This show is just a mess. I find myself having multiple theories, because none of the writers can make up their minds as to which direction they want to take. They had one of the best storyline’s of that summer and they could have turned this show into one of the greatest mysteries in television, but Marlene just doesn’t know how to run a real show. She’s spoiled things for us, lied to us, changed great storylines at the last minute simply because we caught on to her, because our theories were right and she can’t have that. If we guess the show, she has no shock value.
So many questions will go unanswered, and I don’t care how small the question may be. If everything happens on this show for a reason, there needs to be no loose ends left come Tuesday night when the credits roll.
I want to know everything from what Bethany Young looked like, to what really happened with Aria that summer, to the mysterious body in the barrel.
Nothing makes sense, even answered questions make zero sense. How could Lucas and Charles have been friends, but he not know that Charles was transgender? I know they emailed, but I just don’t believe this.
I don’t believe the trans storyline anyway. I think the real Charles is Wren. I always have. I think Charlotte just covered up for Wren so he could keep the game going. Family makes sacrifices for family. I think Wren will be AD and it will be revealed that Wren is Charles. I think Cece being Bethany would be a cool twist and the girl Melissa killed being the real Sarah Harvey, and Sarah we know is just a random runaway using the identity. There is just too much to chose from. I’m glad the show is ending.
------ Submission I'm definitely with you about CeCe's story not being the truth. And I have also thought about the idea that Sara Harvey maybe wasn't the real Sara Harvey. There was a lot about her homecoming situation that didn't make sense. You're exactly right. There are too many options. It's exhausting.











