throughfireandice replied to your post “I'm pretty new to spn and i'm kinda wondering if any of the cast knows...”
you forgot that it's also (imo) wildly ooc. but yeah can't agree more.
Lol Yes I also feel it is wildly ooc and I’m glad you agree
....................................................................................................................................
treefrogie84 replied to your post “I'm pretty new to spn and i'm kinda wondering if any of the cast knows...”
the first time i contemplated reading it, someone described it as Forrest Gump with more angst and without the decent soundtrack. I uh... ran off to Down to Agincourt instead.
*i take that back it was forest gump with less joy
Heh yeah the Forrest Gump rip off is apparently quite clear. I still haven’t read Down to Agincourt because I can’t quite stomach Endverse!Cas but I hear he is portrayed really well in that fic.
....................................................................................................................................
nikoshine replied to your post “I'm pretty new to spn and i'm kinda wondering if any of the cast knows...”
Just don't show fics to the cast period. I don't understand why it's so complicated to understand. If they wanted to read one they'd look for it themselves. Not all fans want to read fics so don't expect the cast to want to read them either.
Totally agree. I don’t think we should be showing the cast fanfics or talking about fanfics with them as they are not going to want to know about it. Especially if those fics are smutty - I mean do you really think Jensen and Misha are going to want to read explicit pornography about their characters? I know they ain’t at all innocent “Chinese Chair” pfft, but still, its a bit different. Same goes for porny or explicit fanart. By all means be proud of your work, but if its pornographic keep it well away from the cast.
(on a completely different note if I was an actress in a popular show I would LOVE to read fanfic about myself and my character... because hell yeah that would be awesome... but I am of a fandom mentality and totally used to the smutty stuff.)
....................................................................................................................................
postmodernmulticoloredcloak replied to your post “I'm pretty new to spn and i'm kinda wondering if any of the cast knows...”
doesn't it frame cas getting aids as the consequence of him, like, 'letting himself go' because of depression and missing dean or whatever, almost like it was his fault because he wasn't careful, like it's your fault if you got aids in the 80s??
So I have heard. Its basically completely problematic and hence I don’t think it “honours” Cas’s character one bit. I also think it makes Dean into a total jackass and doesn’t do a great job of portraying PTSD properly either. But hey, these are my opinions. Best thing to do is just not read it and hope it goes away (wishful thinking pfft)
....................................................................................................................................
destielonfire replied to your post “I'm pretty new to spn and i'm kinda wondering if any of the cast knows...”
i started reading this fic and couldn't get past the first 3k or so...didn't like the characterisation or the writing style at all
Sounds like you did what I did. I read the first two chapters then skimmed to get the jist of the story and hated it. I just don’t understand its popularity, usually even if a fic ain’t written really well or has a few flaws I can at least get through it but I jut failed to remain focused and spent all my time rolling my eyes whilst reading. How is it so popular??
....................................................................................................................................
grey2510 replied to your post “I'm pretty new to spn and i'm kinda wondering if any of the cast knows...”
THANK YOU.
Heh - someone had to say it!
....................................................................................................................................
untamedpassages replied to your post “I'm pretty new to spn and i'm kinda wondering if any of the cast knows...”
bless you
Aww shucks I thought you guys would be mad at me!
....................................................................................................................................
awed-frog replied to your post “I'm pretty new to spn and i'm kinda wondering if any of the cast knows...”
YES
I’m laughing right now because I hesitated posting that post because it is such a ridiculously popular fic that I honestly thought I would just get people protesting my opinion and getting mad at me. I am amazed that so many others also find this fics popularity fucking annoying. What has completely baffled me is how popular it is. If we all can’t stand the bloody thing then why the hell is it still number one on AO3? (with rumours that they may publish it god forbid) Could this become the destiel fandoms fucking Fifty Shades? (hopefully not because of Forrest Gump plagiarism LOL) or even worse.... our “My Immortal”? *shudders*. I just don’t get it. I will never get it. At least I have finally gotten this off my chest though because honestly I think it was considered like a major taboo not to like this stupid thing in this fandom which is ridiculous really. Anyway, thank you to all who replied. You have made me feel much less alone in this!












