The Case of the Stolen Identity: Intersex Edition
Let me set the scene for you.
Imagine that you are 20 years old. You are at a regularly scheduled doctor’s appointment. You are expecting this checkup to be just like every other one you’ve had and yet, it’s not. Instead the doctor, this person you literally trust with your life, tells you something is wrong. You’re scared (as most people in your shoes would be) and you don’t know what to do.
Finally the doctor returns but there is a very somber look on his face. It makes the pit in your stomach grow impossibly bigger.
Doctor: *very seriously* There’s something wrong with you.
Doctor: You’re not who you thought you were.
You: *panicked* Is this some kind of joke?
Doctor: No, it’s not a joke. We made a mistake and well you’re simply not who you thought you were.
Suddenly, the rug has been pulled right out from under you and nothing makes sense anymore. Up is down and down is up. Left is right and right is left. You have entered some kind of alternate universe where you are no longer yourself and there are no words to properly describe how you’re feeling.
Now, this all sounds pretty ridiculous right? How are you “not who you thought you were”? This seems like the kind of straight to television movie no one would want to watch, except perhaps late at night when no one is around (a guilty pleasure of sorts).
Well you’re right, the scene doesn’t unfold like this. But it does unfold in a similar manner for someone who is born intersex.
Intersex, as defined by the Intersex Society of America, is “a general term used for a variety of conditions in which a person is born with a reproductive or sexual anatomy that doesn’t seem to fit the typical definitions of female or male”. To put this into more layman’s terms, intersex resides in the awkward middle ground between being a male or a female.
Confused? If so, I am not surprised. Intersex is not a word we hear very often. In fact, it is not a word I knew even existed until I was a freshman in college. That is because society does not want you to know about this ‘deviant’ category – this awkward sex that complicates the idea that there are only two sexes. To quote a very famous television sitcom, how rude!
I’m just kidding. They are not the rude ones, not at all. They couldn’t help the fact that they were BORN THIS WAY. The people who should be blamed are the ones who do not believe that those born intersex should have the right not remain that way. Those who purposefully harm and practically mutilate these intersex bodies simply because we do not understand them.
I’m looking at you Doctors.
For some reason it is hard to accept that there is some kind of middle ground between male and female (even though science itself proves that this is a pretty common occurrence). So what do they do? They force parents to make a decision – male or female. I kid you not, parents who have children that are born intersex are told that, for their child’s safety, they need to pick either one sex or the other.
And so begins the Case of the Stolen Identity: Intersex Edition.
What kind of identity is a baby supposed to have if it is stolen right out from under them? How are they supposed to grow up and be who they are if, mere moments after they are born, their future is decided for them?
Now that I’ve explained what intersex, let me reset the scene from earlier for you.
Imagine that you are at home going through a box of old things in your attic. You come across a dusty photo album and decide to flip through it (you’ve always been a sucker for reminiscing about your past). When you open it however, you are extremely surprised to find that the pictures are not of you but of someone else. Someone with dressed in denim overalls and smiling at the camera with a small truck in his hands.
You run your hand across the photo, confused. What is this photo doing here and who is this boy? You continue looking through the album and find more photos of the same person but it doesn’t make any sense. You’re an only child. Why is there an album of this boy in your attic among a collection of your things?
Then the puzzle pieces start to fall into place.
This boy looks just like you – same eyes, same nose, same mouth.
He is posed in pictures with your parents and he looks so happy. They do too.
Could it be? Did you have a twin you never knew about? A brother who died early and whom your parents never wanted you to know existed?
You rush downstairs to show your mother the album and, when she bursts into tears, you think you have solved the mystery. For a few minutes, you let this feeling swallow you whole. A brother. A twin no less. Gone before you ever got the chance to know him.
But your world is shattered when your mom sits you down and says, “That’s not your brother sweetie. That’s you.”
Suddenly, the rug has been pulled right out from under you and nothing makes sense anymore. Up is down and down is up. Left is right and right is left. You have entered some kind of alternate universe where you are no longer yourself and there are no words to properly describe how you’re feeling.
Now that you know what you know, that first scene I mentioned seems a little less outlandish. Identities can and have been stolen from people without them ever knowing it until years later.
For our plenary on April 13, we watched a documentary called Intersexion. It told the story of countless intersex individuals and their experiences growing up. For me, it was extremely emotional to hear all these tales of people whose futures were decided for them. Whose identities were stolen right out from under their young noses.
I wonder if the doctors who performed these gender assignment surgeries all those years ago ever stopped to think about the consequences of their actions. Did they ever wonder how much more harm than good they were doing? Because, when I watched that documentary, that’s all I heard. More anger than happiness. More pain than bliss. More feeling lost than being found.
And, if you really think about it, it all makes sense. How are you supposed to be happy with yourself when you don’t even know who you are?
Another thought that crossed my mind after watching this documentary was this: how much untapped potential was stifled because we couldn’t accept that a child was born ‘different’? How many people were too bogged down by the weight of not being accepted to reach their full potential? How many future politicians, doctors, activists, authors, and composers did we lose because we couldn’t say “well you’re a human so we are going to accept you for who you are”?
The more I think about, the more I realize that intersex people had more than just their identity stolen from them. They had their innocence given away the moment a doctor proclaimed, “You have to decide – boy or girl?”
But what if this wasn’t a decision that had to be made? What if, instead of making parents choose between one or the other, we acknowledge the existence of both? What if, as one of the interviewees in the documentary put it, “Instead of saying ‘congratulations, it’s a boy or girl’, we say ‘congratulations, you have a beautiful, healthy baby’?”
To answer his question, I’d say that bringing a baby into this world without the constraints of acknowledging its sex the moment it is born maybe, just maybe, could solve The Case of the Stolen Identity: Intersex Edition.