don't like him. But I don't hate him. Yume's opinion of him. Well.. how is a person who barely interacts with someone meant to think of them? She'll probably find him troublesome, he knew what was going on but when they went up to him to warn him he acted all secretive which was annoying. But.. she doesn't hate him so that should count for something.
Leona Kingscholar: Opinion on him.. I'm actually quite fond of him. Is he my favorite? No. I have no actual favorite favorite in this dorm but if I had to choose it would be him. He hates Malleus? I hate Malleus. You know the saying a enemy of your enemy is your friend. Yume's opinion. Grim stepped on his tail he was upset at Grim, and Grim had made it worse but she quickly shut it off by grabbing Grim and stopping him from continuing, she recognized him from orientation and she wished to apologize. She wouldn't say that she likes Leona but he's quite kind although him like Ruggie doesn't speak to her often.
Octavinelle !𐂠
Jade Leech: My favorite twin, and favorite character in the dorm I sadly don't share the same tastes as liking mushrooms but I digress. I can't quite say what makes me like Jade I simply do. Onto Yume's opinion. Jade they had met in orientation while she hadn't spoke to him she saw him and he saw her, and she's quite scared of him. He's quite tall like Jack, except Jack isn't intimidating Jade is. They've met a couple other times before book three but all those times had been with Riddle and considering what Riddle has told her Jade is the better twin out of the two. Twin is a new word she learnt because of Riddle him having taught her all about the different kinds of twins and siblings. Because of the fact Riddle told her that Jade is the better twin and atleast doesn't bother people as much as Floyd does she found herself preferring Jade as well over Floyd.. Not just Floyd, she prefers Jade over Azul.
Azul Ashengrotto: Azul.. he's quite cute isn't he? I have a favorable opinion of Azul, he reminds me of those squished that change colors when you pull the inside out I have a ton of them, his whole overblot was.. Sad. I relate to him far more then I'd like to admit.. Anyways Yume's opinion. She hates Azul. Despises him, Riddle had told her he holds Azul's talent and capabilities in high regard, but he doesn't trust him. She.. trusts in Riddle's judgment. She recalls the words Azul muttered to himself during orientation and while she hadn't said anything during then because of those twins, she doesn't like Azul one bit. After book three while she feels bad for him but she doesn't quite understand? Bullying..? Such words were never mentioned in her books and Riddle never taught her about those subjects, she'll find herself studying up on the subjects of course and her hatred will eventually turn to simply wishing to keep Azul away from Riddle.
Floyd Leech: Okay. Floyd. He's not my favorite okay? But simply because I relate to him far too much then I would like to say. He's cute sometimes sure, but I feel like I wouldn't enjoy to be around him.. Atleast though his emotions are quite obvious because he doesn't hold how he feels back. Onto Yume's opinion. She hates him despises him. She's seen how he treats Riddle and Riddle has told her that she should stay away from him if she can, so she usually follows his advice but even so Floyd is quite annoying he always bothers her asking her why "goldfish allows her to hug him while Goldfish always runs away from him" she then goes on to tell him that Riddle's name is Riddle not goldfish but then he goes on to laugh and say "koifishie is defending her leader" proceeding to try and squeeze her luckily she always slips away before he could but still..
Floyd calls Yume koifish I'll write it here so I don't forget but anyways. Allow me to explain Floyd usually calls Yuu shrimpy but thats because of the personality traits they have, while Yume holds none of those personality traits that yuu has, everyone knows how Yume acts and everyone saw Yume clinging onto Riddle during orientation. So Floyd calls Yume koifish because she has the personality of a follower Koifish, which you guys can search up if you'd like..
Scarabia !𓆗
Kalim Al Asim: I'll be honest here, both dorms Scarabia and Savanaclaw are both difficult, I would say both of these dorm books are my least favorite. I know that Kalim is my favorite from this dorm, but I don't really have information on why? We interact with Kalim and Jamil so often in book four so it would make sense to have a read on them but I simply can't. Majority of the info we get is Jamil faking his whole personality and Kalim being under mind controll when everything is done its done yes, but that doesn't take back the fact we got practically no emotional impact from them we get Jamil's backstory yeah, but like.. nothing on Kalim. Chapter five we get a bit more info on Kalim but.. Nothing emotionally compelling for me to consider him as anything. Yumes opinion. This is difficult she absolutely can't get a read on Kalim his emotions are all over his face but she understands none of them she has no reason to dislike him, and even during book four she doesn't dislike him. He's hyper but not hyper to the point shes uncomfortable so he gets a pass.
Jamil Viper: I'm scared to give my opinion to be completely honest. But I shall. He.. isn't characteristically interesting I have no reason to like him. He has backstory correct but, that simply gives us his past it doesn't excuse his actions of manipulating us and mindcontrolling us, Kalim forgave Jamil far too quickly in my opinion. I feel like Jamil simply doesn't get the growth after his overblot sadly. And I understand, he had reasons. But. Okay.. allow me to explain. Kalims relationship with Jamil is like. Kalims family is the owners of Jamil's. But Jamil targets Kalim because hes the easiest to target because the actual ones who deserve to be targeted are too hard to target Kalim is quite a few things correct. But. Book four feels like I can't put my tongue on it but a situation that instead of going to the root of the problem you decide to go to the lesser problem which solves nothing except giving you atleast something that makes you feel like your doing something while doing nothing. Not to mention I feel like book four Jamil's thoughts made zero sense hes meant to be smart though.? Jamil wouldn't be given the freedom if Kalim was kicked out of the school he would need to return back with Kalim, and if Kalim truly had done something bad Jamil would be blamed for not stopping him and then his family would be getting in trouble. It simply does more harm then good, I'm not saying Kalim's family is correct I would never say that, I'm saying its idiotic to blame the one who didn't create the problem because that then causes more harm then good. I'll stop writing about Jamil for me because some of this simply may be wrong considering I might not understand his character its just coming from the opinion of the information that we have in the story that I don't have to dig in events or vignettes to get. Onto Yume's opinion. She's suspicious of him she recalls Kalim's almost slip of tongue in book two and has since been suspicious on Jamil. In book four she wasn't happy with having to be in the situation and she most certainly isn't happy when Jamil overblots. She prefers Kalim over Jamil if she had to choose.
Pomefiore !
Vil Schoenheit: I will admit, Vil is pretty but. Thats it. His personality? Is fine. I enjoy it. But other then that hes my favorite in Pomefiore yes, but I'll say it I'll admit it! Neige is my favorite. Listen listen, I always find myself enjoying the side characters more then the main characters well hopefully Neige won't be a side character for much longer but he currently sadly is.. That also means he won't be put in a ranking I'm only currently ranking the playable characters minus the teachers. But anyways so yeah, I already have a bias and Vil is high like high like he is a favorite character even outside of Pomefiore. Well onto Yume. She meets Vil in book two because I'll simply give this away while I haven't wrote for it, I know I plan to make her join the housewarden meeting so they meet there, but after that she doesn't meet him until book five. Her opinion of him.. I'll be honest it probably won't be the best, their mindsets of how to treat guests are completely different lets just say. Not to mention unlike me, Yume doesn't care how people look she doesn't care that Vil is pretty or not atleast thats what I currently believe she is like so no bia's for Vil I suppose.
Epel Felmier: Epel.. Okay so! Listen. I like him, I knew like first glance that he was a man because you know I'm just good like that. He's handsome, I suppose? But hes misogynistic and only until later down the road does he like you know get better because of Vil. But I mean.. I don't really recall how he behaved I would have to go back and read a couple more stuff but like I am fond of him, he is also just like Vil a favorite outside of Pomefiore. Well Yume's opinion now. She saw him in book one, they hadn't spoke then and then they only see each other once more in book five. I don't believe Yume knows anything about the words of Epel like how he is misogynistic like.. I don't believe the books she used to have had anything of the word misogynistic so because she doesn't know and like never met anyone her assumption is that hes simply different like how those books told her how everyone's personality can be different she just assumes thats how Epel is. So she's fine with him, she personally doesn't enjoy his loudness when he gets rowdy but shes fine with him.
Rook Hunt: Rook.. I relate to you so much we both are fans of Neige and Vil. But thats it. I have no reason to have an actual opinion on Rook. We get more interactions with Epel in book five and six then Rook. I enjoy his personality sure but hes not even in that many events and the ones that he are in hes not the main focus so I once again can't truly have something to cling on. Hes not a favorite sadly but luckily I also don't hate him, I simply can't have a true opinion on him from how much content we get of him hes of similar case to Kalim. Yume's opinion, In the prelude while I hadn't included it because Yume hadn't, Rook was stalking her she knows Rook was stalking her but she in turns thinks nothing of it and it'll never be mentioned on her part because its not important enough to note for her. To her Rook isn't important. When they meet in book two she doesn't speak to him, and in book five and six they barely speak to each other. She also doesn't quite understand his words, or his rambles she tolerates him at best.
Ignihyde !모
Idia Shroud: Idia.. Is a favorite hes so cute and cool. But thats it. He has deep lore yes. But thats lore. For his case I like him hes a favorite, but I personally don't have in depth opinion of the boy. Yume.. This is tough. I don't quite wish to spoil anything because he'll be having extra scenes before book six, but her opinion of him is fondness. They sadly aren't close on Idia's part, but if he went outside or to housewarden meetings in person then he would be sitting next to Yume whose sitting next to Riddle for what reason exactly? Well.. while Malleus still exists I can't exactly make make Idia take his place.. But.. lets just say alchemy vignette. Idia's. Because its good for Yume to have friends that aren't just Riddle Ace and Deuce. Because if its not obvious those are clearly her only friends well.. in this section maybe in diasomnia she'll have more.
Ortho Shroud: Ortho, is cute. I mean hes not favorite favorite but hes cute. I don't share the same opinion that others have of thinking of him as my little brother or son, but hes cute I suppose similar to a puppy. But. Once more character speaking hes not interesting maybe he'll be interesting in book seven but I skipped majority of the story that included Malleus in it, I'll probably go back when this plot goes close to book seven. Yume's opinion. She's not close to Ortho, even though shes close to Idia she simply isn't the same with Ortho my goodness its the whole Riddle and Trey situation all over again.. But this time its simply because while shes fine with Ortho she doesn't go out of her way to hang out with him. If its not obvious Ace and Deuce along with Grim are usually always the ones speaking to the freshmen group not her. Although.. Ortho is quite helpful shes able to meet Idia sometimes because of Ortho.
Diasomnia !⚡︎
Silver: Silver is my fav like fav but.. everyone in Diasomnia is my fav. Except Malleus. Book seven just simply amplified my feelings for Silver I truly wish that Yuu and Silver got the kiss scene in book seven but alas. Wait. No.. no I shouldn't I'm not planning on writing romance in the fanfic Yume and Silver shouldn't kiss.. Maybe I'll write a short oneshot of Silver and reader kissing in book seven. Probably not. Anyways back onto Silver the whole book was just chiefs kiss, I love Silver so much but he sadly doesn't beat the side characters. Anyways onto Yume. I haven't.. thought about it. I imagine that they shall eventually become friends, and their might be a chance they become friends sooner then in book seven merely because of Riddle. Yume's opinion of Silver is that shes fond of him. I imagine that I'll make tiny extras together of Yume running into Silver asleep, but sadly they aren't anywhere close to them kissing so my dreams of Silver kissing a version of Yuu in book seven has gone down the drain well that and because Yume isn't healthy Silver would deserve better. Final verdict Yume likes Silver.
Sebek Zigvolt: The people who know me, know that I love Sebek. I have dedicated multiple times of explanations of why Sebek doesn't deserve all the hate he gets and all those allegations. I will not go into depth once again. I love him hes a favorite hes cute I'm fine with his shouting. I simply wish he allowed his hair to stay down and to not speak of Malleus so frequently and instead speak of himself but alas.. Malleus forsakens me.. Yume's opinion. At the beginning she hated how loud he was, and how often he spoke of Malleus she still hates when he speaks of Malleus, but she will grow used to it I would say that in the freshmen group outside of Ace and eventually Deuce she'll be close to Sebek the most. She likes him.
Lilia Vanrouge: I love Lilia as well, hes a cute Lil fae. My final verdict is I like him. He's a favorite, but I wish that he would give Malleus a bit of boundaries that Halloween event was completely uncool. Yume's opinion. I'll be honest sadly, Yume doesn't have a fond opinion of Lilia. Its similar to Trey both Trey and Lilia act as familiar people with Trey acting as a older brother and Lilia having that security of a father. She's uncomfortable with beings such as that because the only family she had was her mother, and she doesn't understand they aren't her mother, they don't act similar to her mother but they seem similar to her mother because, her mother is family and they act as people that are father and brother, but she has no family but her mother, so anything that acts similar to that is bad because she doesn't know that their can be anything else in her family but her mother. And the difference between them and Riddle is the fact Riddle reminds her of her mother but hes warm and not suffocating and not to mention isn't similar to a family bond for her, like Riddle doesn't act as a father or sibling towards her so while he reminds her of her mother he simply doesn't act as someone that is part of a family bond. Trey and Lilia both are similar to a family bond which, makes her uncomfortable while not understanding why because like I said before she doesn't know anything about people being fathers or brothers. Cater is also similar but she doesn't notice because she has more reasons of uncomfortableness with him while with Trey and Lilia its simply the family bond. If Trey didn't give the embrace of an older brother and Lilia didn't have the feeling of a father she wouldn't feel uncomfortable.
Malleus Draconia: Malleus.. I hate this guy. Hate hate him. Why must Yuu choose to be so close to him? Why are we forced to be close to him? He shows up in what? Book two.? Why so early huh? Book seven is your book not two.. We act closer with Malleus on the second time of meeting him, while with Ace and Deuce we actually saw their bond form with Malleus he doesn't give us his name! He doesn't give us the choice of deciding if we can like him with knowing who his identity or not. He makes the choice himself deciding that if we don't know his identity then we would have no reason to dislike him. Then Yuu tells him he can continue visiting the dorm once again we have no idea who this man is we just know hes a student. Not to mention! We tell him our name. I'm already upset writing this but I shall continue. The Halloween event, the whole thing was upsetting final verdict I hate Malleus despise him I have to skip the story when it involves him that's how much I hate the guy, but oh. Since I'm a writer I have to write him in. I hope no one expects for this man to get extra scenes. He already is given enough by the story. Gets more screentime then characters we actually know. Smh. Onto Yume's opinion how great.. She just like me hates the guy. When they first met and he refused to share his name she was upset but she kept her smile on her face her, sadly she doesn't know that people can lie about their names or the saying stranger danger so she told him her name he was then like the whole since people live in the dorm he can't come unlike Yuu, she doesn't tell him he can continue coming she simply says okay and and then leaves he took that as he could return because you know.. hes simply like that. When they meet in book five she gives him tickets not because she wished to but Riddle had been teaching her about being kind to people so she had given Malleus a ticket because she had seen him she unlike Yuu, doesn't give Malleus a name and when she finds out his name she simply calls him Malleus. Throughout all of the books her opinion of him doesn't change I believe in book seven it may get even worse.
Ramshackle !𓉸
Rollo Flamme: Rollo.. my reason my muse. I love Rollo the most hes my most favorite with Skully, Neige Chenya behind him. I mean his desire to get rid of magic was wonderful and we both share the same dislike for Malleus his voice is so wonderful I love him so much. Yume. Well.. I'm still trying to figure out if I'll be adding the events but I sadly don't believe I will. Maybe for like following goals.. But anyways this is her opinion if I were to add events. She.. doesn't quite understand his goal or reasoning, but. He's nice to her. She likes him and it would be better if Riddle liked him as well but he sadly doesn't. So that effects some of her final judgment to Rollo.
Skully J. Graves: Skully, I love him as well, I can't wait to be able to fully max out his card just as I had with Rollo. I'm sad that everyone forgot him and that hes dead but anyways.. Yume's opinion.. is.. well. "Who?" I mean she of course would forget Skully so she wouldn't recall any opinion she formed of him but here I am I recall. Skully and her were close, during this event she sadly wasn't able to be around Riddle or Idia that often but she was around Skully, so they of course grew close. She liked him but was uncomfortable with how much he spoke of Halloween which she had no clue even existed back in her world.. She decided she wouldn't ever tell him that fact. Final verdict they could've been friends they could've been close, but not enough time was given for the both of them.
Grim: him.. okay so like.. I for the longest time, didn't like Grim he reminds me of Paimon with how loud and how much he speaks. He's not my baby. I tolerate him on a good day. On a bad day I'll skip his dialog. But because of a fanfic I grew to be fine with him so.. yeah! Yume. Ah.. this is tough. She doesn't like him. Currently she is tolerating him but he burnt her! So.. not a good impression. She has as I've said before has no reason to like him and won't have any until far down the line, she'll take care of him yes she'll go to rescue him yeah. But she thinks of him as a nuisance. Grim of course won't notice anything about that but yeah she won't be liking him anytime soon. But she enjoys and finds some comfort in his warmth she never had something for so long so eventually after many learning lessons she'll learn to like Grim along with Deuce but I wonder who she'll like first Grim or Deuce?