Can TikTok Thrift Hauls Save the Planet? The Dark Side of #SlowFashion Influencers
Picture this: A TikToker’s “slow fashion” haul features a $200 linen dress tagged #EthicalFashion - while Shein churns out 6,000 new styles daily. Welcome to the paradox of digital citizenship in the age of fast fashion. Let’s dissect how influencers like Venetia La Manna preach sustainability while algorithms profit from our guilt.
The Rise of “Eco-Influencers”
Slow fashion influencers blend activism with aesthetics, using performative posts such as Instagram Reels or OOTDs and wardrobe tracking to promote the movement's ethical and political goals. However, recent studies revealed that there are still complexities and potential pitfalls of sustainable supply chain management, such as unanticipated outcomes, trade-offs, and tensions in operations and supply chains (Matos, Gold & Hall 2020). When Big Sister Swap partners with H&M’s “Conscious” line (accused of greenwashing), is it activism or ambassadorship?
Digital Citizenship ≠ Consumerism
Digital fashion activism, exemplified by the #thriftflip trend, has altered consumption patterns but raised thrift store prices, risking the exclusion of low-income shoppers (Park et al. 2022; Ronobir et al. 2020). Initiatives like #WhoMadeMyClothes challenge fashion brands' sustainability claims (Greco 2022). This creates tension between gendered solidarity and neoliberal consumerism, positioning the female body as both a victim of exploitation and a symbol of ethical consumption (Horton & Street 2021).
#thriftflip trend vs #whomademyclothes
Algorithms vs. Authenticity
Platforms reward performative activism: Aesthetic “capsule wardrobe” videos get 10x more views than posts about unionizing garment workers. Etter & Albu (2020) warned that platforms can commodify citizenship through sorting, filtering, and ranking, but also introduce constraints like information overload and opacity - Shein’s TikTok ads now hijack #SlowFashion tags, targeting Gen Z with $5 crop tops for example. Even eco-influencers face pressure to #advertise “eco-friendly” fast fashion collabs to stay relevant.
Grassroots vs. Gatekeepers
Hope exists! Grassroots movements are leveraging digital platforms for sustainability. While sustainable practices like communal mending and "anti-haul" videos are emerging (Durrani, 2018; Wood, 2020), marginalized creators face algorithmic (in)visibility and biased moderation, leading to self-censorship (Duffy & Meisner, 2022). This highlights the complex role of digital spaces in promoting sustainability and perpetuating inequalities, emphasizing the need for better algorithmic literacy (Henderson et al., 2020).
Is your #ThriftHaul empowering workers—or just inflating an influencer’s brand deal? Drop your most controversial take below. 👀♻️
Reference:
Duffy, BE & Meisner, C 2022, ‘Platform governance at the margins: Social media creators’ experiences with algorithmic (in)visibility’, Media, Culture & Society, vol. 45, SAGE Publications, no. 2, pp. 285–304.
Durrani, M 2018, ‘“People Gather for Stranger Things, So Why Not This?” Learning Sustainable Sensibilities through Communal Garment-Mending Practices’, Sustainability, vol. 10, MDPI AG, no. 7, p. 2218.
Etter, M & Albu, OB 2020, ‘Activists in the dark: Social Media Algorithms and Collective Action in Two Social Movement Organizations’, Organization, vol. 28, no. 1, pp. 68–91.
Greco, S 2022, ‘Twitter Activists’ Argumentation Through Subdiscussions: Theory, Method and Illustration of the Controversy Surrounding Sustainable Fashion’, Argumentation.
Henderson, MJ, Shade, LR & Mackinnon, K 2020, ‘EVERY CLICK YOU MAKE: ALGORITHMIC LITERACY AND THE DIGITAL LIVES OF YOUNG ADULTS’, AoIR Selected Papers of Internet Research, University of Illinois Libraries.
Horton, K & Street, P 2021, ‘This hashtag is just my style: popular feminism & digital fashion activism’, Continuum, vol. 35, no. 6, pp. 1–14.
Matos, SV, Schleper, MC, Gold, S & Hall, JK 2020, ‘The hidden side of sustainable operations and supply chain management: unanticipated outcomes, trade-offs and tensions’, International Journal of Operations & Production Management, vol. 40, no. 12, pp. 1749–1770.
Park, HJ, Kim, JY & Lee, K-H 2022, ‘Interplay Between TikTok & Generation Z: The Trickle-Up Effect of #thriftflip’, Breaking Boundaries, Iowa State University Digital Press <https://www.iastatedigitalpress.com/itaa/article/id/13735/>.
Witton, N 2025, Critical care nurses: thriving or striving through workplace adversity, Worktribe.com. <https://keele-repository.worktribe.com/>.