"So... about last night." Katniss & Peeta //after Snow forced them. Yes, I’m mean. Oops?
Guilt.
It came as a ringing in his ears, a cold rush of blood through his body.
This wasn't how he had wanted this to go, not at all. But how could he have said "no"?
Even now, in the wee hours of the morning after, Peeta felt wide awake in a frightful way. Nightmares from the arena still plagued him, of course, but it wasn't that keeping him awake this time. It was remorse. And love. The fact that he had had Katniss in a way he had, until last night, only dreamed of. But it was a tainted act. Something done not out of spontaneity, not out of adoration or even of choice. It was part of a performance, just like the rest of their relationship had been. And it had been for the viewing pleasure of a sick, twisted, old man who wanted to be sure they were as in love as they claimed to be.
The thought that he had likely watched every moment of it made Peeta want to throw up. Worse was the question of if Snow had been the only one viewing their most intimate moment. After all, weren't they now just some spectacle for the capital? They'd never be free of it. Never.
The kitchen was quiet and Peeta's hands, his apron, were covered in a thick layer of flour. He had already prepped two loaves of bread (on their second proof, a half hour or so still from being tossed into the oven) and was currently working on finishing up a carefully crafted dozen cheese buns. He made his way to the sink to rinse the flour from his palms, pretending that he didn't hear Katniss walk in (and pretending, also, that his heart didn't sink at the sound of her footsteps).
Did she hate him now? She almost definitely felt as used as he did. As embarrassed. As humiliated and degraded and disgusted. But she didn't love him the way he loved her and he wondered if that made this whole situation harder to stomach or easier.
She stayed quiet for a few moments longer and Peeta didn't dare to say anything, either. Instead, he focused on whisking his egg yolks, brushing them atop each of the buns. More cheese followed to top it off before he popped them into the oven, and in maybe 15 minutes or so they'd be nice and hot and ready to be eaten. Though Peeta wasn't sure that he had much of an appetite.
When he finally looked at Katniss, really looked at her, he wasn't sure what expression to make. He wanted to smile at her and tell her everything would be okay, but she had been violated last night. And, yes, Peeta knew that it hadn't been his choice, but he still felt like it had been his fault. He should have done something, said something, not let this happen.
He should have killed himself with that nightlock and spared her all of this. She would have had a much easier time playing the role of a mourning lover than trying to feign real, genuine, love when she didn't feel it. And she wouldn't have had to sleep with him to try to prove something to President Snow.
He thought about it a lot. How much better off she would have been if he had died in the arena. He didn't think there was a single person who would have had real trouble moving on if he hadn't come home.
He parted his lips with the intention of saying something, but nothing came. He felt frozen in time.
But Katniss made up for it by speaking first. Her voice hadn't failed her the way Peeta's had.
She dove straight into the topic and Peeta felt his stomach lurch. He'd wanted her so badly. He had dreamt about kissing her, about his fingers tracing along her skin. But he hadn't wanted her to want it, too. He hadn't wanted… this.
"Last night…" He wanted to say something. Apologize? Call it a mistake? Beg for her forgiveness? He couldn't find the words, least of all when he wasn't entirely sure how she was feeling. Hell, he could hardly decipher what he had felt about it all.
Peeta wanted to pull her into a hug. He wanted to hold her, shield her, tell her everything would be okay. But he couldn't. He wasn't even sure that she would let him touch her…
He swallowed, felt that sting of remorse, of guilt, in his gut.
There was nothing he could say to make this okay. Nothing he could do to make it better.
All he could do was hope that she didn't hate him. That someday she could forgive him.
It hadn't been his fault- somewhere in his head he knew that. But it felt like he had been the cause of all of her misery. Not just this, but all of it.
"Katniss… I'm sorry. I'm so sorry…"