Did the Principles come from the Hordika?
Despite the extensive details about the Principles given in MNOG II, the fact that they only appear in that one game means there’s a lot about them that we don’t know, namely their origins. Were these beliefs that the Matoran held throughout their history, or are these beliefs that specifically emerged on the island of Mata Nui?
I think my favorite theory in regards to this is that the Principles came from the Turaga, who developed them based on their experiences as Toa and in particular, their experiences as Toa Hordika. Each of them struggled with the Hordika transformation in their own ways, ways that actually tie in nicely to the Principles and their enemies. Most of these characterizations of the Hordika can be found in the Challenge of the Hordika novel.
Nokama very noticeably struggled with the feelings of corruption that the transformation brought, and how it caused the Great Temple to reject her, so it makes sense she would emphasize purity
Onewa began feeling very destructive, which contrasts with the Principle of Creation. His violent impulses also notably hampered his ability to think strategically, which is why he might’ve taught the Po-Matoran the skill of strategy.
Whenua very notably wanted to run off into the night and hunt, never having to deal with his responsibilities. This would mean abandoning his Duty and his Destiny, the virtues, Prosperity is based on, and his desire to hunt perhaps shows a dispensation with hunger.
Nuju was most disturbed with the feelings of uncontrollable anger his transformation brought, and how it took all his willpower to keep his Rahi side in check, which could explain why he would emphasize Peace and Willpower.
Matau struggled heavily with his feelings of hopelessness and despair. In addition, his harness towards Vakama during the arc contributed to the team fragmenting. His journey during the Hordika arc centered around rekindling his own Faith, and Vakama’s to bring him back and heal the team.
And with Vakama, it can be argued that the root of his problems lie with his struggles with his fears and feelings of self doubt, that led him to first act too hesitantly, and then too brashly to overcompensate. What he needed was a more balanced view of Courage, and perhaps he taught that to the Ta-Matoran.
Again, all the connection between their struggles and the Principles is just a headcanon of mine, but one I find very compelling due to how it connects their personal arcs to the cultures of their people.
