Oh boy! iPhone 5? Hell no!
When one of my colleagues got his iPhone 5 on the same day Nexus 4 sold out within an hour in 3 countries, I thought I should at least a take a look at it. Knowing that I would obviously pull his leg when I find about the purchase, he didn't actually shout around showing his new phone. So when the news got to me, I asked for the phone and took a look at it. I was actually a bit surprised that he didn't flaunt the new phone and tell me why it 'is damn good'.
The very first impression as I held the phone in my hands, it felt pretty bad. It had a very strange form factor, like some sort of a racket for a weird ball game. The texture of the surface and the weight made it feel like some kinda plastic toy phone. The worst part was whenever I would keep it on the table, I would struggle to lift it. I have to either slide it to the edge of the table, or lift it carefully since there is a high chance I could drop it. The edge is unergonomially thin and slippery. I could already see a lot of scratch on the rear side because of the sliding I guess.
I could not get the idea behind the shape though. They say it is easy for your thumb to reach edge to edge (horizontally), as they haven't increased the width. Then what about the height? The screen size is specified by the diagonal length, so when the phone is 4" long with same width, the height has to shoot up considerably. It is too long, if I can't get to the notification centre with one hand, what's the bloody point? I think notification bar is more important, what if I get a notification while I am driving, cooking, or pooping? I have to use 1 hand!!
My Nexus has 4.65" display, but still I can reach every corner of the screen with one hand, and more importantly the build makes sure the phone doesn't just slip through your hands, the iPhone has a very slippery and "grip-less" shape that it tried to slip through many times.
I tried the camera, and sound. Didn't see anything exceptional. (Nothing good/bad), the Nexus/Lumia800 was very much similar. So I went to try out iOS 6, nothing great there either. There were around 4-5 rows of apps, but something was wrong. The 5th row was empty in every screen. So, the much hyped super smooth back up and transfer wizard forgot the fact that the new phone had one extra row and they could actually fill it?
I tried some popular apps like Flipboard, Path etc, I didn't get the feeling of "extra space" in one single app I used. Rather I felt pixels have been shaved off the sides. Because all these apps had the more width and height (compared to my Nexus). So the '5th row' perk sounds ridiculous to me.
I felt so disgusted and disappointed with the phone that I didn't even go further. Like opening Maps, Siri, browser etc. As I placed the phone on the table, I saw the iPhone 4S. After using iPhone 5, 4S looks a lot better. Looks decent, feels decent. And when I opened my Phone (Nexus), I felt like a king :)
I came to know the phone cost close to $1000 (32GB). That made the phone look even more horrible. For the price I could buy a Nexus 4 ($349) + Surface ($499) and still gift my friend a Lumia 920($99). I will still be left with money to take a round trip to my home town. Or, I could buy an iPhone 4S($800) and half a dozen lightning to 30-pin adapters, which I won't.
PS: I learnt this style of writing from popular bloggers Marco, Seigler, Gruber etc.