Using Varric in Inquisition was such a wasted opportunity too.
Even people who hated DA2 loved Varric so I guess it was a no-brainer to bring him into the new game, but then he was just... there.
His role in the game is to banter with the other characters and bring Hawke into the game. But what do we learn about him? Now that he’s not the narrator of the game, do we see a different side of him? Is this where we find out character flaws he left out of the story he tells Cassandra? Do we get insight into his personality, his backstory?
There are a couple little bits in the banter maybe - like he seems much angrier at Anders than he let on in DA2 - but because it isn’t really explored it comes off as more of an inconsistency in the character than actual development. Does he feel betrayed by Anders, someone he considered a friend, causing him to lose the only home he ever knew? How much blame does he put on Anders? Does he still consider him a friend? Does what happened affect his opinions of mages, his ability to trust people?
They never REALLY dug into how heartbroken he was over the destruction of Kirkwall. He just mentions that Kirkwall’s a wreck in banter once or twice and sounds sad. But come on guys. Give me more. How does it feel for a surface dwarf, his parents exiled from their thaig, now twice-removed from his roots? How is it for him to live at Skyhold after having to flee Kirkwall? Does he want to go back someday? Or is Skyhold his home now? I really can’t tell!
Is he lonely? His friends of over a decade have scattered to the four winds and some of them he will probably never see again. He calls Hawke his best friend and he can only rarely see them, because they’re a fugitive. He apparently sees Bianca only rarely too. How does he feel about this? Is he fine with this arrangement? Does he resent it? Does he miss her terribly all the time? Or is he used to this now, her being a memory? Does he ever think about moving on? Or is that inconceivable? Are the Inquisition companions his friends like the DA2 party were friends, or are they temporary business associates? How does he feel about Cassandra, who technically kidnapped and interrogated him? He can laugh and joke with her, but he’s Varric, he can do that with everyone. Is he still angry at her? Does he even like her? I don’t know these things! Why don’t I know these things?!
I feel like I understand him LESS after Inquisition than I did in DA2 and that’s really sad for me. We can use some of the factoids they added to his backstory to try to reconstruct this stuff but we really, really shouldn’t have to.