Top 5 locations on the map? 🏞 or maybe alternatively and less boring, top 5 worst locations on the map? :D
Why not both!? (In no particular order)
Top 5 Favorite
• Cotorra Springs/Dakota River Valley - Geothermal hot springs are gorgeous, I was convinced the ones at Cotorra were the kind that could kill you if you swam in them, but I’ve since learned they’re not lmao. Also that hugeee valley nearby that the Dakota River runs through with the grey sheer cliffs and rope bridges? I don’t think it has a proper name, it’s just vast and beautiful.
• Strawberry/Big Valley - Strawberry is my favorite town, there’s really not much here that’s useful, but design wise it is whimsical and so pretty. And how can you not like Big Valley? The flowers, big open sky, and mountains are wonderful.
• Tall Trees - I know they try to sell this place as being spooky and dangerous, but I LOVE tall trees, it’s beautiful! I love how tall the trees are (lmao) and all the animals, and the way the light filters down. Also one of my favorite areas in rdr1, I loved the snow here, chasing a bear around with a knife in tall trees remains one of my fondest memories from that game.
• Ambarino - The snow further north is gorgeous, it’s a shame there’s nothing much to do up there, with very few story missions that take place there. And the flower field? The first time I stumbled across it I was in awe.
• Roanoke Ridge - Another place they try to sell as spooky, but it reminds me a lot of the part of Missouri I used to spend my childhood summers at, so it feels so nostalgic to me. Plus one of my favorite ambient tracks plays here.
(Honorable Mentions)
• Great Plains/Heartlands - I know these two aren’t connected or close to each other, but I’m always fond of prairies.
• New Austin Desert - The remade version of this area in rdr2 is stunning and vast, it brings me a lot of nostalgia for the first game, they did a great job recreating it as it was in rdr1, while also making it feel so much bigger.
Top 5 Worst
• Bayou Nwa - I know there is beauty to this place, but the music and atmosphere just fills me with dread, also i keep tripping over gators.
• Rhodes - Everything you own is suddenly dirty and red now. So much bullshit happened here. We lost Sean here! I can’t forgive this place, even if they do have a few poodles.
• Sisika - Hell. Sometimes you just want to catch a legendary catfish and the guards on this prison island don’t like that???
• Beaver Hollow - As a camp it’s just incredibly sad and where the gang falls apart for good. Everyone is so depressed and scared, it hurts to be here. As a base for the Murfree Brood it’s just SUPER creepy.
• Elysium Pool Cave - I’m stretching a little bit here, I don’t fully hate this place, but it is pretty damn creepy. Also I hate that it’s being used to poison the Butcher Creek people, I feel so bad for them
(Dishonorable Mention)
• Annesburg - The guards here suck and everyone is suffering. This is a depressing place.
(Ask me my top 5 anything)

















