You Remember Wrong
Genre: Psychological Horror Erotic Thriller Unreliable Memory / Glitchcore Smut-Heavy Mindfuck Neo-noir Romance Paranormal Erotica, Dead Boyfriend Isn’t Dead, Or Maybe He Is, Gaslight Gatekeep Ghost Dick, Sex and Memory Collapse, Possessive Glitchboyfriend, Mirror Sex, Voicemail Moaning, Fucking Through Amnesia, Trauma-Fueled Lust, “He’s still inside you”, Is She Dead? Is He Real?, No One Knows. Especially Not You, Emotional Manipulation via Orgasm, Unreliable Narrator, Haunting as Foreplay, File://ERROR, You Died. Maybe.
SUMMARY: Every year at exactly 12:12 a.m., you receive a single text. Always from the same name. Always the same word: “Sorry.” The name? Jake. Your boyfriend. Your first love. Declared dead five years ago. You thought the case was closed. You thought you were healing. But this year, the message changes. “You remember wrong.” Reality glitches. Your reflection moves without you. He never left. And he’s not leaving now.
🔞 CONTENT TAGS / WARNINGS (Explicit): MDNI Oral Sex (M→F), Vaginal Sex, Mirror Play, Rough Sex, Creampie, Somnophilia Themes, Breathplay / Choking, Public Photo/Surveillance Kink, Voicemails Featuring Moaning, Glitching Reality / Horror, Forced Arousal via Haunting, Intense Psychological Themes, Unclear Consent in Dream/Memory Sequences, Body Memory / Amnesia, Blood Mention, Flashbacks to Sex and Grief, Possessive Behavior, Distorted Perception, Delusions of Love, Self-Pleasure Induced by Haunting, Manipulation via Pleasure, Mentions of Death, Fire, Identity Erasure, YOU DIED. (Maybe.)
Pairing! Sim Jaeyun | Jake (Enhypen) × Female Reader
Word Count: 3377
🗂🕯️ Permanent Taglist:
⟡ @tashmonellloveskpopboybands,⟡ @yuriloveshee, ⟡ @kookiesnkim, ⟡ @picklemafia, ⟡ @add-this-to-that, ⟡ @xxjoyridingxx,⟡ @enjakey, ⟡ @noidnoentry, ⟡ @avadie, ⟡ @enhaheart8, ⟡ @yourislandgirl, ⟡ @meowwwon, ⟡ @saodk ⟡ @inlovewithparkjisung, ⟡ @verycutesyverymindful, ⟡ @fleurdelises, ⟡ @queenvash, ⟡ @tyongielee, ⟡ @amzingjellyfish,⟡ @enbplvr, ⟡ @6abriellaa, ⟡ @fateismoonstruck, ⟡ @trashlord-007, ⟡ @artemesiareads, ⟡ @d0einheadlights, ⟡ @miuuuw, ⟡ @butwhyareyoureyessosad, ⟡ @rainofcrime, ⟡ @darkblueblueberr, ⟡ @zone444girls, ⟡ @bombombakudanmeow, ⟡ @en-cityy, ⟡ @koya2000, ⟡ @tttbearblog, ⟡ @yb763, ⟡ @freakseung2001 ⟡ @nics-fxy, ⟡ @irers
Your apartment is quiet. Too quiet. The kind of quiet that shouldn’t exist in a city that never fucking sleeps.
It’s not just silence, it’s a void.
You’re half-asleep on the couch, remote still clutched in your hand, your phone balanced on your chest. A candle flickers out in the kitchen. You don’t remember lighting it.
Then the phone buzzes.
You jolt, eyes unfocused as the screen lights your skin. One notification. One word. One name.
It starts the same way it always does. Phone buzzes. Screen lights up. 12:12 a.m. You don’t need to look at the name. You already know.
1 new message from: Jake
Your chest contracts. Your breath stalls. Your fingers twitch. The first year, it said "Sorry." The second, third, and fourth did too. A single word. Unchanging. Like a ghost with manners.
But tonight, tonight, it’s different.
No. This time, it’s you who’s the problem.
You sit up. Every hair on your arm stands. Because… he’s dead.
Jake’s dead. He’s been dead for five years. Found dead, stabbed, burned, unidentifiable. The authorities ruled it a home invasion. But something never sat right. Declared gone at exactly 12:12 a.m. the time carved into every death certificate, every news report, every echo of your memory.
You remember wrong.
You stare. Not at the message. At the room. Like something's about to shift. Crack. Like the floorboards might peel back and spill blood. You’re alone. Of course you’re alone.
Except…
The bathroom door is open. You always leave it closed. The faucet’s dripping. You haven’t used it all night. You back away slowly.
You pull yourself off the couch like the air’s thickened. Something’s wrong. The temperature’s dropped. Your reflection in the mirror across the room looks… too still. Like it’s not moving when you do.
You blink. It blinks back. And then. Your legs brush the edge of your bed. You sit down without meaning to. Hands trembling.
You hear it.
A clink. Metal against ceramic. From the kitchen.
You whisper it before you can stop yourself. “Jake?” The light above you flickers. Just once. A joke, maybe. A coincidence. Except you don’t believe in those anymore.
You haven’t said his name out loud in almost two years. You forgot how it tasted. Bitter. Familiar. Like copper and old perfume.
Your phone buzzes again.
Don’t say it again.
You flinch. You’re not alone. You don’t know how you know. But you know. The air shifts. Thickens. Warms. You feel something press against your shoulder, then nothing.
You turn. No one. Except your bedroom mirror. Fogged over. Like someone breathed against it. Like someone’s still breathing.
Your body moves before your brain does. You stumble to the mirror.
The words smear across the glass like fingerprints. "Shh." And behind your own reflection, someone stands.
Close. Too close. Fingertips graze your waist. Cold. Familiar.
You take a few steps back. Head to the kitchen for water and a sleep pill. You step forward slowly, heart hammering in your chest. There’s a knife on the counter. The same one that went missing last week. The same one from the police report five years ago, missing weapon, presumed disposed.
It’s back. Dripping something dark. Like it was just used.
You take one step back. And then—
A hand wraps around your waist. Familiar. Warm. Firm.
Another hand covers your mouth. You try to scream but it’s breathless, like your lungs forgot how. And then you hear him.
That voice. That fucking voice. Right by your ear. A low whisper, like silk sliding over a wound.
“Shh.” “You talk too much when I’m home.”
You jerk forward but the grip doesn’t loosen. His lips brush your jaw, lazy. Fond. Possessive.
“You weren’t supposed to ask.” “You were supposed to miss me.” You twist around. And you see him. Sim Jaeyun.
Alive.
Or at least, something that looks like him. Hair slightly longer. Skin paler. Eyes… glitched. Like a skipped frame in a movie reel. Too real. Not real enough. Both.
He smiles. And your body betrays you.
You feel wetness between your legs. Because your body remembers. Even if you don’t.
You back up. Your voice breaks: “Are you—?”
He’s already shaking his head. “You remember wrong.”
You wake up on the floor.
Hardwood against your cheek. Cold sweat on your spine. The clock on your microwave says 4:43 a.m.
The knife’s gone. The fogged-up mirror is dry. The message from Jake, deleted. And your phone? Powered off. You don’t remember turning it off.
Your throat feels raw. Your lips are bruised. Your thighs are sore.
You pull your sleep shirt down over your ass as you stand, shaky, like your body’s been used. Touched. Fucked. Like the ghost of a man fucked you open and made you forget your own name.
You try to shake it off. Go to the bathroom. Turn on the light— It flickers. No surprise. You lean over the sink. There’s blood beneath your fingernails.
By noon, you’re sitting at your desk with four tabs open: Jake’s police file An archived news report The coroner’s statement The funeral guest list
Every link says the same thing: Jake died. Five years ago. Time of death? 12:12 a.m. No body ever confirmed. Closed casket. The fire burned his face. They ruled it a match using dental records. That’s what you remember.
Except one file doesn’t open. Jake’s identity archive. The system returns a red blinking message.
FILE://ERROR – IDENTITY MISMATCH. SOURCE UNSTABLE.
You stare. The file isn’t corrupted. You are.
You hear your phone vibrate from the kitchen.
One new voicemail. Timestamped at 2:47 a.m. While you were… unconscious? Dreaming? Coming?
You press play.
You expect static. Garbled signals. You get moaning. Your moaning.
Panting, whispering something over and over. Begging.
“Jake, please, just tell me—” A wet sound. Fingers. Something deeper. Your voice breaks. “What are you, what are you doing to me?” “I’m making you forget.” Click. End of voicemail. You drop the phone.
You curl up on the floor of your apartment like it’ll help you hold shape. Your hand drifts down.
It’s not a choice. It’s instinct.
You’re soaked. You slide a hand under your shorts, two fingers curling in like they’ve been taught. Like someone trained them.
You gasp. The memory floods back, his teeth on your shoulder. His voice in your ear. “I know how to make you come harder than truth.”
The orgasm hits before you’re ready. Violent. Full-body. You come shaking, biting your hand to keep from sobbing.
And just as you blink your eyes open, he’s standing in the doorway.
Not a sound. Not a footstep.
He’s just… there. Leaning against the frame. T-shirt half untucked. Hair wet. Eyes on your fingers.
Jake.
Still not dead. Still not explaining. Just watching you unravel.
You try to speak. Your mouth opens. He raises a finger to his lips again.
“Don’t ask.” “Just come here.”
You wake up naked.
Sheets tangled between your legs. Mouth dry. Skin damp. A bruise blooming on the inside of your thigh in the shape of a hand you know too well. Jake is gone. Again. But he always leaves reminders.
The scent of him on your pillow. The ache in your cunt like you were kept up all night. The slick that clings to your inner thighs, cooling.
You try to clench your legs, flinch. It hurts. God, it hurts. Like you came over and over and forgot how to stop.
Your phone buzzes. You drag yourself to the edge of the bed, grab it with trembling fingers.
Unknown Number
1 New Photo 1 New Voicemail
You don’t open the voicemail. Not yet. Your eyes land on the photo first.
You. And Jake. Laughing. Holding hands. Drinking coffee. Last week.
Date stamped. Geotagged. Smiling.
You drop the phone. Because you don’t remember that moment. You didn’t go out last week. You barely left the apartment.
You haven’t smiled like that since—
That night, he comes back. Doesn't say a word, moves up to your room.
You follow him.
You don’t remember standing. You don’t remember moving. But suddenly, you’re in the hallway, feet bare, heart in your throat, the floorboards creaking like they're holding secrets.
Jake doesn’t look back. He doesn’t have to. You’d follow him off a rooftop right now, and he knows it.
He pushes the door open to your bedroom. Except—
It’s not your bedroom. It’s cleaner. Too clean. Sterile. Like a memory of a bedroom. Your furniture, your sheets, but wrong.
The scent hits first. Jake’s cologne. Faint. Faded. Like he’s been here this whole time, bleeding into the walls. Your knees wobble.
He doesn’t speak. Just sits at the edge of your bed. Legs spread. Elbows on his knees.
And that smile. The one that used to mean “Come here and let me wreck you.” The one that made you soft when you were supposed to stay angry.
It’s back. But colder. Hungrier.
You open your mouth, he raises a hand. Stops you with one look. “I’m not here to explain.” “I’m here to remind you.”
He pulls you by the wrist. You stumble, fall into him, straddle his lap without meaning to.
Your shirt rides up. He palms your hips like you’re his. Like he never died. Like you never forgot how good this felt.
He kisses you like punishment. Like silence. Like you’re not supposed to speak, only break.
Your mouth tastes like grief and heat and déjà vu. You don’t even notice when he lifts you, lays you down, crawls between your thighs. Because your head tilts.
And then you see it. The mirror.
Across the room. The full-length one you never liked. The one you threw a blanket over after he died. It’s uncovered.
You see yourself. On your back. Legs around his waist.
But something’s wrong.
The reflection smiles first. Not you.
Your reflection is moaning before you even feel his cock push inside. Grabbing his shoulders. Tilting your head.
You’re still gasping, still catching up. But the girl in the mirror is already cumming.
Already his. He fucks you slowly. Like he’s memorizing you again. Like he’s carving something into your bones that won’t leave, even after death.
“This is the version of you I like best,” he murmurs. “You never talk during sex. Just beg.”
You want to ask where he’s been. Why no one remembers. Why you’re unraveling. But your mouth won’t work. He’s thrusting too deep. Your voice has become sound, not sense.
The reflection lifts her head. She watches you. Smiling, dazed.
She whispers something you can’t hear— But Jake can. Because he leans down and repeats it into your throat. “You’re mine. You’ve always been mine.”
You cum when his hand closes over your throat. Tears slipping from your eyes, not from pain. From remembering. Everything. Or nothing.
And just before you pass out. The reflection mouths something new. “Don’t wake up.”
You wake up naked.
The knock at your door is too normal. It jars. You tug on a hoodie. Nothing underneath. Still wet. The air stings between your legs. You’re leaking. You open the door a crack.
It’s your neighbor. The old woman from 5B.
She frowns. Takes a step back like she’s seen a ghost. “I thought… sorry, I didn’t think anyone lived here anymore.” “Weren’t you the girl whose boyfriend—”
She stops.
“No, that’s not right. You moved out. Five years ago.” “After the fire.”
She leaves before you can speak. Your lungs seize.
You slam the door shut. Collapse against it.
You're not real. Or maybe reality isn’t.
You crawl back to the bed. The sheets are cold. The mirror across the room is cracked. The voicemail still waits. You hit play. Jake’s voice.
“You're tighter when you’re scared.” “When you don’t understand what I am.” “But your body does, doesn’t it?”
There’s a wet sound. Slapping. Breathing. Your voice. “Jake—please, I can’t—” “You can. You always could.” “I’m the only thing that ever felt real.”
You hear him groan. “Say my name.”
Your voice on the recording sobs it. Moans it. Over and over. Crying it into the crook of his neck. Begging for more.
“Say you’re mine.” “Say it, or I’ll fuck you until you forget your name again.”
You say it. On the tape. Desperate. Shattered.
“I’m yours, Jake—fuck—yours—” He laughs. Low. Ruined.
“Good girl.” You drop the phone again.
You don’t remember the night. But your body does. You’re sore, raw, dripping down your thighs like the proof of possession.
You crawl onto the bed again. Still open. Still warm.
And you feel it, Not just slick but him. Like he’s still inside you. Like he never left.
You reach down.
Two fingers. Wet. Warm.
You fuck yourself with the rhythm he used last night. And in the mirror, you see Jake.
Behind you. No expression. Hands on your hips. Watching. But when you spin around? Nothing.
The email from the archives comes at 3:03 a.m. Just two lines:
REQUEST DENIED. SUBJECT: Y/N [REDACTED] – STATUS: DECEASED.
You blink at the screen. Your name, blacked out. Birth certificate: not found. Hospital file: error. Death record: processed.
You’re not dead. You’re not.
You touch your own pulse just to check. And your fingers come away sticky. Slick.
You’re wet again. Still. There wasn't a time you weren't, with his breath hitting you constantly.
A knock at the door. Not tentative. Not curious. Confident. Like someone who knows you’ll answer.
You grab your robe, still braless, panties nonexistent. Because nothing stays on you these days. Jake makes sure of it.
You open the door. And there he is.
Bare-chested. Black sweats. No shoes. Neck glistening with sweat like he ran here. Or maybe… like he came. His eyes flick over you.
The robe barely clings to your shoulders. His gaze drops between your thighs.
“You’re leaking again.” “Let me fix that.” You don’t speak.
Because your body’s already moving. Letting him in. Locking the door. He doesn’t waste time.
Pushes you against the kitchen counter. Hands under your robe. No patience. You gasp when his fingers slide in—two, immediately. Like he owns the place. Like he’s coming home.
“Still this wet?” he whispers, mouth on your throat. “Even when I’m not around?”
You try to lie. Try to say it’s from the dream, the tape, the memory.
But he curls his fingers inside you just right. Finds that spot. And you choke. He smirks.
“Thought so.” He flips you over the counter.
No warning. Your robe’s yanked open, tits pressed against cold granite. One hand between your shoulders, the other already freeing his cock. You look back. And fuck.
He’s hard. Thick. Mean-looking. The kind of cock you don’t forget, even if reality begs you to.
“Say it,” he growls. “Say what you are.” You hesitate. He doesn’t. He slams in. One thrust. Bottoms out.
You scream, choked, sudden, fucked full.
“Say it.” You sob. “I’m yours.” “Jake, I’m yours—”His hips snap forward, fast, brutal. Your nails scratch the countertop.
“Louder.” “Let the walls remember too.”
You say it. You cry it. You mean it.
Because he’s fucking you like he wants to leave a blueprint inside. Like when you’re gone, your cunt will still remember. You cum hard. On his cock. Around it. Slick splattering down your thighs, onto the floor.
He doesn’t stop.
“That’s it.” “Stay broken.” “Stay mine.”
He pulls out just enough, then slams back in. You feel it in your teeth.
And just before you black out— You hear it again. The mirror. A whisper from across the room. Soft. Feminine. You. “Don’t wake up.”
But you don't, you never fall asleep. The room is quiet after he cums.
He doesn’t pull out. Just stays pressed deep inside, breath tickling your neck, his palm cradling your jaw like you’re made of glass.
You’re shaking. He presses a kiss to your shoulder.
Soft. Nothing like before. No thrust. No demand. Just lips.
“You used to cry when I touched you.” “The first time, remember?”
You don’t.
But your body clenches around him like you do.
FLASH.
You’re nineteen. Jake’s apartment. Messy sheets, your first real boyfriend, his trembling fingers between your thighs.
He’s saying, “Tell me if it hurts.” You’re whispering, “Don’t stop.”
Your legs shake when you cum. You cry into his neck. He holds you like it’s sacred. Back in the present, he fucks you slow again. Almost gentle.
“You were so good for me,” he murmurs. “So fucking sweet. Always so wet. Always mine.” Your eyes sting. You don’t want to cry. You don’t know if this is memory or manipulation.
But he leans in. Kisses your lips, soft. Careful. Real.
“You still are.”
You’re riding him now. Hands on his chest. Your thighs sore. The mirror behind him cracked. Still watching.
You roll your hips. Slow. Needy. And Jake? He’s smiling.
Not that twisted grin. A real smile. “That’s it, baby. Just like that.” “Let me see you. Let me remember.” Your walls clench.
You moan. Loud. Unfiltered. And Jake, his hands shake when he grabs your hips. “You’re my favorite version.” You whimper: “Which one am I?”
He doesn’t answer. Just thrusts up, deep, perfect.
And you come.
FLASH. A picnic. Sunlight. Jake handing you strawberries. Telling you your laugh is his favorite sound.
You laugh now. But it’s hollow. You collapse against him.
He wraps you in a blanket. Cradles your head. Hums. “You used to cry when I touched you.” “But now you forget.” “And when you forget, you let me touch you again.” You fall asleep like that.
Still inside him. Still unsure. Still his.
It starts with a letter. On your pillow. Folded once. No envelope. Your name in blue ink. You recognize the handwriting. Yours.
The signature, though, is Jake’s. “You used to write me letters when you were angry. You said it was easier than screaming. You only screamed when I left. I didn’t leave. You did.”
The paper smells like old perfume. Yours. Or his. You’re not sure anymore.
“You begged me to come back. So I did. I made a home in the only place you’d never look again. Inside your own memory.”
The voicemail comes two minutes later. You play it. Your mother’s voice. Shaky. Frayed. Real. “Sweetie, I—I don’t know why you keep saying his name. You always did this, remember? Imaginary friends. But Jake, Jake never existed. We thought it stopped after the… after the accident.”
“You died. Honey, you died. You weren’t supposed to come back.”
She’s crying.
“Why are you calling me from this number? Whose phone is this?Please stop. Just let it rest.”
The world goes quiet.
The room doesn’t feel cold. It feels… gone. Like the lights are on in a house that was never built. You walk to the window.
And across the street. You see it.
Your funeral. A closed casket. Mourning clothes. Black umbrellas under white sun. Your mother on her knees in front of the altar. Sobbing. The same woman who left the voicemail. Only now it’s hours later.
But you’re not there. You’re somewhere else.
The kitchen smells like eggs and citrus.
Jake stands at the stove. Barefoot. Sweats hanging low. Soft music playing from an old radio that never worked.
He looks up. “Morning.” “You look pale.” “You dreamed again, didn’t you?”
You sit down. There’s orange juice in your cup before you speak. “Jake…”
He slides the eggs onto your plate. Kisses your forehead. “I’m yours. You made me that way.” “I can’t leave anymore.”
You blink. He smiles. “Eat, baby. It’s a long life. And we’re the only ones who remember it.”
In the mirror behind him, you’re smiling.
But you’re not eating. Your reflection tilts its head. Blood drips down its nose. You wipe yours. Nothing. Jake sits across from you. Reaches for your hand. And you don’t ask if he’s real.
You just whisper: “Will you stay?” He doesn’t blink. “I never left.”
Outside, the funeral ends. They bury the casket. The wind carries a single name from your mother’s lips:
“Please. Come back.”
But you’re already home. You always have been.
The End You remember wrong.
masterlist