Save a horse Ride a cowboy- Carter Dutton
Summary: She saw him walk into class for the first time with a hat on, a button up flannel and cow boy boots with a matching belt buckle and she knew she was going to do whatever she could to make sure she rode him with that hat on top of her pretty little head. But the poor thing was so afraid of the constant rejection that he thought she was in his house on his bed asking him to have sex with her as a ruse to humiliate him even more than they do at school. Little did he know she was so desperate she would go to extreme measures just to have him.
warnings: cursing, ⋆˙⟡ warnings sex 18+, p in v, riding, possessive and jealous, dirty talk, pussy eating, implications of a unprotected sex
"Please, I swear I wasn't apart of that group of girls that messed with you at the beginning of the year. I just wanted you so bad I practically begged the teacher to let me tutor you just so I could get you alone to myself."
"You want me?" The mistrust in his eyes evident.
"Are you kidding? I swear I've been holding myself back from throwing myself at you, and then I saw you ride that horse with your dad ripp the other day and I swear I had to sit in soaked panties all day while teaching you geometry. It was hell." You were on your knees on his bed after he moved away from you when you tried to kiss him.
He stood far away with his hands up in surrender and a nervous stutter "look I don't know but I-I." He cleared his throat and in that moment I realized how it looked from his perspective. A pretty girl shows an uneasy amount of interest in him the moment he moves to a small town. But if he knew that I had been getting myself off on just the thought of him. I would cum so hard just thinking about how he would say "Good mornin'." And tip his hat in my direction as he would sit down right next to me.
So Before he started to stutter and fumble some more at the thought that this was some way I was going to humiliate him I decided to show him exactly how serious I was about wanting him. If anyone was going to be humiliated tonight it is going to be me being desperate to get laid. And I am VERY desperate.
If I had time to be slow and subtle I would be but I don't have the time today. So I yanked my shirt over my head before he could complete his sentence. "Listen you might think this is a funny joke but it isn't funny for m-." Shirt off, bra tossed to whatever corner I'll find it at later. I sit on the bed with my tits out and and a sheepish smile on my face.
"Do I look like I'm joking Carter? I like you, I really do. And I'm not afraid to say that I want you." I crawl towards the end of the bed and reach my hand out to Carter. "It's just me and you, and you're a bit overdressed. If you take your shirt off I'll take my pants off?"
You could see the dam in his head cracking. He wanted to give in but I knew about all the stuff those girls did to mess with him? Why? I'll never know. But they messed with his emotions and now All I want is for him to be balls deep inside me and he's standing scared like a virgin. What if I can't convince him. What if he doesn't even want me and I really just humiliated myself? He's my friend and I should have never crossed these boundaries.
The sudden realization that he was standing so far away made my stomach churn. Feeling suddenly so insecure I covered my chest with my arms and look anywhere but at Carter and his dazzling blue eyes.
"Look I'm sorry, Maybe I shouldn't have done this. I don't know what came over me I just- I'm sorry. I'll get dressed and I'll leave and we don't have to talk about-" what he said next made my head practically spin.
"Take your pants off then if this isn't a joke." If I knew that the Deer caught in head lights look I had made him extremely hard then I wouldn't have second guessed myself.
"If you are really willing to take this joke that far then take your underwear off too." He soon realized that this was no joke. He was standing there cock throbbing while the most beautiful girl he's ever seen sits on his bed begging for his attention. If this wasn't some sick joke then this had to be heaven. There was no other way this could be real.
Pants off and discarded I turn my back towards him, I know if I do this right I'll be every boys wet dream. Gently tossing my hair over my shoulder and looking back at him as I hook my fingers in my pink panties taking them off and toss them back at him.
Seconds before his eyes were a bright blue but they darkened as Carter slowly unbuttoned his flannel. I could cum right now looking at him standing there so tall and handsome in a rugged wayy. Just like in my fantasies he was very fit, after all he was a cowboy. I couldn't help but rake my eyes down to the patch of dark hair that led further down. It was a happy trail I was willing to go down.
"Carter I love your belt buckle but It's kind of in the way of what I want. So if you could please take your belt off." His eyes still have a bit of worry but how can he question my intentions when I'm quite literally bare before him.
I can't even be patient because once he has his belt off I pull him close and I unzip his pants. Carter funny enough doesn't seem to understand how or why I'm more excited than him.
Soon his lips meet mine with a desperate passion. Tongues dancing in a foreign way slowly but surely finding a passionate rhythm. His kisses distract me so much that I didn't feel his cock slap on my thigh until I let go of our embrace for a desperate set of breaths.
Despite fighting the urge to not look down I instantly and shamelessly looked. Once I see his dick spring back and hit his belly I know that riding this cowboy will give me saddle sores. If not sores then I can guarantee that I won't be able to walk for a week. How dare he feel shy and embarrassed. Carter doesn't even know it yet but he's bigger than any toy I've ever used on my self. Not to mention the LENGTH, dear God I've died and gone to heaven.
With a smile on my face I watch as he nervously struggles out of his pants and I begin to feel less naked. Once his struggle with his pants are over he looks at me so fucking needing. So desperate yet vulnerable. So afraid that this is a joke but trust me when I tell you that cant be further from the truth. So I kiss him so roughly at first but can't help slow down gently to give the poor boy a chance.
Before I know what is happening he slips his tongue in my mouth and I cant help but feel relieved. It's a tongue in my mouth now but if I have my way in the next few minutes it'll be his tongue in my cunt. I need to play my cards right. I refuse to surrender, Before the day ends I will fuck Carter Dutton.
Slowly I begin to kiss down his jaw, hearing his breath hitch and his whimpers as I go further down his chest leaving gentle kisses. The lower I go the more tongue I use as I kiss my way down his lower belly. Exactly where I want to be. Is it manipulative if I look up at him with pretty fuck me eyes? Well then call me manipulative because behind hooded lashes I lick a stripe up the side of his cock while looking him dead in the eye after my tongue reaches the tip. His pre cum was salty but tasted so fucking good in a sinful way.
If you could pinpoint love in one look trust me when I tell you I might have sucked my way to his heart. Hearing him breathe desperately makes me so fucking wet I could die. He was 10 inches hard with a very thick girth but I refuse to be a quitter. So I hallowed my cheeks and bobbed on his length while constantly stroking him and sucking on his pretty pink head.
He looked slightly shameful and scandalized when he finished in my mouth with a very breathy moan and was quickly replaced with his head falling back and his Adams apple bobbing followed by a very deep animalistic groan.
But this boy is so fucking sweet because seconds after he catches his breath he asks "Is it your turn now? Please I really want to bury my face in your pussy.".
Out of breath and only seconds after an orgasm yet here he is eagerly wanting to return the favor. A true gentleman but still I wanted to tease him so I asked if he wanted it to be my turn or his again. A glimmer of mischief shines in my eyes because his answer surprised me. Pulling me up with him he turns us so he switches our spots on the bed. "I would love to eat your pussy if you'll let me, ma'am." Oh god he lasted a long time I need to breath so I don't finish that fast. God I'm desperate but he doesn't need to know that.
He didn't get the chance to eat my pussy right away because I couldn't help but kiss him, it was such an erotic fucking kiss because there was so much tongue. In between kisses our noses would brush so sensually it made wanting him feel like the right choice. I will remember this moment for a long fucking time.
Before long Carter buried his face in my cunt as I buried my face into the sheets, hands gripping the blanket so tight I could swear I was ripping his sheets.
"Oh god Carter please! Yes. Ahhhhhhh!"
I have no idea who taught Carter to eat pussy but they need to be praised for the rest of their lives. His nose was practically shoved in me while he sucked on my clit. Breathing isn't an option at this point, I'm afraid I was not prepared to be pleased in such a manner. He had a torturing method of rhythm where he alternated between licking my clit back and forth and sucking on it. My ass is arched up for him and I'm grateful because my face down on the bed hides my tears of frustration because I genuinely can't control my breath or control my orgasm. Or should I say orgasms!
I look back and I break, the burning feeling in the depths of my stomach I was trying to control burst. Whining and crying was an understatement because when I locked eyes with Carter and he pulled me back further into his face I came instantly. The neighbors 30 acres away could hear most likely hear me cumming on this boys face.
"oh god, Carter please! I can't! No more ahhhhhhh!!! Uuuuummmmmmm please Carterrr!!! Oh GOD YESSS!!!!" But he didn't give a single fuck. I came into his home, used his bad grades to get close to him and bring down his walls to let me in, all for the selfish intention of solely being fucked by him. And I haven't even been fucked properly yet here he has me begging him not to overstimulate me. Well mission fucking accomplished.
Still he refused let me go like an animal with a bone. I swear he growled as he pulled me firmly back to meet his face. His licks became less erratic as did my breathing. But he still lapped at my pussy like a puppy in a bowl of milk. Making me trust his intentions of slowly bringing me back down to earth as he spread gentle kisses on my inner thighs until he plunged 2 fingers into my folds. In and out with swift motions then slowly before speeding up once again only to pull his fingers out and sucked on them. And here I am still on my knees with my ass up and face down. I want this so bad and now that I'm here I want it to last forever.
It feels like this moment lasts forever but not long enough when I hear "Are you ready?".
Am I ready? I've never wanted anything more in my life. I feel his soft warm head coating itself in my slick before he slowly pushes his way in. Such a gentleman, I just know he'll give me whatever I want, however I want. And I want him to bottom out and he fills me so slowly. I adjust and breathe through it but he still knocks my breath out the second he slowly pulls out and shoves himself back in while bottoming out entirely. Hearing the gush of my pussy as he shoved himself back in me has my eyes fucking ROLLING BACK.
I reach my hand back for some fucking reason unknown to me. My palm reaches his lower belly before Carter grabs my wrist to get a better hold on me. In an erotic rhythm he continues to thrust in and out of me while holding me by my arm as leverage. I can't help it as I bounce my ass back to match his rhythm. No, I want see his face when I cum. Correction; I want to see his face when I make him cum.
"Wait, please stop." And he immediately stops. Searching for my eyes to see if I was okay. I honestly don't even want to imagine what I look like from his point of view but by the look in his eyes I know It's a view to behold so I rein in my insecurities.
"I want to be on top, please." My chest is still heaving from being fucked so deliciously. I move back and pull him towards me before roughly slamming him onto the bed smothering his chest with wet kisses. Throwing my leg over is waist and placing myself perfectly on Carter mounting my cowboy. Carter pulls me up closer by my waist and I feel his cock throb underneath me. Breasts pressed tightly against his chest as he meets my mouth in a passionate heated rivalry. Fighting for Dominance with every kiss and his tongue manages to win, giving him the lead.
He halts our kiss to focus his attention and rough kisses on my chest leaving marks all over, I'm going to need to wear shirts to cover up the marks he is making. Fuck, he's marking me up and I know I should tell him not to or to keep it limited to collar bone down but the second his lips go to my neck I moan like a whore. Did he Just lick up my neck? Fuck this is the best day of my life.
"Put yourself back in, now! I can't wait. I've waited long enough please." Tears pool in my eyes due to the overstimulated wherever it be sexual or emotional.
"Oh yeah, and how long has that been?" He mocks and I swear he got cocky with just a couple thrust in my pussy.
"Please, you didn't even want to fuck me like 30 minutes ago !" God now I'm begging like I said I would, what a fucking prediction!
He reaches down and slowly rubs the head of his cock up and down my folds and when I try to sit on it he denies me, that bastard.
"I said tell me how long you've been wanting to fuck me? Answer and you can ride me into the sunset like a happy ending." Blue eyes are a gift from God to everyone but teenage girls. I might as well be whining like a bitch begging because I'm literally willing to spill my guts just to sit on his dick.
"You walked in math Class with that fucking hat on and boots on with that fucking belt buckle all goofy looking. And that was the moment I knew I had to have you. And it got even harder to get close to you after that stunt those bitches pulled. But my dedication got me something didn't it? So please shove your dick inside me and make me cum. Please!" His eyes held that vulnerable look in the beginning quickly followed by that dark lust before he finally liked himself up properly and I slowly pounded myself down. The feeling of fullness was absolutely addicting. My hands found his face to pull him in for a tender kiss that matched the pace I bounced.
If I wanted too I could reach my hand down and rub my clit furiously to cum and I could do it in an instant looking down at Carter. The thing that stopped me from doing that was the hot burning feeling in my stomach that felt foreign, nothing like the toys I've used to achieve a personal orgasm. But this orgasm was fucking mind blowing. He wrapped his arms roughly around my waist to pick me up and slam me down onto him forcing his own pace building up his own high.
Fingers in his hair and my head thrown back while his mouth attacks my neck as we cum so hard together you could swear all the house could hear was the sounds of loud moans and a scream in pleasure.
"Oh god you're so fucking beautiful keep going!" Sounds of wet skin slapping shamelessly followed my moans that I can't hold in for shit.
"Carter please don't stop! Right there! Yes! Yes! Yes!yes!! Ahhhhhhh goddd Carter!!!"
If I had known his parents got home and had come in the house to hear me begging I would have never gave those last few bounces my ALL. Who am I kidding? Yes I would have, it was fucking worth the humiliation.
"oh god Carter." In the room it's silent except the sounds of heavy breath as I stay sitting on him, chest to chest and nose to nose. I leave a gentle peck on his head and meet his eyes. Forehead full of sweat, eyes dilated and lips swollen. God it's a sight to fucking behold.
Like the cherry on top of the best day ever we hear a set of rythmic clicks suddenly, unsure of what the sounds is we lock eyes and instantly fly away from each other.
Beth is home.
I grab the sheet of the bed and fling myself on the side of the bed you can't see when you walk into the room. Carter panics before the door opens and he grabs a pillow to cover his lower half right as the door opens. My heart drops, dear God I thought there was time for me to fuck his brains out before they came home.
"Boy, what in God's name are you doing in here and with who?" Fuck it's his dad! Fuck he's scary but I thought I heard Beth's heels.
Rip and beth see a pink bra and pair of panties at the foot of Carter's bed along with 2 notebooks and a math book and share a knowing look.
"oh uhm nothing, no one." Fucking smooth Carter, I'm literally naked with my thighs coated in his cum hiding on the side of his bed as he stands naked with only a pillow covering his dick.
Fuck it, I've been bold today, what's being a little more bold. So I sit up, curls all over the place exactly like how you'd imagine sex hair.
"We were kinda in the middle of exactly what you think we were doing. My apologies for the excessive volume." Dear God The tension in the room could be cut with a butter knife.
Ripp rubs his forehead like a tired dad and just looks at Beth like "you're dealing with this." And she did.
"Well you and your TUTOR need to get dressed. Dinner is on the table. Take out." With that they retreat and close the door behind them. Carter and I lock eyes and I cover my mouth and giggle. That was such a fucking situation to be in wow.
"OH and wash your hands!" Beth had yelled after walking down the hallway. All I could do was laugh when I looked into Carters eyes.
"Next time can I wear your hat?" The wild look of disbelief crossed his face.
"There's gonna be a next time?" He arches a brow.
"only if you do that thing with your tongue again, fuck that made my head spin." A deep chuckle resonates in his chest.
"Let's go sit down and eat, fuck this better not be weird." Little did he know the first question that would be asked of us was if we used protection. Poor Carter, I'm in heaven and this kid is being tortured mercilessly.