There’s a pack of feral children that roam the complex I live in. It’s genuinely fucking annoying, they stand unmoving in the face of cars, harass my cats in the sliding glass door, get into our patio bins, and wreak general havoc. Also snoop on my betrothed and I making out, over which I’m the saltiest.
But one aspect of summertime is all the little chalk drawings they leave everywhere. As this is not any of the aforementioned acts of mischief I thoroughly approve of chalk time.
Each day my betrothed and I would sally forth on what they called, “our government mandated walk” and stroll through a gallery of chalk creations.
I think we noticed about the same time as we walked through the complex to the road that amidst the rainbows and nuclear families there was a disturbing repeated phrase.
“Not a lie.”
Over and over, not a lie, not a lie; in various colors and sizes, the same phrase. It looked like a pastel cult. Or like someone trying to escape Aperture Science.
All summer the rains would wash the concrete clean and each new wave of chalk would be accompanied by a new peal of “not a lie”s. We speculated wildly for months over the “not a lie” phrase. What wasn’t a lie? Why weren’t parents concerned about this bizarre obsessive repetition?
Then one day, coming home from our walk, we heard a parent call, “Natalie!”
Simultaneously our eyes widened and we whipped our heads toward each other to say in rapt tones, “Not a lie!”
We still like to creepily whisper “not a lie” in discordant tones like cult followers, but it’s funny knowing it’s just a kids name.
how bad do u want me | natalie scatorccio x reader
“Cause you like my hair, my ripped-up jeans, you like the bad girl i got in me.”
SUMMARY: After a quiet conversation with Coach Ben in the wilderness, you come to a realization about yourself that you’ve been avoiding for a long time - you’re in love with your best friend, Natalie Scatorccio.
warnings: nsfw, smut with plot, slight angst!
𐙚 ‧₊˚ ⋅
The fire was dying again.
You and Coach Ben sat across from it, the silence thick between you. Most nights, no one really talked anymore. But tonight—tonight felt heavy, like something needed to be said. You were chewing on a piece of dried something (you didn’t ask), half-listening to the hiss of the flames when he broke the silence.
“You ever been in love?”
The question felt like it came out of nowhere. You blinked at him. “What?”
He gave a tired shrug. “It’s the kind of question you think about a lot out here.”
You stared into the fire for a long time, the heat kissing your cheeks. “No,” you answered too quickly. Then, quieter: “At least, I don’t think so.”
Coach nodded, then said gently, “What about boys?”
“I dated some, but my heart was never really in it.”You shrugged, pulling your knees up to your chest. “It’s always been like that. I tried. I kissed them. I let them take me out. But it just felt like going through the motions. Like I was acting out a scene someone else wrote.”
He looked at you, not with judgment but with something like… curiosity. “So what does feel real to you?”
Your heart stuttered. The answer lived right there, under your tongue, ready to spill. And once you started talking, it didn’t stop.
And someone came in your mind.
Natalie.
You let out a long breath and started speaking, your voice softer than usual.
“When me and Natalie were younger… I don’t think I ever realized how much I needed Natalie. But there was always something between us, something I could never quite explain.” You paused, taking a moment to collect your thoughts. "When we were at my house, my mom would always be downstairs, cooking or doing something. And Natalie and I would go up to my room, lock the door, and just... be together."
You ran a hand through your hair, trying to find the right words. “We’d lie there in my bed, close, too close sometimes. I’d press my legs against hers, feeling the heat of her body next to mine.”
“I think I always knew, even back then, that I wanted more. But I didn’t know how to say it, how to make it real.”
Coach Ben stayed silent, watching you as you spoke. His presence was comforting, and yet, there was a pang in your chest as you relived those memories.
𐙚 ‧₊˚ ⋅
You and Natalie were sitting on her bed in the dim light of her room, the air thick with the smell of cigarette smoke and the faint aroma of her cheap perfume. The faint sound of music played low, something from the ‘80s. Queen, maybe? You weren’t sure, but the static from the speakers added to the feeling of everything being just a little bit hazy.
She was sprawled across her bed, one leg bent, the other stretched out lazily, her ripped jeans showing more skin than you'd care to admit. Her black eyeliner smudged just slightly, as it always did, and her messy hair framed her face in the way it always did—like she didn’t care, but still somehow looked like she owned the room.
You were sitting a little too stiffly beside her, in your usual outfit of pink, a fuzzy sweater and white skirt with a flower hairclip on top of your head. A stark contrast to her—the good girl, the one who was always so... perfect.
You were used to the way people looked at you both, always wondering how the two of you ended up as best friends. You were opposites in every way. You were the quiet, perfect girl, the one who sat in the front of class and smiled politely. She was loud, messy, always caught up in something she shouldn’t be.
Still, here you were. Side by side, as you always were. Yet tonight, something felt different. You could feel it in the air, that shift that always came before something bigger, something you weren’t ready for but knew was inevitable.
“I don’t get why you hang out with me, (Y/N),” she muttered, her voice laced with something you couldn’t quite place. She turned her head, her eyes searching yours for something—maybe an answer. "I'm trouble, you know that, right?"
You glanced at her, biting your lip. You always hated when she said things like that. Like she wasn’t worth it, like you weren’t worth being around her.
“You’re not trouble,” you said, though your voice was quieter than you intended. “You’re just... complicated. But I like complicated.”
She snorted, a sharp sound that made your heart flutter in an oddly comforting way. “Yeah, sure. You like it ‘cause you’re perfect. You’ve got everything together. I’m just a mess.”
That ache you were feeling deep in your chest earlier felt heavier now. The gap between the two of you was always there, but tonight it felt bigger, harder to ignore. You looked at her again, really looked at her. Natalie—your best friend, the one who you’d known for years, who knew you better than anyone else ever could.
“Maybe I like you because I’m not perfect,” you said, the words spilling out before you could stop them. “And I don’t want to be.”
There was a long pause as Natalie processed your words. She tilted her head slightly, watching you closely, and then a small, almost sad smile tugged at the corner of her lips.
“You’re so good to me, cupcake,” she said softly, her voice barely above a whisper.
Your heart thudded painfully in your chest at the nickname. That nickname. She only ever called you that when she was soft, when she wasn’t trying to hide the part of her that was vulnerable, even if she didn’t always let herself show it.
“I’m not... I’m not good,” you whispered back, your words shaky. You wanted to say more, but the words were stuck in your throat. "You... you’ve been through so much. And you—"
But Natalie cut you off with a shake of her head, her expression turning serious. “You’ve always been good, (Y/N),” she said, her voice like gravel. "You just don’t see it. You always help me, no matter what. You keep me from falling apart."
Her words hung in the air, and you could feel them pressing down on you, making everything feel heavier. You sighed, running a hand through your hair. “You don’t have to let me in, you know? You can—"
“I’m not going anywhere,” she interrupted, her voice suddenly more forceful than before. She moved closer to you, her leg brushing against yours as she did. The proximity sent a jolt through your body, making your pulse quicken.
The closeness was something you both had always shared—laying side by side, pressing your legs together when you watched movies, when you talked about everything and nothing. But tonight, with everything hanging in the balance, it felt like so much more.
You stared at her for a long moment, the words you wanted to say stuck on your tongue. But then she spoke again, her voice quieter, more vulnerable this time.
“Promise me something,” she said, looking down at your intertwined legs. “Promise me you’ll never leave me. No matter how... messed up I get.”
You didn’t hesitate. “I promise.”
The air between you two felt thick now, like something unsaid was hanging there. But you couldn’t bring yourself to say it out loud yet. You couldn’t tell her what you were really feeling, not when the world seemed so uncertain.
You were so different. She was so different. And yet, you couldn’t imagine being anywhere but right here with her.
𐙚 ‧₊˚ ⋅
“She kissed me once,” you admitted, pulling your legs closer to your face.
“Said it was practice."
𐙚 ‧₊˚ ⋅
Madonna crooned from the cassette player, half-muffled by your bedroom pillow.
Like a virgin… touched for the very first time…
Natalie was sprawled next to you, one foot crossed over the other. Her flannel was sliding off one shoulder, eyes smudged with the kind of liner she never wiped off before crashing at your place. She had a joint in hand, laughing at something stupid you’d said about math class.
“Wanna practice?” she asked, not looking at you.
“Practice what?”
She raised a brow. “Kissing.”
You thought she was joking. But then she rolled over onto her side, facing you, close enough to smell the weed and grape soda on her breath.
You hesitated. “Okay.”
She leaned in like it was nothing. Like you were the one being weird about it. Her lips brushed yours, soft, slow, as if she’d done it a hundred times.
You didn’t even move at first. You just felt it—this terrible, perfect spark crawling up your spine. You kissed her back, and it felt like falling. You wanted to cry, and you didn’t know why.
When she pulled back, she grinned.
You wanted her to do it again.
And she did, again and again.
When she kissed you, it wasn’t playful. Not really. It was slow, searching. Her tongue moved against yours like she was memorizing it.
Later, she had pulled back, breathless, eyes darker than the night.
“Damn,” she whispered. “They don’t kiss like that.”
You didn’t sleep that night.
𐙚 ‧₊˚ ⋅
“She kissed me again, later,” you told Coach, your voice cracking. “A bunch of times. And then she touched me.”
You didn’t mean too say it out loud, but it was already gone. Out in the cold air, hanging there like smoke.
𐙚 ‧₊˚ ⋅
It had been late, after another party, when she’d stumbled into your car, laughing. Her eyeliner smeared, her voice sticky sweet with whiskey.
“You’re always so soft,” she murmured, leaning against you in the passenger seat, cheek pressed to your shoulder.
“You’re always so loud,” you said back, trying to steady your voice even though your hands were trembling on the wheel.
She laughed and turned her head, eyes glassy, breath warm on your skin.
You didn’t know what to say, so you didn’t. Just drove her home in silence, the quiet between you almost unbearable.
That night, she left her bedroom door cracked open like she always did when she didn’t want to sleep alone. You followed, heart hammering like you were doing something wrong.
You helped her change. Her skirt was hitched too high, her shirt sliding down one shoulder. When she sat on the edge of her bed, legs loose and lazy, she reached for the strap of your sando, tugging them, letting it leave your shoulder.
“Wanna practice again?” she whispered, lips brushing yours.
Your breath hitched, your cheeks flushing. “Yeah,” you said, and kissed her.
God, you kissed her like it would be the last time. Like it had to count.
It started soft. Your lips, her tongue, the way she cupped the back of your neck. But she tasted like smoke and sugar and something that burned, and soon your sando was half off, her hands under your bra, skimming the bare skin of your sides.
She touched you like she meant it. Like she’d been thinking about it.
Her hand slid beneath your waistband, fingers grazing the elastic of your panties. Your hips jolted.
“Natalie…” you gasped, but it wasn’t a protest. It was a plea.
She paused, eyes locking with yours. “You want me to stop?”
You shook your head.
Her fingers dipped lower, slow and careful, until she brushed against the wet heat of you. You choked out a sound, half gasp, half whimper.
“God, you’re already soaked,” she said, voice low and rough, almost reverent.
She kissed your collarbone as she slid a finger inside, then two. Her touch was practiced, but gentle. She curled them just right, dragging them slow, deep, the heel of her hand pressing firm against your clit. You buried your face in her neck, biting down to muffle the moan tearing from your throat.
“Fuck,” you breathed. “Don’t stop.”
She didn’t. Her fingers worked you open, curling and stroking, coaxing you toward the edge until your thighs were shaking, your back arching, your hands twisted in her sheets.
You came like that, trembling in her lap, forehead pressed to hers, a quiet sob catching in your throat.
She kissed you after, messy and slow. Then she pushed you gently down onto the bed and climbed between your legs.
“Wait - ” you started, but her mouth was already there.
She kissed your thighs first, soft, dragging her teeth across the skin. Her hands pushed your legs open, steady and sure. And then-
Her tongue. Warm, slow, deliberate. She licked a long stripe up your slit, then circled your clit, teasing, tasting.
You cried out.
“Natalie -”
She moaned against you like she was drunk on it. Like she wanted to ruin you slow.
And she did.
The last thing you remembered before the flashback burned out was the sound you made. loud, raw, real - and the way she looked up at you from between your legs like you were something sacred, as she enjoyed
You never noticed but the way she looked at you, it was love.
𐙚 ‧₊˚ ⋅
You looked down at your lap. Your hands were shaking.
“It was my first time,” you admitted.
Coach Ben nodded, listening intently.
You thought that was it—that the conversation would taper off into silence like everything else here did. But then he looked at you again, steady and quiet, like he was waiting for something to click.
“Maybe the love you’re looking for,” he said gently, “has always been in front of you. Waiting.”
You froze.
The fire popped. Your heart did too, in a different way.
He said it like he knew something you didn’t. Like he’d seen it in the way Natalie passed you her joint with soft fingers. The way she always sat just close enough that your knees touched. The way she looked at you when she thought you weren’t looking - tired, tender, like she didn’t know how to say don’t go.
“Maybe,” he added, “you’ve just been looking for it in the wrong people.”
Your throat burned. You didn’t have an answer.
Just Natalie’s name echoing through your chest like a secret you’d been too afraid to tell out loud.
Maybe he was right.
Maybe she’d always been right there.
Waiting.
And as you return to the cabin the, faint rise and fall of Natalie’s breathing as she lay curled up on the cot, her face relaxed in sleep.
There was space next to her, an empty spot on the edge of the blanket, clearly left for you.
You smiled softly to yourself, a strange warmth blooming in your chest. It was a small thing, but it meant the world to you.
As you moved closer, the cool night air from the door fading behind you, you hesitated. You knew what you were feeling now. You couldn’t ignore it anymore. You couldn’t hide from the truth.
Coach Ben’s words echoed in your mind—Maybe the love you're looking for has always been in front of you, waiting. You thought about it again, about how, all this time, you’d been searching for something that was never really gone.
It had always been Natalie.
You gently eased into the space beside her, sliding your arms around her waist and pulling her close. She stirred slightly but didn’t wake, her body fitting into yours like it was always meant to. You hugged her tightly from behind, feeling the warmth of her skin seep into yours.
And in the quiet of that moment, you realized what Coach Ben had meant. You’d been looking for love in all the wrong places, convinced that there was something out there for you, when all along it was right here. Right in front of you. Waiting.
Natalie.
The love you’d been searching for, the love you had been too scared to admit, was already yours.
And as you held her close, the world outside the cabin seemed so far away. The noise, the chaos, it all faded to nothing. All that mattered was the warmth of her body in your arms and the gentle sound of her breathing.
