Captive sand substrates versus wild ones and how they relate to impaction
I think I’ve probably talked about this before, but I’ve decided to take the time to write down some of my thoughts and extrapolations about sand as a substrate and why it is such a concern for impaction.
Now, certain types of sand definitely are bad, such as repti-sand, calci-sand, and most anything of that nature that is marketed as digestible. The reasons being:
Most of these sands are extremely fine grained and easily get into eyes, causing irritation and pain
Most of them are also extremely dusty, coating the respiratory tract and making it harder to fight off infections, also can contribute to eye irritation
Many are dyed, which often increases dust levels, due to the form in which the dye is added to the substrate
While calcium carbonate (the main component of most of these) is somewhat digestible and is even used as a calcium supplement in livestock feeds, it is also a natural pH antagonist that will decrease the acidity of a dragon’s stomach
Calcium carbonate is also a major component of limestone, and, as such, at pH’s such as those achieved in the dragon’s stomach when they ingest sufficient quantities of it, will form what basically amounts to a stone in the digestive tract, which is how these substrates often cause impaction. Calcium carbonate as a supplement is fine since it is not present in sufficient quantities to cause this and is often a lot higher grade, but just like any good thing, it is dangerous in large amounts.
In the case of other pet store sands that are silica-based, the problems are similar in some regards, but slightly different:
Once again, typically have a very small, fine particle size
Are also typically very dusty, especially if dyed
Pure silica is not a great medium for the normal activities that take place in soil to break down waste and prevent the buildup of harmful bacteria
Sand grains can be porous and/ or create a lot of surface area
Because of this, even after scooping stool the bacteria that has already been deposited in the substrate will be able to flourish, especially if there is moisture present
While silica will not form a stone like calcium carbonate will, it does tend to clump (just like the sand at the beach does when it gets wet), and this can form masses of indigestible material in the gut, leading to impaction
Sand tends to be abrasive to the sensitive linings of the gut and can scrape off vili and cilia that are important to nutrient absorption and intestinal motility
Long term exposure to sand can cause permanent scarring to the gut, making nutrient absorption difficult
Finer, more uniformly shaped particles are more likely to clump than irregular ones
Sand in the tank does not have the same variances in moisture that it would in the wild and tends to be uniformly dry and loose
The effects of sands in bearded dragons, especially the stone forming properties, are further exacerbated by husbandry and anatomy related things, though are not exclusive to bad husbandry alone. Intestinal impaction is also a complicated issue with many underlying causes:
Chronic dehydration lowers the moisture available to the digestive tract, increasing the risk of forming balls of compacted material such as loose sand or calcium particles
This also decreases gut lubrication such as mucus linings for much the same reason
Like rabbits and horses, bearded dragons are hindgut fermenters to some degree when it comes to plants, and their intestines are set up accordingly, with an enlarged cecum and lengthy digestive tract to better utilize plant material.
This means that in order to achieve proper intestinal motility they need a substantial degree of fiber compared to other more insectivorous species
Without this fiber amongst the protein and substrate particles, the intestines have a harder time moving material
This is compounded by a narrow opening between the ileum and the rest of the digestive tract and a sharp turn at that junction which makes it difficult to pass large materials through, so without proper motility and lubrication it is easy for blockages to form in this location and a stone can completely plug it
Excessive protein can also play a role in firming up the ingestia and forming balls of other things such as crickets
Poor heating interferes with the activity of digestive system enzymes, which need a certain temperature range to be maintained by the animal in order to function normally. Too hot of temperatures denature them (rending them useless), and too low substantially reduces their activity, increasing the amount of improperly digested material making its way further into the intestines
Small, fine, and uniform particles in the gut are more likely to form clumps in large amounts, which is why sand impactions occur with silica. In the case of play sand, some of these risks are reduced due to more variability in particle size, shape, and composition
Now, when all of these conditions are corrected, the risk of impaction goes down significantly. Even though dragons’ natural anatomy predisposes them to impaction, a properly cared for gut and body makes the chances of one a lot less likely. In the wild, bearded dragons can be found on sandy substrates, and will even burrow through them, so, with all of these factors to consider, how do they do it?
Unlike in most captive setups, the sand you see in the Australian deserts where dragons make their homes is actually a mixture of organic and inorganic material, and, while it may be heavily sand based, still retains its shape when used for burrows. This is due to the presence of difficult to degrade organic fibers, roots, clay, and other components that form a complex soil biome.
This creates an environment where bacteria and matter cycle naturally, reducing the chances of high levels of detrimental bacteria from gathering like it can in silica
While dry on the surface, sandy soils often are somewhat moist several inches down, meaning that they clump and hold their shape. In the case of a burrowing dragon, this also means that when they taste their substrate they don’t typically pick up as many particles. They also hold their shape due to the presence of organic fibers, which, when ingested alongside sand, creates enough variance in composition that the particles are unlikely to clump
Bearded dragons often climb and hunt across a variety of different substrate compositions even within a small radius, meaning that the substrate that they do ingest varies widely enough and is different enough in shape and size that it’s more resistant to clumping as mentioned above
Mixed components in substrates also tends to reduce dust, and moisture, when added occasionally, tends to reduce its output
Many sandy soils in their range are actually quite hard packed, and are unlikely to be easily grabbed in large quantities like loose silica
Dragons can also be found on more loamy substrates with higher organic matter content that often makes them easier to pass
Greater plant eating habits compared to some captive dragons may contribute to increased fiber in the diet and an easier time passing substrate as a result