Upon hearing THAT QUESTION Ava’s tongue suddenly felt like lead. She thought to appease him like before, but it was clear that he would simply see through any lie, and if she were lucky, she would get a detention and 10 points taken off her.
Ava had to make a decision, and fast. Her Professor’s eyes were calculating and almost mocking her upfront.
This will not be dignified regardless of her explanation, and what else would she lose from telling the truth? Hagrid would probably never approach her, that was clear. But what else could be done? In any case, the ball was in Snape’s court. It’s now or never...
“It’s for Hagrid, professor. He asked me not to tell you that it is for him”, Ava started explaining clumsily. Why couldn’t she be her confident self just like she was around other teachers?
Suprisingly to her, he simply rolled his eyes at her words and commented on her poor intelligence. But then he almost smirked at her. That was something new.
“I appreciate your honesty. 10 points to Slytherin. I will continue to reward you for the insight into his future clandestine affairs.”
Something unreadable flashed for a second in Snape’s eyes. They almost softened at her. At least there was a glimpse of a genuine approval. Did he really want an informant?
So be it, Ava decided with finality. She thanked him with a smile. Of course, she will keep him informed.