Almost halfway through Mostly Dead Things, so I figured I’d take the chance to pause and put my thoughts down on paper. Going to try not to spoil anything that happens outside of the first chapter.
First of all, the prologue chapter at the start of the book REALLY grabbed me. Nothing happens in it that isn’t revealed on the back of the book, but regardless, the atmosphere and vague tension in it really hooked me.
Though now that I write this 170 pages later, I worry I might be losing interest a little. I’m still very intrigued by our lead character, Jessa, she has a very unique disposition that makes perfect sense considering all of her past experiences you learn about. Though right now she feels like the only character I have a solid grasp on and some of the prose doesn’t quite do her justice I feel.
One frequent tendency Jessa has is to mentally dissect other women she meets in the same way she dissects animal carcasses for taxidermy. This is incredibly interesting to me and I feel it says a lot about Jessa as a character, but every time you’re given a sentence about Jessa observing the lines of muscle under someone’s skin, it’s immediately followed by a line where she straightforwardly admits shes looking at them the way she views a carcass. I feel like this is something the reader would realize without it being blatantly told to them. The reader given concrete explanations for all of Jessa’s intrusive thoughts like this feels like a missed opportunity for some subtlety to me.
Then there’s the other characters, which are all on the opposite end of the spectrum, as in I feel like I don’t know as much about them as I should being this far into the book. Jessa’s brother, Milo, is in almost every chapter of this book, but he doesn’t feel like much more than a foil to Jessa. Jessa is rough, hardworking, and closed-off while Milo is scrawny, lazy, and emotional (though, now that I think of it, I don’t think I’ve seen Milo be emotional, Jessa just tells us that he is). Then there’s Jessa’s father, the character who this entire novel revolves around, but I feel like I know less about him than anyone else in the book. Half of the chapters take place in the past, but most only mention him off-handedly despite everyone mourning him in the present. At a certain point I think I sort of forgot about him, I don’t even remember his name. It’s apparent to me now that Jessa’s parents’ relationship was a rocky one, and I’m hoping by the end of the novel, I get to see more of that now that Jessa’s mother is starting to play a bigger role in the part I’m at.
While some characters feel a bit flat to me, they all at least feel believably to me, with the exception of one. Throughout the first chapter, characters are described to you with every flab, bloat, and blemish that adorn their bodies. From the beginning, it’s apparent that these characters are not idealized in any way. The exception is at the end of chapter 1 when Jessa is introduced to a woman named Lucinda. Lucinda feels almost otherworldly with how polished and unflappable she is in Jessa’s eyes. I know this is partially because this is a first-person narrative and Jessa is biased towards her, but by the end of the second chapter, Jessa is already making confident character judgments about Lucinda and the book doesn’t seem like it intends to disprove her. Every time she appears it feels like I’m suddenly in a different world to the rest of the book. While every other character is imperfect and unpredictable, Lucinda feels almost like she’s Jessa’s idealized imaginary friend.
While I do feel like some of the writing is repetitive and lacking in nuance, I’m still interested in where the book is going. I’m very attached to Jessa as a character and I’m at least interested to see what she makes of herself. I’ll update again soon once I’ve read more.