Umm hi. I've been reading the httyd books (currently on the 11th) and I was wondering if you knew why they changed hiccup's appearance in the movie. I mean, sure, they made it to make him seem older, but what's with the change from red hair to brown, and from blue eyes to green? Maybe I'm just being paranoid and there's probably not much reason, but yeah.. I just wanted to ask.hehe
Freya. I wish I fully knew.
After all, one time I got bored and made very quick photoshop edits to correct those minor design issues, and DreamWorks Hiccup looks TOTALLY FINE with red hair and blue eyes. And that’s how his design began, if not how it ended. In my opinion, the changes in his appearance in this area are unnecessary.
I mean doesn’t he look fine like this?
The closest explanation we can get regarding Hiccup’s design changes comes from “The Art of How to Train Your Dragon,” where Simon Otto explains, “It was important to make Hiccup a normal kid who would not stand out in our modern world.” Another feature of his appearance described in this book is that “his final build and look is not as stylized as the other young characters in the film, which was a means to help the audience connect with him.”
As horrifically stupid as this sounds, and as much as I cringe to throw out this wild conjecture, perhaps that means movie!Hiccup being a ginger would have made him “stick out too much” and thus not be as visually empathetic and “normal” to audience members. Orange hair is a rare-ish hair color, after all. Ugh. That’s the best - though horrifically shaky - explanation I can come up with. And I don’t like it one bit, because redheads shouldn’t be all that weird, and I don’t think red hair would disconnect him all that much from how the art book and Simon Otto describe his design.
So basically I don’t know. I wish I knew. I often wish he were still a ginger. But hey. He’s got a great character design either way, and besides his hair length, hair color, and eye color, movie!Hiccup is pretty close to what we see in the books. And he looks great.
Perhaps better questions would be why they were so drastic altering other characters’ appearances… for while Fishlegs’ design change might be explanatory in some areas, I have no idea what was going on with Tuffnut. Where’s the close-cropped hair and ear piercing?