Already Over- Simon Riley x Reader
loosely based off of the already over lyrics but instead of sabrina carpenter it’s reader and instead of ex’s it’s a fwb to lovers trope
(idk abt the ending yet so it might change🫣 )
#sfw #fluffifyousquint
-
You and simon have been talking for hours on hours about how you cannot keep talking for hours, or cuddling and kissing after sex. It seems ironic, but if you think about it the two of you haven’t really been talking for hours, you’ve been talking at him for hours about how you think you and him should just stay friends, a conversation the two of you have had before that never seems to stick.
He watches intently as you talk with worried eyebrows and fingers that never cease their anxious movements, nodding every now and then regardless of the fact that he doesn’t agree while you explain that you don’t think you can keep being friends with benefits and that the relationship has rapidly progressed from just being friends who have sex. Simon is more than aware that your friendship and its benefits strongly resemble a relationship, that was his intention when asking you about the arrangement in the first place. He knew he could make you fall for him the way he’d already fallen for you if he could just get an in somewhere and now he feels kind of guilty seeing the anxiety it’s caused you as you admit that you’re beginning to develop stronger feelings and apologize, telling him that you admit total fault. You end your rant by sighing, “I say all that to say I think we’d probably be better off as friends.” You look up at him expectingly, maybe anticipating annoyance or even anger, but it never comes. He looks down at you with an expression that you can’t exactly read and just nods. “I hear you” he says gently, watching as you sigh softly out of relief. “Okay, thank you. I’ll see you later then?” you ask going in to hug him.
“Yeah later” he agrees leaning down and reciprocating your hug, it’s when you go to separate from him that in one smooth motion he catches your lips in a kiss, similar to the ones you’ve shared hundreds of times before he leaves your place that usually come mindlessly. You barely even register it as you kiss him back, softly humming against his lips before he breaks the kiss and you turn to walk towards the door. You start to walk before wiping the dazed smile off your face, “Wait Simon no” You stop dead in your tracks, turning around to look at him. his eyebrows are raised while he walks closer to you, his hand resting on your hip, waiting for you to say something. A thousand thoughts run through your head at once, knowing that no matter how you change your mind it’ll always be on him. For a second the two of you just look at each other before you scrunch your eyebrows in confusion, “Im serious this time. We can’t do that, did you not hear me?”
“Y’wanna just be friends because you caught feelings?” He asks, pulling you closer to him as you let him.
“Yeah?” you quietly answer, caught extremely off guard by his actions, suddenly feeling the spotlight on you casted by his eyes on yours.
“Love, I started this whole thing with feelings for you, now we’re on the same page”