Who of the gang do u think is the most jealous? And how do you think they act when they are jealous? Sorry I am just sucker for jealous men and for the man of the gang(Besides Bill and Micah)
Also, could u add Lenny to this? U mostly left him out since they are based on the your fic
VDLG: Jealousy HCs!
Hii!! I cannot believe I forgot Lenny in the past ones I will def get to adding his when I can 💔!! I feel like they all get jealous but how much is what the ranking is lol!
Dutch
Unfortunately this crazy bitch tends to be high up on these kinds of things lol but he’s most obviously jealous out of everyone. While some can hide it very well Dutch can’t, well more like he won’t try too
He’s like a peacock, seeing you get eyed by someone else or out right hit on, he puffs his chest out, fixes his hair and saunters over.
Might get daring and smack your ass as he approaches and wraps an arm around you as he talks “gentlemen/Folks!! What is going on over here?! I’m keen for a good conversation!”
After all is said and done he won’t be mad at YOU but he will tease you about it. If you express insecurity he’ll pull the “I have to fight men/women off of you, and you think you’re not handsome/good looking?”
If the person won’t back down or away after making a big show if you being his, now it’s a battle of egos and that is a fight Dutch will always win.
Tries to make whoever it is seem stupid/not as successful and hell if they’re still after you so hard Dutch isn’t afraid of a good old fight.
He’ll come back from the alleyway outside of the saloon, slightly disheveled, and slide right back next to you.
He gets nasty with it‼️ open mouth kissing, damn near sex on the counter if you let him lmao
John
He’s so toxic girlfriend about it oh my god
He walks away for one second and his seat gets taken at the bar and some random is talking to you, stroking your arm and you couldn’t look more uncomfortable.
“Who the fuck is this?”
John has found the best way to get people away from you when they’re trying to get in your pants is to get mad at YOU and make a scene
“I leave for one minute and you’re inciting others?” You can tell in his tone he’s not being completely serious but the person who dared sit next to you is now actually super uncomfortable and leaves.
Once they do you try to go back to having fun with John but now is the worse part when he gets jealous.
SLIENT TREATMENT
It will, at most, last 2 days, the only times he will respond when you need something not urgent is to say, “Why don’t you get (person who hit on you) to do it, huh?!” and walk away
But if you butter him up even slightly he stops immediately lol. He’s a bit insecure so a little praise and he’s huffy but melting back into you.
You could go home from the bar, start getting dressed for bed, hug him from behind, kiss his head/shoulder, and tell him he’s the only one you want he will grunt but not pull away.
Javier
He's a loyal man. What can I say
When he notices someone making moves, he tries to exercise some restraint. He knows you can handle yourself, but he's curious to see how long it can go before you get up and move away or the person gives up seeing you not respond.
He'll step in and ignore the person outright, talking to you about anything that will make them step away. If the person is pushy again, he grabs them and leads them out of the bar with a knife to the person's throat.
He goes back to normal after that, but you can tell something is stirring in his eyes—as deep and dark as they are, it's obvious to you.
When you leave town and start to just rest and relax from being around so many people, he'll climb on top of you and just give you a real good time.
Kissing your neck and chest and slowly undoing your shirt, hands trailing down and feeling just how warm and ready you are.
But he'll suddenly stop to lay his head down on your stomach. Staring up at you, he'll ask, "Do you think they'd make you feel this good?"
He'll do this sporadically throughout and will coo at you with different questions on how no one else could treat you this well, how you only act like this with him, and how much he loves that fact.
Sean
He’s a very social butterfly so you two are frequently around groups of people be it at a saloon, poker games, just in crowded towns etc
He has no issue seeing you get hit on cause he knows you’re with him! And damn right you should be hit on! you’re banging!!
He issue comes in when others are helping you
Say you lost something, maybe you misplaced a personal item you loved and he sees Arthur come into camp and giving you a replacement he found on his travels? Oh he’s fuming.
Maybe you mentioned preferring a certain meat and Charles brings that exact meat to camp for Pearson to cook with, intentional or not Sean gets upset
But not at you of course! At THEM
It sorta bubbles inside of him for a bit and his breaking point is when good ol Trelawny comes back to camp and does a trick on you. Something like he did to Mary-Beth and hearing you go “oh wow!!” Sets him off
Sean is already drunk and stumbles over to Arthur grabbing his collar asking what his deal is?! Some kind of pervert trying to get with another mans lover?! He’s just yelling incoherent insults to each man before he gets punched and you have to nurse him in your tent after he gets an awful headache
He gets a bit sad, he’s insecure and still slightly drunk crying about how they’re better men then him and he doesn’t want you to get swept away by someone more capable 💔 he’s not nervous about drunks at bars or a man who’s loosing in poker he’s worried about someone better then him looking more appealing to you.
Just hold him for a bit and he’ll settle down, some complements and he’s back up with an ego
Charles
I think people forget he is impulsive, so that's why he's so far up here
Like he sees you getting hit on that person gets one warning before he’s literally tossing them away from you
You guys aren’t allowed at too many saloons anymore…
He sticks to your side more and more. Cause not alone does he not want people to get cozy with you but he also just feels so comfortable with you. Poor guy is socially awkward from being isolated
But the last place he expected to get the worse of it was camp
It was just a normal day, eating dinner by the edge of camp just enjoying each other energy when he remembers he has something for you! Some drink a general store owner was selling and he got you one to try with him
And he got back to see Micah chatting you up. Well he was trying to.
Before the two of you started dating, Micah had no interest in you, but the second the two of you were sweet on each other now, you were target #1 of his harassment
“Come on (Name), why don’t ya chop some wood? Give a man something to LOOK at!” His voice is grating against the beautiful sounds of birds and animals.
Charles isn’t sure what happened but now Micah is on the ground and the two of you are walking to the opposite end of camp. His arm tight around you not saying a word
Kieran
I think it’s not talked about a lot how Kieran def had a higher level in colms gang cause if he was just a stable boy no way colm would even talk to him or let him know when things like hidden money were. Also it would be why the O’driscolls would even care about him/ recognize him as a traitor
All this to say that if you two are out in the world he’s so much more ready to confront then if it’s someone in the van Der linde gang
The two of you just out drinking having a nice meal together just a good night all around. And you insist on stopping inside some store to buy him something as a surprise. And he relents letting you head in without him at your side.
He leans against the fence post of the shop and pets whatever horse is hitched there.
But it feels like alot of time is passing and when he turns to peak into the shop there’s some O’driscoll blocking his view to you.
It’s not a man he recognizes but he sees the look on your face, and how much the man is leaning in, he is not happy at all.
He steps into the store. The shopkeeper is busy with something else, and he presses his revolver into the O’driscoll’s side before guiding him out of the store and shoving him away. He yells something that causes the man to run off, leaving the two of you alone
Being around you puts him in such a soft and nice headspace, and he saw everything the two of you have built as risk. So he had to get out of that soft headspace to make sure things were handled.
After that he sorta goes back to normal, checks that you are okay and tips the shopkeep.
Arthur
Depends on his honor
High Honor Arthur tries to use his charm to get whoever is on you away.
“I know they’re a looker but I’m afraid they’re spoken for.”
Stays with you the rest of the night and might need some comforting. He doesn’t have the best self-esteem no matter what honor he is, so maybe call him handsome and tell him you love him, and he’s looking at you with those big, sad eyes
High honor Arthur uses his developing social skills to get the person banned from the saloon if it becomes a problem and because he’s such a delight the person is usually kicked out if Arthur doesn’t threaten them himself
Low Honor Arthur has just been TWITCHING for a reason to fight someone in a saloon especially in front of you
Getting to yank some drunken fool off of you and just knock him out cold before taking back his seat next to you
No one will mess with either of you now as he cleans nose blood from his knuckles
Still has the low self esteem but overcompensates with a huge ego
But he’d be lying if getting into a fight and they getting his hands on you (sexually) makes it feel so much more exciting
Lenny
I think he takes more after Hosea than he does Dutch. He’s more level headed but he’s also young
Looking for leads in town causes the two of you to be stuck in a town square and some French man approaching you two
Neither of you have a clue what he needs but the man seems to outright ignore Lenny completely
Which already makes him upset, but whatever, maybe it was something only you could help with
The man pulls you with him and Lenny trails behind. Hell maybe the two of you could get away with robbing the man he seems rich enough to be dressed so nice.
But as he trails behind and sees that the man is pointing to the hotel with a big smile on his face he realizes
Oh
Absolutely not
He speed walks over takes your hand and kisses you right there. It’s a bit dramatic, his hands cupping your face eyes compelling shut
When he pulls away he points to the man and shakes his head.
He’s suddenly shy when you ask him what on earth that was all about?! You two could’ve absolutely robbed that guy!
Lenny sorta huffs and says that his money ain’t worth it. He gets very cuddly when you two are back at camp; wanting to be so close to you, Bill tells you both to get a room or just off of each other
He might not own up to how jealous he felt, but you know, and he knows, you know. He was a little embarrassed, but it felt like a story to kiss you in town like that
Hosea
He’s way more under control with his emotions he’s loves you, you love him he’s happy!
He gets a good idea one day: take out whatever dealer is working at the nearby card tables and have you take their place
Outfit and all of course, he thinks you look very nice in it.
But you get there early and he’s just a “random” man at the table with what seems like a good streak of luck, but Hosea knows better and loses every now and then on purpose to keep eyes off of him.
But some random drunk is taking himself winning and Hosea loosing a bit too far.
Laughing, yelling, just being loud as he wins again. A saloon women walks by, runs her hands across his shoulders and offers some of her services but he manages to pushes her away
“No thanks sweetheart, I’m trying to get in this one’s pants,” he pointed to you “that dumb hat really sets fire to the loins.”
First of all, Hosea loved the hat on you! He picked it out himself for you cause he thought it was cute.
Second of all, excuse him? Before Hosea could speak you did first
“What an odd thing to say mister, you’re not my type anyway.” You shuffled the cards again and looked to Hosea who’s face was slightly pink
“What? Like you’d date some old coot like this?” The man nudged Hoseas arm and cackled.
Hosea tapped the table and magically was back on his winning streak.
Saloon girls surrounding the table as the betting pool went up more and more and how his stacks got higher. He was making all sorts of comments to make the man feel stupid
Sure the two of you were cheating, but let him have this! He’s saying ridiculous gambling advice, tall tales of his life to seem very impressive. But he notices how a few onlookers look suspicious at his winnings so he needs to cut this short.
Taking all of the bills and shoving them in his pockets, “good game there fella, maybe next time.” He pats the man’s shoulder and holds and hand out to you
You laugh and grab his hand stepping out from the table. He plants a kiss to your knuckles and you play up the flattery
And finally the owner sees that you are absolutely not the usual dealer and the two of you have to make a break for Hoseas horse and get out of town
You hold onto his hips and tease him for just how upset he got at a man thinking he had a chance with you