All that glitters is not gold
Pairing: Harvey Kinkle x Nicholas Scratch x Male Reader
A/N: I have no idea why I wrote this. It’s been sitting in my head for a while and because I don’t sleep, I finished it. The reader has powers like the original Sabrina Spellman. Enjoy!
“Y/N, would you please tell us where you're taking us?” Harvey asked his boyfriend as he dragged him and Nicholas up the stairs of the Spellman household. He led them down the hallway to a door upstairs and opened it to reveal his bedroom. The three of them walked inside. Nicholas smirked. “If you wanted to take us to bed, Spellman, you should have just said so. Though, I prefer it without the mortal third wheel here.”
Harvey scowled. “Shut up, dick. Y/N’s my boyfriend, not yours.” Nicholas opened his mouth to say something, but Y/N interrupted him.
“Guys! I didn't bring you to my room so you could fight,” Y/N said.
“Why did you bring us here, Y/N?” Nicholas asked him.
“Because I want to know what this is between us, all,” Y/N said, gesturing to all three of them.
“What do you mean?” Harvey asked him.
Y/N sighed. “Well, it's obvious you both like me, and it's not a secret that you both don't like each other that much. Harvey and Nicholas looked at each other.
“Yup.”
“Got that right.”
“Well, I need to know for sure, and there's only one way to do that,” Y/N said. “Take off your shirts.” He told both boys.
Harvey’s eyes widened. “What?”
Nicholas smiled. “Oh, so it's that kind of game, hmm?”
Y/N rolled his eyes. “Hardly. If I was that kind of warlock, you’d both be naked and strapped to my bed right now. Just trust me, please?” Harvey and Nicholas began removing their shirts and Y/N may or may not have shamelessly checked them out as they did. “Okay, now what?” Harvey asked. Y/N removed his own shirt as well, then walked closer and looked at Nicholas. “Nick, what's your favorite color?”
Nicholas looked at him, puzzled. “Umm… Blue, why?”
“Blue seriously?” Harvey asked him. “Could you be more basic?”
“Oh, what’s your favorite color, Kinkle? Red?” Nicholas asked.
“Guys! I can't do the spell with you two fighting,” Y/N said.
“What spell?” Nicholas asked.
“One my father created to see if my mother loved him. I'm going to put my glitter and sparkle magic to good use.” Y/N put his hands on Nicholas’s chest and could feel his heartbeat as there was a flash of light and a blue trail flew out of Nicholas’s chest and into the air above them and spun in a circle. “Alright, next?” Y/N said as he moved to Harvey and placed his hands on Harvey’s chest like he had Nicholas. Only this time, instead of a blue trail, it was yellow.
“You like yellow?” Nicholas asked.
“Don't start,” Y/N warned as he murmured something to himself, and a green light trail flew up to meet the blue and yellow ones. The three boys watched as the colors merged together with each other and began to make another color. “Okay, while we wait for that to finish, I have something to confess to you both.”
Y/N looked at Harvey first. “Harvey. You and I have been childhood friends for a long time, and I’ve had a crush on you even before I even knew what a crush was. I was so happy when we finally got together because you’ve been an amazing boyfriend and having you around makes me feel normal. Like I'm not just some half-breed freak.”
Harvey smiled. “You’ve never been a freak, Y/N.”
“I know because you never let me feel like that.” Y/N turned to Nicholas. “Nick. I wasn't sure what to make of you when I first met you, other than that you were a handsome warlock. You told me I had two natures, why not date two guys, and that you didn’t mind sharing. You helped me accept my warlock nature as something to celebrate and not hide it and for that, I thank you.”
“You're welcome, Spellman.”
“Guess what I'm trying to say is that… I like you. I like you both and I want this to work between us. The three of us,” Y/N said.
“You mean a Polyamory?”
“Exactly. But only if you both want this too and something tells me you do, too.”
“How do you know that, Spellman?”
“Because of that,” Y/N pointed up. Harvey and Nicholas looked up and saw the colors had turned into a rainbow of colors.
“What does that mean?”
Y/N smiled. “It means I'm not the only person you're both attracted to.” Y/N began to giggle at their shocked faces. “Looks like mortal boys prefer sexy warlocks and warlocks have a thing for mortal boys.”
“Y/N, you don't really believe that I have feelings for Kinkle here.”
“Yeah, and there’s no way I'm attracted to the witch bitch.”
“Why I outta–”
“–Bring it.”
“Yeah, you can lie to yourselves, but you can't lie to me or the magic,” Y/N said. “Come on, admit it.” Harvey and Nicholas blushed and refused to look at each other. Y/N chuckled. “I wonder how far those blushes go. I’d like to find out sometime.”
Just then the door to Y/N’s room was opened as Y/N heard aunt Zelda say. “Y/N would you be a devil and… What in the name of Satan is going on here?!” Behind her was Aunt Hilda, cousin Ambrose, and his sister, Sabrina. The entire Spellman family looked at Y/N and two other boys without any shirts on.
“Harvey? Nicholas?” Sabrina asked.
“Wait, it's not what you guys think. You see, I was trying—”
“—Trying to have your wicked way with both of them?” Ambrose grinned. “Nice one, cousin. Great taste.”
“Ambrose, you're not helping,” Sabrina said.
“I thought we raised you better than that, Y/N,” Aunt Hilda admonished.
“Aunties listen to me I—”
“—What’s that?” Aunt Zelda asked, pointing up to the color of magic floating in the air.
Y/N rolled his eyes. “Well, I would happily explain this whole situation if you guys would quit interrupting me.”
“Very well. Explain yourself, but first, put your shirts back on,” Aunt Zelda advised.
Y/N pointed to Harvey and Nicholas as blue and green magical particles floated out and wrapped around them as shirts appeared on their body. Y/N pointed to himself as a shirt appeared as well. “Aww, it's a shame. I really liked those hard bodies,” Ambrose said.
“Quiet, love,” Aunt Hilda said.
Y/N turned to his family. “Okay, the reason why we had our shirts off was because I needed it from a spell. Not because we were doing anything bad.”
“What sort of spell?” Aunt Zelda asked.
“One dad created it to see if mom loved him. I might have tweaked the spell just a bit, but the principles are still the same,” Y/N said.
Sabrina looked at the floating particles in amazement. “Dad made this spell?”
“Your father went through a love sick phase when he met your mother,” Aunt Hilda explained.
“And that’s all this was, then?” Aunt Zelda asked Y/N. “Just to find out if these two love you?”
“And each other, but yes, that’s all this was. Nothing bad I promise,” Y/N said.
“Good. Next time you do engage in sinful pleasures of the body, do try to lock the door,” Aunt said, turning on her heel and walked out the door. Aunt Hilda, Sabrina, and Ambrose followed after her as Ambrose turned and winked at Y/N with a thumbs up. Y/N closed the door behind them and this time made sure it was locked.
“That was embarrassing,” Harvey noted.
“Tell me about it,” Y/N agreed.
“Oh, come on, Kinkle, and Spellman,” Nicholas smiled. “It could have been worse.”
“Oh, like what?” Harvey asked.
“We could have been naked and been in the middle of having hot and raunchy sex.”
Harvey and Y/N blushed at that as an idea formed in the young halfbreed’s head. “Actually, that’s not such a bad idea, Nic.”
“Oh, really?” Nicholas asked, smirking.
Y/N waved his hands as all their clothes disappeared, leaving them only in their skin tight boxer briefs.
“You’re a kinky son of a warlock, Spellman,” Nicholas said.
“Thanks.”
“Y-you, uh, you know your family's just downstairs, right?” Harvey stammered, stumbling over his words.
“I know, Harv,” Y/N grinned, “The risk is exciting, isn’t it?” He reclined on his bed. “Now, both of you come here and kiss me, or do other things to me if you want.”
Nicholas and Harvey swallowed at the hot sight in front of them. To see Y/N like that, sprawled on his bed, sparked a heat inside them. They both wanted Y/N. Hell, they wanted each other as well. Maybe the three of them could make this work after all.
Nicholas looked at Harvey as the mortal boy turned to the warlock. “What do you say, Kinkle? Feeling like playing?”
Harvey swallowed, his brown eyes blown with lust. He was a good boy, but being around Y/N and Nicholas always made him feel naughty and horny. “Yeah. Yeah, I want to play.”
Both boys moved towards Y/N as the young halfbreed smirked as they did some unspeakable things that would have even made the Dark Lord blush with heat.
