Kino’s Journey Rant (thoughts on the new series)
So the original Kino’s Journey was one of my most formative anime experiences when I was a young teen. It was a show that showed the beauty and pain of the world in way that wasn’t over dramatic or opinionated, it just was. It is a show that has shaped my world views and genuinely made me care more about cultural differences and people as a whole. Kino was one of my first crushes. They were living a life for themself and no one else. They were not hard set in their beliefs and just went with the flow, enjoying the good and the bad that the world had to offer. They were not a pacifist or lawful in any way but they were neutral in a way that made them good. I both wanted to be Kino and be with Kino. This is, ultimately, one of the most important pieces of fiction in my life, and I doubt that will ever change.
The new anime is not the same old Kino. I do not think it is bad by any means, but it is not the quiet, slow paced, philosophical anime I loved. I think Kino is a hard show to mess up too horribly, as the content itself is almost impossibly good. I have not been able to read all of the novels but I have read some and enjoyed every story. I think that the new anime has not necessarily made any bad episodes, but has lacked pacing and put them in an odd order. I know the order was mostly based on peoples votes in Japan on their favorite Kino stories, but I do not think this was the best way to make these decisions. The most interesting stories in the novels do not always make the most interesting stories in an anime adaption. I also think that choosing only the most popular storylines has done a disservice to the way in which Kino thrives, which is by having the more ‘action-packed’ and exciting stories spread out so that they feel fresh and different. The stories where Kino gets involved are spread apart in the novels, whereas they are packed together in the new show. This is not to say that the episodes are bad, I just think that they would have a lot more impact if some of the more quiet and slower stories were spread throughout.
I think that the new show succeeds in its portrayal of Kino as a more chaotic neutral character. I wish that they had them and Hermes talk more in this show as their solitary conversations were some of my favorite parts of the old anime and some of my favorite parts of the bits of the novel I have read. I think that I am more keen on the old character designs because they portray Kino in a slightly less girly way and are more stylized, but I love the backgrounds and the voice acting in the new show. I definitely think that the new show is worth watching and I have greatly enjoyed some of the episodes (Country of Liars and the newest one Various Countries) but I think its main issue is in the pacing being based on popularity and not content. That being said I think that when all the episodes are out I am going to reorder them and see if I can find an order that I feel better suits the story style I prefer. This is all just my opinion but I would love to hear what other die-hard Kino fans are thinking.
(TLDR: New Kino has good episodes but they are put in an order that has made the pacing feel rushed and made the story feel less unique)