you remind me of a tragedy, but i prefer you that way
( love, told in three parts )
amos & aurelia
i. ask me to describe this love in two words, and i’ll tell you: toxic acidity
When Aurelia Theodosia Apfel is born into this world, she sees it in black and white. For a long time, she thinks nothing of it. The world has always been black, white, and varying shades of gray to her, so it doesn’t bother her. She still thinks there’s a beauty in the monochromatic image that greets her every time she opens her eyes.
She’s four years old when she hears her parents describing their new house. In color. Colors that she’s only ever heard of, but has never seen. Reds and blues and greens, hues and shades that they can somehow see. And for a while after that, she’s afraid. Afraid that she’s different from those around her. Afraid that there’s something wrong with her.
When she shares this fear with her parents, they laugh, though it’s not an unkind gesture. “No, Theo,” her mother soothes, brushing hair behind the child’s ear. “You’re perfect, baby girl. You just haven’t found them yet.” That night, as she goes to bed, her parents tell her a story of soulmates. Only when you meet yours – only when you touch them – will the world appear in color. It seems impossible to her – the idea of having some sort of condition that makes the world appear in monochromes makes a lot more sense, even to her four year old mind – but it excites her, nonetheless. She goes to bed that night, and prays to one day find her soulmate.
She’s eight years old when she meets Bishop Villegas. He’s three years older than her, and he’s pretty funny, and protective. He has long hair and a wicked smile, and something in Aurelia pulls her towards him. She thinks that he might be her soulmate, but whenever she touches him, she doesn’t see anything new. There are no new colors, no wonder or beauty that she hasn’t already seen a thousand times.
One day, he tells her that he’s been seeing the world in color for as long as he can remember. “Sometime back in pre-school,” he tells her distractedly, brushing her hair back for her. He has an older sister, and a baby sister, too, and he’s better at doing her hair than she is. “I don’t remember who it was, though.”
“Do you miss them,” she finds herself asking. She doesn’t know if she wants to know the answer.
Bishop is silent for a few minutes. He sets down the brush, and starts to braid her hair. “Sometimes,” he finally answers, his voice quiet; she wonders if this some secret he’s always kept. She wonders why he’s telling her. “I can… feel them, you know? Every time they’re hurt, or sad, or just… worn out. I can feel that. And sometimes, I want to be there for them. I think… I don’t know, they’d feel better if I were.”
Aurelia does understand. She feels her soulmate, too. She’s never met them, but she can feel every mood, every ache and pain. Once, she had seen through their eyes. It was only for a few moments, when they were having an anxiety attack, but she had been right there with them. She only nods, and prompts, “But?”
“But,” he continues, “sometimes, I kind of hate it. Being tied to someone like this. I don’t want to share someone else’s life. And I doubt they want to share mine, either. Sometimes I think it’d be easier to share if I knew them, but other times… I don’t know. I think it’d just make me angrier.”
Aurelia weighs his words for a few moments, before finally asking, “Would you hate them? If you did know them?”
He doesn’t answer immediately. In fact, by the time he does answer, her hair is braided back in an elegant fishtail, and all of the brushes, rubber bands, and headbands have been returned to their respective places. It’s when she gets up to leave that he finally murmurs, “I don’t know. That might be the scariest part.”
She moves to Milwaukee when she turns thirteen. Bishop – sixteen hers old, strong and independent as ever, playing dad to all of his siblings, no matter how much they tell him to chill – hugs her tight, kisses her on the forehead, tells her to stay safe out there. Her friend, Julianne, hugs her briefly and tells her to keep kicking ass and taking names. The rest of her friends – few as they are – give her kinder farewells, but those are the ones that matter the most to her.
Those are the ones that keep her from crying on the plane, and on the way to her new home, and when she’s lying in bed in her new room. She holds onto them, crying out to Bishop and Julianne, if only in her mind. She knows they don’t hear, knows that they aren’t her soulmates, but she aches for them, anyway. And she sends a silent apology to whoever is on the other side of this link. She apologizes profusely for the pain that they must feel, hopes that it doesn’t hurt as much as all of the times she’s felt their pain. She tries to stamp down on the pain of the move and the loneliness, but it’s still there, and no amount of willpower wishes that away.
Her father finds her crying in the middle of the night, and he wraps his arms around her. “Oh, Theo,” he whispers into her hair, pressing a tender kiss there. “It’ll pass, love. It’ll pass.” She wonders if he means the pain of the move, or the pain of missing her friends, or the pain of needing a soulmate.
Whatever he means, she’s glad for it. She keeps crying into his arms, finding comfort in the fact that there’s someone on the other side, somewhere, feeling the same pain. She hopes that they feel the same comfort, but doesn’t bank on it.
She makes sure to touch every person she meets. She’s casual about it, and careful, at the same time. She takes time, being sure not to make them uncomfortable. She’s sure that at least half of them see through her, if their pitying smiles are anything to go by. Of the dozens of people she meets in her time in Milwaukee, not a single one of them brings color to her world.
It’s disappointing, but she expects no less. She stops looking for the one, a fact that makes her parents’ hearts hurt, she knows, and instead looks for friends. She ignores those who pity her, but not those who are fortunate enough to have found their other halves. She listens to their stories of love – romantic or otherwise – and of hatred, because not every soulmate is the one you want. Those stories make her happy. They give her hope; maybe it’s a good thing that she hasn’t found the one, yet. Maybe the world will always be the same three colors, but at least she’ll be happy.
That’s the lie she tells herself, anyway. It… isn’t as convincing as she wants to pretend it is.
When she’s fifteen years old, her parents die.
The bank that they’re in is robbed, and they end up being casualties of war, and she becomes an orphan. She doesn’t have any close family, or any family friends who are close enough for her to live with. She sits at the police station, tear tracks staining her cheeks, wondering what the hell she’s going to do now, when her phone rings.
The caller ID tells her that it’s Julianne, and she damn near breaks down into tears again. She wonders how the other girl knows; she hasn’t been able to call anyone yet. She’s just getting over the shock of everything. Before she answers, she realizes that there’s no way Julianne could know, so she must be calling for a completely different reason. She sucks it up, and answers anyway. “H-hey,” she croaks, cursing her voice for breaking the way it does.
Luckily, Julianne doesn’t notice. “Aur! I found him!”
Aurelia blinks. “You… found who?”
“My soulmate,” Julianne clarifies, sounding more excited than she’s been in the six years that Aurelia has known her. “I was just walking through town square, Aur, and I found him.”
And it’s horrible and selfish of Aurelia, but that’s the last thing she wants to hear. And the fact that Julianne doesn’t get that, doesn’t see that now isn’t the time, it infuriates her. Even so, she paints on a smile. “That’s great, Julie,” she says, trying her hardest to be as sincere as possible. “You have to tell me all about it. Just.. not now, okay?”
On the other end of the line, Julianne pauses. “Of course. Hey, what’s going on?”
“Nothing,” Aurelia lies. And she doesn’t know why she does it. She just can’t find it in herself to rain on Julianne’s parade. Julianne has never cared much for soulmates, but this guy must be something if he’s made her this excited. And Aurelia can’t be the one to ruin that. “I just have this cold, and I fought with my parents, and…” If she chokes up there, she can blame it on her supposed cold.
“Okay,” Julianne accepts, though it doesn’t sound like she completely believes it. “Get better, okay? And, hey, I know what it’s like to fight with your parents. It doesn’t last forever. You guys will be back to being best friends in no time.”
It takes everything in Aurelia not to cry then, because that’s the thing – they won’t. “Y-yeah,” she agrees, biting down hard on her lip to keep the tears at bay. “I’ll talk to you later, okay?” She hangs up before she can break into tears again.
She doesn’t remember calling Bishop, but by the time dawn breaks, he’s storming into the station like a man possessed. He wraps his arms around her, letting her scream into his chest. The officers pass by, giving her pitying looks, but they don’t say anything. Bishop takes her home after some time, and she cries herself to sleep. When she wakes up, he’s packed enough stuff to get her back to Lima. “You’re going to stay with us for a while,” he explains, holding her hands in his. “Freya, Twitch, and I are all over the age of eighteen. We can have legal guardianship over you for a while – just until you can find a better home, or a relative you want to stay with. We…” He must run out of things to say, because he never finishes.
Numbly, Aurelia nods. “Okay.”
“Aur…” He takes a deep breath. “Your dad… he didn’t die on the spot. There was a baby… His parents were killed, too, and your dad… he was going to…”
“We’ll take him with us,” she decides, not bothering to hear him stumble through the rest of it. She already knows where he’s going with this. What do you want to do about it, he means to say. “We… I’ll take care of him.”
Bishop’s brows furrow, and he shakes his head. “Auri, no. You’re only fifteen, you can’t–”
“And you’re eighteen. You can take legal guardianship. Just until I’m old enough to take him by myself. We can’t… Bishop, I can’t…” She bites her lips, and tears come without restraint. She can’t say it, but she can see in her eyes that he gets it. She’s left alone with no parents, and no home, and she can’t leave this baby in this same state. Her parents died trying to give this baby a home, and she won’t let it go without.
Bishop nods, a look of understanding on his face. “Okay.”
They make the decision not to tell anyone.
Bishop is less than approving, and Freya is even less, but they respect her decision. She doesn’t want anyone to pity her for losing her parents, or to try to take her in. They make up this lie that she and Bishop are the reason that Milo is an orphan. They keep it vague, and no one asks. Everyone probably assumes that there was a car accident, or some sort of legal altercation. They don’t care to ask.
And if anyone wonders where Aurelia’s parents are, they sure as hell don’t ask.
Aurelia thinks that Bishop and his family – and maybe even she, herself – are waiting for someone to ask. They’re waiting for someone to notice that someone is wrong. If not Julianne, then one of Aurelia’s new friends: River, or Cassie, or Declan, or someone. They’re all waiting for someone to realize that Aurelia is here, and she’s living with the Villegas family, and no one has ever mentioned her family. They wait for someone to realize that the story is incomplete, but no one ever does.
She lies to herself and says that it’s better that way.
(That lie falls apart, however, when she has a breakdown and ruins her hand. The hand that she needed to get a scholarship to Julliard. Freya holds her tight, and then drives her to the hospital.
They never talk about it after that, but they all know, without a doubt, that Aurelia’s falling apart, too.)
Julianne’s sixteenth birthday comes with a bit of a flourish.
Stephen and Carli – her brother and sister – try to get her to have a big party, though they pretty much all know that she won’t accept it. She isn’t the type of girl who enjoys parties, or social activities, or anything like that. She doesn’t even want to spend time with Stephen’s friends, the pack or something, but shoos her brother away so that he can spend time with them. He argues that he’d rather spend the day with her, but she knows it’s a lie. Instead, she calls over her best friends and her boyfriend, and has a movie night with them.
Aurelia – with a messed up hand and an overwhelming amount of anxiety – arrives last. Pohai, Carli, Cassie, and Jason are all there and seated by the time she gets there. Though Julianne is definitely the best friend she has here, she’s amicable enough with all of them so that she slightly relaxes at the sight of them.
Then Julianne’s boyfriends exits the bathroom. “Oh,” he blinks after they’re introduced. A wide grin spreads across his face. “It’s nice to meet you.”
And that’s that. They make themselves comfortable on the couch; Jason sits on one end, and he playfully pulls Cassie down into his lap. Carli curls up next to him, resting her head on his shoulder, and Pohai takes the love seat on the side, wrapping a blanket tight around her shoulders. Amos takes the opposite end of the couch, throwing his arm around the back, and Julianne curls into him, leaving the only open spot being between Carli and Julianne. Aurelia doesn’t think before she takes it. She simply curls up next to her best friend, enjoying the warmth of being surrounded by people she’s mostly comfortable with. She tucks her cold feet behind Carli’s back, drawing a laugh from the girl.
She makes herself comfortable, leaning against Julianne. All she does, really, is shift just an inch, without even meaning to, and she brushes against Amos’ thumb.
And the world explodes into color. Previously dull colors are now a vibrant and beautiful palette. Julianne’s hair is brown, and Carli’s skin is dark, and Pohai’s hair is white, and the people on the television screen have black hair, and blonde hair, and green eyes. It’s a surreal experience, and she struggles to take it all in.
“Rella?” She looks up, meeting Pohai’s concerned eyes. “You okay, babe?”
No. No, she’s most definitely not okay. Her soulmate is Julianne’s soulmate. She’s tethered to her best friend’s boyfriend, and she has no chance of cutting it. Instead of saying that, she just smiles and says, “Yeah.”
Aurelia knows without a shadow of a doubt that Amos is her soulmate.
She knows with equal certainty that she isn’t his.
She chances a glance at him once after her revelation, but he’s deeply engrossed in a conversation with Julianne. He looks at her like she’s the sun, the stars, the moon, and the one who hung them, and Julianne gives him the same look. But when he looks at Aurelia, he just gives her a polite smile, before looking away again.
It feels incredibly cramped on the couch now, and she can’t take it. When she moves to get up from the couch, she’s met with concerned looks. “Are you leaving,” Julianne asks, frowning up.
“No,” Aurelia denies quickly, even though she should. She should leave, should go back to Bishop’s house, and pretend as though she never felt anything at all. “Just getting on the floor. There are too many of us on the couch, it’s just…” She doesn’t finish, just starts to get on the floor, when a hand wraps around her wrist. And it’s impossible, and it’s horrible, really, but she already knows who the hand belongs to.
“Hey, no,” Amos says, pulling her back onto the couch. “I can get on the floor, okay? You should stay on the couch.”
“It’s fine,” she presses, pulling her hand back. She does it slowly, gently, so that it doesn’t feel like she’s snapping at him, or being rude in any way. “I don’t mind.”
He gives her a look. “No, seriously–”
“Oh my god,” Jason groans, running a hand over his face. “We all fit. There’s no reason for anyone to get on the floor. And if you’re really uncomfortable, Aur, I can go grab the beanbag from Juju’s room.”
Julianne nods, locking eyes with Aurelia. “Do you want him to?” It’s clear in her eyes what she wants Aurelia to say. She wants her to say that it’s fine, that they’re all fine, but she expects the opposite.
Aurelia purposely doesn’t look at Amos when she says, “No. It’s… it’s fine. I’m fine.”
She not. She hasn’t been; not in a while. But he doesn’t need to know that.
Julianne’s brother gets this (horrible) idea to drag Aurelia to his pack parties. Julianne goes without complaint, as does Carli, and the three McKiney-Lowe kids have little dificulty pulling her with them. The fact that Twitch’s girlfriend, Wendy, is coming makes her a bit less reluctant to go, but she’s still uncomfortable, nonetheless.
Wendy smiles kindly at her, keeping a loose hold on her uninjured hand. Aurelia had told the redhead the truth almost immediately after meeting her. There’s something undeniably kind, and trustworthy in her smile. “People see me and think I’m some airhead rich girl,” she had said upon meeting Aurelia. “I’m not that girl, I promise.”
Not even five minutes later, Aurelia was spilling her guts to Wendy. She hadn’t hesitated to promise to keep it secret – even from her own sister and friends – and hadn’t shown an ounce of pity. Being able to tell someone the truth, without having to worry about pity or fake sympathies lifted a weight off of Aurelia’s chest; one she had previously been ignoring.
Having Wendy here made it a bit easier to breathe, despite the anxiety that came from being around so many strangers.
As it turns out, she had no reason to fear. In less than an hour, she’s laughing, bumping into the pack members without a care. Her laughter is abruptly cut when she feels arms wrap around her waist. “No,” she gasps, trying to wiggle out of Kellan’s hold. “Put me down! Kellan Aldridge, put me down!”
Marilyn rolls her eyes, pulling out of her embrace with Tatum. “Kellan, she’s only been here for an hour. Don’t throw her in the pool, or you’re going to scare her off.”
Kellan seems less than happy about it, but he sets Aurelia down with an apology, and whirls around to snap at his snickering best friends.
Ariel shakes her head fondly, making her way to Aurelia. “Ignore the pups,” she advises, a beautiful smile set on her lips. “Help me take these inside?”
She doesn’t think before she agrees. “These,” she asks to confirm, gesturing towards the trays on the table in front of them. Ariel nods, and picks up one, and Aurelia picks up the other.
She makes it four steps before her hand locks up. She doesn’t manage to stifle her cry of pain, nor does she manage to keep her hold on the platter. It clatters to the ground, food scattering every which way. She grits her teeth to hold back tears – tears of pain and humiliation – and keeps her head down as she cradles her hand to her chest. She’s painfully aware of everyone’s eyes on her, and she’s more than aware of how much food she just wasted. All because she didn’t think. “I’m sorry,” she chokes out. “I’m so sorry, I…”
Ariel and Ella exchange a glance, and Ella crosses the short distance to Aurelia. “It’s okay, sweetie,” she mutters, placing a comforting hand on the younger’s girl arm. Behind her, Ariel, Chandler, and Caleb bend down to pick up the fallen food. “It’s okay. Is your hand okay?”
Aurelia chances a glance up at her, eyes lined with tears, and she takes a breath. “It’s fine,” she lies. “It just…” Won’t stop shaking, yet it won’t move. “It’s fine,” she says again.
“Let’s go put some ice on it,” Wendy suggests, placing an arm around her friend’s shoulders. “Come on. I might have some pain pills in my purse.” And it isn’t necessarily a lie; she probably does have pain pills in her purse. But they both know she has Aurelia’s bottle of medication in there, too, prescribed specifically for her hand. “It’s okay. No one’s mad at you. It’s okay.”
Aurelia keeps her head down, allowing herself to be ushered inside. Wendy continues muttering reassurances, and Aurelia keeps her tears at bay. She almost breathes a sigh of relief when they reach the inside of the house, but it’s cut when she hears Julianne from behind her. “What the hell was that?”
Aurelia flinches. “Juli–”
“Don’t,” the smaller teen snaps. “You’ve been hiding a lot from me, and I’ve been fine pretending that I don’t notice. But don’t you dare try to tell me that nothing happened out there.”
Wendy steps forward. “Julianne, I really don’t think now is the time.”
The smaller brunette’s eyes snap to Wendy, and her jaw clenches in a subtle way. Most people wouldn’t be able to decode that look, but Aurelia can. She knows her best friend far too well not to. Julianne is far too stubborn and prideful to admit to something this silly, but Aurelia knows that look too well.
She’s jealous. Jealous that Wendy knows something that she doesn’t; jealous that Aurelia has chosen to confide in someone she’s known for a few months, rather than someone she’s known for most of her life. Aurelia wants more than anything to soothe her nerves, but there’s no way she can. If she opens up about her hand, she’ll have to tell the truth about her parents and Milo, and she’ll be lucky if she can keep from spilling about Amos. Not even Wendy, or Bishop, or anyone knows about that, and Aurelia will be damned if she lets it slip now.
Even so. Even so, she can’t just leave things like this. Not with Julianne. She puts her free hand on Wendy’s arm, giving the redhead a grateful smile, before looking to Julianne. “I, um… when I moved back, I felt a little overwhelmed with everything, and I…” She lifts her shaking hand, and shrugs. “I didn’t want to make you worry. Wendy’s dating Bishop’s brother, remember? She comes over a lot, so..” She shrugs again, as if Wendy found out by accident. As if she just happened to walk in on Aurelia taking her medicine, and that was that.
It couldn’t be further from the truth, but it relaxes Julianne. She nods slowly. “Are you…” She meets Aurelia’s eyes, and the concern there is uncharacteristically open. Guilt eats at Aurelia’s heart for her lies, but she swallows it down. This is for the best. “Your cello…”
“Oh,” Aurelia breathes, as if she’d forgotten about that. “I’m taking physical therapy for it. It’s… helping.”
It’s a lie. Physical therapy doesn’t help; not in the least. She’s too busy trying to put distance between herself and her therapist, who – to his credit –tries not to be a perv. He’s twice her age, and makes it obvious that he isn’t interested in banging fifteen year olds. Even so, his touches sometimes linger, and there are times when his gaze darkens with what she fears is lust before he carefully covers it.
Julianne’s eyes are piercing, and Aurelia has no doubt that she doesn’t believe her.
At the time, though, she has no idea just how much.
“This is unnecessary.”
Amos frowns, while Julianne rolls her eyes. “Shut up.”
“I’m serious,” Aurelia stresses, folding her arms over her chest. She risks a glance at Amos, before hurriedly looking away. “I was fine with my last therapist.”
“Your last therapist scared you,” her companions chorus. Amos continues, his voice dull, yet laced with barely concealed rage, “You literally ran out of your last therapy session in tears because you thought he was trying to feel you up.”
A blush colors her cheeks, and Aurelia looks to the ground. “I am literally never telling you two anything again.”
Amos chuckles, taking her hands in his. It takes everything in her not to jerk away, and let her lead him towards Julianne’s bedroom. “I’m glad you told us,” he admits. “And I’m glad Julianne asked me to do this.” Without even seeming to realize it, he started massaging his thumbs into her hands. “I’m not an expert at this,” he confesses, an almost apologetic tilt to his lips. “But I’ve dealt with messed up hands before. And even if I can’t bring you back to total health, you can trust that I won’t try to cop a feel while your hands are healing.” He pauses, and for a moment, her heart stops, though she isn’t quite sure why. “You do trust me, right?”
Every morsel of her very being screams at her to say no, to take the loophole she’s been presented, and get the hell out. Instead, she finds herself mutterings a breathless, “Yes.”
And dammit if his smile doesn’t make her foolishness worth it.
“You have beautiful hair.”
Tabitha’s nose scrunches up, and she tosses another fry into her mouth. “That’s such a weird thing to say,” she says, swallowing the salty delicacy. Taking a detour through the McDonald’s drive thru probably wasn’t the best idea on the day of Aurelia’s Super Huge Very Big And Important Recital (as Lily had titled it), but half of them had slept in – a result of game night at Percy’s – and none of them had eaten breakfast. It doesn’t really matter. Aurelia isn’t exactly rushing to be on stage again; she’d much rather be hidden in the back corner of Lily’s SUV than on that stage, having a breakdown.
Duke rolls his eyes at his girlfriend, taking a chicken nugget from Aurelia’s lap. She doesn’t know why he’s chosen to sit in the very back with her, instead of in the row ahead with Tabitha and Wendy, but she’s glad for the company. Even if he does devour all of her chicken nuggets. “It’s not weird,” Duke argues.
“Kind of weird,” Wendy sides, not looking up from her phone. Twitch is supposed to be meeting them at the theater – seeing as Lily invited literally everyone in Aurelia’s life, without so much as asking – but had somehow forgotten to set his GPS or MapQuest it. (In short, he just needs a reason to text Wendy while he forces Freya to drive.) “But also kind of sweet.”
Percy – who’s driving, while Lily fiddles with the radio – glances up in the mirror, before looking back to the road. “I agree with Duke, actually,” he says, as they drive past a shopping complex. “Your hair looks marvelous, Aurelia.”
Aurelia blushes, looking down to her lap, but Lily snorts. “Who the fuck says marvelous? You’re not British.”
“Remind me again why I’m dating you.”
Aurelia and her hair are forgotten as the couple dissolves into thinly veiled flirting, but her smile doesn’t leave. In the month following Amos’ induction as her rehab director -- or whatever he’s supposed to be -- it’s gotten a lot easier to use her hand. Thankfully, he hasn’t asked what happened to it in the first place, and he doesn’t seem too curious. He’s taught her how to play guitar, shown her how to play some of his songs – because, yes, that’s her life; her soulmate is pop star, of all things – and given her so many compliments, she’s almost managed to fool herself into thinking he might actually think she’s cute.
Except, she knows that’s not it. She knows that all of his compliments are just a result of his own altruism. He wants to boost her confidence, so he throws words like beautiful and talented at her. She knows they’re empty.
Duke’s hand misses the tray of nuggets entirely, and lands on her knee. When she looks at him, he doesn’t look the least bit apologetic. He gives her a sad smile, as if he can hear her thoughts, and squeezes her knee encouragingly. “You’re going to be fine,” he swears. And it’s not you’re going to do great, or everything will be fine. It’s a promise that she will be fine, and she’s left to wonder how much he’s figured out. They spend so much time together, it wouldn’t be out of the realm of possibility for him to know anything, or even everything.
Instead of asking, she just wraps her hands around his, and reminds herself to breathe.
There is nothing like being in the spotlight.
It’s a beautiful thing, actually. It doesn’t highlight the fact or feeling of every eye in the room being trained on you. It doesn’t make every nerve in your body tense up until movement is a laughable notion. The light is sucked out of the rest of the room, drowning the world around you in darkness. When the spotlight shines on you, the only thing you can see is the space two, three feet ahead of you.
It’s you and your instrument.
Aurelia and her cello.
Her heartbeat slows to a manageable drum when the lights go off, and she can finally breathe. In the seconds before the accompaniment starts the song, she inhales. Everyone she knows is there. She saw them walk through the door. Dashiell, Oliver, Milo, and the Villegas family. The rebellion. Brielle and her friends (and teacher). Some of the members of the pack. Jason and Luna. Cassie and her group of friends. Julianne. Amos.
Her parents’ absence hits so strongly, it brings a fresh sting of tears to her eyes, and she’s forced to push them back.
Then, the piano starts, and her moment is over. She exhales, and starts to play.
She may not be able to see them, but she can feel the weight of their gazes on her. She can feel every eye that’s trained on her, can hear every murmur that leaves the lips of her enraptured audience. She feels every breath that’s drawn, feels it like it’s her own.
The song isn’t even halfway through when her hand starts hurting. The pain is dull, at first, and she forces herself to push through it. If therapy with Amos hasn’t taught her anything else, it’s taught her how to push through the pain. So she continues to play, feeling the song resonate in her spirit. She closes her eyes, the way her mother used to do when she played the violin, and she makes herself forget.
She forgets that everyone is watching her. She forgets that her best friends have taken time out of their days, time when they could be spending with each other, to be here for her. She forgets that Julianne’s hand is probably gripping Amos’ right now, wallowing in his love, ignorant to the turmoil that Aurelia experiences with every moment they spend together. She forgets that her soulmate is her best friend’s soulmate, and has no idea how she feels, or what she knows. She forgets that everyone she loves is in love, and they’re happy, and she doesn’t have that. She forgets that her parents are dead, and she has no one to talk to about this, because it’s no one’s problem but her own. She forgets that at the end of the day, she’s alone, and there’s no changing that.
Tries to, anyway.
When she opens her eyes, the song is over and tears threaten to fall from her eyes. The audience applauds, and she hears a few cat calls and wolf whistles, and she forces a smile to her face as she stands to bow. The pianist takes her cello from her hand, and she smiles gratefully as she walks off stage. She doesn’t know what happened to her cello; she doesn’t care.
She makes it to her dressing room and decidedly does not cry.
Aurelia finds out very quickly that Monty cannot bake.
"This isn’t funny,” he grumbles, egg yolk dripping from his fingers. And, okay, maybe it isn’t supposed to be funny. He had asked her to teach him to bake a cake, and she had promised that she would. Baking is something that she was good at before her accident. She and her parents used to bake every Saturday, as a family bonding sort of experience. She hasn’t done it since their passing, but when Monty had asked, she had refused to reject him simply because of what could never be again. And he had been so serious about baking, she was sure it would go smoothly.
It did not.
She has to grasp the counter, wheezing as tears pour from her eyes. Laughter shakes her entire frame, and she doesn’t even jump when he tosses flour at her. She just laughs harder, marveling at the sight of him covered in flour and egg, a grimace marring his face. “I’ll stop,” she gasps, standing up straight again. More giggles escape her lips, and she places her hand on his chest, biting her lip in an unsuccessful attempt to keep from laughing again. “We’re not done, okay? We – we have more eggs, we…” She has to stop to laugh again because they’re at egg number four now, and he genuinely has no idea how to crack one without getting it all over the place.
“You’re the opposite of helpful,” he notes, and she bursts into laughter again. “You’re incorrigible, you know that?”
“I do,” she giggles. “I do, I promise. And I’ll be better.” She laughs some more, until she realizes how silent he is. She looks back up at him, blinking at the pensive look on his face. A final laugh escapes her, and she tips her head at him. “What?”
He shakes his head. “Nothing,” he mutters, reaching for another egg.
She rolls her eyes. “Monty,” she stresses, turning him to face her. She gives him a firm look. “It’s not nothing. What? Are you upset that I laughed? Because I’m not apologizing.”
His lips twitch. “I didn’t expect you to. And it’s not that, it’s…” He shrugs. “I’ve never seen you laugh like that before.”
She pauses. “Really?”
Monty nods slowly. “You’ve lived with us for about a year now, and you rarely ever laugh. Even with Wendy and the others, you always seem…” He goes quiet for a moment, searching a word to fill the gap. “…withdrawn, I guess. And I get that. Anyone in your shoes would be, probably. It’s just…”
Her breath halts, and she finds herself anxiously waiting for whatever comes next.
He shrugs again, and smiles at her. “It’s nice to see you smile. For real.”
And she finds herself agreeing with him. It’s been too long since she’s laughed this way. What with her parents dying, and taking in Milo, and everything with Amos, she hasn’t had much reason to smile. And when she had agreed to bake with Monty, she had expected it to be a more emotional struggle. She had expected tears and heartache, expected to feel an obvious void that couldn’t be filled in her heart where her parents used to be. But for the first time in over a year, she’s laughed her heart out, and she feels… lighter for it. As if an impossible weight has been lifted off her chest, now allowing room for something else.
When she looks up again, the world seems a bit brighter.
And if Freya walks into the kitchen to find her wrapping flour coated around Monty as tears of relief sting at her eyes, she just smiles warmly, and walks back out.
It’s about time.
Her new found happiness lasts about a week before the next big thing happens.
Game night with the Villegas family is always an experience. She’s no longer allowed to participate in board games – you flip a table one time – and Monty and Bishop are always very likely to start fighting when video games got involved. Granted, they’re leagues better than Duke and Tabitha – who take their cutthroat competitiveness to a whole new level when any form of Mario gets involved – but still. It’s always a risk.
It’s probably why Twitch chooses a very harmless game of Twister for the night. Last week was Scattegories, and more than a little bit of blood was shed. Once Ryker finally left, cop car lights finally shut off, they had unanimously agreed never to do that again. Twister is the halcyon replacement, but Aurelia gives it about an hour before one of them finds some way to get this one banned, too.
Dash chooses to be the caller – “I can see a dozen ways this can go south, and I don’t want any part of it.” – and Bishop swears with no shortage of vigor that he will be King of Twister. Twitch just shoves him and tells Dash to call the first circle.
They’re on the second game, in a very compromising position. Aurelia – who’s sort of admitted to meeting her soulmate, but never saying who – Wendy, Bishop and Monty are the only ones left on the board, and there’s very little space left between their bodies. Aurelia can’t even laugh, for fear of collapsing, and she has to shuffle her foot two spaces down to reach the green circle Bishop’s hand occupies.
Then the headache hits.
“Ah,” she gasps, crashing to her knees. Her hand reaches to her head, and she winces.
“Aurelia?” Someone drops to their knees beside her – Freya – and a hand lands on the small of her back. “What’s wrong, sweetheart?”
“Nothing,” Aurelia winces, starting to stand. “I just h – ah!” The crippling pain that hits then is all consuming, stealing her voice away. She falls back to the ground, knees colliding with the ground and nothing to soften the impact. She’s blinded in agony and, for a moment, the world is devoured in pure white.
When color comes back, her world is unfocused and different. She’s not in the living room of the Villegas residence, anymore, but in a spacious, empty room of some sort. The world tilts, and she flashes back to the Villegas house. Her head bangs against the floor, and she’s back in the empty room. A guitar clatters to the ground next to her, a hand and watch falling into her line of vision, then it all disappears, and dots of color float in her sight.
“Amos,” she whispers through her gasps. Hands grab at her, but she forces herself to her feet. “I have to get to him,” she tries to say to them, stumbling to the couch, but the pain in her head is too blinding. She flashes back to Amos, the world turned sideways, blurring more and more with every second that passes. “I have to…”
Amos’ vision goes black, and she’s pushed back to the chaos of her own home.
It’s lucky that Bishop’s arms are around her, because not a second later, her eyes roll to the back of her head, and the world is swallowed in blessed darkness.
Amos is awake. Of all of the possibilities she’d run through in her mind, this – foolishly – had not been one of them. When she convinced Bishop’s family that she was fine, and on her way to the hospital, and when she was talking to the receptionist, she had not accounted for the fact that he might be awake.
But he is, and she’s seriously considering going home.
She’s about to step back out when his eyes land on her. “Hey, beautiful,” he breathes, a smile breaking onto his face. Her heart crumbles with that smile, but she returns it, taking a step into the room, her grip tightening on the straps of her gift bag. “What are you doing here?”
“Well,” she starts, finding the least direct way to answer that. “This guy I know is in the hospital, so I figured I could come say hi.”
Amos chuckles, shaking his head at her evasiveness. There’s no way he doesn’t see what she’s doing, but she doesn’t have an answer other than I felt your brain explode, and had to come see you, and that just won’t cut it. “Come here,” he beckons softly, grinning at her. And because she’s terrible and unable to resist him, she finds herself stepping closer to the bed, her nails digging into her palms. When she’s close enough, he takes one of her hands, tugging her down until she’s sitting on the bed. “How’d you know?”
“Stephen called,” she lies, internally wincing. She never meant to drag anyone else into this, but it’s too late to take it back. “He told me about your…”
“Aneurysm,” he finishes for her. “They said I had an aneurysm.” His smile fades, and a sorrowful frown replaces it. “Julianne felt when it happened. She had to feel all of that. They wouldn’t have found me if she hadn’t, but I can’t believe she had to go through that. I never thought this soulmate thing would hurt her like that.”
And suddenly Aurelia is reminded again that no matter what she feels, and how much she wants him, he belongs to Julianne. Their hearts are tied together in a way that Aurelia doesn’t fit into. Julianne feels every ache and pain, every sleepless night, every happy moment Amos experiences, and he feels hers. They share their happy moments, and when they’re unhappy, they aren’t afraid to call each other and ease the pain. It’ll always be Amos and Julianne. It will never be Amos and Aurelia, and though she’s always known that, the cold reminder leaves her feeling dizzy, and for a moment she’s afraid she’ll be sick.
“He mentioned,” Aurelia lies. She can’t paint a smile on anymore, so she glances away from him. “I should go check on her.” Julianne is actually the last person she plans on seeing, but it’s an easy out. So she puts the gift bag on Amos’ bed and starts to stand, before his hand wraps around hers again.
“Hey,” he calls, but she keeps her eyes on the door. “Can you look at me?”
Something in her doesn’t allow her to deny him anything, so she glances his way, even though it’s the last thing she wants to do.
His eyebrows knit together, and he gives her a concerned look. “What’s wrong? Did I say something?”
“No.” Yes. “I just… I wasn’t thinking.” I shouldn’t be here. “Julianne felt your brain explode, and she…” She’s your soulmate. She’s your finish line. “She could probably use a friend right now.” If I have to stand here any longer, I might cry, so please just let me go.
Amos studies her for a moment. “Can I ask for something?”
God, why? “Anything,” she swears, turning to face him completely.
“Can I have a hug?” His lips kick into a half-smile. “It’s been a rough day, and I could use one…”
And I’m convenient. The thought hurts more than it should, but she paints on another smile for him, and scoots closer. She’s mindful of the wires and tubes attached to him, finding a way to wrap her arms around him without disconnecting anything. He embraces her, his scent engulfing her in spite of the antiseptic that odors the room. She can’t resist the urge to be selfish for just a moment, and she turns her head into his chest. She allows his steady heartbeat, and his strong and spicy scent to calm her, flooding her senses in a way she’s only ever imagined. The need to cry hits her, but she pushes it back. She’s so damn sick of crying; over her parents, and over her hand, and definitely over Amos.
She’s so sick of it all.
A moment later, she pulls out of his embrace, and gives him a slightly realer smile. “Get better, okay?”
“Yeah,” he agrees distractedly, as if he’s hearing her from far away, despite staring right at her. He smiles then, placing a hand on her cheek. “Thanks, Aurelia.”
She’s always hated it when he says her name. Hated it, maybe, because of how much she loves it.
Bishop is livid.
Some part of her has always expected him to be. She doesn’t know exactly why he’s reacting this way, but she knew he would. Maybe it’s a protective anger; he’s always been that way. Getting angry for her and those around him; protective before she lost her parents, and infinitely more so since she had. It’s also possible that this is just downright fury at her falling for someone else’s boyfriend.
She wouldn’t blame him if it was.
“Amos Mendes,” he repeats for the fourth time, his hands clenching his coffee mug a bit too tight, “is your… soulmate.”
Tabitha meets her gaze, and there’s a question in her eyes. Do you really want to answer that? As if there’s still time to change her answer and make this all better. But there isn’t. She’s so tired of hiding from them. From the Villegas’ and from the rebellion. She can never tell Julianne, or Amos, or the pack, but she can trust these few people. She can tell them the truth, and she wants to. She doesn’t want to keep lying. She spent months pretending to see the world in dull colors before she’d finally confessed to meeting her soulmate. And maybe not saying who she was tethered to was still a viable option, until she had felt said soulmate have an aneurysm. There was no way they hadn’t heard his name leave her mouth. No way to keep lying to them.
This is for the best, she tells herself. The secrets are eating her up inside, and she can’t take that anymore.
“He is,” she says.
“And you… you felt him… having an aneurysm.”
“I did,” she says, and she sees Percy run a hand over his face.
There’s a fire in Bishop’s eyes, and he sets down the coffee mug. “Does he know?” His voice is cold as steel, hard and empty and unforgiving.
Oh, boy. “He… no. He doesn’t.”
“Goddammit, Aurelia!”
“Bishop, stop,” Twitch demands, placing a hand on his brother’s shoulder.
“No!” Bishop shoves his brother off, and rounds back on Aurelia. “You’ve known this guy for seven months, Aurelia. You’ve been hiding this for seven months. And you’ve… you’ve felt everything. Every heartbreak, every sickness, every late night, every joy… you felt him having a fucking aneurysm!”
“That’s hardly his fault,” Aurelia defends, though she doesn’t know why. What is there to defend? Fate being a bitch? The universe taking humor in her misery? No one chooses their soulmate. He knows that. “And even if I didn’t know him, he’d still be my soulmate. I’d still feel those things. And he would still have had an aneurysm, regardless!”
“You think I don’t know that? No, it wouldn’t have changed anything. But if he had any clue what you felt, do you think he would’ve done everything the same?”
She flinches. “What are you talking about?”
His eyes are piercing, and she no longer wants to have this conversation. “Every time you felt your heart breaking… every night you were up restless and lethargic, for seemingly no reason… every minor and major pain… you think he’d be so open in his heartbreak if he knew you were feeling it? You think he’d stay up, night after night, if he knew that someone else was suffering for it?”
She swallows thickly, because she knows the answer to that, just as well as Bishop does. “Julianne is his soulmate,” she says, her voice sounding foreign to her own ears. “She feels it all, too.”
“That’s different,” Bishop hisses. “It’s different when it’s the person you’re in love with, Aurelia. It’s one thing to share that pain, and the exhaustion with them. That’s something you can talk about the next day, and laugh at in a month. You want to share those experiences with the person you love. You want to share their exhaustion, and their heartache. It’s different, then. But you’re been hurting yourself for almost a year, and for what?”
His eyes beat into her, but she can’t come up with an answer. Everything that he listed off was a shot to the chest, her throat clogging up more and more with every word. She keeps herself from crying, swallowing the vile bitterness that’s come to a head within her, and she forces herself to keep eye contact.
She sees the realization dawn in Bishop’s eyes. “Because you’re in love with him.”
Wendy’s head snaps up.
Aurelia looks away, unable to deny, but unwilling to confess.
“Goddammit, Aurelia,” Bishop repeats, his voice softer but still rough as he crosses the room to her. He pulls her into a hug, and she burrows into him. “Goddammit.”
Amos calls her three days later. He’s still confined to his bed, and can’t even make it downstairs, but he tells her that he needs to see her immediately. She doesn’t think it through when she goes over. She ignores the disapproving look Dash throws her way, and rushes over because Amos has called, and she’s hopeless.
She stands at his front door for fifteen minutes before his dad opens it. “Amos saw you through the window,” he says, giving her a knowing smile. “He said twenty minutes is more than enough time to rethink coming here. He’d come get you himself, but bed rest and whatnot.”
“It’s fine,” Aurelia tells him. She actually likes his dad. He’s the sheriff, and not as lenient as the cops in this town are, but he’s a huge goof ball. He’s never been anything less than warm and welcoming, and Aurelia is grateful. She greets him and his wife before heading up to Amos’ room. She tries to come here as infrequently as possible, but she and Amos have had a few therapy sessions here, so she knows the place by heart.
When she knocks on Amos’ door, he calls for her to enter. When she opens the door, he’s pacing. She’s fairly certain he’s not supposed to be doing that, but she’s in no position to tell him what to do. He stops when he sees her, and he gives her a smile. It’s a watered down version of what she’s used to. “Hey,” he greets weakly. “Close the door?”
“Hi,” she replies quietly, softly pushing the door shut. She stands in front of it, her hand on the knob in case she needs to run. Her heart races at a hundred miles per hour, and she has this horrible feeling that she won’t like what happens here. “What’s going on?”
“I don’t know,” he answers honestly, his voice brutal in its softness. “I just – I’m a little confused here.”
“O…kay?” She has no idea what it has to do with her, or why he’s being so cryptic, but she figures it can’t hurt to just go with it. “About what?”
“You.” His face is blank as he says it, and the sense of foreboding strengthens. “You confuse me, Aurelia.”
She tries to take another step away from him, but the door knob is already stabbing her in the back, and she can’t get any further without opening the door and just running. And it isn’t as if he doesn’t have her number, or know where she lives. “Amos…”
“How did you know about my aneurysm?”
Her breath halts, and her heart skips. Not in a good way. “I-I told you,” she mutters, struggling to keep eye contact. “Stephen–”
“–hasn’t heard from you in weeks,” Amos cuts her off, and the only thing keeping her on her feet is the fact that if she falls over, Amos will know. If he doesn’t already. “I talked to him yesterday, and he said the last time he talked to you was on the day of your recital. He hadn’t even thought to call you. He wanted to make sure his sister was okay, and he hadn’t thought to call Declan, let alone you. So I’ll ask again: how did you know?” His tone makes it startlingly clear that he won’t take anything but the truth. She knows that he’ll see through any lie she tries to tell, and will get the truth out of her one way or another.
That doesn’t mean she’ll help.
She looks away from him, but can still feel his eyes boring into her. He calls her name, but she pretends not to hear. She pretends that this isn’t happening. She hears his footsteps coming towards her, and she grits her teeth. Please no. Please don’t.
“Aurelia,” he starts, his voice taking on a tone of desperation. “Did you feel my aneurysm?” She doesn’t speak, doesn’t even look at him, but her jaw clenches. It’s answer enough. “Jesus.”
“I’m sorry,” is all she can say.
“You’re sorry?” He sounds angry and betrayed and incredulous, all at once. It’s a terrifying combination. “God -- can you look at me for once?” She flinches at his tone, but complies. “You’ve known... you’ve known since the day we met that we were soulmates, and you d--”
“That you’re my soulmate,” she corrects. “I’m not yours, Amos.”
He falters, but his resolves strengthens in a flash. “How could you not tell me?”
She tilts her head, giving him a strange look. “Why would I? It doesn’t change anything, Amos. It doesn’t mean anything!”
“It does!”
“I’m not your soulmate,” she yells at him. “And, yes, I’ve known since we met. I’ve known for almost a year now, and no, I didn’t tell you, but I didn’t have a reason to. Julianne is your soulmate. She’s your sun and your moon and your stars and I’m--”
“You’re what?” His eyes hold her, and she wonders if he even has the answer to that. “What are you to me?”
It takes a moment before she can figure it out herself. “The girl whose world you colored,” she finally answers, willfully ignoring his sharp intake of breath. “I’m just another girl who... who fell for the pop star. The only difference between me and any girl out there is that by some cruel twist of fate, you’re my soulmate.”
“You’re wrong,” he snaps. “You know the difference between you and every other girl out there? You’re my friend, Aurelia. We’ve spent seven months together. We’ve been through so much, and you... you couldn’t even tell me.”
“What would it have changed, Amos,” she asks tiredly. “What honestly would have been the difference in the past seven months if you’d known?”
“You could’ve come to me,” he tells her. And he sounds weary now. He sounds as if everything she’s felt over the past seven months has hit him in the past seven hours, and it’s left him worse for wear. His eyes are rimmed red and a bit on the puffy side. She wonders if he’s cried, or if he’s just been restless. Part of her already knows. “You... I’m your soulmate, Aurelia.”
“I’ve noticed.”
“No, you haven’t.” He shakes his head. “I’m your soulmate. There’s no one on the other end of your string, Aurelia. There’s no one that--”
“I know that,” she cuts him off. How dare he say she hasn’t noticed? She’s lived sixteen years praying for the love of her life, or the ultimate comforter to be on the other end of her pain. She’s lived the past seven months feeling empty and heartbroken at the prospect of being alone for the rest of her life. She will always feel Amos’ pain. When he dies, she will feel that. But when she’s hurt, and when she dies, no one will feel it. She will be alone. She has dealt with that every minute of every day since his thumb brushed her shoulder.
There is no greater or more painful truth in her story, and he has the audacity to accuse her of not knowing?
“No, you don’t! I’m your soulmate, Aurelia,” Amos says again, as if he’s waiting for something to click. “Maybe I don’t feel your pain the way you feel mine. And maybe I don’t see through your eyes, but you are my friend. I know that you feel alone, but I have always been here. From the moment we met, you had me. Every time that you cried... every time you smiled... every time you felt something, and you ached at the thought of having no one to share it with, you had me. You could’ve come to me. I would have been here. And you never once tried.”
Aurelia tries to speak, but can’t find a response. She realizes with a sinking heart that he’s right. Amos would’ve been there for her. Every night that she cried about being alone, and every night that she missed her parents, and every night she had no idea what to do, he would’ve been there. He would have hugged her, and taken her mind off of it. Amos would have never pushed her away, even if she isn’t his soulmate.
“Did you ever think about that?” He asks, not expecting an answer. He takes a step towards her. “Do you know what it means to be a soulmate? It means that you’re a constant comfort. It means that rain or shine, night or day, hell or high water, you’re there if you’re needed. It means that you are destined to change someone’s life; to walk through life with them. Even if.. even if you’re not my soulmate, I’m yours. I’m made to a part of your life. Don’t you realize that? I’m meant to be there for you. I am sorry that I’m not connected to you the way that you are to me. I..” He laughs mirthlessly, and a tear falls from his eye. “I wish you were my soulmate.”
She bites down on the inside of her cheek to keep from sobbing. Blood fills her mouth, and tears fall relentlessly. “Amos--”
“I wish you were my soulmate.” He’s in front of her now, just inches separating them. “I wish I could feel your insecurities. I wish I could feel every time your heart ached, and I could just make you smile, and take away every hurt you feel. I wish I could see through your eyes when you got so happy, you could barely keep still. I wish I could feel your heart beating out of your chest every time you saw the person you loved the most. I wish I could be that for you, Aurelia, but I can’t. I can’t and I’m sorry.”
“I’m not,” she chokes out. She tries to breathe as she speaks, tears blurring her vision and clogging her throat. “Because I -- it all hurts so much,” she laughs. “Being alone. Watching everyone around me find happiness, and find their soulmates,and knowing that I -- that I won’t ever have that. I just -- God, Amos, I don’t remember the last time I wasn’t sad. And I don’t want you to feel that. I don’t want you to feel what I do.”
“I do,” he says softly, wiping her tears. “I don’t need a soulmate bond to love you, Aurelia Apfel. Do you hear me? I don’t need to be tied to you to feel something. I love you without being linked, and I loved you way before I knew that I was your soulmate. And I know how sad you are. I don’t know why -- I wish I did. But I know how sad you are. And if I could make that any easier, I would in an instant. That’s what I want, Aurelia. I want to be able to take your pain away, and I want to watch you fall apart; I want you to put your back together. I want to be there every time you find something to make you smile, and every time you love. I want to talk you down, and bring you up. I want to be your soulmate, Aurelia. Let me. Please,” he begs, his hands cupping her cheeks. “Stop... stop holding out on me. Let me in.”
Her throat is dry, and she doesn’t even know where to begin. She can’t tell him how much she wants the same thing. She doesn’t just want someone on the other side of her link. She wants him. She wants his to be the voice that calls when she feels something so strongly, it threatens to swallow her whole. She wants him to be the one to show up at her door at three o’clock in the morning because she refuses to go to sleep. She wants him to hold her when she cries. She wants to tell him about her parents, and about Milo, and about her. She wants him to know who she is. But he can’t, because she-- she isn’t Julianne.
“Julianne,” she croaks, not knowing what else to say.
Amos shakes his head. “She won’t mind,” his thumb runs over her cheek, and she tries not to lean into his touch. “You really have no idea how much she loves you, do you? All she wants is for you to be happy. She wants you to have the soulmate of your dreams, someone who can be... this for you. And if it’s me, she won’t care.”
No. It’s not that easy. Aurelia shakes her head, pulling away. “She’s not just your girlfriend, Amos,” she fights. “She’s your soulmate, too. And you’re hers, that’s -- that’s bigger than this, than me.”
“No, it’s not,” he denies, his voice unrelenting. “I’m both of your soulmates. And maybe I’m linked to her in a special way, but I’m still yours. Don’t you see that? I’m still yours. Just as much as I am hers.” His lips quirk into a small, sad smile. “You can fight me on this all day, Aurelia. I’m not letting you push me away anymore. I’m your soulmate, and I’m going to be that, whether you want me to or not.”
She wants to fight it. She can’t take him from Julianne. She can’t call him at insane hours of the night to share trivial stories that won’t matter in the grand scheme of things, but seem to be bigger than life in the moment. She can’t be the one that he stands by when the sky falls. She won’t be the one to slant her mouth over his time and time again, simply because she can. She won’t be the one to take him apart with her hands and her lips, and lie with him when the sun falls, and when the only thing that exists under the light of the moon is their bond. She will never have that.
But she will have him. She may not be his love, but she will have him. She’ll have something. And it’s so much better than being alone.
"You’re so sad.”
Aurelia is totally justified in flipping Monty off. Mentally, anyway. She has Milo and Oliver for the day, and only one of them is asleep. She gives Monty a hard look, which he doesn’t seem too fazed by. “You’re a bully.”
“I’m okay with that,” he says matter-of-factly. “And you’re hiding.”
She throws him an affronted look, picking up the dirty diaper bag. “I am not hiding.”
She’s definitely hiding. Despite the emotional progress she and Amos made a week and a half ago, she hasn’t spoken to him since, though not for lack of trying on his part. He’s called and texted, but she’s dodged every single effort to reach out. It isn’t that she doubts him. She knows he’ll fulfill every promise, and be there for every second that she needs him. He’s always been that guy, since the moment they met.
It doesn’t mean she knows how to do this.
She spent almost a year avoiding this. Avoiding him knowing, avoiding him caring, avoiding him trying. Now, it’s out in the open, and she has no idea how to cope with the significance of that change.
“You’re hiding,” Monty reprises. “It’s sad, and almost physically painful to watch.”
“Ha ha,” she says dryly, holding out the diaper bag. “Get out.”
He gives her a sickeningly sweet smile as he takes the trash and turns to walk out. “Oh, yeah,” he says as an afterthought, turning back to face her. “Amos is here.”
Her mouth drops open, and Monty guffaws. “You jerk,” she whisper-shouts so as to not wake Milo. “He can’t be here!”
“He is,” Monty nods. “And he’ll be up here in about thirty seconds, so figure out what you want to say, and stop being a wimp.”
“Get out of my room,” she hisses again. “I hope Freya burns your pizza!”
Monty just continues to snicker, carrying the bag out of the room. Amos passes him on his way in, his eyes immediately finding Aurelia. He gives the girl a smile. “Hey, beautiful.”
“I’m not avoiding you,” she blurts, and she can practically hear Monty mocking her for that slip up.
“Yes, you are,” Amos says, an amused twitch to his lips. “And I get that. But I did tell you I wouldn’t give up.”
“That, you did,” Aurelia agrees, taking a seat on her bed in front of Milo. In the crib, Oliver amuses himself with a taking Minion toy.
“And seeing as you skipped your rehab this week,” Amos continues pointedly, taking a seat next to her on her bed. “I had to improvise. I figure this is better, anyway. No guitar to get in the way, or any physical strains... it’s just us. And I realized I don’t know much about you.”
Aurelia nods slowly. She figures she can understand where he’s coming from. “Okay,” she drags out. “What do you want to know?”
“Let’s start easy,” he decides. “What’s... your middle name?”
She laughs, because that’s the exact opposite of easy. “Theodosia,” she reveals. “My parents used to call me Theo.”
“Used to,” he notes.
She nods. “Used to.” She bites her lip, wondering if it’s okay to continue. But Amos’ eyes are open and honest, and she hasn’t talked about it since she met Wendy. She wants to tell Amos. Some part of her needs to. “When I was fifteen, there was this bank robbery...”
chandler & a r i e l
ii. the fire in my veins cools in comparison to the fire in your eyes
Chandler’s favorite story to tell anyone is the story of how he meets his soulmate. It’s a horrible story, actually, but it never fails to get people laughing, and it always leads to him damn near reliving the event.
He’s six years old when he meets her. They’re at recess, and they’ve somehow found themselves in the same group of friends. He doesn’t know her name, actually; she’s just another cute girl that got dragged into playing cops and robbers with them. She’d wanted to be robber, but they had already filled spots for robbers, so she was stuck as a cop.
Chandler has this knack for putting his foot in his mouth, even at the tender age of six. He says something that he knows he shouldn’t-- even if it escapes his mind seconds after -- and Hollis lets out a long suffering sigh. The girl whose name he still doesn’t know marches right up to him, lifts her hand, and brings it down hard against his cheek.
When he sees the brown tanbark approaching, he thinks she’s simply smacked him too hard. But when he looks up, he notices her flaming red hair, and her wide green eyes. “Oh,” he says. “Hi.”
“Hi,” she echoes. “That’s weird.”
And that’s the story. He tells it to anyone who will listen, no matter how much they genuinely do not care, because he’s horrible at picking up social cues. “She smacked me so hard, I saw color,” he’ll always snicker.
And she’ll roll her eyes, and give him an unimpressed look. “Want me to smack it out?”
Chandler is seven years old when he decides that he does not want to be Ariel’s soulmate. He’d much rather be Ollie’s soulmate, or Adelaide’s. Heck, he’d even be Mari’s; at least he’d never have to worry about bullies.
“You can’t just not be someone’s soulmate anymore,” Loki tells him in a bored tone, lazily stirring sugar into his tea. “Red’s the Romeo to your Mercutio. Deal with it.”
Chandler gives him a blank look.
“Nevermind. Look,” Loki sighs. “She’s not that bad. And even if you did ask Harry’s mom to draw up a contract, you’re not getting a divorce. It’s not like you two can sign some papers, and you’ll suddenly be bound to other people. It doesn’t work that way, Chandler. You two are fated to be in each other’s lives, so just... suck it up and move on.”
Ollie’s head swivels back and forth between them, and he tosses an orange slice into his mouth, waiting for a retaliation.
Chandler blinks. “Dude, you’re a Terrible Friend.” With capitals and everything, because it’s actually that serious.
Loki just rolls his eyes. “At least Ariel’s cool. Be glad you’re not stuck with, like, Ezra, or anything.”
Ollie stiffens like a board, and all playfulness leaves his eyes. “What’s wrong with Ezra?” His voice is sharp as a knife, and for a second, Chandler is scared it’s the Gay Thing. Ezra had come out to them last year, stating in no uncertain terms that he was going to marry Mister Smythe down the block, or his son, Landon, when he grew up and it was legal and all. Chandler highly doubts that will happen, but his mom said that coming out was a Big Thing, and he should just be glad Ezra trusted them enough to tell them.
(Mister McAlister had been very accepting, by the way. He’d just grinned and said, “Ollie’s older, anyway. He’ll just have to find a rich girl to marry, unless you can find a rich guy. Oh, hey, what about that Butler kid who just moved down the street?”)
Chandler really hopes it’s not the Gay Thing. Because Loki may be a Terrible Friend, but he’s sometimes a really swell fellow, and he promises to make life interesting for anyone who knows him. Chandler is hoping that one of his friends marries Loki, just so he’ll have a reason to stay in his life. And when he’s super rich and successful, Chandler won’t ever have to work, because he can just mooch off of Loki. But that can’t happen if he has a problem with the Gay Thing. Chandler doesn’t need that type of influence in his life.
Loki gives them dubious looks, as if they’re idiots. “Isn’t it obvious?” He asks rhetorically. “Ezra’s bound to be the least favorite twin. Whoever’s mated to him will have to deal with all of his hurt feelings, and abandonment issues, and he’ll probably end up joining the army and getting himself killed somewhere down the line, and their world will go colorless again as a result of his stupidity.”
Ollie and Chandler both stare in silent shock for a moment, struggling to process that whirlwind of negativity.
“I cannot believe you’re Adelaide’s soulmate,” Ollie finally says.
Loki just shrugs and finishes off his sandwich.
When Chandler’s little brother goes missing, he doesn’t call anyone. He doesn’t think he can handle their worry, or their false platitudes, or their pity. He can’t really handle the world at all, right now.
Dessie and Storey are in the next room over, crying their eyes out. He knows he should go comfort them. He’s their big brother; taking care of them is all he’s good for. But he feels the loss of his brother too strongly, and it seems impossible to even get out of bed, let alone go out and comfort someone else.
There’s a knock on his door. He doesn’t answer, but he doubts they expected one anyway. The door opens, and he doesn’t look up. He already sort of knows who it is. He just continues to stare up at the ceiling, running over the last two days in his mind, trying to figure out where he went wrong.
The bed dips as she slides in, and he stays still as she curls at his side, her head resting on his shoulder. Her hair is pulled back into a ponytail for once, but loose strands still tickle at his cheek. “Hi,” she whispers, resting a curled hand on his stomach.
“Hi,” he replies, his voice hoarse from lack of use. He swallows the lump in his throat, keeping his eyes fixed on the white ceiling above him. “Easton’s gone.”
“I know,” Ariel says, her fist tightening. She sounds as if she’s been crying, and he’s suddenly reminded of the fact that she’s feeling his anguish. Every time his heart constricts at the loss of Easton, she feels that. And suddenly, he feels bad for being hurt. He feels bad for bottling it up, and hurting her more than he needs to. “I... Audie felt Dessie crying.”
“Oh.” He pauses, trying to digest that. He’d forgotten that Dessie had found her soulmate. “Is she...?”
“She’s with them now,” Ariel reports.
“Oh,” he repeats, feeling stupid for his lack of reaction. He's glad that Audie is here. She’s Ariel’s cousin, and has her strength. Even when her heart hurts, he knows she’ll hold Des and Storey up, no matter what. She’s resilient in a way that only the Hayes girls ever are. She can be there when he can’t. At the same time, he feels a sense of numbness settling in his stomach. He doesn’t know what to feel. “That’s good.”
Ariel lets out a hum.
“I’m sorry,” he blurts, swallowing again.
Ariel sighs. “Shut up.” She wraps her arm around his waist, pulling him nearer. He feels tears soaking through his shirt, and realizes that she’s crying. Every tears that he refuses to shed leaks from her eyes, and he feels her shaking against his side. “I’m sorry, Chan. I’m so sorry.”
Chandler just stares up at the ceiling, and is silently grateful as she cries for him.
Four years after Easton disappears, their dad dies.
His mom feels it as if happens. The bowl of popcorn falls from her hands, and she releases a pained gasp. Fifteen year old Chandler is already out of his seat, running towards her, when she collapses. Shaking hands over her abdomen, as if she’s expecting a wound there. (A gunshot wound, he later finds out.) But nothing is there. “No,” she gasps, tears rushing from her eyes. “No.” She blacks out in Chandler’s arms, and twelve year old Storey screams.
The funeral for their dad is a weak later, and Loki puts the entire thing together. They’re too young to be doing this type of thing, but there’s no other choice. Chandler’s mom isn’t really there, anymore. It’s a miracle if she pulls herself out of bed, nowadays. Most days, Chandler has to drag her out of bed, wash and feed her, and take care of the girls while he’s at it. He has to make lunches, and find money to give them, and make sure they’re fed and taken care of, day after day. When it became obvious his mom wasn’t going to do it, he was going to arrange the funeral, but Loki had already swooped in to save the day. He paid for and arranged the entire thing, and had only asked that Chandler write the eulogy.
The three remaining Reese children sit in the front row, dressed in all black. Audie stands next to Dessie, holding her hand in a vice-like grip, and Chandler runs his fingers through Storey’s hair. His mother is despondent, even during the funeral, silent tears slowly creeping down her face. Chandler holds her hand, anyway, because he doesn’t believe for a second that she isn’t in pain. Ariel is still alive, and has never even been majorly hurt in her life, so he can’t sympathize with his mom. He doesn’t know what she feels, but he tries to imagine if Ariel was no longer in his life. If the sizable portion of his heart that she occupied were ever to be carved out, and his world flipped upside down. He tries to imagine losing all of the color in his world, so soon after losing Easton, and he finds himself in agony, just at the thought. He doesn’t blame his mother for checking out, but he does wish she were still here.
(He wishes he didn’t have to be the strong one.)
He doesn’t ask Ariel, or Ollie, or Loki to stand with him in the front row. Even when they – along with Caleb, Tatum, and Holden – offer to stand by his side, he politely refuses. He doesn’t begrudge Audie for staying with Dessie; no, he’s glad she’s there. Dessie needs an anchor, especially now. But he has to stand on his own two feet today, tomorrow, and every day after. When his mom gets back, maybe he’ll allow himself to grieve. Maybe he’ll finally feel the loss of his father, stronger than ever before, and allow himself to cry the way that the girls have. But until then, he has to power through on his own. Because the second one of them holds his hand, or tries to comfort him, he knows he’ll unravel at the seams, and he doesn’t know if he’ll be able to pull himself together again.
The minister straightens at the podium. “And now the eulogy, delivered by his son, Chandler Reese.”
Storey’s grip on him tightens, and Chandler kisses her forehead before pulling away. Every eye is trained on him as he walks up to the altar, and he breathes quietly as he faces the congregation. On reflex alone, his eyes meet Ariel’s, and he gives her a sad smile. Her eyes hold a scary blankness, but tears run unhindered down pale cheeks. Loki grips her hand tightly, and Chandler has never been more grateful. He’s still a Terrible Friend, but he’s also one of the best guys ever. Adelaide steps forward, taking his place between Storey and his mother. Storey launches herself into Adelaide’s lap, burying her face in the older girl’s lap.
Chandler takes another breathe.
He can do this.
“My dad,” he starts, keeping his voice even, “was my role model. He was always strong, even in the hardest times. When we lost my brother…” He tunes himself out, speaking the words from memory alone. At some point in his speech, Des releases a heart wrenching scream, and for the first time, Chandler feels a pain that he can’t shut out. Ariel gasps as it hits, and Chandler tries to shut it out. He can’t cry. He can’t lose it. Not here. Not now. Ariel cries into Loki’s suit, and Chandler keeps speaking, powering through the speech. “…never shaken. He wasn’t just a dad, or a friend, he was a hero. My hero. He seemed invincible, he seemed like one of the guys who would never die,” he finds himself saying, though he doesn’t remember it being part of his speech. The congregation is silent as death (ironically), and he wonders where to go from here. “But now he is gone, and we…”
There’s nothing left to say. For a few stilted moments, the church is so silent, he could hear a pin drop. His mouth opens and shuts as he searches for a way to finish that. What does he say now? He meets Adelaide’s wet eyes, and she bites her lip, shaking her head silently. She doesn’t know either, which is strange, because Adelaide has always known. Even when he didn’t, and when Ariel didn’t, Adelaide has always known exactly where to go, and what to say. And when he looks to Marilyn, she shakes her head, too, incapable of forming any sort of words.
When the silence can’t seem to drag on any longer, Tatum stands. He steps out of the aisle, and Chandler watches with wide eyes as he makes his way onto the stage. He places his hand on the small of Chandler’s back, gently pulling him away. “Come on,” the older teen whispers, rubbing his back. “It’s okay. You did great.” The minister gives Tatum an appreciative look as he leads Chandler off of the stage.
The minister speaks again, asking everyone to rise for the congregational hymn. Chandler takes his spot again, Tatum only squeezing his shoulder as he makes his way back to his own row. Adelaide presses a kiss to his cheek, then goes back to her own seat. Storey attaches herself to him again, and his mother stays seated. Chandler keeps his eyes forward, singing along to the hymn he’s heard a thousand times, and he wonders if he’ll ever be able to enjoy it again after this.
The funeral takes too long to end, and Chandler is silently thankful that there isn’t a wake. They don’t watch the coffin get lowered into the ground, either, which is good, because Chandler isn’t sure how much he would be able to handle. After he’s loaded his mother and sisters into the limo, he turns to his friends. When he’s hugged his way through the most of them, he hugs Tatum. “Thank you,” he mutters, hating how choked up he feels. “Thank you, I…”
“You did great,” Tatum reiterates, gripping the back of his neck tightly, and Chandler thinks he’s a little bit in love with him. “You did great, Chandler.”
Then, Loki. He usually doesn’t allow himself to be touched, let alone hugged, but it’s a different occasion. Loki hugs him back with vigor, telling him to shut up when he tries to thank him. “Take care of yourself, dumbass,” he whispers, holding Chandler tightly, as if his hold can keep the boy from falling apart. “Call me if you need something.”
Chandler just smiles and nods, then hugs Adelaide. He can’t stop himself from pecking her on the lips, though he doesn’t know why he does it. “Thank you,” he whispers to her. “For being there for the girls. They needed you.”
Adelaide laughs quietly, a watery and weak sound in his ears. “I’m your friend, Chandler,” she says. “I’m always going to be there.”
Finally, he hugs Ariel. “I’m sorry,” is all he can say before he pushes himself into the limo. He doesn’t know what else to say to her. There doesn’t seem to be anything else to say, nothing that can adequately encompass all that he wants to tell her. So he settles for running away.
Audie sleeps over that night and the next, stuffing herself into bed with Dessie and Storey. Chandler’s told her repeatedly that she doesn’t have to stay if she doesn’t want to, but she’s steadfast. She helps him through the day, mostly tending to his sisters. She’s there for every breakdown, and pulls them through every time they start to sink into the despair that threatens to overwhelm them at any given moment. Chandler spends most of his days taking care of his mother; she’s still despondent, and doesn’t even seem to recognize him when he talks to her. She just stares blankly at him, not even putting up a fight as he puts her in a bath, and forces food down her throat.
Months pass in that fashion – Chandler pushing his mother to live, and Audie helping to get the girls back on their feet – before someone finally questions it.
“I’m just worried about you,” Holden confesses, pulling the food out of the oven. “I mean, I get why you’re doing everything that you are. You have to take care of your family. But…”
Chandler raises an eyebrow, pulling out the pitcher of punch front from the fridge.
Holden shrugs. “I’m just scared you’re going to run yourself into the ground.”
“I’m fine,” Chandler promises sincerely. He is fine. He doesn’t feel like the world is falling apart anymore, nor does he feel like he’s falling apart. His sisters are smiling again, and Storey’s even sleeping in her own room now. His mom is still withdrawn, but taking care of her is easy, now. He’s fine, so he doesn’t see why Holden is so worried. “I’m not going to fall apart or anything.”
“Yeah, you say that.” Holden pulls the knives from the drawer, rinsing them off before using one. “But no one can power through five months that way. You have, and that’s awesome, but it’s scary, Chan.” He hesitates, his eyes unsure, before they settle on Chandler with a sad but resigned look. “You’re going to burn out eventually, Chandler. And I don’t know for sure that we’ll be able to bring you back when you do.”
“I think I’m in love with Adelaide.”
Tatum chokes on his Pepsi, and Holden coughs around his taco. Ollie clears his throat awkwardly, and all eyes turn to Loki. He continues to poke at his rice bowl for a moment before looking up and glancing around. “What?”
Cedric’s eyes narrow at his best friend. “Didn’t you hear him? He’s in love with Adelaide.”
Loki continues to stare. “So?”
“So,” Ollie prompts. “Does that bother you or anything?”
Loki gives them his patented You’re All Freaking Idiots Swear to God I Need New Friends look. “Why would that bother me? Since when do I care who you’re into?”
“Since… it’s your soulmate?” Chandler honestly has no idea what’s happening, or why he’s ever been convinced Loki has a heart. “You really don’t care?”
Loki shrugs. “It’s not like I’m into her or anything. I mean, yeah, I thought about it before, but I’m over that. Besides, if I really had a problem, do you think I’d be so chill about you two screwing behind my back?”
Tatum sets the Pepsi down, swearing as it goes down the wrong pipe again. “What?”
Loki – the asshole – smirks at Chandler. “I’m her soulmate, nimrod. I can feel you two f—”
“Too much,” Caleb says, grimacing at them. “Too much, dude.”
Loki rolls his eyes. “I don’t care what you two do. Just don’t break her heart or anything, or I will have you eliminated.”
It’s about as close to approval as Chandler is going to get, so he takes it.
Chandler loses, like, half of his friends in one fell swoop.
Loki, Holden, and Caleb all move away suddenly. Loki goes to London – or France? Fuck if Chandler knows – and Holden moves to Boston. Caleb doesn’t say where he’s going, but he promises that it isn’t permanent. He and Asher will be back before they know it, or something like that. Then he’s gone, and so is Holden, and so is Loki.
Ariel’s heart breaks when Loki leaves, and the pain of it all pulls Chandler out of his bed. He rubs his hand over his heart for a moment, frowning at the burn he feels there. His sisters are sleep, and his mom’s meds should keep her down for at least another twelve hours. Knowing that the house will survive without him for a while, he pulls on his shoes and jacket and makes sure to lock the front door behind him.
Ariel’s brother is the one who opens the door, and he seems to already know why Chandler is here. He gives him a small smile. “Hey,” Mickey greets. “She’s up in her room.”
Chandler gives the redhead a grateful smile and toe his shoes off before going up to Ariel’s room. Out of common courtesy, he knocks twice before pushing the door open and leaning against the door frame. Predictably, she’s working on homework that probably isn’t due for the next month, her head bowed close to the desk as she scribbles furiously on a piece of lined paper. She doesn’t look at him when he enters, but he knows that she knows he’s here. “Hi,” he greets, out of routine more than anything else.
“Hi,” she says back, keeping her eyes on her paper. “What are you doing here?”
“Can’t sleep,” he says, instead of telling the whole truth. The last thing she needs is guilt on top of her heartbreak. “What are you working on?”
“Shuester’s essay,” she answers absentmindedly. “You know how he gets. If it’s not perfect, he’ll give me one of those disappointed looks, and I’ll never forgive myself for getting anything less than a hundred percent.”
Chandler’s pretty sure she’s projecting. Mr. Shue is probably the nicest teacher they have, and hardly cares whether or not their essays are publication ready. She’ll probably get a hundred percent, just because of her effort, but it won’t matter if he says so. “Okay.” He nods, before standing up straight. He walks over to her, pulling the chair away from the desk.
“Wha – what are you doing?”
“Putting you to bed,” he answers simply. He takes her hands, pulling her out of the chair. “And don’t try to fight me, because I do this with three women every night. Trust me, I could do this all night, and I will win.”
She throws him a sharp look, but allows him to pull her up. He takes the pen from her hand, setting it down on the desk, then guides her to the bed. He pushes her down until she’s lying on her side, and he takes a seat. She puts her head in his lap, drawing in a shaky breath as his fingers start carding through her hair. “He’s gone,” she says.
“I know.”
“He doesn’t–” She breathes, tears welling up in her eyes. “He doesn’t want to come back.”
“He will,” Chandler tells her confidently. “No matter how he feels right now, this will always be home to him. He’ll always come back here. Adelaide’s here. You’re here. That’s more than enough to pull him back. It might not happen tomorrow,” he admits, taking the rubber band from her hair. He allows her locks to fan out across his thigh, his fingers scraping against her scalp. “It might not happen this year, or even the next. But he’s going to come back. You just have to wait for him.”
Ariel’s quiet for a long moment, tears leaking to his jean clad thigh. “Promise he’s worth it?”
Chandler hesitates. Is Loki worth it? Yes, he’s done amazing things. He’s always been protective and supportive, and he took care of Chandler’s dad’s funeral. He’s Adelaide’s soulmate, and Ariel’s best friend, so he’s definitely great. But is he worth the heartache? “I promise,” Chandler finally answers, hoping that he’s not wrong. “He’s going to be worth it.”
Ollie is, without a doubt, Chandler’s best friend.
It’s different from how Holden, Adelaide, and Tatum are his best friends. Chandler’s kind of in love with them, which takes them out of the running for Best Friend of the Year, because that’s kind of biased. Chandler isn’t in love with Ollie, though he could see himself falling for him somewhere along the line. Marilyn could be his best friend, except they kind of hate each other half the time, so it doesn’t work out. Ollie is his best friend, though, simple and plain, and Chandler values that friendship. He knows that Ollie values their friendship, too, even if he can’t compete with Ezra for Best Friend. Even if he isn’t Best Friend, they’re still comfortable with each other, and have always been able to tell each other everything.
Which is why Ollie kind of avoiding him, and being super awkward is a horrible and confusing thing.
Loki, Holden, and Caleb all left three months ago, and the pain of that is still a bit too prominent. Chandler is kind of possessive of his friends now, and gets jittery when things like this happened. He damn near had a heart attack when Hollis went missing, though he knew exactly why she was leaving. He’s still nervous about it, and doesn’t think he can handle losing anyone else. Ollie has been a constant presence in his life since the first grade, and he doesn’t think he can lose him, too.
“Did I do something wrong?”
Ollie’s eyes snap up, and they widen at the sight of Chandler. “What?” He takes his earbuds out, his eyes narrowing in concern. “What are you talking about, dude?”
Chandler shifts on his feet. He probably should’ve called before coming over, but that would’ve just given Ollie time to run away. “You’ve been avoiding me. Did I do something wrong?”
“What? Dude, no.” Ollie shakes his head, turning in his computer chair to face Chandler. “It’s not – no, Chan, it’s not you.” He gestures to his bed. “Sit down?”
Chandler eyes him warily for a moment, but complies nonetheless. “What’s going on?”
Ollie wheels himself closer, until he’s sitting just in front of Chandler. “I was trying to figure out a way to tell you, but I couldn’t figure out how,” he admits. “I guess I haven’t been handling it the right way, but I really didn’t know what else to do.”
“Tell me what,” Chandler asks, his heart thumping a bit painfully. Nothing that makes Ollie this nervous can be a good thing.
Ollie blushes, clearing his throat. “I was, um… I asked Ariel out.”
Chandler stares for him, the news not quite sinking it. Then, after a few moments, he says, “Oh.”
“Y-yeah…” Ollie rubs the back of his neck. “I know it’s probably ill timing, with Loki and everything, but we’ve been hanging out, and she said yes, so…” He shrugs. “I just didn’t know if you’d be okay with it, and couldn’t figure out a way to tell you.”
“Oh.” Chandler really needs to find a better way of reacting to news, but for now, oh is all he’s got. “That’s great.”
Ollie blinks. “That’s… great?”
“Well, yeah. I mean, obviously you two like each other. At least, I hope so. And it’s not like I’m her boyfriend or anything. She can see whoever she wants. And, honestly, I’m just glad you don’t, like, have cancer or anything.”
“Wait, what?” Ollie’s eyes widen comically. “Cancer?”
Chandler shrugs, a sheepish grin forming on his face. “It was on my list of Possible Reasons for Ollie Avoiding Me.”
Ollie stares for another few seconds, before laughing. And in that moment, everything is alright again.
Desiree looks like she’s three seconds away from bursting into tears.
Chandler’s mind goes into overdrive, shooting straight to Overprotective Big Brother Mode. He quickly runs down a list of everything that could be wrong, and wonders if he should call Audie over, or ask Dustin for that shotgun his dad keeps under the kitchen table.
Des stands close to the door, looking ready to bolt at the first sign of trouble. “I… can we talk?”
What kind of question is that? “Yeah, of course,” Chandler answers, scrambling to his feet. He wraps an arm around his sister’s shoulders, leading her to the bed. He sits down on the edge, pulling her down with him. “What’s going on?”
“I, um…” She sniffles, swiping her hand over her cheeks to clear any tears. “I’ve been thinking a lot, and I – I figured some things out, and I don’t – I don’t want to hide it from you. You’ve always been there for me, and I don’t want us to start lying to each other, now or ever, so I–”
He shushes her, squeezing her hands comfortingly. “Hey, it’s okay. You can tell me anything. You know that, right? I’m your brother, Dessie. You can tell me anything.” He prays and prays that it’s nothing serious. He hopes that in her discoveries, she’s simply found out that she’s failing geometry or something. Something that she would be ashamed of, maybe, but something that could be fixed. He hopes it’s nothing serious or bad, but if it’s brought her to tears, he doesn’t know how it could not be.
“I know,” she croaks, but it doesn’t sound as though she really believes it. She sniffles again, nodding. “I know I can, and that’s why… it’s why I want to tell you first. Before Audie, or Harmony, or mom.”
Chandler’s heart pangs at the mention of their mother. Even though it’s been almost a year since his father’s death, she hasn’t made any progress. He lives for her, guiding her through the routines that should be instinctual by now. He doesn’t remember the last time she’s had a conversation with her daughters. Of course Dessie wouldn’t tell her anything first. He nods slightly. “Okay.”
“I, um… Audie’s my soulmate. We’ve been best friends our entire lives, and I’ve always loved her. I always knew she would always be in my life, but I never knew how. But I think… I think I know how.”
Chandler has a pretty good idea of where she’s going with this. He just nods encouragingly, keeping his face devoid of any emotion.
“I… I think I like girls,” Dessie finally says, tears spilling down her cheeks. She flinches from her own words. “Is that… is it bad?”
Not for the first time, Chandler is reminded of how young they all are. Only just thirteen, Dessie is at an impressionable age; one misspoken word, and her entire opinion of herself will change. She will never be comfortable with herself unless he accepts her first. Not that it would be a problem. He smiles warmly at her, wiping her tears, before placing his hands on her shoulders. “Not even remotely. Do you feel better, now that you’ve said it?”
Dessie stares at him in shocked silence for a few seconds before nodding. “It… yeah. You… you really don’t mind?”
A proud smile on his face, Chandler shakes his head. “Some girls like boys, and some girls like girls, and some girls like both; and some girls just like people. Some girls don’t like anyone at all. It’s the same thing for boys. It doesn’t matter who or what you like, Dessie. You’re always gonna be my awesome baby sister, no matter what.” He thinks for a moment. “Does this mean…?”
Dessie blushes, already knowing where he’s going with that. “I like her,” she mumbles. “For a while, I thought it was just the way best friends like each other. Or like sisters. But she’s not my best friend, or my sister. I mean, she’s totally both of those, but I…”
Chandler chuckles, nodding. “I get it. And she can be both, you know,” he tells her. “She can be your best friend and that other thing. She doesn’t have to fit into one category or the other. And I don’t think she would want to just fit into one category exclusively.”
“I don’t, either,” Des agrees, smiling at him. “Is it like that for you?”
Chandler freezes. “What?” He sincerely hopes that she isn’t talking about Holden, or Tatum, because while he isn’t going out of his way to hide his crushes on them, he isn’t really trying to go public about it either.
“With Adelaide,” she clarifies, brushing against his shoulder. “Is she your best friend and that other thing?”
He takes a few seconds to think about it, before nodding. “Yeah. She’s my best friend and… that other thing.”
Tatum agrees to pick the girls up from school, which gives Chandler the day off. Tatum’s like that cool uncle who doesn’t just pick you up from school, but takes you out for ice cream and burgers, and asks about school and somehow makes the entire day fun, even with the suckiness of school and teachers being a core part of said day.
Tatum has the girls, so all Chandler has to do is get some food in his mom, then make sure she takes her pills before bed. The relative ease of the day takes the tension from his shoulders as he enters the house. It’s quiet without the constant chatter of sisters.
Not for the first time, he wonders if Easton would be like them. He wonders if he would talk, day in and day out, only ever quieting when he retreated to his room. He wonders if he would be an artist, like Storey, or if he would be a socialite, like Dessie. He wonders if Easton would be mature like him, or even withdrawn, like his mother. He wonders how Easton would have reacted to his father’s death. Easton had always been closer to their dad than Chandler was. He wouldn’t have been able to compartmentalize the same way that Chandler had; Chandler wouldn’t have wanted him to.
Would Easton have been happy?
(Is Chandler happy?)
Chandler sighs, tossing his bag down by the front door. “I’m home,” he calls to no one, before pausing. If he listens closely enough, he can hear… is that water? “Mom?” Impossible. She hasn’t dragged herself out of bed in almost a year. He had tried every method under the sun to bring her back to them, but nothing had worked. Why today?
Automatically, he knows. Five years ago today, Easton had been taken from in front of their house. It’s reason enough to drive anyone out of their bed.
His heart races as the fact finally catches up to him. “Mom?” He knocks lightly on the door where the running water is coming from. “Mom, I’m home. Have you eaten? Mom?” Having seen her naked more times than he would like to admit, Chandler doesn’t hesitate to push her bathroom door open.
What he sees makes his heart stop.
“Mom!” The sight of your mother in a bathtub, with slit wrists and tears falling from her eyes sounds like a horrible cliché. It sounds like, and it is one. At least, until it becomes your reality. The water is overflowing from the bathtub, and he wonders how he hadn’t noticed the wet ground before. Her eyes are wide open, tears running unabashedly from her eyes. The only comfort is that he can still see her chest rising and falling, meaning that he isn’t too late. He tears through the bathroom, shoving things out of his way until he grabs the biggest towels he can find. “Jesus, Mom,” he cries, wrapping the towels around her wrist.
She just stares back at him as he calls nine-one-one, saying nothing as he fumbles through an explanation of what’s happening. They tell him to stay on the phone, but he hangs up, tossing his phone to the side. He applies more pressure to the towels, glancing into his mother’s blank eyes. “How dare you,” he asks through gritted teeth. “How dare you?!”
It’s only after she’s been loaded into the ambulance that he remembers to call Tatum. Just keep them for the night, he requests, keeping his voice even and empty. Or drop them off at Audie’s. I’ll tell you everything later.
Ariel shows up when he’s at the hospital, eyes as red as her hair. She draws him into a hug, and cries into his shoulder. He wonders how much of that she saw. He wonders if she’s as traumatized as he is, wonders if she’ll ever recover from this. While he feels nothing but bleakness, she seems to take all of the sorrow and horror that he doesn’t allow himself to feel. “I’m sorry,” she sobs, shaking against him. He can’t find the strength to hug her back. Not when he’s wet and covered in his mother’s blood, and faced with the knowledge that if he’d been any later, he and his sisters would be orphans.
Ollie and Ezra seem to appear from thin air, faces paling in a morbidly comical way when they see the blood on his clothes and hands. “It’s not mine,” he half-jokes, passing Ariel over to Ollie. “Keep an eye on her, okay? She’s been through a lot tonight.”
Before anyone else can say anything else, he makes his way into his mother’s hospital room. She looks small in the bed, the gown of white swamping her entirely. There are bandages wrapped around her wrists, tubes running from her arms. She’s still damp, but her hair seems to have absorbed most of the water. Her eyes are rimmed red from tears, and she flinches when he enters. She looks almost rueful. It’s the most emotion he’s seen from her since his father died. “Chandler,” she gasps. “Baby…”
“Don’t,” he bites out, and he finally allows himself to feel something. He’s felt nothing but pity and tenderness for his mother since his dad died. He’s always put her first, being patient with her, regardless of how much work he has to do just to get her through the day. He’s never gotten frustrated with her, has never once hated her for how fast she forced him to grow up. But in this moment, he feels nothing but contempt for her. “You had no right. You had no right.”
“I’m sorry,” she tries.
“The hell you are,” he snaps. “I – do you know how hard this year has been for me, Mom? I lost my baby brother, then I lost my dad. And not only did I lose them, but I lost you. You fell into this – this abyss, and nothing I did pulled you out. You were just gone, mother, and I had no choice but to step up. I had to get two jobs, and learn how to file taxes, and pay bills. I’m indebted to every person I call a friend, because every time I got a paycheck, it wasn’t enough. I needed more money than I had to raise two kids, and feed myself and you. Not to mention three of my closest friends moved away, and my soulmate’s heart broke.
“And Dessie – Dessie found herself this year, did you know that? Do you know how much fucking progress she’s made? She’s happy, mother, but you wouldn’t know that, because you’ve spent the past year wallowing in self-pity. Storey – Storey likes to draw. And she’s amazing at it. I mean, you should see her art. She draws like no one I’ve ever seen before. She drew a picture of Easton, and it might as well have been a damn photograph, it was so good. She drew you, too. And she tried to show you, but do you know what you said? Nothing! You didn’t say a goddamn thing! You didn’t even look at her. You broke her heart that day. It took Dessie and me hours to make her smile again. All she wanted was to make her mother smile, but you – you ignored her.
“Our lives have completely changed this year,” he rants, and hot tears streak down his cheeks. “Nothing is the same as it was before, and we – we needed you. But you didn’t give us the time of day. You missed every game – which reminds me, I had to give up soccer, the one thing that was holding me together in order to pick up a second job – and every art gallery, and every science fair. You missed every moment of the past year, and you… you have the nerve to try to kill yourself. As if – as if you’re the only one who lost him! As if you’re the one who’s been struggling!”
His mother cries openly, hands clenching the sheets as sobs wrack her body. Her heart monitor beeps uncontrollably, and he knows that maybe he should stop, but he doesn’t care. He can’t find it in him to care anymore. He’s been holding back for a year now, and he’s so tired. “Tell me how to fix this,” she cries. “I’m – I’m here, now, baby. Just tell me – tell me what to do.”
Chandler freezes, his back going ramrod straight. “Sign over your rights,” he demands, his eyes blazing as he watches her face contort in confusion. “Dessie and Storey. Sign over your parental rights.”
Her eyes widen and she shakes her head. “No – no, no, you can’t make me.”
“The hell I can’t,” he growls. “You are going to sign over your rights. The girls are going to go and live with Aunt Claire. And I’m going to put you in a mental institution, so you can get better. Obviously, nothing I do at home is going to help you. So you’re going to get some help. And you’re going to stay out of their lives.”
“Chandler, please,” his mom pleads, crying profusely. “Please, don’t – I’m sorry, okay? Baby, I’m so sorry, just don’t – don’t, don’t do this, please, I can’t–”
Chandler shakes his head, taking another step back. “You don’t get to do this,” he laughs. “You don’t get to do this, Annette. Do you have any idea what could happen to those girls? CPS could come and take them away right now! You’ve been out of the picture for a year, this – this is just a nail in the coffin! You have been a terrible mom since Dad died, so please. Do this one thing. Sign over your rights to Claire, and stay out of our lives.”
“Why do we have to go,” Storey asks him again, her hands shaking at her sides.
Chandler sighs, zipping up her last duffel bag, before he turns to look at her. “Mom is really sick, Storey,” he lies. Well, it’s only a half-lie. As far as the girls know, his mom is suffering from an undisclosed potentially terminal illness. They’re ignorant to her depression, which is all Chandler can ask for. He knows that, in the long run, this plan won’t work. It’ll come back to bite him in the ass sooner or later, but he can’t think about that, now. He can only think about the girls. “She can’t take care of you. And it’s been fine for a while, just me taking care of you and Dessie, but it’s not easy. If you stay with Aunt Claire for a while, you can be in a safer, more stable environment. I can take care of Mom, and when she gets better, I’ll come back and get you, okay?”
Storey’s bottom lip quivers in a telling way, and she takes a gulp of air as tears fall. “I don’t want to leave you here,” she breathes, shaking her head. “Chandler, I won’t – I’m not going to lose you, too. I can’t lose you.”
His heart shatters into a million pieces.
“Storey, no.” He stands up, crossing the room and wrapping his arms around her. “You are not losing me, okay? I’m still here. And you can call me every day. And you can visit whenever you want. I’ll pick you up from school, and I’ll take you out – you can stay here on the weekends, if Aunt Claire allows it. Okay? You. Are not. Losing me. Not now, not ever.”
He wonders if he can really do this. If he can really send both of his sisters away, and stay in this house with Annette for an indiscernible amount of time. He’s never been too far away from his sisters, never for more than a day. He doesn’t know for sure that he won’t break without them to hold him up. He doesn’t know for sure that his hatred won’t swallow him whole, or that he won’t fall apart the next time he looks at her. Annette has gone back to locking herself in her room, but he checks on her by the hour, leaving her with no time for another suicide attempt. They have a deal: if she gets better, and doesn’t try anything like that again, he’ll bring the girls back, and this can be swept under the rug. But if she recedes into herself again, the way she’s doing now, she’ll never see those girls again. She’ll be out of their lives, and Chandler will never let her back in.
He knows it’s harsh. He knows and understands how the loss of her child and soulmate in less than five years can tear her apart. He understands that she isn’t okay. He doesn’t blame her for that. But he blames her for what he’s had to do. He blames her for all of the work and hardship that he’s gone through, all because she refused to even speak after the loss of his dad. He hates her for watching him put his own happiness on the backburner, wearing himself thin, and choosing to kill herself instead of helping him. He isn’t even eighteen, yet. If she’d died, he wouldn’t have been able to keep the girls. They all would’ve been put into the foster system, and there’s no guarantee that they would have been kept together. He would be in the system for another two years, and would have been put into a different home from them. He would’ve lost his baby sisters if she’d died. At least this way, he knows where his sisters are going. He can visit them whenever he likes, and knows for a fact that they will be safe.
This is for the best, he tells himself. This is the best thing he can do for his sisters.
Storey holds him tight, as if he’ll never be able to escape the grip she has; as if they’ll never be separated. “I can’t – please. Not you, too, Chandler, I can’t – I can’t take it if we lose you, too. Please don’t make us go. Or come with us! Don’t… please.”
Her pleas remind him too much of Annette’s, when they were in the hospital just a week ago. As far as his sisters know, his mother was admitted to the hospital because she passed out. He doesn’t have the heart to tell Storey, only thirteen and still so lost in the world, that her mother chose death over her. He can never tell her that.
He sits her down on the bed, wrapping his arms around her. She clings to his arm, crying into his shoulder. “Storey, I’m not leaving you,” he promises firmly. “I am never leaving you. But someone needs to stay and take care of Mom. And you and Dessie need to be in a home where you’ll be taken care of. You need stable income, and someone who can help you with your homework, and go to your art galleries. Mom… Mom can’t do that. And I don’t think it’s healthy for you to stay here and wait for her. I don’t want that for you. I don’t want you and Des to have to… to stay in this house, with so many bad memories. Not for a while, at least.” He pulls away, forcing her to look him in the eyes. “I need you to do this for me, Storey. It’s just for a few months. Just get out of this house, and be happy. Okay? Please.”
She holds his gaze for a moment, before nodding determinedly. “I’m coming back every weekend,” she tells him, leaving no room for any sort of argument. “I’m calling you every day. And you’re going to come see my art shows, and you’re going to be there for my birthday, and… and…”
Chandler nods, forcing back tears of his own. “I will. I promise.” He presses a long kiss to her hair, before wrapping his arms around her again.
Dessie stands in the door, tears reaming at her own eyes. When they meet gazes, she just shakes her head and walks out.
“Bad time?”
“Never,” Chandler yawns, dragging a hand over his face. The girls moved out a week ago, and while his mother has made some progress, he still does a large portion of the work for her. She speaks sometimes, but withdraws from reality every time he gives her a less than tender response. It’s easier, now that he doesn’t have to take care of the girls, too, but still exhausting. He’s ready to let sleep overtake him, but is glad to hear from Ollie. “What’s up, man?”
“You sound exhausted.”
“I am exhausted,” Chandler confesses. “It’s just been a long day, man. Nothing big.” Another thing: none of his friends know, either. They don’t know that Annette is in perfect physical health; it’s her mental stability that’s in question. For this elaborate lie to work out, he needs to be the only one who knows the truth. The weight of the lie seems to be harder to carry than the weight of taking care of his mother, but he’s okay with it. “What’s going on? You didn’t call me at…” He checks the clock on the stove. “…one o’clock in the morning to tell me I’m tired.”
“Not that I wouldn’t,” Ollie points out. “I actually think Mari’s staging an intervention, so you should probably avoid her at all costs.”
Chandler chuckles. “Okay.”
Ollie’s silent. Chandler doesn’t push him; instead, he starts to put the dishes up, momentarily grateful of how much his mother doesn’t eat. It saves a lot of dishes. By the time Ollie speaks, the glass plates have been put up. “A new girl moved in next door.”
“Yeah?” Chandler puts the phone on speaker, setting it down on the counter. He grabs the glass bowls, carrying them over to their cabinet. “Is she cute?”
“The cutest,” Ollie gushes. “Her name is Effie, and she’s the most adorable girl I’ve ever met. She’s sort of awkward, but not in a bad way, like, at all. She seemed kind of freaked out by me at first, but I think she confused me with Ezra. I’m half-convinced he met her earlier and did something to scare her off before she was even finished moving in.”
“I wouldn’t be surprised,” Chandler rolls his eyes.
“Right?” Ollie laughs, and there’s rustling on the other end. “I touched her, Chan.”
Chandler stills, knowing the implications of those words. “And?”
Ollie takes a breath. “She’s my soulmate.”
Two years and one month after Easton disappears, they have a funeral for Annette.
Chandler’s mom isn’t dead. That’s just what everyone believes.
She’s supposedly cremated, and her funeral goes by a lot quicker than his father’s did. There are still a lot of tears, but not nearly as many as there would’ve been two years ago. She hasn’t talked to anyone other than Chandler since her husband was shot, leaving her estranged to everyone she once loved. Even Dessie and Storey are more controlled, shedding quiet tears as they stare at an old picture of their smiling mother.
How long ago was it that Annette was smiling? Chandler can hardly remember.
When he gives his mother’s eulogy, he meets Claire’s desolate eyes. She’s the only person in the world who knows the truth about what Chandler did. She had given her consent for it, just a few weeks before his mother’s admission to the mental hospital in the next town over. She hasn’t been close to her sister in a long time, he remembers. Even before his father was taken from him, Claire and Annette had been at odds, for reasons he’s never known. Regardless of the reason, she doesn’t even pretend to mourn her sister’s supposed death.
He doesn’t care as much as he should.
When all is said and done, the girls go back to Claire’s, and he lets Tatum and Ariel drive him home. He hears them follow him into the house, but he ignores them, storming up to his room. He doesn’t know why he’s so angry, now; he doesn’t know why he feels as though he’s about to fall apart, despite being the orchestrator behind this entire time. He knows his mom isn’t dead, knows that his sisters are safe, and things will be easier now. Even so, he feels a fire beneath his skin, acid running through his veins, and screams rising his throat.
He slams the door behind him.
He paces his room for a few minutes, dragging his hands through his hair. Why does he feel like this? Why does his heart hurt so much?
When his vision stops swimming, and his blood stops boiling, he listens for his friends. He knows they all followed him here, knows they’re all still here. They wouldn’t leave him.
“He’s losing it,” Marilyn is saying, something foreign in her voice.
“Do you blame him?” It’s Ezra. “He’s lost both of his parents, and all of his siblings. Wouldn’t you lose it?”
“It’s not this,” Holden pipes up. “Back when his dad died, remember? He was doing everything under the sun. Taking care of his mom, and his sisters, and himself, juggling two jobs… He hasn’t even mourned his dad yet.”
“I don’t even think he’s mourned Easton,” Tatum adds.
There’s a long bout of silence. “He hasn’t been handling it,” Effie says. “Everything that’s happened to him… it’s all hitting him at once.”
“So what do we do,” Ollie asks. “We can’t just leave him like this.”
“Let me talk to him,” Ariel orders immediately.
“Are you crazy,” Braeden asks incredulously. “Ari—”
“He won’t hurt me,” Ariel cuts her off. “Chandler would never hurt anyone, even if he is hurting. And I’m his soulmate. His soulmate, and his best friend. And I’m not leaving him like this.”
There’s more silence, before a knock on Chandler’s door startles him. Ariel steps in, and his eyes narrow to slits. “Get out.”
Unfazed by his words, Ariel close the door behind her, and leans against the wall.
“I said,” he hisses, “Get. Out!”
“No,” she says simply. “I’m not leaving you.”
Ariel is right about one thing – he won’t hurt her. Not even when his world is falling apart. But he wants to hurt something. He wants to watch something shatter, the way that his life has. He wants to see something break the same way that he is. So he picks up the snow globe his mother had gotten him for his birthday three years ago, and hurls it at the wall. It isn’t near Ariel, but she flinches anyway.
He shoves everything off his desk, including the lamp he and Easton had painted when Chandler was in the fifth grade.
He stabs a pair of scissors into the soccer ball his dad had given him before his first soccer game, before throwing it.
He rips apart every loose piece of paper he finds, smashing every breakable object he can find. When his room has been destroyed, and the hurricane of emotions has passed, Ariel is still standing there. For once, he’s the one crying. “Do you feel better?” She asks patiently.
His mouth opens, and he searches for words – an apology, an explanation, something – but comes up empty. Ariel steps away from the wall, careful not to set foot on any glass, and wraps him in a hug.
“You’ve been so strong,” she whispers, holding him close, her fingers threading through the hair at the nape of his neck. “You’ve held yourself up for everyone. It’s okay to let go now. You don’t have to be strong anymore.”
He crumbles in her arms, his body sagging against hers. He’s exhausted. It feels as if he’s carried the weight of the world for so long, and it’s finally gotten to him. He feels as though he’s fought a hundred wars, and the one against himself is the one he can’t win.
There’s a hesitant knock at the door. Tatum shuffles on his feet. “Chandler…”
Dessie steps into the room, her eyes widening when she sees the destruction wrought on the room, and on her brother.
Chandler pulls away from Ariel, stepping towards his sister. “Des, you need to go home.”
Des’ eyes move back to him, hardening. “I am home. And I’m not leaving again.”
He really isn’t in the mood for this. “Des—”
“No,” she snaps, pushing him back. “You don’t get to push me away, Chandler. You don’t get to act like you haven’t been playing superman for the past two years. I know, okay? I’ve seen you run yourself to the ground. I’ve seen it. And you will not stand here and act like it hasn’t hurt. Don’t you dare act like this hasn’t been weighing on you. Did you even realize your birthday was last week?”
He hadn’t, actually. Seventeen, huh? So far, it’s not all that great. “Des,” he tries again. “I’m going to be okay. But you need to go home. Claire is going to worry—”
She shoves his hand away. “I’m not leaving you,” she screams at him. The house goes quiet. “I am not leaving you alone again, Chandler. You’ve been alone for so long, and I’m not leaving you in this house by yourself anymore. I’m not letting you drown, Chandler Uriah Reese. Do you hear me?” Tears are in her eyes, but she stands firm. She won’t take no for an answer, and Chandler doesn’t think he’s ever been prouder.
His hand wraps around her wrist and he pulls her into him, hugging her tightly. “Don’t leave me,” he begs her, tears dropping to her shoulder. “Please don’t leave me.”
“I won’t,” Desiree promises, her arms slipping around his waist. “I’m not going anywhere. I’m never leaving you alone again. Not ever.”
Over her shoulder, he meets Ariel’s eyes. The redhead smiles, nodding slightly.
They’re going to be okay.
Ariel shows up at his door, her lips twitching in amusement. Chandler brightens at the sight of her. “Ariel! Ariel. Ariel, come in, you need to get in here, right now.”
She laughs as he drags her inside. “What’s got you in such a good mood? You haven’t been this happy since Ezra told you he would date you before he dated Loki.”
“Listen, it’s an honor to be someone’s second choice, especially to be chosen over your pretentious boyfriend.”
Ariel rolls her eyes fondly. “Chandler.”
The curly-haired boy – now eighteen, and infinitely happy than he had been before – whirls around to face her, and his eyes shine with joy. “Easton’s home.”
Her heart almost falls out of her chest. “W-what?” She can’t believe her ears. It’s been three years since Easton disappeared, and they had almost given up hope of ever finding him. She feels dread pool in her stomach, uncertain that this isn’t some sick prank someone is pulling on her soulmate. If it is, Loki will have them erased. (The same way Holden’s dad was. Even now, months later, she still has no clue what happened to him.) “Chandler, are you… are you sure?”
His smile fades, and he frowns. “Of course I’m sure, Ariel. I know my brother, okay? And he knows me. He recognized me, and the girls, and he recognized Tatum and Adelaide, too. It’s Easton, Ariel.”
She still isn’t sure, but she could never be the one to rain on his parade, so she nods, smiling at him. “I want to see him.”
His beams at her, and continues to drag her through the house. When they near the kitchen, a cacophony of voices reaches her ears. She can hear Adelaide fussing over someone, Storey teasing her for being such a mom. Ariel’s heart beats painfully against her rib cage, and she prays to every deity she can name that this isn’t some trick. It took so long for Chandler to smile again. After his mother died, he’d fallen apart. It broke her heart to see him that way, day after day. They had never feared that he would take his own life – not while his sisters were living, anyway – but they had feared for his mental state. He hadn’t been Chandler for a long time.
But they had finally gotten him back. He started to smile, and to laugh, and to joke around. His grin became as infectious as it was before, and he would throw himself over any of his friends. Even Loki could only act annoyed with him half of the time. He had crawled out of the pits of depression, and Ariel never wants to see him go back.
She needs this to really be Easton. She needs this to be Chandler’s brother, and she needs him to stay. Because if it isn’t, or if he leaves again, then nothing in the world will bring Chandler back. She can’t lose Chandler to himself again – none of them can – and this boy, claiming to be Easton, has all the potential to break his heart. No one in this world has more power over Chandler in that moment, and Ariel hates that.
When she lays eyes on the boy, her breath catches in her throat.
Undoubtedly Easton – who else would have such hair? Such eyes? Who else looks at Chandler as if he hung the stars, and Storey as if she is a star, and Dessie as if he’s blessed to be a part of her orbit? – the boy looks up at her, and smiles hesitantly. “Hey, Ariel.”
Chandler squeezes her hand, and she forces herself not to break into tears. “Hi, honey. Welcome home.”
josiah & m-a-r-i-n-a
iii. who knew you would be the greater of the two evils?
Marina Margaret Matthers is five years old when she meets her best friend.
Her mother is having a business meeting in the living room, and while she’s cognizant to the rules –
( cognizant: adjective, having knowledge of. )
-- she can’t help but sneak down the stairs to peek at the company. She knows her mother won’t be happy about it, but refuses to let herself be deterred by that. There’s always the chance that she won’t get caught – slim chance, but still a chance – she just has to be careful. She creeps down the stairs, lightly stepping on her tip toes, until her mother’s voice floods her ears. Her mother speaks so often, it would be virtually impossible for Marina not to recognize her voice.
She stops at the foot of the stairs, peeking around the corner to catch a glimpse of who her mom is talking to. She sees a tall woman, and a little girl with what looks like light hair. Her mother continues to speak, the woman paying rapt attention, but the little girl seems bored out of her mind. Marina stifles a snicker at the sight of her. She doesn’t make a single noise, but the little girl’s eyes snap to her. She blinks curiously, before turning back to Marina’s mom. “Missus Matthers?”
Her mother trails off in the middle of what is surely an epic speech about something no one really cares about. “Yes?”
“May I please use your restroom?”
“Of course, Summer. It’s right down that hall, second door on the left.”
The girl – Summer – nods with a smile, then wiggles off of her stool. Marina can only watch with dawning horror as the girl waddles her way towards her. She presses her back firmly against the wall behind her, her eyes wide as the stranger approaches. Summer gives her a funny look. “What are you doing?”
Eyes darting to her mother, Marina presses a finger to her lips. “Shhh!” She grabs Summer’s hand and pulls her into the bathroom, shutting the door shut behind them. “You’re going to get me in trouble!”
“For what,” Summer inquires, confused. “Going to the bathroom?”
Marina wonders if this girl is being intentionally thick. “I’m not s’posed to be down here.”
“It’s a bathroom.”
“That’s not the point!” Marina makes sure to keep her voice quiet. She lets out a sigh. “This was a bad idea.”
Summer shrugs. “Probably.” Her lips widen into a childish grin, and she sticks her hand out. “Summer Lopez-Pierce, at your service.”
“Marina Matthers,” she replies, smiling almost shyly. “It’s a pleasure to meet you, Summer.”
The girl examines her for a long moment, then starts bouncing on her toes. “I have an idea!”
“Oh?” Something just tells Marina this isn’t as revolutionary as the gleam in Summer’s eyes would indicate. “And this idea is…?”
“Be my best friend!”
Marina pauses, her disposition softening at the simplicity. “Be… your friend?”
“Best friend,” Summer corrects. “It can be you, and me, and Lilah! That’s my soulmate, by the way. We can all be best friends! What do you say, Marnie?”
“…Marnie?”
Summer pouts. “You don’t like it? I think it’s cute.”
Marina rolls the name around in her head for a few more seconds, before lifting her shoulders in a brief shrug. “Marnie, it is. And I’ll be your best friend, as long as you promise to help me with my spelling words.”
Summer rolls her eyes – they’re only five, and it’s somehow offensive – but nods. “Sure. And I’ll teach you how to have fun while we’re at it.”
“Spelling words are fun!”
“They’re really not.”
It’s a true testament to how far she’s come that Marnie doesn’t even jump when someone’s arms wrap around her shoulders. She doesn’t even lift her head from her book, only slightly pressing into the embrace. She knows that it can only be one of her friends. Jennifer isn’t as tactile as her welcoming demeanor would lead one to believe, so it probably isn’t her. Summer is supposed to be at the gym with her big brother, and she actually likes him enough to actually attend their bonding events, so she’s out. Which means –
“What are you reading?” Delilah asks, resting her chin on Marnie’s shoulder.
Marnie – ten years old, best friend to the other girls for about five years now – flips the page. “Edgar Allen Poe,” she answers distractedly. “It’s his book of poems.”
The name seems to mean something to Delilah, as she goes quiet for a few seconds. “The book we’re supposed to read in, like, high school?”
“That would be it,” Marnie acknowledges, closing the book. “Technically, we don’t have to read it. It’s really dependent on which English courses you choose to take. If you take literary analysis sophomore year—”
Delilah giggles in her ear, sending shivers down her spine. “I don’t need details, Mars.” Her friend unwraps her arms from her shoulders and takes a seat on the bench next to her, facing the opposite direction. “You have to be the only ten year old ever to go to the park, just to read.”
Marnie concurs. “Summer doesn’t approve,” she says, fanning her hands out behind her. She leans back, looking up at the clouds that lazily peregrinate overhead –
( peregrinate: verb, to travel or journey. )
-- without any sense of urgency. It’s silly, but she’s almost envious of them. “She thinks I should my time doing something more productive.”
“Like what,” Delilah prompts, a teasing edge to her voice. “Learn to put on make-up?”
Marnie scoffs. “It’s a useless skill for kids our age. Not to mention that cosmetology, while excelling in marketing and production, isn’t a very progressive industry. Someone with a heart like Summer’s should be doing something that goes against the objectification of women.”
Delilah’s lips twitch. “I don’t think all make-up is objectifying,” she counters. “To say that it is would be to feed into the stereotypical notion that a girl only puts on make-up to catch the eyes of whatever guy -- or girl – piques their interest. If that were true, Summer wouldn’t look twice at her moms’ make-up. Some women wear makeup simply because they want to. In essence, the cosmetics industry is fairly empowering. I wouldn’t call it a trademark for feminism or anything, but it’s definitely not a stigma. Not to mention the gross connotation that genderfluid or non-binary persons can’t rock lip gloss and eyeliner.”
Marnie nods, taking a moment to formulate her response. She knows, rationally, that this isn’t an actual debate. Neither of them has outlined their rebuttals or anything, and Delilah is doing this largely to humor her. And it isn’t really as if they’re on opposite ends of the argument. She vastly agrees with her friend, on many points. It’s just that now that they’ve started the deliberation, she isn’t quite ready to let go. “It’s not the make-up itself that would be the stigma,” she finally acquiesces. “Rather, the marketing strategies.”
“Ah.”
“Rarely ever do you see cosmetics ads that are geared towards the empowerment of women. They always aim for sexiness and allurement. And that in and of itself wouldn’t be such a bad thing, if not for the presentation. And you bring up a good point, actually. The lack of representation for genderfluid, transgendered, and non-binary persons is appalling, and always overlooked, because that’s not the kind of message we want to send our kids,” she mocks.
“Those conservatives, right?”
“Precisely! And it isn’t as we should eradicate the gestalt of the Republican Party -- because, let’s be honest with ourselves, it’s them – or uproot their belief system, but they should aim towards a more enlightened mindset. Eventually, they have to realize that we’re a whole new generation, and we’re not so blind as to believe that same sex marriage is wrong, or that our gender is confined to what genitilia we were born with. Even at our age, we realize that sexual identity and sexual orientation have nothing to do with what body parts we are born with, or what family we are born into. The world has taken a more radical view, and it’s sickening that some people refuse to accept that, on the grounds of preserving innocence or religion, of all things, as if God would be so hateful! We cannot simply keep acting like this isn’t happening, like we aren’t moving forward as a nation, and keeping the LBTQA community out of the media does nothing but lower our op—mmf.”
“Enough,” Delilah decides, keeping her hand firmly over Marnie’s mouth. “That is the last time that I try to go toe to toe with you in a debate. I don’t even know what half of those words mean, Marnie.”
Marnie pulls Delilah’s hand off away from her face, and can’t help but grin at her. “You brought up some really good points,” she compliments, kissing Delilah’s palm. “Come to me when you’re ready to talk gentrification. I can’t wait.”
Delilah gives her a fondly exasperated look. “This is why Summer wants you to do other things,” she teases. “You’re such a nerd, Marnie.”
Marnie pouts, an affronted look on her face. “I’m not a nerd.” She hesitates for a few seconds, biting her lower lip. “Am I?”
“You’re the only person I know who thinks in vocab words,” Delilah points out, an affectionate smile lining her lips. “But I don’t think there’s anything wrong with it. I think it’s cute.”
No one’s ever called me cute before. “What do you think I should do? Instead of read all the time?”
Delilah thinks for a moment. “I think you should do whatever makes you smile. I don’t think you should care what Summer, or your mom, or anyone thinks. If reading and thinking in flashcards is what keeps you smiling, then I think that’s exactly what you do.” She leans her head over Marnie’s shoulder, closing her eyes. “There’s nothing wrong with you, no matter what you choose to do. All that matters is that you’re happy.” She pauses. “Are you happy?”
Marnie lets out a contemplative hum. “Thinking in flashcards is pretty empowering.”
“You only say that because it makes you smarter than the rest of us.”
Marnie laughs. “Only a little,” she accedes. “I just… I like knowing things, you know? I like having a repertoire of words at hand. No matter what I’m feeling, or what the situation is, there’s always a litany of words running through my mind that can be used. I always have something to say, and my mom…” She trails off, not sure why she starts down that path.
Delilah brings her head up, smiling wistfully at her. “I know.” All of the girls know how Marnie’s mom is. She’s notorious for her obsession with perfection, known for her mercilessness when it comes to mistakes. She had pushed her daughters to read dictionaries instead of picture books, doing math at university levels when they should’ve been learning their time tables. She isn’t a bad mother, Marnie will always argue; she simply wants her kids to be as educated as possible.
Education is key, after all.
Jennifer lets herself in.
Marnie startles when she sees her, pulling her blanket over her head. “Go away,” she calls out, sniffling and biting back another sob. She can’t believe this is happening. Just a month ago, this had been unfathomable. But now it’s happening, and she doesn’t know what to do. She doesn’t want to leave her room, for one thing. She hopes that if she stays in her room, the world will right itself, and when she comes out, this will have all been a horrible dream. She closes her eyes and prays for that to be. “Go away, Ferret.”
“No,” Jennifer denies. “Be glad it’s just me. Deli and Sims are still downstairs trying to figure out which ice breaker would be least offensive, and whether you’ll prefer Chinese food or Mexican food.”
Marnie rolls puffy eyes, wiping at her nose as she pulls the blanket down from over her head. “Chinese, obviously,” she gripes. “Mexican food is not comfort foot.”
Jennifer laughs softly. “I’ll let them know.” The mattress dips slightly as she takes a seat. “I’m sorry about your parents, Marnie.”
Marnie bites the inside of her cheek to keep from crying again. “It’s not that big of a deal,” she lies. “Have you seen divorce rates lately? Everyone’s doing it. It’s not like my parents are special or anything.”
“They are special,” Jennifer contradicts. “They’re your parents.”
A few more tears leak from Marnie’s eyes and she tries to keep her lips from wobbling. “I’m on my period,” she sobs. “Jenni, this sucks.” She had been so excited to turn twelve just a few months ago. So far, she hates it.
Jennifer tries for a smile, but it looks too pained and sorrowful to quite be called such. “I know, babe,” she mutters comfortingly. “Which is why you have us girls. We’re going to eat all the Chinese food we can handle, and watch every Patrick Swayze movie in your collection, and totally regret how much we ate in the morning.”
Despite the situation, Marnie finds herself smiling at the younger girl. “Yeah,” she croaks, wiping her eyes. “That’d be awesome, Fetter.”
It’s only later, after Dally’s death that one of them speaks again. The four girls are curled up in Marnie’s bed, limbs entangled haphazardly. Marnie is between Delilah and Jennifer, her cheek pressed against Delilah’s shoulder as Summer’s fingers graze her side. “My parents are getting a divorce,” Marnie says, her eyes remaining dry for once. “What am I going to do?”
Someone squeezes her hand.
“You’re going to be okay,” Summer tells her. “You’re going to hold your head up, and you’re going to call us every time your world feels like it’s imploding. You’re going to continue being you, Mars. It’s what you’ve always done, and you’re not going to let this stop you.”
Marnie goes quiet, before: “And you’ll still be here?”
Delilah chuckles quietly, pressing her lips to her shoulder. “You couldn’t get rid of us if you tried.”
Marnie is fourteen years old when she finally meets her soulmate.
She hasn’t really thought about them up until this point. She knows that she has one – at least, she sincerely hopes she does – but she hasn’t been too concerned with finding them. Unlike most people, she doesn’t mind the invariance of her world. She isn’t enough of a romantic to think of how beautiful the world is, or to wax poetic over the artistry of a black mountain painted against the gray of a colorless sky. She doesn’t particularly care if the sky is actually gray, or if it’s the deep azure that her father has described to her. To her, scenery is just that.
And it isn’t that she’s some sort of heretic. She isn’t against the idea of soulmates or of the world existing in more than three colors. She would like to see what the world looks like in color, sure. She wonders what green grass, and white carnations, and red velvet, and brown horses actually look like. She wonders what the world looks like through the eyes of someone who’s touched their other half, and who sees the world in an array of colors, instead of in monochromes. It isn’t that she doesn’t want to know; it’s just that she’s not hard pressed to find out.
In a word, she’s impartial. Books are written in black ink against plain paper, and that’s enough for her.
Anyway, her soulmate.
“So, you guys know my sister, right?”
Marnie and Jennifer look up from their game of tic tac toe, staring blankly at Summer. “Yes,” Marnie draws out, straightening in her seat. It’s their lunch period, which places them in the midst of rambunctious middle schoolers, with junk food clogging their arteries and Cheeto dust coating their fingers.
“We’ve pretty much known you forever, Sims,” Delilah points out. “It’s impossible not to know your siblings.”
Marnie nods. “Judging by that non-sequitur, something’s up with Brooke?”
Summer twirls her fork between her fingers, appearing far more disinterested than she actually is. “Not exactly.” She stills her fork, plunging it into her salad. “But she’s having her birthday party tonight, and inviting her friends.”
Jennifer takes pause, scrunching up her nose. “The Unholy Trinity?” Marnie can’t quite resist the urge to roll her eyes. While she’s aware that Brooke and her friends didn’t actually come up with it, she’ll never understand that name.
“Those would be the ones,” Summer nods. “They’re coming over, and you know they’re just going to invite their friends, and Mami will let them.” She lets out an agitated huff, shoveling an overstuffed forkful of salad into her mouth.
Delilah grimaces. “Okay, Sims, gross.” She plucks a napkin from Marnie’s lunchbox and hands it to Summer, who’s gotten ranch dressing all over her mouth. “And why do you care? Why not just come over to my place like you usually do when Brooke’s friends are over?”
If there’s one constant source of amusement in Marnie’s life, it’s how much Summer hates her siblings’ friends. Brooke’s best friends – Treasure and Lolita – and Taylor’s – Remy and Peter – have a knack for making her grumpy, with only the mention of their names. Marnie has no idea why Summer dislikes them all so much – she doesn’t even think Summer knows – but she has always gone out of her way to avoid them when possible. This usually means a night spent at Delilah’s, and some hurt feelings on Brooke’s part the next day. After years of this, one would think that Brooke would build up the same disregard for her sister’s behavior that Taylor has, but she still gets offended every time Summer dismisses her best friends.
Marnie is only partially convinced that Summer doesn’t act that way just to upset her sister.
“Yeah, I would,” Summer stresses, “except the moms want me to be there for her. Thirteenth birthday or whatever.”
“I love how much she cares,” Jennifer stage whispers to Marnie, bumping her shoulder as the two burst into giggles.
That gets a crouton tossed in their direction. “And I don’t want to have to put up with Brooke’s lame friends and their lame friends by myself.” A long suffering sigh escapes her lips, before she pouts pleadingly at her best friends. “Please come to this stupid party? It’d mean the world to me.”
Delilah tugs at the end of a strand of her soulmate’s hair. “We’re going for Brooke,” she articulates. “At least, that’ll be the official story. You were really excited for your little sister to be turning thirteen, and you wanted as many people to come as possible, so you invited your friends, too. Okay?”
Summer swats her hand away. “Yeah, yeah, okay. So you’ll be there?” She looks to Jennifer and Marnie, beaming childishly at them.
Marnie stifles a sigh, shaking her head. “You’re hopeless, Pierce.”
And that’s how Marnie finds herself at the doorstep of the Lopez-Pierce residence, fidgeting awkwardly, and asking herself why she didn’t accept Delilah’s offer of a ride. She isn’t particularly close to Brooke or her friends. Unlike Summer, Delilah, and Jennifer, she isn’t very social. They’re the only friends she has, and she doesn’t really talk unless she’s with them. She only talks when it’s the four of them, so why would she come to a party and risk being alone?
She’s here for Summer, she reminds herself. She’s here to keep Summer from ruining her sister’s thirteenth birthday party, or smothering herself with a pillow to get out of it.
“The doorbell’s not going to ring itself, genius.”
Marnie whirls around, almost tripping over herself. “W-what?”
A younger girl – Treasure, she thinks – rolls her eyes. “The doorbell.”
One of the boys with her – there are four, who the hell goes anywhere with four boys who look way too old to be here – nudges her disapprovingly. “Stop being rude, Tre,” he admonishes. His gaze shifts to Marnie, and he gives her an apologetic smile. “Sorry about her. You–”
The door is ripped open, and Marnie flinches away from it, only to relax when she sees that it’s just Summer. “Why are you just standing there,” her best friend asks in an impatient tone.
Unlike with Treasure, Marnie is used to her lack of courtesy, and just gives her a hard look. “Trying to remind myself of why I let you talk me into this,” she quips back, softening when Summer sticks her tongue out at her.
“Well, this is fun,” Treasure chirps sarcastically. “But it’s kind of cold out here, and I think we’d all like to go inside.”
In a way that only she would, Summer ignores Treasure altogether, taking Marnie’s wrist in her hand. “Come on. Ferret and Deli are already here, and I don’t trust Brooke not to hide the chocolate covered strawberries.”
As her best friend drags her inside, Marnie glances back at the group at the door. Treasure’s cheeks are tinted red, either in anger or humiliation at being so blatantly ignored, and the boys seem to still be processing the exchange. Marnie just shrugs, giving them a conciliatory smile.
The house is already filled with people Brooke has befriended over the years. All three Hudson children are in attendance, as well as the Chang siblings, and pretty much everyone with the last name Puckerman is making themselves comfortable at the snack table. The Anderson-Hummels are there, too, Jessica playfully bickering with her older brother. Delilah’s younger sister, Dylan, is there, too, though Mason and Ruby are nowhere to be seen. There are a few more people there that Marnie doesn’t recognize, and she shrinks into herself.
Summer leads her down the hall towards the rec room. She isn’t entirely sure why the Lopez-Pierce family has such a large house when there are only five people living in it, but it makes it easier to avoid social situations. Taylor has probably already taken his friends to the home theater – because they actually have one of those, Marnie has no idea why – as it’s the room he has unofficially claimed for avoiding his little sisters’ friends. The rec room is Summer’s Avoiding My Sister’s Lame Friends room; probably because it has the pinball machine and Pac-Man. It’s become as close to a home that Marnie will ever get in this house, so the sight of it eases the anxiety gnawing at her heart.
Delilah and Jennifer are already curled up on the couch, discussing what sounds like the pros and cons of living in the 60’s – a conversation they abruptly stop before Marnie can join in, which is probably for the best – when they enter, and they grin when they see the last of their quartet arrive. “Took you long enough, Mar,” Delilah says, tossing a Jolly Rancher into her mouth.
“I got held up at the door,” she explains, crawling onto the couch by Jennifer. “Treasure and some guys…”
Summer plops down on the other side of Delilah, releasing an annoyed grunt. “Apparently, one of those guys is her brother. Brooke asked her to bring him, and his friends. Keep in mind that Brooke doesn’t even know these guys.”
Delilah elbows her soulmate. “Stop complaining about everything, Sims, honestly. It’s one night, and your sister just wanted people here. Let her live.”
The subject is dropped after that, and the girls fall into their easy flow of conversation. Subjects change at the speed of light, the way they always do with them. At some point, they end up on the floor, limbs twined in a way that’s equally comfortable and uncomfortable. Marnie and Delilah lie side by side, their heads pillowed on Summer’s stomach and thighs, Summer’s arm tossed out to the side, Delilah fiddling with her fingers. Jennifer lies across their tangled legs, hair tickling their exposed stomach, shirts having ridden up long before. Delilah’s elbow digs into Marnie’s side, and every time Summer laughs, the entire group is shaken. But it’s comfortable, lying like this, lost in the felicity of the moment.
Marnie has no idea how much time passes before Brooke walks into the room. She glares at the group as a whole, crossing her arms over her chest in a typical pissed off little sister fashion. Having been in their lives since she was four, Brooke has more or less grown up viewing all of them as sisters. Even though Jennifer is a year younger than Brooke – a minor detail that Summer will never let her forget – they’re all kind of her big sisters. Ergo, she doesn’t have to be polite about her agitation. “You can’t hide in here forever.”
“We can, actually,” Summer points out, because it’s practically impossible to ask her not to piss her siblings off. “At least until your party ends.”
Delilah pokes her soulmate in the boob. “Her birthday, Sims.”
“But hiding out’s no fun,” someone else speaks. Treasure, Lolita, and the four boys from before all enter the room and Marnie recoils. Delilah’s hand curls around her own, the pad of her thumb rubbing over her friend’s knuckles soothingly. The boy who spoke – tall, with a wide, goofy grin, and what looks like a bruise forming on his collar bone – leans against the wall next to the Pac-Man machine. “The fun of parties is interacting with everyone.”
Summer opens her mouth to argue, but Jennifer quickly mutters, “Summer, say nothing.” The older girl obediently shuts her mouth.
Brooke rolls her eyes, shaking her head in irritation. “Whatever. I’m going back to my party.” She storms out of the room without another word. Lolita doesn’t hesitate to follow her out, and Marnie pinches Summer to keep her from spewing what she just knows will be offensive quips.
Treasure, shockingly, just sighs and makes her way into the room. She drops down next to their entanglement, sitting criss-cross by Delilah’s legs. “She’s just going to go flirt with Harry again.”
Summer scoffs. “Why do you think we’re hiding in here? It’s horrible watching the two of them together.”
One of the boys – with dark coiffed hair and dainty fingers – chuckles. “I never thought thirteen year olds could flirt that hard.”
“Welcome to my world,” Summer grins, manic and just asking for trouble. “I’m Summer. The two laying on me are Marnie and Delilah. And the tiny one laying on them–”
“I am not tiny, shut up—”
“—is Jennifer. Want to avoid Brooke’s party with us?”
Jennifer lifts a hand to swat at Summer’s hand – though that’s probably because of the tiny comment, rather than the offer – without looking. “Treasure’s her best friend, dummy. Not everyone here is terrible like you.”
“Actually, I’d rather stay in here,” Treasure speaks, leaning her weight back on her hands. “I love Brooke, but the rest of the night will be her flirting with Harry, and Lolita mooning after Sami, who I’m pretty sure is crushing on that Dani kid.”
The girls are quiet for a moment, before Delilah’s lips twitch. “Want to join the huddle?”
“This is not a huddle, it’s—”
“Marnie, hush. Treasure?”
Treasure eyes them for a second – which is understandable, seeing as they’ve never actually talked to Treasure, and the one time Marnie had, she’d been pretty rude about it – before shrugging. “Yeah, why not.” Jennifer scoots further up their legs until her head is on Delilah’s hip, and Treasure lies down next to her. “Oh, yeah – the boys. The one with the light hair is my brother, Josiah. The one by the wall is his best friend, Landon. The one with the hair is Sterling, and the one who looks like he’s ready to run is Reid.”
“Do you guys always travel in packs,” Jennifer blurts, squinting her eyes at them. “Or is it just because you’re at a thirteen year old girl’s birthday party?”
“Yes,” Landon answers unhelpfully. He walks further into the room, lying across the couch as if he owns it. Josiah rolls his eyes fondly, taking a seat in front of the couch, in the spot Treasure previously occupied. Sterling drags Reid over to the pinball machine with the fervor of someone who knows for sure they’ll win. “And you say it like we asked to be here.”
“Then why are you here,” Summer asks, with her usual lack of decorum. “I don’t even want to be here. And I live here.”
Josiah laughs freely, a sound that brings a smile to Landon’s lips. “Treasure asked,” Josiah says simply. “And I’m kind of terrible at telling her no.”
“Wherever Josiah goes, Landon follows,” Sterling informs them, laser-like focus on the game of pinball. “And Reid and I have to go, otherwise Landon might succeed in talking Josiah into doing something stupid.”
“That would never happen.”
Landon smirks at his best friend. “That’s what you think.”
“Summer, say nothing,” Marnie warns when she feels Summer take in a preparatory breath. She meets Josiah’s eyes as he throws a curios look in her direction. She gives him a timid smile. “She has a knack for sticking her foot in her mouth at any given opportunity.”
“All part of my charm,” Summer sing-songs, eliciting an eye roll from her three best friends.
Suddenly, Jennifer gasps, looking over at Treasure. “Wait, Landon Smythe?”
Treasure nods, confusion written across her face. “Yeah. Why?”
“Ronan’s big brother!”
Landon perks up at the name of his little brother. “You know Nano?”
“He’s the only person she talks to that’s actually her age,” Delilah teases, giggling when Jennifer threatens to bite her. “He’s a cute kid.”
“First of all, you’re not that much older than me, Deli, can it. And second, we are not kids!”
“Compared to us,” Reid pipes up, “you are. But that’s not a bad thing.”
“Yeah,” Sterling agrees, distractedly. “It’s adorable.”
Jennifer whines, drawing laughs from all of her companions. “Oh,” Marnie winces, putting a hand on her stomach. “Okay, let me up.”
Treasure sits up, giving Marnie a concerned look. “What’s wrong?”
Summer snickers. “She has to pee.”
Jennifer sits up, scooting away from her. “Here,” Sterling says, offering a hand to Marnie. She sits up carefully – otherwise she might actually explode – and takes his hand. He pulls her up, and the world spins. A cluster of colors bursts in her vision, all hitting her so fast that it makes her nauseous. “Hey. You good?”
She stares blankly into his eyes, blinking, then shaking herself out of it. He didn’t feel it. “I’m good,” she lies, nodding. “Except my bladder is going to do some serious damage to my insides if I don’t get to the bathroom, ASAP.”
Delilah flicks her ankle. “Then go, girl!”
Marnie sees the out that she’s been offered, and she takes it.
She spends more time than her pride will let her admit to freaking out. It isn’t that she cares so much about having a soulmate, or even about her soulmate being at least two years her senior. She isn’t too worried about that, at all. What freaks her out is that she doesn’t seem to be his soulmate. It’s not an unheard of occurrence. There are thousands of people whose soulmate links aren’t mutual. She knows that, has all of the statistics memorized, but it still freaks her out.
She has never cared about finding her soulmate, but she had always thought – she’d thought that when they finally met, it would be something amazing. It would be a new thing for both of them, and they would be mutually amazed by the kaleidoscopic colors blossoming in their vision. She had thought – foolishly, she’ll admit – that it would be like Summer and Delilah, and that her soulmate would become her best friend.
She had never banked on it being the older brother of a girl she’d never even spoken to.
Once she’s calmed down and her bladder’s been emptied, she takes a deep breath, splashing water on her face. She didn’t want much out of the soulmate connection, anyway. She doesn’t necessarily care that she found her soulmate, or even that she isn’t his. It’s perfectly reasonable for her to freak out, anyway, right? Anyone would. You’re fine, she tells herself. It’s not even that big of a deal.
When she exits the bathroom, she isn’t expecting to find Josiah standing there. “Oh,” she squeaks in surprise. “…Hi?”
Josiah – who’s blond, and has alluring green eyes – gives her a smile. “Reid.”
She blinks. “Um… what?”
“Sterling’s soulmate,” he tells her, seeming ignorant to the way her heart stops. “It’s Reid.” He tips his head to the side, eyes analyzing her. “You were wondering why he didn’t react to the touch, right?”
Marnie jerks away from him. “I—I don’t—”
“Landon,” Josiah interrupts. “He’s my soulmate.”
She waits for a second before asking, “Are you…?”
His lips spread into a melancholic smile. “We got the short ends of the stick.”
( see also: unrequited feelings. )
Marnie lets out an oomf! as her body collides with the ground. It’ll leave some nasty bruises, no doubt, but she doesn’t have the time to think about that. She scrambles to her knees, trying desperately to crawl away, gun clutched tightly in her hand.
“Oh, no, you don’t!” A strong arm folds around her waist, and she lets out a terrified shriek as it yanks her back. She tries to get away, but is held down in place. She’s helpless as her assailant straddles her hips, the barrel of his gun pressed against her forehead. He smirks, smug and unbothered, as she looks up at him, a defiant gleam in her eyes. “I win.”
Marnie raises an unimpressed eyebrow. “What? Pinning down a girl half your size is your ultimate power move?”
Sterling’s complacent smirk is replaced by a pointed look. “Way to make it sound weird.”
“You’re straddling a fifteen year old girl, Sterling. It is weird.”
“But it’s not like that,” he whines, holding up his gun. “It’s a Nerf war. Everything goes.”
Well, there’s no denying that. “You’re right,” Marnie concurs. “Which is why this isn’t cheating.”
Sterling gives her a confused look. “Why what isn’t—” An arrow dart hits the back of his head, then another, then a thicker bullet from a mega blaster hits him between the shoulder blades. While he’s reeling from the shock, Marnie lifts her own gun – a pistol – and shoots him in the forehead. She’s not strong enough to push him off of her, but she’s confident that she won this round, if the hurt look on his face is anything to go by. “Did you turn my best friends against me?”
Marnie gives him a sweet smile. “You still have Reid.”
“Had,” Landon corrects, coming down the stairs. He makes a frighteningly good sniper. Josiah steps out from the corner he’d strategically hidden himself in, crossbow propped up on his shoulder. “Nano took him out with an arrow to the heart. And Treasure’s hunting down the girls now.”
Sterling stares at them in shock for a moment before pouting. “I can’t believe you jerks teamed up. What are you going to do when you take all of us out?”
“Turn on each other,” Josiah answers, as if it should be obvious. “Have you not seen the Hunger Games?”
“Does that make you Cato or Glimmer?”
“I like to think I’m closer to Finnick than either of them.” Josiah contemplates the question. “Nano would probably be Peeta with a bow, Treasure’s Glimmer, Landon is probably Marvel. And if I had to guess…” His eyes shift down to Marnie. “That would be Cato.”
Sterling looks back at Marnie, before scrambling off of her. “The horrifying part is that you’re not wrong.” He assists Marnie to her feet, then sighs. “I’m going to go try to save the girls. If I’m lucky, Treasure hasn’t crushed them yet.”
“I’ll come with,” Landon offers, tossing an arm over Sterling’s shoulders as they disappear down the hallway.
Once alone, Marnie and Josiah exchange manic grins, and she high fives him in glee. They had come up with the idea of teaming up when Delilah had confessed to wanting nothing more than a Nerf war for her birthday. They had thought about including her in their Career pack, but to do that, they would’ve had to eject someone else, and every member was vital to their game plan. They hadn’t expected it to work so well – it’s almost five minutes into the game, and they’ve yet to suffer any hits.
“I’m Cato?” Marnie asks, incredulous but amused.
Josiah shrugs. “This was all your idea. Granted, you’re a lot smarter than Cato was, but that’s neither here nor there. And the closest they have to Katniss is Ferret, but I don’t think she’ll last to the end of the Games.”
Marnie rolls the idea around in her head for a moment, before shrugging. “Ronan’s probably going to win this, and I’m honestly okay with that.”
“Ronan? Have you seen Treasure with that Rampage?”
“Oh, she’s definitely making it to the end,” Marnie concedes. “But Ronan’s a deadshot. He can lay eyes her from any distance, and will have shot her in the head four times before she’s even lined up her shot. But she’s definitely going to take the rest of us out before she faces him off.”
Josiah nods forlornly. “Probably. We’ll just have to step up our game in the next round.”
“Change our strategy, too,” Marnie points out. “They know that we’ve teamed up now. We have to – oh my god!” Driven by pure terror, Marnie jumps into Josiah’s arms, legs wrapping high around his waist. He staggers back, having not been expecting that. “Did you see that?”
“I didn’t see anything,” the eighteen year old says, carrying her effortlessly over to the kitchen. He sets her down on the counter, giving her a confused and amused look. “What scared you so much?”
A blush colors Marnie’s cheeks, and her bottom lip juts out. “There was this bug…”
Josiah eyes her for a moment before bursting out laughing. “A bug? Really, Monkey?”
Her eyes widen slightly. “Monkey?”
“Do I really need to recount how many times you’ve climbed me in the past year?”
“Do I really need to tell you how wrong that sounds,” Treasure drawls, striding into the kitchen with a confident swing of her hips, blue gun dangling from her fingers. “And if we’re nicknaming, I’m calling it right now, Landon’s Beastie.”
Landon scoffs, rolling his eyes at her. “Okay, Monster.”
Marnie looks back to Josiah. “If I’m Monkey, then what are you?”
“Charmander,” Jennifer proposes, as the rest of them file into the room. “I think Jose would make a pretty good Charmander. And I think I will stick with Ferret, thank you.” She leans into Josiah as he presses a brotherly kiss to her forehead.
“I vote we stay completely unoriginal and call Reid Doc,” Summer offers up, elbowing the boy in question.
Reid shrugs. “I don’t care,” he bluntly states. Honestly, he doesn’t care about much at all. “I vote baby bird for Sterling.”
Sterling flounders indignantly. “No.”
Everyone else voices their agreement with Reid, which elicits a frosty silence and a pout from Sterling. (It’s just not his night.)
“Ronan can be brother bear,” Treasure suggests. “I think it fits him.”
“So the real question,” Marnie prompts, wrapping her arms around Landon’s neck as he leans his back into her. “What do we call Delilah?”
“Is defenestration legal in Ohio?”
“Defenestration isn’t legal anywhere.” Her words finally sink in, and Marnie’s forehead wrinkles as a frown forms of her face. She shifts the cell phone against her ear. “How do you even know what that word means?”
She can practically hear the indignant eye roll. “I know things, too, Marnie.” A beat. “It was in the word of the day calendar Donnie got me for Christmas last year.”
“Ah.” Last Christmas had been more of a gag year; she doesn’t think a single honest gift was exchanged amongst the group. Settling the phone between her ear and her shoulder, Marnie continues washing the dishes. It isn’t her kitchen night, but Chelsea is sick, and she’s too kind to make her ailing sister tire herself out over a few dishes and a broom. “Is there a reason you’re thinking about throwing someone out of a window?”
Summer scoffs, sharp and sarcastic. “I’m always thinking of throwing someone out of a window,” she says, and if the eleven years that they’ve been friends are anything to go by, she isn’t bluffing. “It’s just that now there’s a word for it.”
“Psychopathic,” Marnie supplies. “That’s the word you’re looking for. Defenestration is just the act.”
“Whatever,” Summer dismisses. “Hey, Monkey?”
“Yes, Sunshine?”
“How do you deal with it? With your soulmate being…”
Marnie freezes, before forcing herself to keep moving. “There’s nothing to deal with,” she maintains. “Sterling is his own person, and it isn’t as if I love him or anything. I mean, I love him, it’s—”
A noise from Summer cuts her off. “I get it. I mean, I don’t believe you for a second—” Marnie winces. It’s incredibly difficult to hide a crush from someone who’s known you for eleven years. Granted, even Josiah knows about her feelings, but Marnie actually told him. “—but I get the gist. Still. Doesn’t it, like… bother you? To see him—”
“Fawn over Reid?” Marnie finishes for her, draining the dish water. “Sometimes, I guess. He tries to be fair.” It had been damn near impossible to tell Sterling that he was her soulmate; she’d almost had a heart attack just at the prospect of having to. But Josiah – who’d only known her for a week at the time – had allowed her to hold his hand while she did so, and then hide out in his treehouse until it finally sunk in. After finding out, Sterling had promised her that even though he didn’t return the connection, he would still be the best soulmate he could be. “He answers every time I call, comes whenever I need him, and he understands why I just randomly show up at his place sometimes. I can’t get mad at him for wanting to spend time with Reid; they’re mutual soulmates.”
“And he’s in love with him.”
One foot stumbles over the other, and Marnie is almost sent sprawling to the ground. She scrambles to keep her phone by her ear, gripping it tightly. “He – what?”
Summer is quiet for a few minutes. “Nothing, babe. I sh – I don’t know why I said that, sorry. I guess I’m just projecting.”
“Projecting?” That seems like a much easier topic to delve into than who Sterling may or may not be in love with. Marnie isn’t sure that’s something she’ll ever be ready to talk about.
It’s eerily silent on the other end, and then Summer sighs. “I think Delilah has a crush on someone.”
Marnie blinks. That’s new. “She… does? Is it—”
“It’s not me,” Summer states dryly. “She always gets this feeling, like I can’t describe, but it’s never around me. When I asked about it, she started blushing and got all fidgety.”
Marnie takes some time to process this, wiping down the counters as she thinks. “Does it bother you because she’s your soulmate, or because you love her?”
“The latter,” Summer recognizes. “Maybe both? I don’t know. Taylor says I should be happy for her, regardless. It’s not my place to get possessive.”
“You told Taylor?” It isn’t entirely out of the realm of possibility, she supposes. Summer has notably matured in recent years, and has grown closer to her siblings as a result. The only friend that she’s befriended is Treasure – much to Brooke’s chagrin – but she’s less of a brat to the others. It isn’t impossible that Summer would tell Taylor about her feelings, but– “Before me?” That’s unlikely.
Summer hums. “Not really. He noticed I was upset, and kind of just figured it was Lilah. She’s pretty much the only reason I ever sulk.”
That’s not news. “So who are you throwing out of a window?”
There’s a pause, then she just imagines the smile forming on Summer’s face, sharp, beautiful, and horrifying all at once. “Whoever she likes, of course.”
“Summer, you creep.”
“I’m stealing her,” Treasure declares as she storms into Josiah’s room. Her hand clasps around Marnie’s wrist, and she tugs her out of the computer chair she’d been chilling in.
“Whoa, hey,” Josiah interrupts, sitting up in bed. “We were having a conversation, Treasure.”
The blonde whirls on her brother, eyes narrowing to slits. “You have three other best friends – who, I remind you, are your age – and you choose to hide yourself in a room with a seventeen year old girl?”
Marnie’s eyes widen, and she lets out a quiet proclamation of shock. The age differences in the group is something that they rarely speak of. None of them have anything to be ashamed of, they know. But with the boys all reaching twenty this year, and none of the girls being over seventeen – Ronan and Jennifer still at fifteen – the ragtag group is often the subject of gossip, as no one outside of the group can figure out why the ages vary so heavily within the group. None of them are ashamed of it, but they stray from the topic anyway. And Treasure is undoubtedly saying that to strike a nerve. “Hey, it’s fine,” Marnie placates, laying a hand on Treasure’s arm. “Let’s go, okay?” She throws Josiah a repentant smile. “I’ll be back.”
Treasure just lets out a low grunt, and continues to drag Marnie out of the room. The brunette is quiet as her blonde friend leads her down the hallway, to the room that she’s slept in so many times, she’s lost count. It’s hilarious to think that, just three years ago, the two had never even spoken to each other; even funnier to think that the first words exchanged between them had been the doorbell isn’t going to ring itself, genius. Though Marnie is admittedly closer to Josiah, she easily counts Treasure as one of her best friends. Even if they don’t have the same extensive history, she’s one of the girls.
Treasure closes the door behind her, and the two girls make themselves comfortable on her bed. “What’s wrong,” Marnie asks immediately. Treasure is historically irascible, but it isn’t often that she turns her wrath on her older brother. Their relationship isn’t the same as Landon and Ronan’s, but they’re rather close, as far as siblings go.
The blonde sighs, dragging a hand through her curls. Treasure is one of those people who are annoyingly beautiful. It’s not an effortless thing, make no mistake. Marnie has witnessed firsthand how long it takes Treasure to get ready in the morning. But even without the aid of cosmetics, Treasure is gorgeous. Her skin is a natural tan that makes most girls jealous after only glancing her way. Her hair is naturally curly, though she spends a significant amount of time curling them into larger ringlets when she wakes up in the morning. Her eyes are an unnatural blue that kind of just makes Marnie wants to smack her every time she sees her. Treasure turns those eyes on her, and Marnie sees a vulnerability there that she doesn’t often show. “My birthday’s coming up,” she preludes.
Marnie arches an eyebrow. “I’m aware.”
“Right. And I – I had this idea for what I wanted to do.” She nibbles on her lower lip, a nervous twitch that she’s never quite grown out of. “I wanted to have a masquerade ball. And it’s dorky, I know—”
“No,” Marnie disagrees. “I actually think that’s pretty awesome, Tre.”
Treasure beams at her, wide and grateful, before it fades. “I wanted to have it, and I talked to my parents about it. It won’t cost too much; I’ve looked over the pricing a hundred times, set a low budget, and everything. It’ll be pricey, but Josiah’s thirteenth birthday party cost almost twice as much.”
How do you even know that? Marnie very carefully does not ask that.
“And my dad is totally on board. He thinks it’s a great idea, and he’s willing to go for it. But my mom doesn’t think so. She thinks it’s too big and flashy for a sixteenth birthday. Which it’s not; if I wanted to go big and flashy, I could do much more than invite some people in dresses and masks over. But my mom is being—”
“Intransigent,” Marnie provides.
Treasure nods slowly, supposedly weighing the word. Marnie isn’t sure her friend knows what it means, but this is Marnie’s playground. If she says a word fits, it probably does. “She refuses to see reason,” Treasure continues. “I’ve gone over the pricing with her, but she swears that I’ve calculated wrong, and that this whole thing will be more trouble than it’s worth, and I hate that she won’t just listen to me.”
Marnie silently wonders why Treasure is coming to her about this. Is it because she wants Marnie to talk to her mother, or because she knows Marnie can relate? Growing up with her militant, perfectionist mother, she knows better than anyone how impossible it can be to convince someone – most of all, a parent – who refuses to listen. Treasure – who has met her mother, and has watched them go at each other’s throats – knows this.
( intransigent: adjective. unwilling to change one’s views or to agree about something; unyielding. )
Marnie swallows the vile feeling at the prospect of being used because of her acidic relationship with her mother, and gives Treasure a comforting smile, placing a hand atop of her. “I’ll go over the budgeting, okay? Your mom knows me. She knows how seriously I am about my math. We can all sit down and talk it out, and if she wants to change something, we can work it out, okay?”
Treasure relaxes, turning her hand in Marnie’s to grip it tightly. “Have I told you recently how much I love you?”
“It’s always implied,” Marnie reassures her, planting a kiss on her cheek. She steps off of the bed, stretching when both of her feet are on stable ground. “I should go back before your brother thinks I’ve dumped him for you.”
The blonde nods, oddly silent. Then, as Marnie’s leaving, she calls: “Marnie?”
The brunette turns back to look at her, hand on the doorknob.
“You…” She shakes her head, blonde locks swinging slightly. “Nevermind. Stupid question.” She gives her friend a smile, folding her hands in her lap. Something in her eyes tells Marnie that it isn’t nearly as stupid as Treasure would like her to believe, but she knows better than to push. If Treasure wanted her to know, she would’ve said. So Marnie only returns her smile, and leaves the room.
When she’s gone, Treasure’s smile drops and her shoulders sink. She drags a hand over her face. “I really hope you know what you’re doing, Marnie.”
Marnie won’t admit it to anyone, but she still isn’t all that fond of crowds. It isn’t quite as much a fear as it used to be, which is good enough for her. Less of a fear, she supposes, and more of a geared hatred. She doesn’t go out of her way to avoid them, but she usually tries to avoid situations in which she’s likely to run into them. They’re easier to handle when she’s with a friend – especially the boys; she’s a feminist, through and through, but there’s no denying the safety and comfort she feels when she has one of them pressed against her back, quietly guiding her through thick masses, their large frames concealing her entire back, towering over her just so – but never pleasant, despite.
As one might assume, Treasure’s birthday party pulls in a rather large crowd. One that, of course, she can’t avoid. Even her slight claustrophobia wouldn’t explain her missing her best friend’s sweet sixteen.
She comforts herself by staying against the wall. She swishes a glass of fruit punch – probably spiked – in her hand distractedly, her eyes roaming over the crowd. Everyone seems to be having a good time, thankfully. Treasure dances with Brooke and Lolita – they’re still friends, of course, still ruling school with an attitude that garners them a less than favorable reputation, but they don’t seem too hard pressed to change that – shining all over. She looks like royalty, Marnie notes with no shortage of amazement. This may as well be her coronation, rather than a belated birthday bash.
Summer and Delilah dance with each other, playfully (and not so playfully) grinding against each other every so often. Ronan and Jennifer dance at a much more relaxed pace, holding up steady conversation as he twirls her, oddly in rhythm with the hip-hop that plays over the loud speakers. Landon is dancing between two girls she’s never seen before, pressed tight against them, and though she highly doubts he plans on going anywhere with this, he really needs to stop leading teenagers on. Sterling pushes Reid to the dancefloor, whispering coaxing words in his ear.
Her grip on her glass tightens.
She hasn’t seen Josiah all night, but that’s hardly a surprise. He’s been avoiding her for some time, now. She doesn’t think they’ve had an actual conversation since the night Treasure pulled her into her room to talk about the birthday party. According to Summer, the siblings had gotten into some cataclysmic fight that night, and hadn’t talked to each other for a week afterwards. They had made up, of course, but Josiah’s relationship with Marina – he’d actually called her Marina – had changed. Even Sterling had noticed, and it’s rare that he notices anything that doesn’t directly involve Reid. Though that may just be her bitterness talking.
Rolling her eyes at herself, Marnie knocks back her glass of punch, and ventures over to get another glass. She’ll probably be drunk off her ass before the night is up, but it’s preferable to wallowing in self-pity.
“You look like you could use a pick me up.”
She jumps, almost dropping her glass, and turns to face an amused Sterling. “Sterling! Hi! What – weren’t you just—?”
“Summer and Delilah are with Reid,” he says, nodding to where the pre-med student is reluctantly dancing with the two girls. At some point, a slow song had started, and he takes turns spinning them around.
“So I’m your second choice,” she mutters before she can think about it. She groans, slapping a hand to her face. Her pristine white glove slides against her glittered mask, and she puts it back at her side. “I’m buzzed. Forget I said that.”
“Dance with me,” Sterling requests, instead of responding, which gives her the impression that he certainly will not forget it.
“Sterling, no, I—”
“Not because of that,” he assures her, taking her hand. She stubbornly ignores the way her heart skips a beat. “I was coming over to ask you to dance, anyway. And not because Reid is busy, either. Because I want to dance with you. Please?”
Marnie stares at him for a few notes, then sighs, setting down her empty glass. He grins, leading her out onto the dance floor. Sam Smith sings loudly and melodiously, the piano seeming to follow his lead. How will I know if you really love me, he begs, I say a prayer with every heartbeat. I fall in love whenever we meet, I’m asking you what you know about these things.
Sterling guides Marnie’s arms around his neck, then wraps his own around her waist. They sway back and forth, and she holds back a blush. She’s never been this girl. She’s never cared about soulmates, or about boys, or about anyone but her girls. It’s baffling that Sterling so easily reduces her to a blushing mess, seemingly without even knowing what he’s doing. She wonders if Reid really has no idea how he feels; wonders how Reid could possibly not return those feelings.
(Because love between soulmates isn’t necessarily pathological, or requited. The bond may be mutual, but the feelings aren’t always.)
“I’m sorry,” Sterling says suddenly, snapping her from her reverie.
Her face contorts in confusion. “What for?”
“Being a crappy soulmate,” he says simply. “And I know that our bond isn’t mutual, but I’m still your soulmate. I’m still supposed to be there for you, and I’m not there nearly as much as I should be. I know it seems like I’m always choosing Reid over you, but—”
“I get it,” Marnie states before he can continue. “He’s your soulmate, and you’re his. It would be weird if you paid more attention to me than him.” She doesn’t mention his blatantly obvious feelings. He hasn’t acknowledged them yet; she isn’t even sure if he knows about them.
Sterling shakes his head. “It’s not that. I mean, yeah, it is that. He’s my soulmate, I’m biologically engineered to always want to be with him. But it’s more than that. He’s my best friend, too. And he’s…”
Marnie raises an eyebrow.
“He’s alone,” Sterling says at last. “After his parents…” Marnie nods. She remembers the day they all realized Reid’s parents had abandoned them, and he had neglected to tell them. She remembers how hurt they’d been that he’d hidden it, how angry they’d been at his parents, how angry Sterling had been with himself for not noticing; how Landon and Reid had numerous shouting matches as a result of Reid being a secretive dick, and Landon having more secrets than he even knew what to do with. It had been a hard time for all of them, but Reid most of all. “Sometimes, I worry about him. I think that if I’m not around him enough, he’ll disappear, too. Or he’ll convince himself that we’ve all abandoned him, like they did.”
It’s actually sound reasoning, as illogical as it may seem. Reid has never been an assertive guy. He’s passive to a fault, and so rarely ever says what’s on his mind. If he is ever to be left again, he would silently sit back and let it happen, never once speaking of his pain, or even allowing himself to feel it. It would be so easy for him to convince himself that he’s being abandoned. It makes sense that Sterling would attach himself to him in the way that he has. “That’s actually kind of sweet,” Marnie confesses, smiling softly. “He’s really lucky to have you as a friend.”
Sterling smiles appreciatively, spinning her before he pulls her back in. “But in doing that, I’ve neglected you. Which has never been my intent. I’ve never wanted that. And I want to make it up to you.”
“Oh?” She feels a smile tugging at her lips. “How so?”
“Go out with me.”
The words sink in, maybe too quickly, and her smile drops. She pulls out of his embrace, and tries to stamp down on her hurt. “This was a mistake.”
“Marnie, no.” He grabs her hand, pulling her back. “I shouldn’t have worded it like that. It’s not a pity date. And it’s not a sorry date. It’s me actually wanting to go out with you, and needing an excuse to ask.”
Her jaw remains clamped shut as she stares him down. She allows him to put her hands back on his shoulders and start swaying them, but she doesn’t speak.
“I’ve wanted to ask you out for a while,” he admits. “But you’re only seventeen, and it’d look bad if I started dating you now. But I don’t want to keep waiting and end up losing you. So,” he attempts again, twirling her, and pulling her back to his chest, “when you turn eighteen, I want to take you out. If you’d let me.”
Marnie takes a few steadying breaths before she replies. “Are you asking me to wait for you?”
“Yes,” he confirms, turning her back so that they’re face to face. “You’ll be eighteen in, what, nine months? If you want to date someone in that time, I can’t stop you. But I’m asking you to remember that I asked you out first.”
Her lips twitch at the undertone of jealousy in his voice. “I doubt I’m going to start dating anyone before I turned eighteen. I haven’t dated anyone yet, have I?”
“That’s because you’re oblivious,” he says. “There are a lot of guys who want to go out with you. And they’re not going to stay quiet forever. So when they ask, remember that I, your soulmate,” he teases, “asked first, and has therefore called dibs.”
Unable to stay mad, Marnie laughs, readjusting her arms around his neck. “I’ll make a sticky note,” she promises.
Sterling grins. “That’s all I ask.”
Behind him, someone clears their throat. Marnie glances behind him to find Josiah standing there, smiling at Sterling. “Mind if I cut in?”
I found myself dreaming, the girl on stage sings, in silver and gold, like a scene from a movie.
Sterling glances back at Marnie, then smiles at Josiah with an understanding that Marnie can’t quite place. He claps his friend on the shoulder, then walks off in the direction of the refreshment table. “Careful not to get too close,” Marnie warns Josiah, an unforgiving gaze turned on him. “You might actually have to talk to me.”
Josiah winces, stepping close. “I deserved that,” he accepts, slipping his hands onto her waist. She glares at him as she connects her fingers behind his neck, allowing him to guide her in an informal waltz. “But it looks like Treasure is finally rubbing off on you.”
“I’ve known Summer since she was five,” Marnie reminds him. “I had an arsenal of sarcastic responses years before I met Treasure.”
“Granted,” he agrees. “Look, Monkey, I really am sorry for how I’ve been acting. I—”
“It’s fine,” she cuts him off, not really interested in an excuse. “You’re dancing with me, and that’s good enough.” She glances behind him to where Landon and Treasure are pressed close together, gazing adoringly at each other as they dance. “Oh.”
That every broken heart knows. We were walking on moonlight, and you pulled me close. Split second and you disappeared and then I was all alone.
“Yeah,” Josiah grunts without turning to see what she’s looking at. “Treasure has it bad for him. And he doesn’t even notice.” He doesn’t seem to notice how bad he has it for her, either, they both think, but neither of them say.
Marnie’s eyes snap back at to him. “Is that what you two fought about?”
He looks shocked that she knows about the fight, but shakes his head. “Not that. She knows how I feel about him, so she won’t try to make a move on him. And she’s underage, so he won’t make a move, either. At this point, there’s really nothing anyone can do, and no reason to be upset.”
She nods her understanding. “Then why did you two fight?”
“That’s why I’m dancing with you,” he confesses, twirling her around. “I have something I need to tell you. Tre was upset that I hadn’t told you before; she said that the longer I kept it from you, the more it would hurt you. I told her she was being ridiculous, and that you wouldn’t care, but she insisted. And, honestly, it’s kind of been wearing on me since them, and I don’t want to keep putting it off.”
I woke up in tears. With you by my side…
“You’re scaring me,” she tells him, her heart beating fast in her chest. “What do you need to tell me?”
A breath of relief, and I realized, the girl continues.
“I’m going to Europe,” he blurts, choosing to rip off the proverbial band aid. “There’s this expedition thing…” He rattles on about it, explaining the sights, and the tours, and the groups, but it all blurs together for her. She can’t hear anything over the words I’m going to Europe repeating in her head.
No, we're not promised tomorrow.
What is she going to do without him? He hasn’t been in her life for a long time, but it feels like he’s always been there. The thought of him not being there is unbearable. She never thought she would’ve become so close to the boy who’d waited outside of the bathroom, that night, to tell her that he knew what she felt. She never thought she would become so close to the boy whose sister had previously hated her. She never thought she would be closer to him than to any of the girls. But it quickly became her reality, and she’s always taken it for granted. She’s always assumed he would just be there. She thought him avoiding her was hard.
What is she going to do with him gone?
“Monkey?”
“You’re leaving?” She knows she should be happy for him, should grin and tell him all of the hot spots to visit. But it’s still sinking in that he’s going to be gone, and she’ll be here alone.
“It’s just for fifteen months.”
“Just fifteen months,” she repeats incredulously, her voice barely above a whisper. She swallows the lump rising in her throat.
So I'm gonna love you, like I'm gonna lose you. I'm gonna hold you, like I'm saying goodbye.
“Does – does Landon know?”
He hesitates. “He does.”
“And he’s… he’s okay with it?”
“He encouraged me to go,” he tells her, his voice blank.
Wherever we're standing,I won't take you for granted 'cause we'll never know when -- when we'll run out of time, so I'm gonna love you.
“Do you wish he’d told you not to go?” She asks carefully.
“I wish he’d tell me what he really feels,” he responds honestly. “I know Landon. He doesn’t do well with people leaving. I know he wants me to be happy, and he wants me to do whatever makes him happy. But I’ve always been here for him. With Hunter, and… I just don’t know if he really wants me to go.”
Marnie forces down her own feelings of how much she doesn’t want him to go. This isn’t about her. “You should go,” she advises. “Landon doesn’t want to hold you back. He won’t hold you back. And it’s just fifteen months, right? He’ll be here when you get back. We all will. You… you seem really excited,” she notes, forcing a smile to her face. “This is what you want, Josiah. And none of us are going to let you pass this up.” She thinks back to the understanding smile that Sterling had thrown his way, and realizes that she might be the last one to find out. She swallows bile, not letting her smile drop.
Like I'm gonna lose you.
Of course, he sees through it. “You don’t want me to go.”
“I do,” she lies, nodding vigorously. “I want you to go, I just… I’m really going to miss you,” she chokes out, wrapping her arms around his neck, pulling him into a tight embrace.
I'm gonna love you, like I'm gonna lose you.
Marnie pulls away from him, pushing back tears. “I need to go to the bathroom,” she excuses herself, walking away before he can stop her. She feels his eyes on her, and wills herself not to break down.
“…Marnie?” Treasure calls as she passes them. Marnie hears her excuse herself from Landon, then the telltale sound of heels clicking against the ground, racing after her. “Marnie! Marnie, hey! Slow down!”
“Not now, Treasure, please,” Marnie pleads, turning to face her friend. She hates that the mask shows her eyes, undeniably wet and reddening.
In the blink of an eye, just a whisper of smoke.
Treasure’s eyes widen at the sight of her. “Come here.” She grabs Marnie’s hand, leading her off of the dance floor, and closer to the doors. “What happened?”
“Josiah’s leaving,” Marnie says, lacking the will to lie. “He’s leaving, and I – God, I’ve been so mad at him. And – it’s your birthday, Treasure, I’m so sorry—”
You could lose everything. The truth is you never know.
Treasure shushes her, pulling her into an embrace. “My brother is an idiot,” is all she says, allowing Marnie to cry on her shoulder. “I’m so sorry, baby girl.”
( heartbreak: definition pending. )
Marnie is ninety-eight percent sure this is an intervention.
She knows she needs to stop letting Jennifer’s bambi-eyes get to her; it’s the one thing other than Ronan’s tears that can lure her into any trap, and the group isn’t afraid to exploit that weakness. They always send in one of the two youngest when they want to convince Marnie of something that they know she wouldn’t do otherwise. And it isn’t that she’s incapable of saying no, even to them; she can say no, she just has a much harder time doing it when faced with doe eyes and Ronan tears.
A combination of the two is the perfect weapon to lure her into an intervention.
By the time she’s been seated on Delilah’s bed, she’s already come up with seven ways she can escape this. Ronan is the only boy in attendance – for some reason, he’s always included in the girls’ plans, willingly or no – and even he isn’t strong enough to keep her down if she chooses to run. She could just book it to the door, but that seems rather anticlimactic, so she discredits the plan entirely.
She sighs. “What is this?”
“An intervention,” Delilah states.
“Well, obviously,” Marnie snaps, low on patience. “But why?”
“That’s why,” Summer tells her. “You’ve been grumpy as hell for weeks now, and frankly, we’re getting sick of waiting for you to calm down.”
“That’s enough,” Jennifer mumbles, nudging Summer.
“I’m fine,” Marnie mutters, looking away from them.
“No, you’re not.” Treasure shares a glance with the other girls, then takes a seat on the bed with her. She reaches for Marnie’s hands, stifling a flinch when she pulls them away. “Babe, I know Josiah leaving was hard –”
“I don’t care that he left,” Marnie bites out without hesitation. “I told him he should go.”
“Because you’re a good friend,” Ronan nods. “You would never ask him to stay behind. But you would never want him to go, either. It hurts too much.”
Marnie shakes her head, standing from the bed. “I’m not doing this.”
“Why didn’t you just tell him,” Treasure calls after her.
She resists the urge to roll her eyes, turning back to face her friends. “What are you talking about,” she asks in an irritated tone.
“Josiah. Why didn’t you just tell him you’re in love with him?”
Marnie’s eyes widen, and she hears someone mutter a low oh, shit. “What the hell are you talking about?”
Treasure doesn’t wither under her gaze. She stands confidently, her eyes ablaze in their own manner. “I’m not an idiot, Mars,” she says. “You think I didn’t notice?”
“He’s my best friend. Just because you can’t separate your feelings doesn’t mean the rest of us can’t!” She knows she’s being irrational. She knows that she’s not being fair, bringing up Landon, and she knows – maybe – that Treasure is right. But she won’t admit to it.
Treasure’s jaw tenses, but she stands strong. “This isn’t about him being your friend,” she snaps. “You think your feelings give a damn about what label you put on your relationship? You want more than a friend, but you’re too scared to go for it. Hell, you probably didn’t even realize that you wanted to until after he left!”
“Shut up,” Marnie shouts at her, silently grateful when Ronan holds her back. “You don’t know anything!”
Similarly, Delilah grabs Treasure’s hand, pulling her away from the shouting match, though it doesn’t seem to derail her in the least. “I do! I know my brother, and I know you! You realized that Sterling isn’t the only person you like, and that scares you! Now you’re scared at the thought of liking more than one person, and pissed because you realized it too late!”
“You are so full of it,” Marnie laughs, anger boiling in her veins. “I’m not you, Treasure, I don’t fall for people I know I can’t have!”
Treasure recoils, and Marnie knows she’s struck a nerve, but she feels no glee in it. When Treasure speaks again, her voice is silent but deadly. “You’re full of it,” she grits out. “You try so hard not to fall for people, because you’re so afraid of being rejected, but when you realize you can’t stop yourself, you lash out. You try to hurt everyone around you, so that no one realizes how much you’re hurting. You push away anyone who tries to help you. And your damn intransigent m—”
“My intransigence?”
“—your intransigent mindset makes you your own worst enemy,” Treasure continues. It’s probably offensive, but Marnie is surprised she remembers that word, or what it means. “You’re hurting yourself, and if you keep pushing, no one is going to help you anymore. When that happens, don’t you dare come crying back to us.”
This time, Treasure is the one who tries to storm out. No one stops her.
( 03:23 pm ) Are you okay?
( 03:24 pm) Why wouldn’t I be?
( 03:24 pm ) Don’t do that, Monkey.
( 03:25 pm ) Nano told me.
( 03:29 pm ) How much?
( 03:30 pm ) Just that you and Treasure had a fight yesterday.
( 03:31 pm ) Why?
( 03:31 pm ) No reason. I just didn’t know how much you’d heard.
( 03:31 pm ) It’s fine.
( 03:32 pm ) It’s not. I’m in Europe for one month, and you two are already at each other’s throat? What happened?
( unsent ) You left.
( 03:34 pm ) I’ve been an idiot. They were just trying to help me out, and I completely snapped. I want to apologize, but I’m too embarrassed to even call.
( 03:38 pm ) Realize that it’s Treasure you’re talking about. It’s not like she’s never done that before. All you have to do is apologize to her. She’ll forgive you for it.
( 03:40 pm ) Doesn’t make this any less embarrassing.
( 03:44 pm ) Just try. For me?
( 04:00 pm ) I’m sorry.
( 04:01 pm ) I am, too. I shouldn’t have said that stuff.
( 04:01 pm ) But you weren’t wrong.
( 04:02 pm ) I know that I love Sterling. I don’t doubt that at all.
( 04:03 pm ) And Josiah?
( 04:05 pm ) I don’t know.
( 04:07 pm ) Did you talk to her?
( 04:10 pm ) Monkey?
( 04:10 pm ) Yeah. Ronan asked me to.
( 04:12 pm ) Thank you.
( see also: tempus fugit )
It would be a blatant lie to say that the next fourteen months passed with any sort of speed. The group did everything in their power to make it pass quicker – for her, Treasure, and Landon – but the wait was unbearable, regardless of what they did.
In Josiah’s absence, a lot changed, she muses. For one thing, Treasure now had a boyfriend – and a girlfriend. Amy – her soulmate, actually – had been in her life since before he’d left, so it wouldn’t be much of a shock for him to know that. The shock would be in finding out that her ex-boyfriend, Caleb, had come back. It wasn’t shocking that the two of them had chosen to pick up where they left off. What was shocking was the toll that it was taking on her relationship with Amy. It wasn’t just Caleb that was wearing on the relationship, Marnie reminds herself. The relationship itself has too many problems of its own, with or without the aid of Caleb and his children.
Another notable thing would be that Marnie and Sterling are together now. He knows about it, of course. It isn’t something she had been able to keep herself from telling him about. Even now, she’s still reeling from the fact that Sterling chose her over Reid. She knows, rationally, that part of it has to do with Reid not even knowing about his feelings, let alone reciprocating. She still doesn’t know how Reid feels, other than that he’s not nearly as in love with Summer as he thinks.
Despite her uncertainty in their relationship – which she will never mention to Sterling – he had been faithful. The longing looks haven’t even slightly diminished, but he hasn’t done anything more than a bit of flirting. That, she doesn’t mind so much. She isn’t insecure enough to throw a fit every time he flirts with other people. Sterling isn’t the kind of guy who would cheat on anyone, least of all her. No matter how, she knows that he loves her. Far too much to ever hurt her that way. Be it with Reid or anyone else, she trusts that he’ll leave her before he even thinks to cheat.
The thing that’ll shake him the most, she thinks, isn’t her relationship or his sister’s. It isn’t how tall Ronan has gotten, or that Mister Smythe has found someone who makes him really happy. It isn’t that Summer’s little sister has gotten married, or that Jennifer now has a rapport with the cops. What will shake him the most is the one thing that she knows he doesn’t know, because no one has had the heart to tell him.
How are they supposed to tell him that Landon has met his soulmate?
The welcome back party is probably a bit much. It’s not that Josiah would mind having a party. He likes partying just as much as any of them; they all need nights of fun, every once in a while. Even Ronan enjoys the thumping music, the copious amounts of alcohol, and the dirty dancing, and he typically hates crowds. Marnie loathes crowds, and hates drunk people altogether, but partying is something she can always get behind.
This, however, is just a bit too much.
There are more people than they’d expected. The shocked look on Treasure’s face says as much, as people they probably don’t even know pour into the warehouse, clothes already disappearing. The music is louder than it has any business being, and there’s more alcohol than they know what to do with. Not to mention that someone ordered pizza and strippers, and Marnie honestly has no idea how this could not end horribly.
Most of the group members are drunk off their asses, she notes with disdain. Summer has a knack for stripping when she’s drunk, and she’s down to her shorts and a bra. Delilah either doesn’t notice, or is too drunk to complain about it. Ronan and Avia are making out under the strobe lights, more explicitly than is in either of their personalities. Landon and Penelope are putting their stripper moves to use, hips rolling and buttons opening more than is appropriate. She lost sight of the others a while ago, and can only hope that Jennifer isn’t getting roofied and whisked away by some douchebag that Landon will have to kill, leading to a horribly HTGAW scenario.
Marnie pushes her thoughts away, drinking some of her cup of whatever the hell is in the punch bowl. As far as she can tell, it’s ninety-nine percent alcohol, and one percent actual punch. She’s only had one cup, and she’s already feeling it kick in. She can see why the others have lost all sense of dignity; she’s seen each of them come back for at least two more doses. She has to bite back a smile at the thought of what comes next. Their hangovers will be a bitch.
“Why do we always find you straddling the wall?”
Her eyes slide from Treasure, who’s giving a strip tease on top of a table, to her approaching brother. “Parties aren’t my thing,” she yells over the music. “And even if they were, I want no part of this.”
Josiah winces, laughing inaudibly. “Yeah, I can’t argue with you there.” He takes the cup out of her hand, taking a long gulp of it, and leans back against the wall. “What the fuck is even in this?”
“No idea,” she shouts, taking the cup back. “But Treasure has had five cups, and Summer is about to take off her shorts. If I weren’t such a good friend, I’d be taking pictures right now.”
Josiah shakes his head fondly, a smile on his lips. It’s quiet between them for a few long minutes before he speaks again. “It’s her, isn’t it?” He glances over, chuckling at her questioning look. “Penelope. That’s her, isn’t it?”
Marnie freezes. Shit. She hadn’t thought she’d be the one to have to tell him. “Jose…”
He waves her off. “I’m not upset,” he lies, and he knows she sees through it. They know each other too well not to. “I just wasn’t expecting it. Why didn’t you tell me?”
“I didn’t know how,” she tells him honestly. “I couldn’t figure out how to tell you, and no one else could. And he wanted to. I swear, he did, but he…”
“He didn’t want to hurt me,” Josiah finishes dryly. “Of course.”
“It sounds lame,” she concedes. “I know. But you know Landon. The last thing he ever wants to do is hurt you. Even…” Even if he did fall in love while you were gone.
Josiah nods a few times, as if trying to force those words to sink in. “Sterling and Reid are together right now.” He says it nonchalantly, as if it’s just a passing mention, but she knows it’s more than that. She doesn’t know if he intended to hurt her or not. She doesn’t know if that’s ever been his intention, but it still makes her look away from him. “They won’t remember me this in the morning.”
“No,” she agrees, reaching for another cup of punch. “They won’t. Probably a good thing.”
Josiah takes the cup from her, placing it back on the table, and he pulls her into his chest. His arms wrap around her waist from behind, and he rests his chin on her shoulder. “We really did draw the short sticks, didn’t we, Monkey?”
She can only smile sadly, reaching up to rake her fingers through his hair. “Story of our lives, Charmander.”










