☠: A popular fanon headcanon about my character that bugs me.
SEND ME A SYMBOL AND I WILL TELL YOU
Her death is just fanon, okay?
but seriously, this fandom is small and Etain doesn’t seem to be one of its most popular characters, so I don’t think I see a lot of fanon considering her. Actually, I’m not sure I see any that comes from outside our RP group…
That said, I will fight certain people for the way they tend to characterize Etain and her canon actions.
Like, yes she has moments where she is alternatively stupid, selfish, or naive. But that is not the sum of her character, and some people treat her really harshly for
not being Bardan, basically
doing the same things that they praise Kal for
choosing to sacrifice herself for another person, which is apparently “stupid” or “selfish” because she’s a female character who happens to be married and have a child (I have seen this and it made me LIVID)
being a young woman in an incredibly vulnerable position who doesn’t entirely know how to handle it
Like, they reduce her to this self-absorbed, thoughtless (sometimes promiscuous, for which we have KT to thank for all the completely unnecessary lines) caricature obsessed with her supposed self-righteousness, when instead what we have is a vulnerable young adult in love whose entire world has been turned upside down, has no healthy emotional training and no real support system, and who is doing her best to make decisions when her entire morality system has been upended.
On a, uh, less vehement note, there also seems to be this perception that if she’d lived she would have turned her back entirely on the Jedi and her sense of herself as a Jedi, and I just really disagree with that? Like, I think some people are mixing her up with Bardan, or with KT’s authorial stance, bc we see her carrying that conflict between disillusionment and the Jedi values and self-identity she was raised with in every book. She literally dies bc of that conflict.