Chubby!Reader Specific Reads | Fic Rec List
Just me compiling yet another list, but this time consisting of all the comfort fics for us chubby girlies! Below is a list of fics that I reread consistently and itch this lil niche in my brain. These are written by some of the most talented writers I've come across, so be sure to spread the love and go through their masterlists if you get the chance!
And if you’ve got recommendations? You already know I’m all ears.
Massive shoutout to @cafekitsune for the insane number of dividers I'm obsessed with.
Key: A - Angst | F - Fluff | S - Smut | C - Comfort | HC - Hurt/Comfort
Clark Kent | Superman 2025:
> Just the Right Fit by @onlyasteelmancanbealover
Tags: One Shot, Smallville!Clark, 2nd POV, F + C Word Count: 2k Description: Clark thinks you’d look cute in any mass-produced Halloween costume… even if it’s too tight.
> 'Cuz I'm A Punkrocker (Yes I Am) by @/onlyasteelmancanbealover
Tags: One Shot, Smallville!Clark, Alt/Emo Reader, 2nd POV, A + HC Word Count: 3.8k Description: There’s a certain strength that has to come with being even the least bit different. It seems like you can’t be anything but exactly like everyone else these days. But you do your best to be a person you’re proud of, and Clark thinks that you are totally punk rock for that. Almost as punk as you are perfect.
> Fallen Angel by @/onlyasteelmancanbealover
Tags: One Shot, Smallville!Clark, Chubby!Reader, 2nd POV, F + HC Word Count: 11.1k Description: Clark had lost all hope that he’d find love someday. until you fell out of the sky… literally.
> The Perfect Girlfriend by @/onlyasteelmancanbealover
Tags: One Shot, Smallville!Clark, 2nd POV, C + F Word Count: 3k Description: Coming from a lifetime of being single, you have quite the fear of losing things when they’re just starting to feel like you have them. So when it comes to Clark, you cannot allow yourself to fuck it up. What do you do when you have the perfect boyfriend? You become the perfect girlfriend, of course.
> The Odd Couple by @/onlyasteelmancanbealover
Tags: 18+, MDNI, Smallville!Clark, One Shot, 2nd POV, F + S Word Count: 3.5k Description: Nobody expects the frat boy and the chubby, nerdy girl to ever look in each other’s direction. But who cares what people expect?
> I Guess It's Just The Woman in You/That Brings Out The Man in Me by @/onlyasteelmancanbealover
Tags: 18+, MDNI, Smallville!Clark, Chubby!Reader, One Shot, F + S Word Count: 6.8k Description: You’re finally ready for your first time, and Clark is just about prepared to move heaven and earth over it.
> My Constant by @/onlyasteelmancanbealover
Tags: One Shot, Chubby!Reader, Smallville!Clark, F Word Count: 8.7k Description: Clark lucks out with a best friend who loves comics. Talk about universal irony.
> See Me Like You Do by @cursedheartsclub
Tags: 18+, MDNI, One Shot, 2nd POV, A + HC + S Word Count: 5.6k Description: "Could you write something about chubby fem reader and Clark, pls? They work together, and the reader has a huge crush on him, but is so insecure (maybe cos of her mom constantly bringing up her weight if ur comfortable writing some family dynamic angst), and fails to notice he’s in love with her because of that?"
> Happiest Girl in the World by @sapphichotmess
Tags: One Shot, 2nd POV, A + F + HC Word Count: 5.1k Description: Angst (miscommunication, bad thoughts about self/body) fluff, soft, Clark is a yearning man and so obsessed with you, oblivious reader, mutual pining, smut.
> Caught in L-O-V-E by @alwritey-aphrodite
Tags: One Shot, 2nd POV, C Word Count: 1.1k Description: Chubby reader and Clark, where reader gets injured and Clark takes care of her.
> Clark Kent x Reader by @freiys-fics
Tags: One Shot, Chubby!Reader, 2nd POV, F Word Count: 711 Description: Clark x chubby, insecure reader, because my writing is nothing if not self-indulgent. This can be triggering for you if you struggle with disordered eating or body image issues, so please feel free to scroll past this if either of those affects you!!!
Frankie Morales | Triple Frontier:
> Real Love, Baby (Frankie Morales) by @guess-my-next-obsession
Tags: One Shot, 2nd POV, A + C Word Count: 1.3k Description: Talks of body image issues/insecurities/maybe a kiss of inner angst.
> Second Best (Frankie Morales) by @beezusvreeland
Tags: One Shot, 2nd POV, A Word Count: 2.4k Description: Frankie is put on the spot by the guys, who want to know if he would date you or not. He feels bad about his answer, but not as bad when he hears yours.
> Frankie Morales x Reader by @berryispunk
Tags: Series, 2nd POV, A + F + C Word Count: 9.4k Description: You swiped right on a man in a baseball cap and somehow found the kind of warmth you stopped believing in.
> Altitude and Ache (Frankie Morales) by @/berryispunk
Tags: Series, 2nd POV, A + F + C Word Count: 380
> More Than Enough by @/berryispunk
Tags: 18+, MDNI, One Shot, 2nd POV, HC + S Word Count: 4.7k Description: You were used to being too much. Until the one man who knew you best showed you you never were.
> Wingman by @tateypots
Tags: 18+, MDNI, Series, 2nd POV, A + HC + F + S Chapter Count: Pt. 1 | Pt. 2 Description: You meet Frankie at the bar and think he’s perfect. Shame he’s only talking to you because his friend is interested in yours.
Jack Abbot | The Pitt:
> From The Start (Jack Abbot) by @fromsil
Tags: 18+, MDNI, One Shot, 2nd POV, A + HC + S Word Count: 16.1k Description: Ending up at the Pittsburgh trauma medical centre should have been a delight—so many familiar faces and some of the best doctors you knew. But it was also the very hospital where your ex-husband worked. As you waited for results, time passed, getting you closer to the night shift. The dread of seeing him pulled you down memory lane, and every step felt heavier than the last.
> Little Secret (Jack Abbot) by @/fromsil
Tags: One Shot, 2nd POV, A + HC Word Count: 3.1k Description: Trips to the emergency room landed you in the path of none other than Doctor Jack Abbot, and maybe it was just fate trying to push things along a little faster.
> The Terrible Date (Jack Abbot) by @/fromsil
Tags: One Shot, Chubby!Reader, F + C Word Count: 5.5k Description: A terrible date, on your evening off, ends you up at the emergency service in a bad state. the very same emergency service you work at.
Miscellaneous:
> Watch Me (Frank Castle) by @nohugsallowed
Tags: 18+, MDNI, One Shot, Chubby!Reader, 2nd POV, HC + S Word Count: 1.4k Description: You start thinking bad about your body so Frank has to teach you that no body talks bad about his girl
> Chubby Fem!Reader by @letstalkaboutfandomsbaby
Tags: Drabble, 2nd POV, F Word Count: 331 Description: Chubby fem!Reader and an absolute besotted man —just the right way to make me MELT.