Hey so like. In lieu of the Community as of late I want to make something absolutely 100% crystal clear - specifically considering this is my AU and I paint Mapleshade as much more of a protagonist?
I do not believe Mapleshade's Vengeance was black-and-white. I believe the only (main) cats not guilty of being irresponsible code breakers in this story are Reedshine, Perchpaw, Myler, and the kits.
Mapleshade should not have had a cross-Clan relationship or had the kits cross in the flood. She should not have killed a medicine cat, nor attempted murder on a queen.
Appledusk should not have had a cross-Clan relationship, nor should he have betrayed Mapleshade and used Reedshine as his crutch to stay safe in RiverClan.
Ravenwing should not have spilled the secret that was not his - or if he did, he should have spoken to the kits staying. He deliberately endangered the kits for the sake of honesty, and thus broke the warrior and medicine cat codes.
Frecklewish and Oakstar should not have acted in the way they did at all. Murder or no, both of them deliberately threatened, endangered, and neglected kits in an already dangerous situation, and allowed them to die. They broke the warrior code.
Darkstar... I don't entirely blame. I do believe she should have allowed Mapleshade at least a night's stay, but her response other than the immediate pardonning of Appledusk was appropriate. I believe Appledusk should have been further punished, though the book does portray him as having desperately wanted to be a father (loving Maple's kits at first sight, seeming shocked and upset when he found out she had risked the flood, and immediately trying to get Reedshine pregnant) so maybe that speaks to why he wasn't punished.
As far as Maplestar's Light is concerned, this is written in an alternate telling where, instead of Maple going feral following the deaths of her kits, she goes entirely numb. Angry still, sure, but she didn't make an attempt on Ravenwing or Frecklewish. She ended up just getting malnourished and exhausted, and passing out on WindClan turf on her way to somewhere new. She is still guilty of breaking the code, but instead of further causing anguish, she works to redeem her actions with Talltail and Palebird, and succeeds in that. Having the support system helps her.
Sorry for the tangent, but I just wanted to put that out there before anyone got the wrong idea. I'm not a Mapleshade apologist at all - she's honestly one of my favourite villains and a compelling read. I just really like writing happy-ending stories and what-ifs.
And also pretending that these cats can use their brains and actually talk things out for once instead of killing each other all the time. That too.













